Arminfo.info


 Monday, November 25 2024 13:39
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Orientalist: While Pashinyan thinks in terms of the "present", Aliyev  thinks in terms of the "future"

Orientalist: While Pashinyan thinks in terms of the "present", Aliyev  thinks in terms of the "future"

ArmInfo. During an  interview with PTA on November 22, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol  Pashinyan brought up a new point of discussion regarding the  opposition of Western Armenia to the so-called "Western Azerbaijan".  This is how orientalist Sergey Melkonyan commented on the latest  statements made by the Armenian Prime Minister that there is no need  to be offended when Ilham Aliyev uses the narrative of "Western  Azerbaijan", because Armenians themselves often say Western Armenia.

In this context, the expert pointed out that these two concepts are  diametrically opposed to each other.  "Western Armenia is a  historical region. The so-called "Western Azerbaijan" is an  unrealized product of geopolitical engineering that has never  actually existed," he noted. Melkonyan emphasized that "Western  Azerbaijan" is in opposition to the idea of the "Republic of Armenia"  and is intended to destruct the current Armenian statehood. "Western  Armenia is not aimed at destroying Turkey, but rather serves as an  alternative name for modern Eastern Turkey, referencing one of the  historical names for this region, such as Eastern Anatolia. 

Furthermore, the fundamental inconsistency of Pashinyan's thesis lies  in his attempt to incorporate the historical term "Western Armenia"  into his new concept of "real Armenia", whereas Aliyev integrates the  notion of "Western Azerbaijan" into the historical paradigm. That is,  while Pashinyan thinks in terms of the "present", Aliyev thinks in  terms of the "future", trying to come up with "historical  justifications".  Therefore, putting two concepts on the same level  just because the word "Western" is present is, at the very least,  frivolous," the political scientist asserted. Melkonyan believes that  Pashinyan has actually set a new agenda for discussions. According to  him, on one hand, participation in the discussion legitimizes the  topic and helps promote the agenda. "On the other hand, the absence  of comments and criticism may indicate that Pashinyan's position  aligns with the majority of the population," the orientalist  concluded.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
EAJ delegation visits Armenian Genocide memorial EAJ delegation visits Armenian Genocide memorial 
Several ways of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process - Jeyhun Bayramov Several ways of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process - Jeyhun Bayramov 
UJA condemns arrest of journalist Lilit Aghekyan UJA condemns arrest of journalist Lilit Aghekyan 
`Defeated Nazism must not rise again!` - delegations` statement `Defeated Nazism must not rise again!` - delegations` statement 
Armenia`s MOD refutes Azerbaijan`s disinformationArmenia`s MOD refutes Azerbaijan`s disinformation
International community should resolutely respond to use of force as  means for conflict resolution - RA Rep at UNInternational community should resolutely respond to use of force as  means for conflict resolution - RA Rep at UN
No `secret agreements` with European pharmaceutical companies - RA  Premier`s Office No `secret agreements` with European pharmaceutical companies - RA  Premier`s Office 
Armenian MP on three-year-long custody of General Mikael ArzumanyanArmenian MP on three-year-long custody of General Mikael Arzumanyan
Azerbaijani armed forces open fire on Khnatsakh settlementAzerbaijani armed forces open fire on Khnatsakh settlement
Armenian and Marseille medical institutions to collaborate in   maternal and reproductive health areasArmenian and Marseille medical institutions to collaborate in   maternal and reproductive health areas
Azerbaijani side shelled a residential building in KhnatsakhAzerbaijani side shelled a residential building in Khnatsakh
Pashinyan left for Moscow on a working visitPashinyan left for Moscow on a working visit
Criminal charges may be pursued for ANIF fund abuses - Prosecutor  GeneralCriminal charges may be pursued for ANIF fund abuses - Prosecutor  General
Human rights activist: Armenia`s National Security Service does not  have intelligence data  on 1,160 missing persons in the Karabakh  conflictHuman rights activist: Armenia`s National Security Service does not  have intelligence data  on 1,160 missing persons in the Karabakh  conflict
Armenia`s Security Council Chief to leave for IndiaArmenia`s Security Council Chief to leave for India
Ambassador of Belarus to Armenia honors memory of Great Patriotic War  heroesAmbassador of Belarus to Armenia honors memory of Great Patriotic War  heroes
Pashinyan honors memory of Radik MartirosyanPashinyan honors memory of Radik Martirosyan
Putin congratulates leaders and citizens of foreign countries on 80th  anniversary of  Victory in  Great Patriotic War Putin congratulates leaders and citizens of foreign countries on 80th  anniversary of  Victory in  Great Patriotic War 
Ruling Ruling "Civil Contract" party to  run for 2026 elections  independently
Boycott at Yerevan School  after Pushkin - teachers and students  protest against  dismissal of  institution`s directorBoycott at Yerevan School  after Pushkin - teachers and students  protest against  dismissal of  institution`s director
Germany is Armenia`s reliable partner: Pashinyan congratulates Merz  on assuming officeGermany is Armenia`s reliable partner: Pashinyan congratulates Merz  on assuming office
" Five Human Rights Defenders Initiative ": Nikol Pashinyan`s  behavior is anti-democratic and extremely dangerous
In Armenia, it is now possible to buy and sell vehicles, as well as  register and request license plates onlineIn Armenia, it is now possible to buy and sell vehicles, as well as  register and request license plates online
RA Prosecutor General`s Office striving to improve efficiency of  combating corruptionRA Prosecutor General`s Office striving to improve efficiency of  combating corruption
All cases related to Azerbaijan`s actions are confidential -  Prosecutor GeneralAll cases related to Azerbaijan`s actions are confidential -  Prosecutor General
“My Ameria, My Family” – Lots of Benefits, Raffle of 300+ Gifts and Much More“My Ameria, My Family” – Lots of Benefits, Raffle of 300+ Gifts and Much More
Public and political figures visit Yerablur military pantheon to  commemorate 33rd anniversary of Public and political figures visit Yerablur military pantheon to  commemorate 33rd anniversary of "Wedding in the Mountains" operation
Armenia to eliminate age restrictions for  Police serviceArmenia to eliminate age restrictions for  Police service
Preliminary investigation into October 27 case underway - RA  Prosecutor General Preliminary investigation into October 27 case underway - RA  Prosecutor General 
U.S. Government to support Armenian border guards with equipment,  vehicles U.S. Government to support Armenian border guards with equipment,  vehicles 
RA Prosecutor Gen`s Office often refrains from appealing court  verdicts RA Prosecutor Gen`s Office often refrains from appealing court  verdicts 
Muster of reservists to take place in Armenia June 3 to Aug 22Muster of reservists to take place in Armenia June 3 to Aug 22
Betrayer that surrendered Artsakh and part of Armenia`s territory  seeking to remain in power by lying to people - ARF Betrayer that surrendered Artsakh and part of Armenia`s territory  seeking to remain in power by lying to people - ARF 
Andranik Berberyan`s music performed at opening ceremony of 60th  European Karate ChampionshipAndranik Berberyan`s music performed at opening ceremony of 60th  European Karate Championship
RPA vice-chairman invites Armenia`s premier to public debate RPA vice-chairman invites Armenia`s premier to public debate 
French ambassador to Armenia get aquainted with situation in  Armenia`s Lori after last year`s flood French ambassador to Armenia get aquainted with situation in  Armenia`s Lori after last year`s flood 
Azerbaijani president not to attend military parade in Moscow Azerbaijani president not to attend military parade in Moscow 
Hayordi Camp is the May beneficiary of The Power of One DramHayordi Camp is the May beneficiary of The Power of One Dram
Pashinyan speaks about  events leading up to signing of  Prague  Declaration and  recognition of Artsakh as part of AzerbaijanPashinyan speaks about  events leading up to signing of  Prague  Declaration and  recognition of Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan
Tensions rising again in Armenian parliament,  authorities and  opposition accuse each other of all mortal sinsTensions rising again in Armenian parliament,  authorities and  opposition accuse each other of all mortal sins
Minister: We must recognize the right of the state to defend itself  against terrorismMinister: We must recognize the right of the state to defend itself  against terrorism
Pashinyan: We are not getting ready for early parliamentary electionsPashinyan: We are not getting ready for early parliamentary elections
"Armenia" faction MP explains why it is impossible to impeach  Pashinyan in current political climate
Pashinyan confirms his visit to Moscow to participate in Victory  Parade on May 9Pashinyan confirms his visit to Moscow to participate in Victory  Parade on May 9
Converse Bank Joins the Asian Development Bank`s Green Finance CommitmentConverse Bank Joins the Asian Development Bank`s Green Finance Commitment
Catholicos of All Armenians holds farewell meeting with Ambassador of  BelarusCatholicos of All Armenians holds farewell meeting with Ambassador of  Belarus
Armenia`s Constitution text is in development phase- MinisterArmenia`s Constitution text is in development phase- Minister
Race for  title of <first oppositionist> started: Hayk Konjoryan`s  remarks on  initiative to impeach  Prime MinisterRace for  title of started: Hayk Konjoryan`s  remarks on  initiative to impeach  Prime Minister
 NA Committee Chair, representative of Polish Institute of  International Affairs discuss Armenia`s foreign policy NA Committee Chair, representative of Polish Institute of  International Affairs discuss Armenia`s foreign policy
Armenian, Cypriot Defense Ministers discuss defense cooperationArmenian, Cypriot Defense Ministers discuss defense cooperation
  "80 Lights of Victory" project  launched in Yerevan
US Embassy in Armenia announces  transition to  new online visa  application systemUS Embassy in Armenia announces  transition to  new online visa  application system
Ombudsman of Culture: Fraternal cemetery in occupied Stepanakert   desecrated just before the 80th anniversary of the Victory in the  Great Patriotic WarOmbudsman of Culture: Fraternal cemetery in occupied Stepanakert   desecrated just before the 80th anniversary of the Victory in the  Great Patriotic War
Tougher control to be established over disability documents Tougher control to be established over disability documents 
Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sport, ACMC  sign memorandum on transfer on old church Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sport, ACMC  sign memorandum on transfer on old church 
Environmental patrols to get government guarantees in Armenia Environmental patrols to get government guarantees in Armenia 
Armenia willing to host Centre for investment dispute resolution - RA  Deputy FMArmenia willing to host Centre for investment dispute resolution - RA  Deputy FM
Special wage coefficients to take effect for Armenian army sergeants Special wage coefficients to take effect for Armenian army sergeants 
Severer punishment for breaking traffic rules to take effect in  Armenia Severer punishment for breaking traffic rules to take effect in  Armenia 
River cleaning procedure to be simplified in Armenia River cleaning procedure to be simplified in Armenia 
Read more



Commented