Monday, April 15 2024 14:45
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Orientalist: Iran responded to Israel asymmetrically, thereby raising  escalation bar in Middle East

Orientalist: Iran responded to Israel asymmetrically, thereby raising  escalation bar in Middle East

ArmInfo. Iran responded to Israel asymmetrically, thereby raising the bar for escalation in the Middle East. This is how APRI Armenia researcher and orientalist Sergei Melkonyan commented on Iran's attack on Israel on the night of April 13.

The expert noted that initially there was confidence that Iran would  respond as symmetrically as it has done many times: either attacks on  Israel with the help of its allies in Syria, Iraq, Lebanon and Yemen,  or attacks would be on Israeli positions in the region. According to  him, this attack was unprecedented in this sense, since Iran hit  Israel from its territory.

According to Melkonyan, the following conclusions can be drawn.

"Firstly, Iran responded asymmetrically, thereby raising the bar of  escalation. Therefore, with a high degree of probability, one can  expect a response from the Israeli side. Amid ongoing discussions,  few want to escalate the situation, so the response may be limited to  saving face.  Secondly, we can assume that a new model of Iran's  behavior in the region is being formed. That is, in the event of a  similar crossing of red lines, attacks from Iran on Israel may  gradually become the norm for the region.

Third, the divergences in the Arab world have become more visible.  Some states, mainly from the Persian Gulf, openly stated that they  would not provide their territory to the United States to repel the  attack.  Others, for example, Jordan, have actually integrated into  the military format of cooperation with Israel and the United  States," the orientalist noted.

At the same time, the expert drew attention to the important  consequences of this blow.

In the context of the economic consequences, Melkonyan noted that,  according to various estimates, repelling the attack cost $1-1.5  billion for Israel and the United States. "Tehran used a well-known  arsenal, but in minimal quantities. In the event of more dense  attacks, the possibility of which Iran has, Israel will have serious  problems with security costs. In this sense, the advantage is on the  side of Iran, for which the production of these missiles and UAVs  costs almost ten times less," the orientalist is sure.

From the point of view of domestic political consequences for Israel,  according to the Armenian expert, Bibi actually got what he wanted.  "The crisis in relations with the United States against the backdrop  of differences over the operation in Rafah has faded into the  background before the closest possible cooperation due to the threat  from Iran. Thus, pressure on Bibi from the outside may be reduced. In  many ways, Netanyahu's main trump card, which would allow him to keep  power against the backdrop of both external and internal pressure was  an increase in stakes, namely, the escalation with Iran, which was  caused after Israel's attack on the Iranian consulate in Damascus,"  he noted.

Speaking about the military-technical consequences, Melkonyan stated  that Iranian missiles "passed their test" in the sense that they were  used for their intended purpose for the first time.  "At the same  time, as follows from the reports, a small part hit the targets. The  Israeli air defense system again confirmed its reliability, albeit at  a high cost. Now the parties can switch places, and Israeli  missiles/drones and the Iranian air defense system will be tested. If  Israel wants to reduce the intensity and stop the course of  developments, then the strikes should be directed not at Iran, but at  its allies," the expert noted.

In conclusion, touching on the diplomatic component of the issue,  Melkonyan noted that it would be interesting to look at the  statements of the main powers: some will condemn, and others will  make reference to the UN Charter and Iran's right to defense. "And  then it will become clear that external forces are not interested in  a regional war," the orientalist concluded. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
An American journalist criticized foreign diplomats who visited occupied Artsakh.An American journalist criticized foreign diplomats who visited occupied Artsakh.
Former Artsakh official to foreign diplomats: You must not allow ethnic cleansing in the NKR to be turned into a tourist routeFormer Artsakh official to foreign diplomats: You must not allow ethnic cleansing in the NKR to be turned into a tourist route
Opposition MP asked Armenia’s ombudsperson to discuss her steps to protect Armenian prisoners of war held in BakuOpposition MP asked Armenia’s ombudsperson to discuss her steps to protect Armenian prisoners of war held in Baku
Opinion: Armen Grigoryan and those like him have made Armenia’s security and territorial integrity a subject of bargainingOpinion: Armen Grigoryan and those like him have made Armenia’s security and territorial integrity a subject of bargaining
Armenian authorities have decided to play the 102nd Russian Military Base card in the matter of a possible increase in gas prices for the republicArmenian authorities have decided to play the 102nd Russian Military Base card in the matter of a possible increase in gas prices for the republic
An Armenian historian harshly criticized the visit of Western coalition diplomats to occupied ArtsakhAn Armenian historian harshly criticized the visit of Western coalition diplomats to occupied Artsakh
Tsarukyan from the NSS basements: Armenia is at a very difficult historical stageTsarukyan from the NSS basements: Armenia is at a very difficult historical stage
Narek Karapetyan: In the 2026 parliamentary elections, four opposition forces received 80% more votes than in 2021Narek Karapetyan: In the 2026 parliamentary elections, four opposition forces received 80% more votes than in 2021
Armenian expert: TRIPP and European integration are incompatibleArmenian expert: TRIPP and European integration are incompatible
Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia spoke about the country’s preparations for COP17 on the sidelines of the 32nd OSCE Economic and Environmental ForumDeputy Foreign Minister of Armenia spoke about the country’s preparations for COP17 on the sidelines of the 32nd OSCE Economic and Environmental Forum
Pakistan`s first ambassador presented his credentials to the President of ArmeniaPakistan`s first ambassador presented his credentials to the President of Armenia
Ameriabank presented technological solutions in the customer service sector at the 4Future banking conference.Ameriabank presented technological solutions in the customer service sector at the 4Future banking conference.
The Lebanese President discussed bilateral relations with the Armenian AmbassadorThe Lebanese President discussed bilateral relations with the Armenian Ambassador
The Deputy Minister of Defense of Armenia and the Chief of the General Staff of the Polish Armed Forces discussed prospects for expanding military cooperation.The Deputy Minister of Defense of Armenia and the Chief of the General Staff of the Polish Armed Forces discussed prospects for expanding military cooperation.
Armenia`s Deputy Minister of Environment discussed prospects for green finance development in the country with World Bank partners.Armenia`s Deputy Minister of Environment discussed prospects for green finance development in the country with World Bank partners.
Legislative changes related to the property confiscation mechanism are being prepared in Armenia.Legislative changes related to the property confiscation mechanism are being prepared in Armenia.
Samvel Karapetyan: Armenian prisoners of war will not return from Baku while Pashinyan is in powerSamvel Karapetyan: Armenian prisoners of war will not return from Baku while Pashinyan is in power
Team Telecom Armenia is the technology partner of the Tour of Armenia.Team Telecom Armenia is the technology partner of the Tour of Armenia.
Samvel Karapetyan: “Strong Armenia” is developing a program to turn Tigranashen into a tourist centerSamvel Karapetyan: “Strong Armenia” is developing a program to turn Tigranashen into a tourist center
Armenia’s Foreign Minister Met with Pakistan’s First Ambassador to the CountryArmenia’s Foreign Minister Met with Pakistan’s First Ambassador to the Country
Samvel Karapetyan: Armenia will be left defenseless if the 102nd Russian military base is withdrawnSamvel Karapetyan: Armenia will be left defenseless if the 102nd Russian military base is withdrawn
Samvel Karapetyan: ESA will be returned to its rightful ownerSamvel Karapetyan: ESA will be returned to its rightful owner
More than 70% of respondents consider discrimination in Armenia a serious problem - CRRC-Armenia studyMore than 70% of respondents consider discrimination in Armenia a serious problem - CRRC-Armenia study
The prospects for further deepening and expanding relations between Armenia and Russia were discussed in the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia.The prospects for further deepening and expanding relations between Armenia and Russia were discussed in the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia.
NAS RA: Armenia—A Platform for Scientific and Cultural Dialogue Between Europe and IndiaNAS RA: Armenia—A Platform for Scientific and Cultural Dialogue Between Europe and India
Issues concerning the development of interparliamentary relations between Armenia and Russia were discussed in YerevanIssues concerning the development of interparliamentary relations between Armenia and Russia were discussed in Yerevan
The Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia and the European Public Prosecutor`s Office signed a cooperation agreementThe Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia and the European Public Prosecutor`s Office signed a cooperation agreement
“Strong Armenia” Responds to Pashinyan’s Claims That Calling Tigranashen Armenian Territory Would Lead to War“Strong Armenia” Responds to Pashinyan’s Claims That Calling Tigranashen Armenian Territory Would Lead to War
Meeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with the State Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry of JapanMeeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with the State Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry of Japan
The office of Armenia`s second president reminded Pashinyan of Mussolini`s fateThe office of Armenia`s second president reminded Pashinyan of Mussolini`s fate
The President of Uzbekistan Advocated Strengthening Connectivity by Developing Transport Corridors Linking the Regions of Central Asia and the South CaucasusThe President of Uzbekistan Advocated Strengthening Connectivity by Developing Transport Corridors Linking the Regions of Central Asia and the South Caucasus
Armenia intends to sign a protocol amending the Council of Europe Convention on the Prevention of TerrorismArmenia intends to sign a protocol amending the Council of Europe Convention on the Prevention of Terrorism
Armenian authorities plan to update the official text of the oath taken by government members, adapting it to the concept of “Real Armenia”Armenian authorities plan to update the official text of the oath taken by government members, adapting it to the concept of “Real Armenia”
Head of the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports: Armenia highly values the friendship and partnership established with Switzerland on the basis of mutual trustHead of the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports: Armenia highly values the friendship and partnership established with Switzerland on the basis of mutual trust
An opposition lawmaker proposed holding discussions on the Armenian prisoners of war held by BakuAn opposition lawmaker proposed holding discussions on the Armenian prisoners of war held by Baku
The Catholicos of All Armenians expressed his gratitude to the “French Light” association for supporting Armenia’s medical institutions.The Catholicos of All Armenians expressed his gratitude to the “French Light” association for supporting Armenia’s medical institutions.
Alen Simonyan: There is no agreement on my visit to BakuAlen Simonyan: There is no agreement on my visit to Baku
Gas in Armenia is not cheap – Prime MinisterGas in Armenia is not cheap – Prime Minister
Interior Ministry: Recently, there has been an increase in the number of drugs detected and removed from illicit circulationInterior Ministry: Recently, there has been an increase in the number of drugs detected and removed from illicit circulation
“Country to Live”: Banning regional transport from entering Yerevan will not solve the capital’s traffic congestion problem“Country to Live”: Banning regional transport from entering Yerevan will not solve the capital’s traffic congestion problem
Vaginak Vardanov Appointed Deputy Chair of the National Assembly Committee on Defense and SecurityVaginak Vardanov Appointed Deputy Chair of the National Assembly Committee on Defense and Security
Arush Arushanyan will run in the local self-government elections from the <Solidarity> blocArush Arushanyan will run in the local self-government elections from the bloc
Armenia Intends to Ratify the Treaty on the Procedure for Organizing and Conducting an International Controlled DeliveryArmenia Intends to Ratify the Treaty on the Procedure for Organizing and Conducting an International Controlled Delivery
Hajiyev: The latest meeting between the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan took place in a very constructive atmosphereHajiyev: The latest meeting between the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan took place in a very constructive atmosphere
Armenia and Luxembourg intend to deepen cooperation in the field of criminal justiceArmenia and Luxembourg intend to deepen cooperation in the field of criminal justice
The Armenian government will allocate 20.4 million drams to create a unified sports management platformThe Armenian government will allocate 20.4 million drams to create a unified sports management platform
Armenia’s Investigative Committee and China’s Ministry of Public Security Sign Memorandum of UnderstandingArmenia’s Investigative Committee and China’s Ministry of Public Security Sign Memorandum of Understanding
The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the Ambassador of Bulgaria Discussed Prospects for Developing Bilateral CooperationThe Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the Ambassador of Bulgaria Discussed Prospects for Developing Bilateral Cooperation
Armed Forces of Armenia Delegation Learns About the Capabilities of the Indian Air ForceArmed Forces of Armenia Delegation Learns About the Capabilities of the Indian Air Force
The stage of the <GOY> theater has been dismantledThe stage of the theater has been dismantled
Leaders of Armenia and Uzbekistan Discussed the Issue of Unblocking CommunicationsLeaders of Armenia and Uzbekistan Discussed the Issue of Unblocking Communications
“Hayaqve” supported the initiative of the Artsakh authorities to begin political consultations with Armenia’s parliamentary and extra-parliamentary forces.“Hayaqve” supported the initiative of the Artsakh authorities to begin political consultations with Armenia’s parliamentary and extra-parliamentary forces.
Armenia and Poland to Deepen Cooperation in the Defense SectorArmenia and Poland to Deepen Cooperation in the Defense Sector
Former Armenian MP: By invading Armenian territory, Azerbaijan pursued a specific goal—the control of its infrastructure and resourcesFormer Armenian MP: By invading Armenian territory, Azerbaijan pursued a specific goal—the control of its infrastructure and resources
“Strong Armenia” stated that handing over Tigranashen was unacceptable and proposed a development strategy for the village.“Strong Armenia” stated that handing over Tigranashen was unacceptable and proposed a development strategy for the village.
Sharp warming expected in ArmeniaSharp warming expected in Armenia
Russia and Türkiye emphasize their interest in continuing the work of the 3+3 Regional Cooperation Platform.Russia and Türkiye emphasize their interest in continuing the work of the 3+3 Regional Cooperation Platform.
The development of educational infrastructure and the progress of modernization of school buildings were discussed with the head of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian FederationThe development of educational infrastructure and the progress of modernization of school buildings were discussed with the head of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation
Multi-sectoral cooperation between Armenia and Poland was discussed in Yerevan.Multi-sectoral cooperation between Armenia and Poland was discussed in Yerevan.
Polish Secretary of State: Warsaw is ready to continue supporting Armenia`s reform programPolish Secretary of State: Warsaw is ready to continue supporting Armenia`s reform program
Read more



Commented
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place
Political scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and strugglePolitical scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and struggle
Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.
Zakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itselfZakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itself
Putin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent characterPutin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent character
Putin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic UnionPutin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic Union
Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.
Aram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  ParliamentAram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  Parliament
Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs 
 "In Baku, we gave a worthy rebuff to the false claims regarding the  past and present of our people" – Former Artsakh Parliament Speaker  from Baku captivity 
NA Vice Speaker candidate  believes his wife`s salary as director of  HayPost is the lowest in the company`s historyNA Vice Speaker candidate  believes his wife`s salary as director of  HayPost is the lowest in the company`s history
RF Permanent Representative: There is no CSTO-Armenia conflictRF Permanent Representative: There is no CSTO-Armenia conflict
Moscow: NATO seeking to Moscow: NATO seeking to "Pull" Armenia away from CSTO Allies
Political analyst: Russia intends to determine which Political analyst: Russia intends to determine which "Camp" Armenia  will choose through a referendum
Narek Karapetyan will give up his parliamentary salary in favor of charitable contributions.Narek Karapetyan will give up his parliamentary salary in favor of charitable contributions.