Friday, September 22 2023 18:12
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

ArmInfo. In an exclusive interview for Blankspot, genocide researcher Melanie O'Brien explains  why the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh can be considered an ongoing genocide.

Already two years ago, Melanie O'Brien, Chair of the International  Association of Genocide Scholars, warned that the developments in  Nagorno-Karabakh could be likened to genocide. Two years later, her  concerns have been repeatedly confirmed to the extent that she and  her colleagues have appealed to the UN to stop what is happening.

Despite this, the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh has turned into a  full-scale offensive where the Armenian civilian population is given  no way to flee.

In an exclusive interview with Blankspot, she explains why  Azerbaijan's actions constitute genocide.

In addition to being the chair of the Genocide Studies Society, she  is currently a visiting professor at the Center for Holocaust and  Genocide Studies at the University of Minnesota in the USA.

What are the legal arguments for calling it genocide?

"It is clear that Azerbaijan is attacking the Armenians of  Nagorno-Karabakh because they are Armenians.  Therefore, the group is  being targeted as an ethnic and, or, national group, both of which  are protected groups under the Genocide Convention", says Melanie  O'Brien.

She continues to argue that the genocide process excelled with the  blockade of the Latjinkorridor.

"However, since the blockade of the Lachin Corridor, the deliberate  starvation and denial of access to healthcare demonstrates an intent  not just to ethnically cleanse Nagorno-Karabakh of Armenians, but to  physically destroy them. Denial of food and healthcare only leads to  death, and these actions are a crucial part of genocide, which we  have seen in other genocides including the Holocaust, the Armenian  Genocide, the Cambodian Genocide and the Rohingya Genocide"

How do the developments of the last few days affect this?

"Azerbaijan said it would open the Lachin Corridor to let residents  of Nagorno-Karabakh out. However, they won't be able to return. Thus,  the choice of those 120,000 people in Nagorno-Karabakh is: stay and  suffer genocide through starvation and lack of healthcare. This is  despite the fact that the International Court of Justice in The Hague  (ICJ) has made it clear to Azerbaijan that the blockade of the Lachin  Corridor creates a direct risk to Armenians."

Melanie O'Brien also argues that Azerbaijan is fully aware of this.

"Azerbaijan is aware of the order from The Hague but continues the  blockade. In addition, Azerbaijan has bombed civilian areas in recent  days, which is also considered a war crime. Thousands have fled from  villages that Azerbaijan has taken and occupied without anywhere else  to go but to other parts of Nagorno- Karabakh. Azerbaijan is now  killing by bombing, starvation and denial of healthcare."

She points out that Azerbaijan has committed to delivering fuel and  food.

"Azerbaijan has said it will deliver food and fuel to  Nagorno-Karabakh, but it remains seen as to whether this will be  done, after 9 months of denying such humanitarian needs."

You warned several years ago that it was beginning to resemble  genocide, what has happened since then?

"The risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh, including hate speech and destruction of Armenian  cultural heritage sites such as churches. Hate speech and  demonization have occurred, among other things, from leaders in the  country, in the media, and in school education.  However, from  December 2022, when Azerbaijan blocked the Lachin Corridor and  subsequently other roads out of Nagorno-Karabakh, this is when we saw  the risk of genocide rise, and once this blockade continued, it has  become genocide. This is because the people of Nagorno-Karabakh have  been unable to leave the enclave".  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Samvel Karapetyan was transferred from the Investigative Committee to the court for a decision on a preventive measure.Samvel Karapetyan was transferred from the Investigative Committee to the court for a decision on a preventive measure.
This year, the Shakespeare & Co international festival program will also include Russian classics.This year, the Shakespeare & Co international festival program will also include Russian classics.
Democrats won the elections to the House of Representatives and the Senate.Democrats won the elections to the House of Representatives and the Senate.
From November 5 to December 28, traffic on the lower section of the Lambada Bridge will be partially restricted, according to Yerevan Municipality.From November 5 to December 28, traffic on the lower section of the Lambada Bridge will be partially restricted, according to Yerevan Municipality.
Narek Karapetyan considers the Investigative Committee of Armenia`s accusations against Samvel Karapetyan regarding the misuse of ESA funds absurd.Narek Karapetyan considers the Investigative Committee of Armenia`s accusations against Samvel Karapetyan regarding the misuse of ESA funds absurd.
Lawyers: The ECHR`s ruling on Azerbaijan`s liability for the torture and murder of an Armenian soldier has entered into force.Lawyers: The ECHR`s ruling on Azerbaijan`s liability for the torture and murder of an Armenian soldier has entered into force.
Armenia`s Health Minister: One child injured in a traffic accident on the Yerevan-Ashtarak highway has been discharged, while the condition of two children remains serious.Armenia`s Health Minister: One child injured in a traffic accident on the Yerevan-Ashtarak highway has been discharged, while the condition of two children remains serious.
Dozens of citizens gathered outside the court where the issue of Gagik Tsarukyan s preventive measure is being considered.Dozens of citizens gathered outside the court where the issue of Gagik Tsarukyan s preventive measure is being considered.
Azerbaijan has declared 14 Iranian citizens, including members of the Majlis, personae non gratae.Azerbaijan has declared 14 Iranian citizens, including members of the Majlis, personae non gratae.
Human rights activist: Simultaneous searches at 60 addresses associated with Strong Armenia should be viewed in the context of criminal intentHuman rights activist: Simultaneous searches at 60 addresses associated with Strong Armenia should be viewed in the context of criminal intent
Levon Kocharyan: What`s happening around Levon Kocharyan: What`s happening around "Strong Armenia" has nothing to do with law and legitimacy
The National Academy of Sciences of Armenia and the Northwestern Polytechnical University of China signed a memorandum of cooperationThe National Academy of Sciences of Armenia and the Northwestern Polytechnical University of China signed a memorandum of cooperation
Yerevan notes the importance of intensifying Armenian-Hungarian relations and deepening parliamentary cooperationYerevan notes the importance of intensifying Armenian-Hungarian relations and deepening parliamentary cooperation
Armenian National Security Service officers have detained Samvel Karapetyan, the leader of the Strong Armenia opposition party, for the second time.Armenian National Security Service officers have detained Samvel Karapetyan, the leader of the Strong Armenia opposition party, for the second time.
The Investigative Committee accuses Samvel Karapetyan of embezzling loan funds raised for the needs of Electric Networks of Armenia CJSC.The Investigative Committee accuses Samvel Karapetyan of embezzling loan funds raised for the needs of Electric Networks of Armenia CJSC.
A ruling party MP said that if the opposition tries to disrupt the peace process, it will cause public discontent.A ruling party MP said that if the opposition tries to disrupt the peace process, it will cause public discontent.
CSTO Secretary General: Russia proposed applying Article 25 of the CSTO Charter to ArmeniaCSTO Secretary General: Russia proposed applying Article 25 of the CSTO Charter to Armenia
Political scientist: It`s the opposition`s turn to make a proposal to Armenian societyPolitical scientist: It`s the opposition`s turn to make a proposal to Armenian society
Garnik Danielyan: Pressure on the Armenian opposition will only intensifyGarnik Danielyan: Pressure on the Armenian opposition will only intensify
Political scientist: The failure of the mission to adopt a new Armenian Constitution could raise the question of Pashinyan`s resignation.Political scientist: The failure of the mission to adopt a new Armenian Constitution could raise the question of Pashinyan`s resignation.
WADA is ready to assist Armenia in establishing licensed anti-doping laboratoriesWADA is ready to assist Armenia in establishing licensed anti-doping laboratories
Grigory Yeranosyan will head the Civil Contract party`s election list in Nor HachnGrigory Yeranosyan will head the Civil Contract party`s election list in Nor Hachn
Pashinyan appointed Tigran Simonyan as deputy head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture.Pashinyan appointed Tigran Simonyan as deputy head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture.
The deputy director of a music college in Gyumri is accused of accepting a bribeThe deputy director of a music college in Gyumri is accused of accepting a bribe
Deputy Secretary of the Russian Security Council: Europe is drawing Armenia into its orbitDeputy Secretary of the Russian Security Council: Europe is drawing Armenia into its orbit
The secretary of the Strong Armenia faction linked the searches at the Karapetyans’ homes to Pashinyan’s “proposal” to the opposition.The secretary of the Strong Armenia faction linked the searches at the Karapetyans’ homes to Pashinyan’s “proposal” to the opposition.
Abdul El-Sayed declared his intention to advocate for peace, dignity, security and the right to self-determination of the Armenian peopleAbdul El-Sayed declared his intention to advocate for peace, dignity, security and the right to self-determination of the Armenian people
Minister: It is regrettable to note that Armenia lacks a culture of road safetyMinister: It is regrettable to note that Armenia lacks a culture of road safety
Aram Hambaryan: Corrupt American politicians will no longer be able to secretly pocket Aliyev`s bribes with impunity.Aram Hambaryan: Corrupt American politicians will no longer be able to secretly pocket Aliyev`s bribes with impunity.
RPA: The defeat of the incumbent US president`s camp in the midterm elections is more of a historical pattern than an exceptionRPA: The defeat of the incumbent US president`s camp in the midterm elections is more of a historical pattern than an exception
The Public Council for the Defense of Gagik Tsarukyan called on the court to release the businessman from prisonThe Public Council for the Defense of Gagik Tsarukyan called on the court to release the businessman from prison
"Strong Armenia": Out of fear, Pashinyan ordered new searches and arrests
Lawyer: Searches in the homes of Samvel and Narek Karapetyan are a manifestation of political persecutionLawyer: Searches in the homes of Samvel and Narek Karapetyan are a manifestation of political persecution
Oppositionist: Armenia lives in a country of mirrorsOppositionist: Armenia lives in a country of mirrors
Pashinyan: Armenia may formally apply for EU membership in 2027 or 2028Pashinyan: Armenia may formally apply for EU membership in 2027 or 2028
The head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs: one of the department`s important tasks for 2027 will be the implementation of the project to liberalize the visa regime with the European UnionThe head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs: one of the department`s important tasks for 2027 will be the implementation of the project to liberalize the visa regime with the European Union
The Investigative Committee of Armenia confirmed searches at 65 addresses associated with the Karapetyans.The Investigative Committee of Armenia confirmed searches at 65 addresses associated with the Karapetyans.
Investigators from Armenia’s Investigative Committee have been conducting searches in Samvel and Narek Karapetyan’s apartments since this morning.Investigators from Armenia’s Investigative Committee have been conducting searches in Samvel and Narek Karapetyan’s apartments since this morning.
A major road accident in Yerevan left 8 dead and 3 injuredA major road accident in Yerevan left 8 dead and 3 injured
Another Round of Turkmen-American Political Consultations HeldAnother Round of Turkmen-American Political Consultations Held
Khachkar Studios Publishes Week #8 of Weekly T•A•P Reporting Across 26 PilotsKhachkar Studios Publishes Week #8 of Weekly T•A•P Reporting Across 26 Pilots
Pashinyan Called It Realistic to Submit Armenia’s Application to Join the EU in 2027–2028Pashinyan Called It Realistic to Submit Armenia’s Application to Join the EU in 2027–2028
The Russian Foreign Ministry received the Armenian AmbassadorThe Russian Foreign Ministry received the Armenian Ambassador
Pashinyan and Koopman discussed the Armenia-EU cooperation agenda.Pashinyan and Koopman discussed the Armenia-EU cooperation agenda.
Outstanding pianist Dmitry Masleev will perform his first solo tour in Armenia.Outstanding pianist Dmitry Masleev will perform his first solo tour in Armenia.
The head of the Investigative Committee of Armenia announced the existence of criminal proceedings against former ruling party MP Hayk Sargsyan.The head of the Investigative Committee of Armenia announced the existence of criminal proceedings against former ruling party MP Hayk Sargsyan.
IDBank and Idram Hold Financial Literacy Session for Young Chess PlayersIDBank and Idram Hold Financial Literacy Session for Young Chess Players
ReA Fest will cross the threshold of coming of ageReA Fest will cross the threshold of coming of age
The launch of a new flight between Yerevan and Sofia will give new impetus to economic, cultural, and tourist ties between Armenia and Bulgaria.The launch of a new flight between Yerevan and Sofia will give new impetus to economic, cultural, and tourist ties between Armenia and Bulgaria.
Following Pashinyan, the head of the Armenian Investigative Committee attempted to justify the actions of an Azerbaijani soldier against a resident of Shaki.Following Pashinyan, the head of the Armenian Investigative Committee attempted to justify the actions of an Azerbaijani soldier against a resident of Shaki.
The remains of Armenian composer Harutyun Oganesyan, who died defending Leningrad during WWII, were ceremoniously buried in the Leningrad region.The remains of Armenian composer Harutyun Oganesyan, who died defending Leningrad during WWII, were ceremoniously buried in the Leningrad region.
Roberta Mezzola: The European Parliament will continue to cooperate closely with Armenia to effectively advance the bilateral agendaRoberta Mezzola: The European Parliament will continue to cooperate closely with Armenia to effectively advance the bilateral agenda
Armenian prosecutors are improving their professional knowledge of the process of executing decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.Armenian prosecutors are improving their professional knowledge of the process of executing decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.
Oppositionist: All of Armenia is under arrest todayOppositionist: All of Armenia is under arrest today
Armenia and Georgia agreed to exchange experiences in the process of reforming the Armed ForcesArmenia and Georgia agreed to exchange experiences in the process of reforming the Armed Forces
The head of the Investigative Committee: some investigators are unable to cope with the workload and are quitting, despite salary increases and a qualitative improvement in working conditions.The head of the Investigative Committee: some investigators are unable to cope with the workload and are quitting, despite salary increases and a qualitative improvement in working conditions.
The Governor of Syunik and the Iranian Consul General discussed the development of bilateral cooperation.The Governor of Syunik and the Iranian Consul General discussed the development of bilateral cooperation.
Lavrov: Russia expects a meeting in the Lavrov: Russia expects a meeting in the "3+3" format in the near future
238 buildings and structures have been dismantled on 81 plots of land on Lake Sevan238 buildings and structures have been dismantled on 81 plots of land on Lake Sevan
ANC Deputy Chairman: The British magazine The Critic criticized the West for supporting the Armenian authorities amid pressure on the AACANC Deputy Chairman: The British magazine The Critic criticized the West for supporting the Armenian authorities amid pressure on the AAC
Read more



Commented
Drmeyan: The ECHR rejected Azerbaijan`s appeal in the case of Artsakh Defense Army Major Hayk ToroyanDrmeyan: The ECHR rejected Azerbaijan`s appeal in the case of Artsakh Defense Army Major Hayk Toroyan
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.
The participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassiesThe participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassies
Expert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and EastExpert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and East
The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.
The Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behaviorThe Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behavior
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide