Arminfo.info


 Thursday, August 1 2024 14:21
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Russian expert comments on U.S.-Georgia cooling

Russian expert comments on U.S.-Georgia cooling

ArmInfo. There was no turn towards Moscow named after Mimino and Georgia-film, inflating expectations is not only unnecessary, but also dangerous. This is how Russian political scientist Sergei Markedonov commented on the latest processes in Georgian-American relations. The expert stated that relations between Georgia and the United States are increasingly demonstrating the need for the second law of dialectics for analyzing international processes. According to him, the quantity of problems is gradually turning into their quality.

"Official Washington, through Antony Blinken, announced that the United States would suspend financial aid to the Georgian government in the amount of 95 million US dollars. State Department spokesman Vedant Patel made a small but important clarification: Washington is ready to redirect financial flows to support NGOs and "civil activists." Senators Jeanne Shaheen and Jim Risch proposed the "Georgian People's Act," which offers both "sticks" and "carrots" for Tbilisi. Deputy Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs James O'Brien strongly recommends that the Georgian authorities think again about implementing a joint project with the Chinese to build a deep-water port in Anaklia. The word "sanctions" has already been put into circulation, and the corresponding lists have been compiled. In general, the goals are clear and the tasks have been defined," the political scientist noted.

In this vein, Markedonov asked himself what it is about Tbilisi's behavior that Washington is so unhappy with. The expert is sure that to answer this question, it is extremely important to discard the rhetorical tinsel that complicates understanding the real reasons for the discord between the strategic allies. He noted that for many years, Georgia's foreign policy turn to the West was presented as a kind of "value choice." Markedonov noted that both the Americans and EU representatives contributed to the rooting of this idea.  "Of course, Georgian intellectuals also contributed to the establishment of this explanatory model.  Meanwhile, the so-called "Euro-Atlantic choice" of Tbilisi was not a given once and for all. Georgia joined the CIS in 1993-1994, signed the Collective Security Treaty, and agreed to the presence of Russian troops and border guards on its territory. There were hopes that Moscow would "return" Abkhazia and South Ossetia. When these plans were not realized for various reasons, the eyes of the Georgian establishment were turned not to "the sun rising from the North, but to the sun rising from the West." Just business, nothing personal," the political scientist believes.

In this vein, he recalled that one of the most insightful and less dogmatized British experts on the Caucasus, Thomas de Waal, even

cited data from opinion polls.

"When choosing between the options of "joining NATO/EU" and "restoring territorial integrity," Georgian respondents overwhelmingly choose the latter! Ideological "Westernism" is a fairly superficial phenomenon. It can be defined by Arnold Toynbee's formula as a "critical minority," or it can be called "loud." But the passions surrounding the so-called "foreign agent" bill showed that this is not the "voice of the whole people." Contrary to the predictions of many external observers, "the whole people, as one man," did not rise up against it. This problem is of a peripheral nature for the majority of the population (if you like, the "deep

Georgians")," the expert noted.

At the same time, Markedonov is confident that the current Georgian political class did not "see the light" overnight. According to him, his disappointment in the "political West" is a long and multidimensional process.

"Here are memories of 2008, and promises to marry into NATO/EU with vague prospects of membership, and relations based on the principle of political expediency (Ukraine appeared, Moldova became relevant, Georgia, as a "beacon", was forgotten). In the collision between national interests and abstractions of "democratic solidarity", Bidzina Ivanishvili and Co. chose the former. Once the ancestors of today's Georgian politicians chose the "sun from the North" in comparison with the prospects of the Turkish and Persian luminaries. Then new generations turned to the West, when the warmth from the "northern sun", in their opinion, ceased to warm. If necessary, tomorrow they will choose the "sun from the East" with a Chinese soul, if it promises benefits. No turn to Moscow named Mimino and Georgia-film happened, inflating inflated expectations is not only unnecessary, but also dangerous. But the awareness of that, "It is useful that foreign policy is not built on values alone," the political scientist concluded.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
UAR Head: The West cannot guarantee Armenia`s security UAR Head: The West cannot guarantee Armenia`s security 
Tehran: Iran`s long-standing policy remains unchanged in opposing any  changes to  regional geopolitical mapTehran: Iran`s long-standing policy remains unchanged in opposing any  changes to  regional geopolitical map
ANC: We need a political force that can advance an undistorted and  real peace agendaANC: We need a political force that can advance an undistorted and  real peace agenda
Former Minister:  Nagorno-Karabakh issue to remain alive  until  justice restoredFormer Minister:  Nagorno-Karabakh issue to remain alive  until  justice restored
Zangezur Corridor is a decisive test of US ability to forge mutually  beneficial solutions in contested regions - ForbesZangezur Corridor is a decisive test of US ability to forge mutually  beneficial solutions in contested regions - Forbes
Ambassadors of Armenia and Iran to Russia discuss current  regional  developmentsAmbassadors of Armenia and Iran to Russia discuss current  regional  developments
Artsakh State Minister summoned to RA Investigative CommitteeArtsakh State Minister summoned to RA Investigative Committee
Donald Trump: Armenia and Azerbaijan pretty close to peace dealDonald Trump: Armenia and Azerbaijan pretty close to peace deal
Ruben Hakobyan arrested for 2 monthsRuben Hakobyan arrested for 2 months
Lawyer: Health condition of 18-year-old Andranik Chemichyan, arrested in Lawyer: Health condition of 18-year-old Andranik Chemichyan, arrested in "terrorism" case,  worsened
Azerbaijani FM to leave for GeorgiaAzerbaijani FM to leave for Georgia
Eye for Eye: Draft law  on cinematography puts at risk filmmakers` copyright and freedom Eye for Eye: Draft law  on cinematography puts at risk filmmakers` copyright and freedom 
Romanos Petrosyan appointed interim manager of ENARomanos Petrosyan appointed interim manager of ENA
Ardshinbank vPOS Customers Now Accept Instant Payments with Apple PayArdshinbank vPOS Customers Now Accept Instant Payments with Apple Pay
MP from  MP from  "Armenia" faction: Police  conducting illegal arrests in   Verin Dvin community
Monument to  great Chansonnier unveiled in  YerevanMonument to  great Chansonnier unveiled in  Yerevan
 Tashir Foundation  files lawsuit against Yerevan Municipality Tashir Foundation  files lawsuit against Yerevan Municipality
Online payments via Apple Pay now available for vPOS clients of  Ameriabank Online payments via Apple Pay now available for vPOS clients of  Ameriabank 
Religious freedom advocates urge Armenian government to end attacks  on the ChurchReligious freedom advocates urge Armenian government to end attacks  on the Church
27-year old high-profile murder solved27-year old high-profile murder solved
Hayakve: Samvel Karapetyan`s arrest to contribute to  political  consolidation of oppositionHayakve: Samvel Karapetyan`s arrest to contribute to  political  consolidation of opposition
Political scientist: new project emerging right before our eyes:  Armenia`s gypsyization Political scientist: new project emerging right before our eyes:  Armenia`s gypsyization 
Postanjyan on her removal as a defense attorney: This decision was  dictated by a single center and is aimed at undermining my advocacyPostanjyan on her removal as a defense attorney: This decision was  dictated by a single center and is aimed at undermining my advocacy
Yerevan to host U16 European Volleyball Championship - MOESCSYerevan to host U16 European Volleyball Championship - MOESCS
NA Member: The US is a friendly country for Armenia, and Russia is an  ally. However, the issue doesn`t lie with them, but rather with the  Armenian authoritiesNA Member: The US is a friendly country for Armenia, and Russia is an  ally. However, the issue doesn`t lie with them, but rather with the  Armenian authorities
Belgian House of Representatives adopts resolution condemning  Azerbaijan`s aggression against ArtsakhBelgian House of Representatives adopts resolution condemning  Azerbaijan`s aggression against Artsakh
Diplomat: Iran welcomes normalization of relations between Armenia,  Azerbaijan, and TurkeyDiplomat: Iran welcomes normalization of relations between Armenia,  Azerbaijan, and Turkey
Armenia`s potential involvement in EU regional initiatives discussed  in BrusselsArmenia`s potential involvement in EU regional initiatives discussed  in Brussels
Armenian Deputy PM, Gert-Jan Koopman discuss opportunities for  unblocking regional communications Armenian Deputy PM, Gert-Jan Koopman discuss opportunities for  unblocking regional communications 
Armenian Prime Minister goes on vacationArmenian Prime Minister goes on vacation
Armenian Deputy FM holds talks with Director General of the  International Commission on Missing PersonsArmenian Deputy FM holds talks with Director General of the  International Commission on Missing Persons
Ombudsperson: Training specialists to teach languages of national       minorities is still a relevant issue Ombudsperson: Training specialists to teach languages of national       minorities is still a relevant issue 
EU-Armenia SME Fund, managed by Amber Capital Armenia, invests USD 4 million in Auto Gallery.EU-Armenia SME Fund, managed by Amber Capital Armenia, invests USD 4 million in Auto Gallery.
AraratBank`s “The Will to Get Back on Your Feet Again” Film Series to Be Featured at Armenian National FestivalAraratBank`s “The Will to Get Back on Your Feet Again” Film Series to Be Featured at Armenian National Festival
Politician: In 2019, OSCE Minsk Group submitted two proposals to  RA  Prime MinisterPolitician: In 2019, OSCE Minsk Group submitted two proposals to RA Prime Minister
Armenian Prime Minister receives British AmbassadorArmenian Prime Minister receives British Ambassador
 NA Speaker  receives newly appointed Ambassador of China NA Speaker receives newly appointed Ambassador of China
The Russian Federation is not going to The Russian Federation is not going to "look into the pockets" of Armenia and the European Union - Russian MFA
Armenian Parliament Speaker  discusses  regional security issues with   British Ambassador, who is concluding his missionArmenian Parliament Speaker discusses regional security issues with British Ambassador, who is concluding his mission
Pashinyan dismisses head of  State Control ServicePashinyan dismisses head of State Control Service
Yerevan, Montevideo to sign twinning agreementYerevan, Montevideo to sign twinning agreement
Armenia-UK defense cooperation discussed in YerevanArmenia-UK defense cooperation discussed in Yerevan
Representatives of Ombudsman Office  visit arrested mother of three  minorsRepresentatives of Ombudsman Office visit arrested mother of three minors
RA Security Council Secretary  holds phone conversation with his  counterpart from IranRA Security Council Secretary  holds phone conversation with his  counterpart from Iran
Shahverdyan: Aliyev shows Berdimuhamedov  Upper Mosque of Shushi  restored by Ruben VardanyanShahverdyan: Aliyev shows Berdimuhamedov  Upper Mosque of Shushi  restored by Ruben Vardanyan
Georgian Prime Minister tells what their choice will be if faced with  decision between peace and stability and visa-free regimeGeorgian Prime Minister tells what their choice will be if faced with  decision between peace and stability and visa-free regime
Armenian Prime Minister holds farewell meeting with Lebanese  AmbassadorArmenian Prime Minister holds farewell meeting with Lebanese  Ambassador
Samvel Karapetyan`s nephew mentions three fakes that Armenian  authorities will use against  new political forceSamvel Karapetyan`s nephew mentions three fakes that Armenian  authorities will use against  new political force
RA government  to allocate necessary financial resources  to prepare  Armenian athletes for   2028 Olympic Games RA government  to allocate necessary financial resources  to prepare  Armenian athletes for   2028 Olympic Games 
Armenia, Greece to cooperate to protect and maintain cultural valuesArmenia, Greece to cooperate to protect and maintain cultural values
Efforts to ensure successful organization and execution of COP-17  conference will continueEfforts to ensure successful organization and execution of COP-17  conference will continue
ECHR requests information from Armenia about detention conditions of   arrested mother of three minor childrenECHR requests information from Armenia about detention conditions of   arrested mother of three minor children
Diplomatic relations have been established between Turkmenistan and the Republic of RwandaDiplomatic relations have been established between Turkmenistan and the Republic of Rwanda
A telephone conversation took place between the heads of the Foreign Ministries of Turkmenistan and the Republic of CroatiaA telephone conversation took place between the heads of the Foreign Ministries of Turkmenistan and the Republic of Croatia
Kremlin: Russia  is interested in collaboration with Armenia in all  directionsKremlin: Russia  is interested in collaboration with Armenia in all  directions
Idram at Tech Week 2025Idram at Tech Week 2025
Ucom Subscribers Increasingly Use Internet While RoamingUcom Subscribers Increasingly Use Internet While Roaming
Signing ceremony for  EIB financing of  Armenia - Sustainable Syunik program held in LuxembourgSigning ceremony for  EIB financing of  Armenia - Sustainable Syunik program held in Luxembourg
Ardshinbank: the Driving Force of Armenia`s EconomyArdshinbank: the Driving Force of Armenia`s Economy
Pashinyan: The document with OSCE Minsk Group proposals  is a result of negotiations during Serzh Sargsyan`s presidency Pashinyan: The document with OSCE Minsk Group proposals  is a result of negotiations during Serzh Sargsyan`s presidency 
Read more



Commented