Monday, August 21 2023 16:55
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Former state minister of Artsakh sees three scenarios of resolving  crisis round Artsakh

Former state minister of Artsakh sees three scenarios of resolving  crisis round Artsakh

ArmInfo. In an interview with Caucasus Watch, former state minister of Artsakh Ruben Vardanyan  spoke of three scenarios of resolving the crisis round Artsakh

In response to a question as to where he sees Karabakh 20 years from  now, Mr Vardanyan said: 

"We have established a movement that supports the 'Artsakh 2035  Vision.' Of course, nothing will come easily. We aim to live in our  own homeland, and there are several potential scenarios to achieve  this goal. It is an arduous journey, replete with obstacles, but we  draw inspiration from world history and analogous cases that  demonstrate such movements can persist for decades. We are prepared  to undertake this path with ample determination and resilience.

"Our vision is to defend our homeland. From our side, I see a great  determination for people to stay and take a stand. A change in the  Armenian government could bring a greater political alignment between  Armenia and Artsakh. There may also be greater involvement by  international actors. Therefore, the first scenario we are  considering as quite possible for the next 30-to-50 years is status  quo maintenance.

"This would be maintained by both sides: on the one hand, I do not  see how the local population can accept to live as an Azerbaijani  ethnic minority; on the other hand, a subdued Artsakh - that would  wish to unite with Armenia - is a useful trigger of 'perpetual  national emergency' that is convenient for the Aliyev regime.  Nevertheless, the dream for unification continues to persist. If  these assumptions hold, the new normal will be periods of conflict  with intervals of relative stability. We will maintain the status  quo, dynamically."

The second scenarios is, according to Mr Vardanyan, the one involving  the satellite-like integration of Artsakh into Russia.

Different circles envision an alternative scenario that goes beyond  maintaining the status quo -Russia is the West's adversary today and  that would affect how the West sees Artsakh in this scenario. But we  are talking about 20 years from now. Do we believe that Russia will  remain an adversary to the West? 

"A third scenario entails an 'international mandate' or intervention  by external powers, providing certain security guarantees. South  Caucusus was always viewed by the West and the rest as Russia's  domain. West delegated South Caucuses security to Russia. It could be  changing now. Iran is highly likely to move in to balance  Azerbaijani-Israeli alliance in the region. Reminding you, Iran has  better relations today with Ankara (NATO member) than with Baku. If  Iran becomes a security guarantor in the Caucasus. How would the West  react to that?

"However, it's crucial for people to recognize that the future rests  in our hands. We cannot merely stand by and debate others' scenarios;  we must formulate our own plan and narrative. I believe assuming  responsibility and actively shaping our future is paramount.  Important note. Armenia and Artsakh might be young democracies, but  they are still democracies sandwiched between mighty Turkey,  Azerbaijan, Russia and Iran. I do not see Armenians being subjected  to limitations of their human rights and freedoms willingly or submit  to power without putting up dignified resistance.

"But it is very important for people to realize that the future is in  their hands. And with their own actions, they can have an impact on  these scenarios; indeed, they can insist on and achieve the  implementation of their own scenario," Mr Vardanyan said.  

Asked whether he sees three scenarios: status quo maintenance with a  view to eventual unification with Armenia, or Russian satellisation,  or an international mandate, presumably like the status of Palestine  before the establishment of the State of Israel, Mr Vardanyan answer  in the affirmative. 

Although the situation is undoubtedly very challenging, Mr Vardanyan  does not think that Azerbaijan is preparing to initiate another  large-scale military operation after Autumn 2020. 

"Having said that, we need to understand that Azerbaijan is shooting  civilians who work in the fields on a daily basis. Furthermore, they  tend to prefer small-scale local operations, which help maintain a  sense of tension and fear among the people regarding potential  military actions.

"The blockade is exerting both humanitarian and economic impacts. The  military threat appears intended to affect us psychologically.  However, I am not convinced that they are inclined towards an  aggressive scenario. They employ various tactics to subdue us, waging  a hybrid war on multiple fronts- informational, psychological, moral,  economic, and involving numerous other factors. They use the  humanitarian crisis as a weapon to reach political goals. The food  issue is weaponized and used against us," he said.

"Those who believe that Azerbaijan only desires Nagorno-Karabakh are  gravely mistaken; their recent aggressive actions towards Armenia  proper have demonstrated the opposite. Aliyev is deeply convinced  that he will always remain unpunished, leading him to resort to the  use of force or threats of force. On a daily basis, their media  prepares the groundwork for this. Their insatiable appetite for more  will eventually turn against them, sooner or later," Mr Vardanyan  said. 

The full interview is available here:  https://caucasuswatch.de/en/interviews/ruben-vardanyan-no-matter-  what-there-will-be-resistance.html

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Yerevan`s fountains will cease operating on November 1Yerevan`s fountains will cease operating on November 1
ANC: One of the problems of modern Armenia is that the authorities have chosen an unwise policy of constant concessionsANC: One of the problems of modern Armenia is that the authorities have chosen an unwise policy of constant concessions
The GOALS Girls Summit 2026 was held in YerevanThe GOALS Girls Summit 2026 was held in Yerevan
Pashinyan: Khash season is openPashinyan: Khash season is open
The Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Lebanon discussed the further development of their partnershipThe Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Lebanon discussed the further development of their partnership
The head of the RA Ministry of Foreign Affairs is participating in the Manama Dialogue conferenceThe head of the RA Ministry of Foreign Affairs is participating in the Manama Dialogue conference
Ecuador will take over from ArmeniaEcuador will take over from Armenia
Issues related to the adoption of documents in the field of migration and crime prevention were discussed in ArmeniaIssues related to the adoption of documents in the field of migration and crime prevention were discussed in Armenia
The Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs warns of a new type of fraud via the social network TikTokThe Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs warns of a new type of fraud via the social network TikTok
Head of MoESCS: the statutes of scientific institutes have already been approved, while the formation of governing boards is a priority taskHead of MoESCS: the statutes of scientific institutes have already been approved, while the formation of governing boards is a priority task
Moscow explained the risks Armenia faces by cutting ties with RussiaMoscow explained the risks Armenia faces by cutting ties with Russia
New rules for obtaining residence permits will come into effect in Armenia on November 1New rules for obtaining residence permits will come into effect in Armenia on November 1
Armenia is among 29 countries in which Russia plans to open information and consulting centers, according to the Russian Foreign MinistryArmenia is among 29 countries in which Russia plans to open information and consulting centers, according to the Russian Foreign Ministry
Armenian rescuers pumped out 27 tons of waterArmenian rescuers pumped out 27 tons of water
The opening ceremony of the HayPassl office, designed to issue new biometric documents, took place in YerevanThe opening ceremony of the HayPassl office, designed to issue new biometric documents, took place in Yerevan
The Central Election Commission of Armenia has assigned serial numbers to parties and party blocs participating in the local government elections on November 29The Central Election Commission of Armenia has assigned serial numbers to parties and party blocs participating in the local government elections on November 29
Temperatures are expected to rise in ArmeniaTemperatures are expected to rise in Armenia
Political scientist: Pashinyan`s statements about the adoption of a new Constitution of Armenia indicate that the Armenian Prime Minister has found himself in a multi-layered political impassePolitical scientist: Pashinyan`s statements about the adoption of a new Constitution of Armenia indicate that the Armenian Prime Minister has found himself in a multi-layered political impasse
Armenia`s Ombudsman responded to the Shirak region governor`s statements without pointing fingers.Armenia`s Ombudsman responded to the Shirak region governor`s statements without pointing fingers.
Artsvik Minasyan elected as a member of the Competition and Consumer Protection CommissionArtsvik Minasyan elected as a member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission
IDBank Supports the Reconstruction of the Spandaryan Canal: Commemorative Plaque Dedicated to the Project SignedIDBank Supports the Reconstruction of the Spandaryan Canal: Commemorative Plaque Dedicated to the Project Signed
IDBank and Idram Presented Several Environmental Initiatives at COP17IDBank and Idram Presented Several Environmental Initiatives at COP17
Representatives of the Strong Armenia faction discussed the domestic political situation in the country with the Canadian Ambassador.Representatives of the Strong Armenia faction discussed the domestic political situation in the country with the Canadian Ambassador.
Heritage on the brawl in the Armenian parliament: The Armenian government`s political arsenal is practically exhaustedHeritage on the brawl in the Armenian parliament: The Armenian government`s political arsenal is practically exhausted
Pashinyan discussed youth involvement in public administration.Pashinyan discussed youth involvement in public administration.
The Foreign Ministries of Armenia and India held political consultationsThe Foreign Ministries of Armenia and India held political consultations
Alen Simonyan will travel to Moscow to attend a meeting of CIS Security Council Secretaries.Alen Simonyan will travel to Moscow to attend a meeting of CIS Security Council Secretaries.
Opposition factions in the Armenian parliament have nominated a former member of the National Assembly for the position of member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission.Opposition factions in the Armenian parliament have nominated a former member of the National Assembly for the position of member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission.
Anna Grigoryan: The authorities` proposal to join the process of adopting a new Constitution is unacceptable for the opposition Anna Grigoryan: The authorities` proposal to join the process of adopting a new Constitution is unacceptable for the opposition "Armenia" faction
The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament: If the opposition is convinced that the Armenian people are against the new Constitution, let them put the issue to a referendum.The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament: If the opposition is convinced that the Armenian people are against the new Constitution, let them put the issue to a referendum.
“Strong Armenia”: Azerbaijan cannot be a guarantor of peace for Armenia“Strong Armenia”: Azerbaijan cannot be a guarantor of peace for Armenia
Armenia and Slovenia discussed opportunities for the consistent development of relationsArmenia and Slovenia discussed opportunities for the consistent development of relations
Regular Yerevan-Sofia-Yerevan flights will begin on November 7, 2026 – Bulgarian EmbassyRegular Yerevan-Sofia-Yerevan flights will begin on November 7, 2026 – Bulgarian Embassy
The Supreme Judicial Council will consider the issue of disciplinary action against the judge who recused himself in the case of the Catholicos of All Armenians.The Supreme Judicial Council will consider the issue of disciplinary action against the judge who recused himself in the case of the Catholicos of All Armenians.
The Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia held discussions with the Coordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental ActivitiesThe Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia held discussions with the Coordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental Activities
The lawyers for the former head of the State Revenue Committee: Gagik Khachatryan needs urgent hospitalization, but remains under arrest.The lawyers for the former head of the State Revenue Committee: Gagik Khachatryan needs urgent hospitalization, but remains under arrest.
An oncologist from Armenia has announced his candidacy for the post of WHO Director-GeneralAn oncologist from Armenia has announced his candidacy for the post of WHO Director-General
Deputy Prime Minister: The process of visa liberalization is an important area for expanding contacts, mobility, and ties between Armenian citizens and EU countriesDeputy Prime Minister: The process of visa liberalization is an important area for expanding contacts, mobility, and ties between Armenian citizens and EU countries
Ten people have been detained in connection with a criminal case initiated by the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia on cases of bribery and bribery.Ten people have been detained in connection with a criminal case initiated by the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia on cases of bribery and bribery.
Specially protected natural areas, including green zones, cannot be privately owned, says the Prosecutor GeneralSpecially protected natural areas, including green zones, cannot be privately owned, says the Prosecutor General
Discussions on the candidacy of a member of the Commission for the Protection of Competition and Consumer Interests began at a plenary session of the Armenian Parliament.Discussions on the candidacy of a member of the Commission for the Protection of Competition and Consumer Interests began at a plenary session of the Armenian Parliament.
ARFD Delegation Discussed Prospects for Bilateral Cooperation in Russia’s State DumaARFD Delegation Discussed Prospects for Bilateral Cooperation in Russia’s State Duma
«Here’s the screenshot, the money has been transferred»: IDBank warns of fake payment scams«Here’s the screenshot, the money has been transferred»: IDBank warns of fake payment scams
A magnitude 2.6 earthquake struck ArmeniaA magnitude 2.6 earthquake struck Armenia
The Working Visit of the President of Turkmenistan to the Republic of Turkiye Has BegunThe Working Visit of the President of Turkmenistan to the Republic of Turkiye Has Begun
An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.
Issues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in YerevanIssues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in Yerevan
A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.
Criminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal AffairsCriminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal Affairs
Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine                Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine            
First Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream LaunchedFirst Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream Launched
Rate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency ExchangeRate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency Exchange
The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.
An Armenian version of the American drama An Armenian version of the American drama "Closer" will be filmed in Yerevan.
Human rights activist: Human rights activist: "Protecting the rights of the people of Artsakh is a matter of the rights of all Armenians."
Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.
Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.
One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.
A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.
ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.
Read more



Commented
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.
The participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassiesThe participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassies
Expert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and EastExpert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and East
The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.
The Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behaviorThe Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behavior
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place