Arminfo.info



 Friday, September 22 2023 18:12
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien

ArmInfo. In an exclusive interview for Blankspot, genocide researcher Melanie O'Brien explains  why the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh can be considered an ongoing genocide.

Already two years ago, Melanie O'Brien, Chair of the International  Association of Genocide Scholars, warned that the developments in  Nagorno-Karabakh could be likened to genocide. Two years later, her  concerns have been repeatedly confirmed to the extent that she and  her colleagues have appealed to the UN to stop what is happening.

Despite this, the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh has turned into a  full-scale offensive where the Armenian civilian population is given  no way to flee.

In an exclusive interview with Blankspot, she explains why  Azerbaijan's actions constitute genocide.

In addition to being the chair of the Genocide Studies Society, she  is currently a visiting professor at the Center for Holocaust and  Genocide Studies at the University of Minnesota in the USA.

What are the legal arguments for calling it genocide?

"It is clear that Azerbaijan is attacking the Armenians of  Nagorno-Karabakh because they are Armenians.  Therefore, the group is  being targeted as an ethnic and, or, national group, both of which  are protected groups under the Genocide Convention", says Melanie  O'Brien.

She continues to argue that the genocide process excelled with the  blockade of the Latjinkorridor.

"However, since the blockade of the Lachin Corridor, the deliberate  starvation and denial of access to healthcare demonstrates an intent  not just to ethnically cleanse Nagorno-Karabakh of Armenians, but to  physically destroy them. Denial of food and healthcare only leads to  death, and these actions are a crucial part of genocide, which we  have seen in other genocides including the Holocaust, the Armenian  Genocide, the Cambodian Genocide and the Rohingya Genocide"

How do the developments of the last few days affect this?

"Azerbaijan said it would open the Lachin Corridor to let residents  of Nagorno-Karabakh out. However, they won't be able to return. Thus,  the choice of those 120,000 people in Nagorno-Karabakh is: stay and  suffer genocide through starvation and lack of healthcare. This is  despite the fact that the International Court of Justice in The Hague  (ICJ) has made it clear to Azerbaijan that the blockade of the Lachin  Corridor creates a direct risk to Armenians."

Melanie O'Brien also argues that Azerbaijan is fully aware of this.

"Azerbaijan is aware of the order from The Hague but continues the  blockade. In addition, Azerbaijan has bombed civilian areas in recent  days, which is also considered a war crime. Thousands have fled from  villages that Azerbaijan has taken and occupied without anywhere else  to go but to other parts of Nagorno- Karabakh. Azerbaijan is now  killing by bombing, starvation and denial of healthcare."

She points out that Azerbaijan has committed to delivering fuel and  food.

"Azerbaijan has said it will deliver food and fuel to  Nagorno-Karabakh, but it remains seen as to whether this will be  done, after 9 months of denying such humanitarian needs."

You warned several years ago that it was beginning to resemble  genocide, what has happened since then?

"The risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh, including hate speech and destruction of Armenian  cultural heritage sites such as churches. Hate speech and  demonization have occurred, among other things, from leaders in the  country, in the media, and in school education.  However, from  December 2022, when Azerbaijan blocked the Lachin Corridor and  subsequently other roads out of Nagorno-Karabakh, this is when we saw  the risk of genocide rise, and once this blockade continued, it has  become genocide. This is because the people of Nagorno-Karabakh have  been unable to leave the enclave".  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
American diplomats held talks in BakuAmerican diplomats held talks in Baku
Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Slovakia discuss possibilities of  expanding bilateral cooperationForeign Ministers of Armenia and Slovakia discuss possibilities of  expanding bilateral cooperation
ICRC visits Armenian detainees in BakuICRC visits Armenian detainees in Baku
Expert: Yerevan failed to offer any significant idea of cooperation  to its American partnersExpert: Yerevan failed to offer any significant idea of cooperation  to its American partners
Canadian Prime Minister`s Special Envoy- Ottawa supports Yerevan`s  peace efforts Canadian Prime Minister`s Special Envoy- Ottawa supports Yerevan`s  peace efforts 
Armenian FM held separate meetings with diplomats from Slovenia and  VaticanArmenian FM held separate meetings with diplomats from Slovenia and  Vatican
Reforms programme to bring Armenia closer to European standards -  minister of justice Reforms programme to bring Armenia closer to European standards -  minister of justice 
Armenian NA speaker promises fewer chauffeured cars next year Armenian NA speaker promises fewer chauffeured cars next year 
Armenian Catholicos concerned over global geopolitical development,  their impact on South Caucasus Armenian Catholicos concerned over global geopolitical development,  their impact on South Caucasus 
Baku dictator`s demands as artificial as the name `Azerbaijan` -  expertBaku dictator`s demands as artificial as the name `Azerbaijan` -  expert
Turkiye expects progress in negbotiations to result in  Armenia-Azerbaijan peace agreement Turkiye expects progress in negbotiations to result in  Armenia-Azerbaijan peace agreement 
No ethnic implications in words about `Armenian carousel` - president  of Georgia No ethnic implications in words about `Armenian carousel` - president  of Georgia 
Armenia has not paid its share to CSTO for two years - Alexander  Pankin Armenia has not paid its share to CSTO for two years - Alexander  Pankin 
Armenia`s Defense Minister, U.S. Sec of Defense discuss military  cooperation Armenia`s Defense Minister, U.S. Sec of Defense discuss military  cooperation 
National Leader of Turkmen People, Chairman of the Halk Maslahaty of Turkmenistan met with the Crown Prince, Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Saudi ArabiaNational Leader of Turkmen People, Chairman of the Halk Maslahaty of Turkmenistan met with the Crown Prince, Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Ardshinbank Partners with the European Investment Bank to Improve Climate Risk ManagementArdshinbank Partners with the European Investment Bank to Improve Climate Risk Management
Yerevan is determined to continue efforts to achieve peace with Baku:  Ararat Mirzoyan at the 31st OSCE Ministerial CouncilYerevan is determined to continue efforts to achieve peace with Baku: Ararat Mirzoyan at the 31st OSCE Ministerial Council
NB8 countries support efforts to achieve a stable peace agreement  between Armenia and AzerbaijanNB8 countries support efforts to achieve a stable peace agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan
Deputy Minister presents Armenia`s energy prospects   to Vice  Ambassador of NorwayDeputy Minister presents Armenia`s energy prospects to Vice Ambassador of Norway
RA MFA: Yerevan agreed to Mirzoyan-Bayramov meeting in Malta with  Blinken`s mediationRA MFA: Yerevan agreed to Mirzoyan-Bayramov meeting in Malta with Blinken`s mediation
Armenia`s FM participates in the opening ceremony of OSCE CMFA  meetingArmenia`s FM participates in the opening ceremony of OSCE CMFA meeting
Ruben Sargsyan: 25,000 forcibly displaced Artsakh residents  officially found employment in ArmeniaRuben Sargsyan: 25,000 forcibly displaced Artsakh residents officially found employment in Armenia
Russian Foreign Minister calls Armenia`s desire to withdraw from CSTO  a sovereign decisionRussian Foreign Minister calls Armenia`s desire to withdraw from CSTO a sovereign decision
Converse Bank completes  tranches of dollar and dram bonds ahead of  scheduleConverse Bank completes tranches of dollar and dram bonds ahead of schedule
Alen Simonyan discusses regional issues with Canada`s Special EnvoyAlen Simonyan discusses regional issues with Canada`s Special Envoy
OSCE ready to support Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process - FearonOSCE ready to support Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process - Fearon
GANHRI presented recommendations for improving Armenian legislation  in the field of human rightsGANHRI presented recommendations for improving Armenian legislation  in the field of human rights
Bahrain confirms Armenia`s right to host the 2027 World Weightlifting  ChampionshipsBahrain confirms Armenia`s right to host the 2027 World Weightlifting  Championships
Kaja Kallas held separate talks with Mirzoyan and BayramovKaja Kallas held separate talks with Mirzoyan and Bayramov
Career diplomats to get much higher salaries in Armenia Career diplomats to get much higher salaries in Armenia 
Minsk aims at developing peaceful mutually beneficial relations with  Yerevan - ambassador  Minsk aims at developing peaceful mutually beneficial relations with  Yerevan - ambassador  
Nelli Davtyan appointed head of RA Migration Service Nelli Davtyan appointed head of RA Migration Service 
Armenia`s government reiterates readiness to prevent gender violenceArmenia`s government reiterates readiness to prevent gender violence
Hayakve initiative member reports crime to RA Prosecutor General`s  Office Hayakve initiative member reports crime to RA Prosecutor General`s  Office 
Argishti Mekhakyan appointed Armavir governor Argishti Mekhakyan appointed Armavir governor 
Armenian, Georgian FMs discuss latest regional developments Armenian, Georgian FMs discuss latest regional developments 
Armenian, Greek defense ministers discuss defense cooperation for  next yearArmenian, Greek defense ministers discuss defense cooperation for  next year
U.S. company could design new uniforms for Armenian army U.S. company could design new uniforms for Armenian army 
Center of Hungarian studies to open in Armenia Center of Hungarian studies to open in Armenia 
World Athletics Association removes Armenia from its watch list over  possible manipulationWorld Athletics Association removes Armenia from its watch list over  possible manipulation
IDBank donated 10,000,000 AMD to the 27th IDBank donated 10,000,000 AMD to the 27th "For You, Armenia!" Telethon
Arpine Sargsyan: Failure to pass certification will result in  dismissal of police officersArpine Sargsyan: Failure to pass certification will result in dismissal of police officers
Pashinyan: Armenia has no reason to attack AzerbaijanPashinyan: Armenia has no reason to attack Azerbaijan
Head of MESCS: It is impossible to provide quality education in all  60 higher education institutions of ArmeniaHead of MESCS: It is impossible to provide quality education in all 60 higher education institutions of Armenia
RA Prime Minister: We consider ourselves outside the CSTORA Prime Minister: We consider ourselves outside the CSTO
Armenian Minister of Health participates in the Summit of GAVI, the  Vaccine AllianceArmenian Minister of Health participates in the Summit of GAVI, the Vaccine Alliance
Pashinyan: On December 8, 9, and 10, we will knock on the doors of  Gyumri residents and offer to vote for the future candidate for the  position of Gyumri mayorPashinyan: On December 8, 9, and 10, we will knock on the doors of Gyumri residents and offer to vote for the future candidate for the position of Gyumri mayor
RA President: Fostering relations with the Arab world is among the  priorities of Armenia`s foreign policyRA President: Fostering relations with the Arab world is among the priorities of Armenia`s foreign policy
Armenia reaffirms its commitment to ongoing democratic reforms in the  country - MFAArmenia reaffirms its commitment to ongoing democratic reforms in the  country - MFA
Armenian Ambassador to Italy presented copies of his credentialsArmenian Ambassador to Italy presented copies of his credentials
Zakharova: Yerevan`s participation in the Rome Statute directly harms  Armenian-Russian relationsZakharova: Yerevan`s participation in the Rome Statute directly harms  Armenian-Russian relations
CSTO Secretary General: The organization`s relationship with Armenia  is determined by the country`s military-political leadershipCSTO Secretary General: The organization`s relationship with Armenia  is determined by the country`s military-political leadership
ARF representative discusses the release of Armenian prisoners with  former French PresidentARF representative discusses the release of Armenian prisoners with  former French President
Armenian FM travels to Malta Armenian FM travels to Malta 
Drastic measures only way out in some cases - Yerevan mayor Drastic measures only way out in some cases - Yerevan mayor 
Dominant faction of Armenian NA to discuss member`s issueDominant faction of Armenian NA to discuss member`s issue
Committee to be formed to deal with election-related human rights  violationsCommittee to be formed to deal with election-related human rights  violations
Armenian NA approves electronic naturalization system Armenian NA approves electronic naturalization system 
Armenian NA approves eletonic labor contracts Armenian NA approves eletonic labor contracts 
Hovik Aghazaryan leaves dominant faction of Armenia`s NAHovik Aghazaryan leaves dominant faction of Armenia`s NA
Read more



Commented