Arminfo.info



 Friday, September 22 2023 18:12
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

ArmInfo. In an exclusive interview for Blankspot, genocide researcher Melanie O'Brien explains  why the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh can be considered an ongoing genocide.

Already two years ago, Melanie O'Brien, Chair of the International  Association of Genocide Scholars, warned that the developments in  Nagorno-Karabakh could be likened to genocide. Two years later, her  concerns have been repeatedly confirmed to the extent that she and  her colleagues have appealed to the UN to stop what is happening.

Despite this, the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh has turned into a  full-scale offensive where the Armenian civilian population is given  no way to flee.

In an exclusive interview with Blankspot, she explains why  Azerbaijan's actions constitute genocide.

In addition to being the chair of the Genocide Studies Society, she  is currently a visiting professor at the Center for Holocaust and  Genocide Studies at the University of Minnesota in the USA.

What are the legal arguments for calling it genocide?

"It is clear that Azerbaijan is attacking the Armenians of  Nagorno-Karabakh because they are Armenians.  Therefore, the group is  being targeted as an ethnic and, or, national group, both of which  are protected groups under the Genocide Convention", says Melanie  O'Brien.

She continues to argue that the genocide process excelled with the  blockade of the Latjinkorridor.

"However, since the blockade of the Lachin Corridor, the deliberate  starvation and denial of access to healthcare demonstrates an intent  not just to ethnically cleanse Nagorno-Karabakh of Armenians, but to  physically destroy them. Denial of food and healthcare only leads to  death, and these actions are a crucial part of genocide, which we  have seen in other genocides including the Holocaust, the Armenian  Genocide, the Cambodian Genocide and the Rohingya Genocide"

How do the developments of the last few days affect this?

"Azerbaijan said it would open the Lachin Corridor to let residents  of Nagorno-Karabakh out. However, they won't be able to return. Thus,  the choice of those 120,000 people in Nagorno-Karabakh is: stay and  suffer genocide through starvation and lack of healthcare. This is  despite the fact that the International Court of Justice in The Hague  (ICJ) has made it clear to Azerbaijan that the blockade of the Lachin  Corridor creates a direct risk to Armenians."

Melanie O'Brien also argues that Azerbaijan is fully aware of this.

"Azerbaijan is aware of the order from The Hague but continues the  blockade. In addition, Azerbaijan has bombed civilian areas in recent  days, which is also considered a war crime. Thousands have fled from  villages that Azerbaijan has taken and occupied without anywhere else  to go but to other parts of Nagorno- Karabakh. Azerbaijan is now  killing by bombing, starvation and denial of healthcare."

She points out that Azerbaijan has committed to delivering fuel and  food.

"Azerbaijan has said it will deliver food and fuel to  Nagorno-Karabakh, but it remains seen as to whether this will be  done, after 9 months of denying such humanitarian needs."

You warned several years ago that it was beginning to resemble  genocide, what has happened since then?

"The risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh, including hate speech and destruction of Armenian  cultural heritage sites such as churches. Hate speech and  demonization have occurred, among other things, from leaders in the  country, in the media, and in school education.  However, from  December 2022, when Azerbaijan blocked the Lachin Corridor and  subsequently other roads out of Nagorno-Karabakh, this is when we saw  the risk of genocide rise, and once this blockade continued, it has  become genocide. This is because the people of Nagorno-Karabakh have  been unable to leave the enclave".  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Turkmenistan Secures its Seat on UN Commission on Population and Development for 2024-2028Turkmenistan Secures its Seat on UN Commission on Population and Development for 2024-2028
RA lawmaker: Armenia will sign peace treaty when it is confident that  it corresponds to country`s national interestsRA lawmaker: Armenia will sign peace treaty when it is confident that  it corresponds to country`s national interests
Return of 32 Armenian POWs from Azerbaijani must take place in  nearest time- MPReturn of 32 Armenian POWs from Azerbaijani must take place in  nearest time- MP
Armenia welcomes U.S. Sec of State`s proposal to hold Armenian,  Azerbaijani FMs` meeting Armenia welcomes U.S. Sec of State`s proposal to hold Armenian,  Azerbaijani FMs` meeting 
Armenia`s vice-speaker, OSCE MG co-chair discuss regional  developments Armenia`s vice-speaker, OSCE MG co-chair discuss regional  developments 
Yerevan, Baku share opinion on historic chance to achieve  long-awaited peace in regionYerevan, Baku share opinion on historic chance to achieve  long-awaited peace in region
Early presidential election to enable Aliyev to prepare for new war  against Armenia with `people`s mandate` - expert Early presidential election to enable Aliyev to prepare for new war  against Armenia with `people`s mandate` - expert 
ECHR rejects complaint of Constitutional Court ex-judges against  ArmeniaECHR rejects complaint of Constitutional Court ex-judges against  Armenia
Nassim Taleb on Ruben Vardanyan: Nassim Taleb on Ruben Vardanyan: "he is treated as "terrorist"
Azerbaijan`s attempts to portray Armenia as anti-Semitic country did  not work - Israeli analystAzerbaijan`s attempts to portray Armenia as anti-Semitic country did  not work - Israeli analyst
Alen Simonyan: Azerbaijan is trying to artificially complicate   conclusion of a peace treatyAlen Simonyan: Azerbaijan is trying to artificially complicate   conclusion of a peace treaty
Guilty without guilt: Baku court sentences POW Voskanyan to 18 years  in prison Guilty without guilt: Baku court sentences POW Voskanyan to 18 years  in prison 
Syrian ambassador to Armenia: Syria is interested in expanding  cooperation with Armenia in various fields of artSyrian ambassador to Armenia: Syria is interested in expanding  cooperation with Armenia in various fields of art
Alen Simonyan: Whether Artsakh people return to their homeland or not  is a matter of timeAlen Simonyan: Whether Artsakh people return to their homeland or not  is a matter of time
The Power of One Dram to the Health Fund for Children of ArmeniaThe Power of One Dram to the Health Fund for Children of Armenia
Alen Simonyan: At moment, no discussions or agreements have been  reached regarding Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting Alen Simonyan: At moment, no discussions or agreements have been  reached regarding Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting 
Consultations with Russian side regarding violations of  Armenian-Russian broadcasting agreement to be held this year -  minister Consultations with Russian side regarding violations of  Armenian-Russian broadcasting agreement to be held this year -  minister 
Early presidential election to take place in Azerbaijan on February 7Early presidential election to take place in Azerbaijan on February 7
Ukraine appoints new charge d`affaires ad interim in ArmeniaUkraine appoints new charge d`affaires ad interim in Armenia
Spitak earthquake commemorated in ArmeniaSpitak earthquake commemorated in Armenia
Armenian delegation`s absence from CSTO PA meeting not to affect  decision on joint air defense system - Russian officialArmenian delegation`s absence from CSTO PA meeting not to affect  decision on joint air defense system - Russian official
Armenian FM considers his recent meeting with Sergei Lavrov  productiveArmenian FM considers his recent meeting with Sergei Lavrov  productive
Deputy PM: Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation is rather complex  and lengthy processDeputy PM: Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation is rather complex  and lengthy process
Armenia attaches particular importance to establishing diplomatic  relations with Saudi Arabia - MirzoyanArmenia attaches particular importance to establishing diplomatic  relations with Saudi Arabia - Mirzoyan
Law is law, and while it is in force, it must be followed - Prime  MinisterLaw is law, and while it is in force, it must be followed - Prime  Minister
We don`t kill politicians, unlike our predecessors: Pashinyan answers  question of  former president`s MP sonWe don`t kill politicians, unlike our predecessors: Pashinyan answers  question of  former president`s MP son
Pashinyan: My task is the future of ArmeniaPashinyan: My task is the future of Armenia
Civil Contract unilaterally terminates memorandum of cooperation with  Balasanyan Bloc partyCivil Contract unilaterally terminates memorandum of cooperation with  Balasanyan Bloc party
Saakashvili continues to advise Pashinyan to stay away from Russia as  much as possibleSaakashvili continues to advise Pashinyan to stay away from Russia as  much as possible
Developments in Alaverdi can be described as victory for law-  ministerDevelopments in Alaverdi can be described as victory for law-  minister
Zakharova: It was precisely at Westerners` instigation that not  single word was mentioned about rights and security of Karabakh  ArmeniansZakharova: It was precisely at Westerners` instigation that not  single word was mentioned about rights and security of Karabakh  Armenians
Footage posted by Azerbaijani Footage posted by Azerbaijani "military expert" was taken in 2017 -  NSS
Armenia, Egypt discuss opportunities for cooperation in military  industryArmenia, Egypt discuss opportunities for cooperation in military  industry
Armenian PM: everything that is associated with lack of institutional  mechanisms cannot be considered justiceArmenian PM: everything that is associated with lack of institutional  mechanisms cannot be considered justice
What happened in Alaverdi community seizure of power - Arman Tatoyan What happened in Alaverdi community seizure of power - Arman Tatoyan 
U.S. Senator Ben Cardin urges U.S. Secretary of State to remain  focused on holding Aliyev regime accountable for ethnic cleansing in  Nagorno-KarabakhU.S. Senator Ben Cardin urges U.S. Secretary of State to remain  focused on holding Aliyev regime accountable for ethnic cleansing in  Nagorno-Karabakh
Gyumri blacksmithing tradition inscribed in UNESCO`s Intangible  Cultural Heritage of HumanityGyumri blacksmithing tradition inscribed in UNESCO`s Intangible  Cultural Heritage of Humanity
Dropping all diplomatic engagements with Azerbaijan would be against  the interests of peace and security in the region - U.S. Department  of StateDropping all diplomatic engagements with Azerbaijan would be against  the interests of peace and security in the region - U.S. Department  of State
U.S. ambassador to Armenia delivers humanitarian aid to forcibly  displaced people in LoriU.S. ambassador to Armenia delivers humanitarian aid to forcibly  displaced people in Lori
India, as G20 member state, supports any initiative aimed at  achieving peace - AmbassadorIndia, as G20 member state, supports any initiative aimed at  achieving peace - Ambassador
Federation Council, State Duma comment on Armenian parliamentarians`  decision not to participate in CSTO PA in MoscowFederation Council, State Duma comment on Armenian parliamentarians`  decision not to participate in CSTO PA in Moscow
Tense situation in Armenia`s Alaverdi due to dismissal of mayorTense situation in Armenia`s Alaverdi due to dismissal of mayor
Borrell on Azeri aggression in Karabakh conflict zone: Azerbaijan`s  military intervention made 150,000 people move in one week Borrell on Azeri aggression in Karabakh conflict zone: Azerbaijan`s  military intervention made 150,000 people move in one week 
Meeting of the Ministers of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan and RussiaMeeting of the Ministers of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan and Russia
Swedish MP considers Azerbaijani rhetoric towards Armenia bizarreSwedish MP considers Azerbaijani rhetoric towards Armenia bizarre
List of intangible cultural heritage values of Armenia in need of  immediate protection supplemented with new elementsList of intangible cultural heritage values of Armenia in need of  immediate protection supplemented with new elements
EU technical mission to discuss details of Armenia-EU defense  cooperation - EU Ambassador to ArmeniaEU technical mission to discuss details of Armenia-EU defense  cooperation - EU Ambassador to Armenia
Armenian NA speaker not to take part in CSTO PA Council`s meetingArmenian NA speaker not to take part in CSTO PA Council`s meeting
Government of Azerbaijan has no intentions of peace - Arman TatoyanGovernment of Azerbaijan has no intentions of peace - Arman Tatoyan
Will you judge the Russian President for recognizing Artsakh as part  of Azerbaijan? - Alen Simonyan to opposition Will you judge the Russian President for recognizing Artsakh as part  of Azerbaijan? - Alen Simonyan to opposition 
60 U.S. Senators and Representatives call for increased security aid  for Armenia, humanitarian assistance for Artsakh refugees60 U.S. Senators and Representatives call for increased security aid  for Armenia, humanitarian assistance for Artsakh refugees
Armenia`s authorities destroying parliamentarism - opposition MPArmenia`s authorities destroying parliamentarism - opposition MP
Armenian Security Council Sec, U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of  Defense discuss defense cooperationArmenian Security Council Sec, U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of  Defense discuss defense cooperation
Construction in Shushi cause of devastating toll to to Armenian sites  - Caucasus Heritage WatchConstruction in Shushi cause of devastating toll to to Armenian sites  - Caucasus Heritage Watch
EU special rep reacts to killing of Armenian serviceman EU special rep reacts to killing of Armenian serviceman 
Collective failure in genocide prevention should not be a  justification for individual inaction for each and every UN member  state - Armenian FMCollective failure in genocide prevention should not be a  justification for individual inaction for each and every UN member  state - Armenian FM
Armenia, Russia not to go to court under failed arms supply contractArmenia, Russia not to go to court under failed arms supply contract
Armenian-Greek Research Center in Athens starts publishing  Greek-language Armenian maganzineArmenian-Greek Research Center in Athens starts publishing  Greek-language Armenian maganzine
Armenian film director Suren Babayan dies aged 73Armenian film director Suren Babayan dies aged 73
EU-Armenia Civil Society platform concerned about processes  surrounding election of two Commission membersEU-Armenia Civil Society platform concerned about processes  surrounding election of two Commission members
Read more



Commented