Arminfo.info



 Wednesday, November 9 2022 14:39
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Former Deputy FM: Armenia`s refusal of Artsakh`s  right to  self-determination means that it imposes on itself the stigma of an  aggressor

Former Deputy FM: Armenia`s refusal of Artsakh`s  right to  self-determination means that it imposes on itself the stigma of an  aggressor

ArmInfo. Armenia's refusal of Artsakh's right to self- determination means that it imposes on itself the stigma of an aggressor, with all its dangerous  consequences. Former Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia Shavarsh  Kocharyan announced on November 9, at the discussions organized by  the opposition forces. 

At the same time, he recalled that the basis of international law is  the UN Charter, which is similar to the Constitution of the state in  the international hierarchy. "That is, if any clause contradicts the  Constitution, then the Constitution must apply. The same rules apply  to the UN Charter. This is important from the point of view that  initially, from the very beginning of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict,  there were two contradictory positions "Armenian position and  Azerbaijani position. The Armenian side emphasized the right of  peoples to self-determination, while the Azerbaijani side emphasized  territorial integrity," he stated.

At the same time, the former head of the Armenian Foreign Ministry  noted that there is a misconception in the Armenian society that the  principles of "the right of peoples to self-determination" and  "territorial integrity" are equivalent. In this regard, he drew  attention to the fact that the principle of the right of peoples to  self-determination prevails in the UN Charter.

"Article 1, paragraph 2 of the UN Charter on the purposes of the  Organization states: "to develop friendly relations among nations  based on respect for the principle of equal rights and  self-determination of peoples, as well as to take other appropriate  measures to strengthen world peace."

Meanwhile, self-determination is already mentioned in the fourth  paragraph of the second article of the Charter, which lists the  principles according to which it is possible to achieve the goals  listed in the first article of the UN Charter: "All Members of the  United Nations shall refrain in their international relations from  the threat or use of force, as against territorial integrity or  political independence of any State, or in any other manner  inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations." That is, if we  are again talking about international law, then the principle of  territorial integrity should serve the goal of the right of peoples  to self-determination. That is, at least, it cannot be opposed to  it," Kocharyan stressed.

At the same time, the diplomat emphasized that the refusal of the  state from the principle of the right to self-determination would  have catastrophic consequences for it in a conflict situation.

"There was a conflict, thousands of dead, wounded, destruction - who  is responsible for this? If the problem concerns self-determination,  then it turns out that the aggressor Azerbaijan, which, in response  to the realized right of Artsakh to self-determination, resorted to  power politics. First, this manifested itself in forced deportations,  mass pogroms - Baku, Sumgayit, etc. ,and then turned into a  large-scale military aggression against the self-determined  Nagorno-Karabakh," the former deputy foreign minister of Armenia  noted.   According to him, if we take the territorial dispute as a basis, then  it will be very difficult for Armenia to defend itself from the  stigma of an "aggressor". "If Armenia voluntarily renounces  self-determination, lowers the bar, this is nothing but imposing the  stigma of an aggressor on itself," said Kocharyan.  In this regard,  the diplomat touched upon the consequences of such a development of  events. And it is the following: "The aggressor must be punished." 

In this regard, Kocharyan gave examples of punishments applied in  international practice to aggressor countries. "Among the applicable  punishments is the forced expulsion of the population both from the  territory of the affected state and from one's own territory, if it  was transferred to the victim as a punishment. This is the first  measure. The second measure is compensation with the territories, the  third one is reparation," he said, citing the example of Germany  regarding the results of the Second World War as an example of these  points.  At the same time, the diplomat stated that there were no  deadlines for compensation, and it turns out that if you find  yourself in the status of an aggressor, then in fact you remain with  this stigma forever.  Another point he called the restrictions of a  defensive nature, which are imposed on this state. Kocharyan stated  that the army, the military-industrial complex, the sector of arms  procurement, etc. would suffer from this.  "The fifth measure is to  identify and punish war criminals and bring them to justice. The  sixth measure is to control the internal life of the state so that  revanchism does not raise its head," he said.  In conclusion, the  well-known diplomat reiterated that Armenia's refusal of the  principle of the right to self-determination of Artsakh is tantamount  to impose on itself the stigma of an aggressor, and, moreover, "if we  look carefully, we will see that Turkey and Azerbaijan all their  actions lead to attracting Armenia accountable precisely as the  aggressor. And unfortunately, in this process the current authorities  of Armenia assist them".  "The Prime Minister of Armenia, by his  signature under the tripartite statement dated November 9, 2020,  where it is indicated that Armenia is returning territories to  Azerbaijan, assigned the country the status of an aggressor. And now,  this whole story continues in different directions," Kocharyan summed  up. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Turkmenistan and Germany aim to deepen multifaceted cooperationTurkmenistan and Germany aim to deepen multifaceted cooperation
All government institutions must deal with Artsakh Armenians`  problems All government institutions must deal with Artsakh Armenians`  problems 
Armenia`s government intends to solve forcibly displaced people`s  housing problem - ministerArmenia`s government intends to solve forcibly displaced people`s  housing problem - minister
American senator calls on U.S. administration to impose sanctions  against AzerbaijanAmerican senator calls on U.S. administration to impose sanctions  against Azerbaijan
German Foreign Minister: UN visit to Nagorno-Karabakh needs to take  place without delayGerman Foreign Minister: UN visit to Nagorno-Karabakh needs to take  place without delay
 14 people died on Stepanakert-Goris road - RA Minister of Health 14 people died on Stepanakert-Goris road - RA Minister of Health
There are practically no Armenians left in Nagorno-KarabakhThere are practically no Armenians left in Nagorno-Karabakh
ANCA calls for immediate action to cut off all military aid to  Azerbaijan and impose sanctions against that countryANCA calls for immediate action to cut off all military aid to  Azerbaijan and impose sanctions against that country
France sends medical equipment and medicines to Armenia for needs of  those displaced from Nagorno Karabakh France sends medical equipment and medicines to Armenia for needs of  those displaced from Nagorno Karabakh 
Cyprus considers hosting some refugees from Nagorno-KarabakhCyprus considers hosting some refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh
Because of ethnic cleansing policy of Azerbaijan already about 90.000  persons have been displaced from Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia - NA  Standing Committee ChairBecause of ethnic cleansing policy of Azerbaijan already about 90.000  persons have been displaced from Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia - NA  Standing Committee Chair
Armenia appeals to International Court of Justice to indicate  provisional measures against AzerbaijanArmenia appeals to International Court of Justice to indicate  provisional measures against Azerbaijan
About 93 thousand residents have already left ArtsakhAbout 93 thousand residents have already left Artsakh
Azerbaijani State Security Service arrests Major General David  ManukyanAzerbaijani State Security Service arrests Major General David  Manukyan
Third round of Stepanaker-Baku negotiations ended in YevlakhThird round of Stepanaker-Baku negotiations ended in Yevlakh
Media reports: Azerbaijan detains Armenian generals Levon  Mnatsakanyan and Arshavir GharamyanMedia reports: Azerbaijan detains Armenian generals Levon  Mnatsakanyan and Arshavir Gharamyan
Idram and VIVA Fund for Armenians of ArtsakhIdram and VIVA Fund for Armenians of Artsakh
Nagorno Karabakh Armenians` rights and security must be  internationally guaranteed - Alen Simonyan Nagorno Karabakh Armenians` rights and security must be  internationally guaranteed - Alen Simonyan 
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker: I am not surprised that Turkiye,  Azerbaijan and Russia are often using the same rhetoricArmenia`s Parliament Speaker: I am not surprised that Turkiye,  Azerbaijan and Russia are often using the same rhetoric
MEPs set to condemn Azerbaijan`s latest unjustified attack against  ArtsakhMEPs set to condemn Azerbaijan`s latest unjustified attack against  Artsakh
There are no tendencies for increased tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani  border yet - RA Deputy Defense Minister There are no tendencies for increased tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani  border yet - RA Deputy Defense Minister 
French MP Anne-Laurence Petel severely critical of key EU structures French MP Anne-Laurence Petel severely critical of key EU structures 
Lebanese Armenians hold protest in front of Azerbaijani Embassy in  Beirut Lebanese Armenians hold protest in front of Azerbaijani Embassy in  Beirut 
Decree dissolving Republic of Artsakh signed as a result of  Azerbaijan`s aggression - Artak BeglaryanDecree dissolving Republic of Artsakh signed as a result of  Azerbaijan`s aggression - Artak Beglaryan
U.S. Department of State spokesperson refrains from commenting on the  Artsakh president`s decree dissolving Republic of ArtsakhU.S. Department of State spokesperson refrains from commenting on the  Artsakh president`s decree dissolving Republic of Artsakh
Less than 40,000 Armenians remain in Nagorno-Karabakh Less than 40,000 Armenians remain in Nagorno-Karabakh 
Canada provides $2.5 mln in humanitarian assistance funding ICRC to  address urgent needs of forcibly displaced people from  Nagorno-Karabakh Canada provides $2.5 mln in humanitarian assistance funding ICRC to  address urgent needs of forcibly displaced people from  Nagorno-Karabakh 
EU watches as Azerbaijan achieves the goal of ethnic cleansing -  German MPEU watches as Azerbaijan achieves the goal of ethnic cleansing -  German MP
USAID administrator USAID administrator "spent more on photographers for her visit to  Armenia than on USAID programs in Artsakh" - ANCA
Spain to allocate EUR 1 million to help refugees from  Nagorno-KarabakhSpain to allocate EUR 1 million to help refugees from  Nagorno-Karabakh
U.S. to deploy  response team in South CaucasusU.S. to deploy  response team in South Caucasus
AMD 100,000 to be allocated to each of those forcibly displaced from  Artsakh - PMAMD 100,000 to be allocated to each of those forcibly displaced from  Artsakh - PM
Armenia`s CEC approves lists of political forces in Yerevan Council  of EldersArmenia`s CEC approves lists of political forces in Yerevan Council  of Elders
Nothing should distract from issue of providing Armenians of Artsakh  with decent life in Armenia - Armenia`s 1st President Nothing should distract from issue of providing Armenians of Artsakh  with decent life in Armenia - Armenia`s 1st President 
Anahit Manasyan: Information about kidnapping of our citizens by  Azerbaijan has been sent to international partnersAnahit Manasyan: Information about kidnapping of our citizens by  Azerbaijan has been sent to international partners
Armenian opposition resumes protestsArmenian opposition resumes protests
Armenia`s decision to ratify Rome Statute to have most negative  consequences for Armenian-Russian relations - Russian Foreign OfficeArmenia`s decision to ratify Rome Statute to have most negative  consequences for Armenian-Russian relations - Russian Foreign Office
Opinion: Russian peacekeepers to remain on Nagorno-Karabakh territory  at least until 2025Opinion: Russian peacekeepers to remain on Nagorno-Karabakh territory  at least until 2025
Over 70 thousand people have already been forcibly displaced from  Artsakh to ArmeniaOver 70 thousand people have already been forcibly displaced from  Artsakh to Armenia
Former Artsakh State Minister is free and safeFormer Artsakh State Minister is free and safe
Armenians have suffered continuous ethnic cleansing and genocide -  Nassim TalebArmenians have suffered continuous ethnic cleansing and genocide -  Nassim Taleb
Mass media on EU sanctions against Azerbaijan amid ethnic cleansing  in Nagorno-Karabakh - `Sanctions looks unlikely`Mass media on EU sanctions against Azerbaijan amid ethnic cleansing  in Nagorno-Karabakh - `Sanctions looks unlikely`
Kremlin: Armenia is acting extremely hostile towards Russia as it  plans to accede to Rome StatuteKremlin: Armenia is acting extremely hostile towards Russia as it  plans to accede to Rome Statute
Serzh Sargsyan: For me, Artsakh`s chapter will never be closedSerzh Sargsyan: For me, Artsakh`s chapter will never be closed
Search operations in Nagorno-Karabakh: remains of 11 people found Search operations in Nagorno-Karabakh: remains of 11 people found 
Ministry of Health of Armenia calls on citizens to donate bloodMinistry of Health of Armenia calls on citizens to donate blood
Azerbaijan must guarantee the rights of ethnic Armenians in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Morris Tidball-BinzAzerbaijan must guarantee the rights of ethnic Armenians in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Morris Tidball-Binz
There will be no more Armenians left in Nagorno Karabakh in coming  days - Armenia`s premier There will be no more Armenians left in Nagorno Karabakh in coming  days - Armenia`s premier 
Armenia intends to ratify Rome Statute of International Criminal  CourtArmenia intends to ratify Rome Statute of International Criminal  Court
Baku arbitrarily detains Armenians at checkpoints. Issue should be  resolved properly - PashinyanBaku arbitrarily detains Armenians at checkpoints. Issue should be  resolved properly - Pashinyan
Armenia proposes to Russia to conclude bilateral agreement regarding  Rome Statute - KirakosyanArmenia proposes to Russia to conclude bilateral agreement regarding  Rome Statute - Kirakosyan
Mel Gibson on situation in Artsakh: We are witnessing modern genocideMel Gibson on situation in Artsakh: We are witnessing modern genocide
Armenian government to allocate AMD 360 million to regional  administrations for needs of Nagorno- Karabakh forced migrantsArmenian government to allocate AMD 360 million to regional  administrations for needs of Nagorno- Karabakh forced migrants
Yerevan applies to ECHR with request to protect Ruben Vardanyan`s  rightsYerevan applies to ECHR with request to protect Ruben Vardanyan`s  rights
96 US Senate and House lawmakers call on Biden Administration to  sanction Azerbaijani leaders for Artsakh blockade and attacks 96 US Senate and House lawmakers call on Biden Administration to  sanction Azerbaijani leaders for Artsakh blockade and attacks 
Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) to cease to exist from January  1, 2024  Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) to cease to exist from January  1, 2024  
Nagorno-Karabakh presidential advisor ready to turn himself in to  Azerbaijani law-enforcersNagorno-Karabakh presidential advisor ready to turn himself in to  Azerbaijani law-enforcers
CE Committee of Ministers holds extensive discussion on Azerbaijan`s  military attack on Nagorno- KarabakhCE Committee of Ministers holds extensive discussion on Azerbaijan`s  military attack on Nagorno- Karabakh
Over 65,000 people flee Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia Over 65,000 people flee Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia 
People fleeing Nagorno-Karabakh because attacked by Azerbaijani  military - Edmon Marukyan  People fleeing Nagorno-Karabakh because attacked by Azerbaijani  military - Edmon Marukyan  
Read more



Commented