Arminfo.info



 Friday, November 4 2022 16:38
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Being an ally of Turkey, Azerbaijan is de facto becoming NATO`s entry  point to the South Caucasus - Russian expert 

Being an ally of Turkey, Azerbaijan is de facto becoming NATO`s entry  point to the South Caucasus - Russian expert 

ArmInfo. Russia has leverage on Azerbaijan and Armenia on the implementation of the Sochi agreements of the leaders of the three countries of October 31.

A similar opinion was expressed by Feodor Voitolovsky, Director of the  Primakov Institute of World Economy and International Relations  (IMEMO), Russian Academy of Sciences, Member of the Presidium Council  for Science and Education under the President of the Russian  Federation, referring to the Sochi meeting of the leaders of Armenia,  Azerbaijan and Russia.  At the same time, as the key achievements of  the Sochi meeting, the doctor of political sciences mentioned the  obligations of the parties to refrain from the use of force or the  threat of force, as well as the further activities of the Russian  peacekeeping contingent in Nagorno-Karabakh. At the same time, he  believes that there is no point in expecting breakthroughs from the  Sochi declaration - its very value lies in the fact that the parties  agreed to meet and continue negotiations on acute and painful issues.

The political scientist considers the presence of Russian  peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as various political and  diplomatic instruments, economic and other instruments of influence,  as instruments of influence on all parties to the conflict for the  implementation of these agreements.

To the remark that if Russia has leverage, then how did Azerbaijan  violate the ceasefire, the political scientist admitted that indeed,  such violations took place. Voitolovsky stated that throughout the  entire post-war period, Azerbaijan took a rather tough position,  which was based on the support of Turkey and the tacit support of the  United States. "Yes, yes, precisely on the support of the United  States, because if the United States had actually sanctioned Turkey's  actions during the 44-day war of 2020, then Ankara could not afford  the freedom of action and the support that Baku provided," he said in  an interview with Public Television of Armenia.

When asked whether Azerbaijan could start a war without Russia's  consent, Voitolovsky expressed his conviction that Baku started the  war without Moscow's consent. According to the expert, Russia  received the information, in fact, only on the eve of the start of  hostilities.

He once again stressed that Russia has leverage that works. In this  vein, the expert stated that if these levers did not work, Ilham  Aliyev would not have come to Sochi to talk with Vladimir Putin and  Nikol Pashinyan.  Otherwise, Azerbaijan would not have stopped the  war where it stopped and would have received not only 7 regions  surrounding the Nagorno-Karabakh unrecognized republic, but would  have received the entire territory of the unrecognized NKR and  Stepanakert, and possibly would have gone further. After all, as we  know, Azerbaijan is promoting a very firm position that it can move  further, because the borders are not delimited and not demarcated,"  the political scientist said, recalling that now it is Russia that is  actively proposing to the parties to conduct this process.

At the same time, Voitolovsky drew attention to the fact that, unlike  other draft peace treaties proposed by the EU and the US, the Russian  Federation clearly states its position on the need to recognize the  interests of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh, residents of the  unrecognized NKR. "And Russia has not changed its position in this  case," he remarked. And to the question, what is Russia's position on  Nagorno- Karabakh, Voitolovsky asked a counter question about  Armenia's position on Artsakh. "And what is Armenia's position on  Nagorno-Karabakh? Armenia does not have a clear position. Armenia has  not recognized the independence of Nagorno-Karabakh," he said. And in  response to the journalist's comment that this does not mean that  Armenia does not have a clear position, the Russian expert noted that  Russia does too.

"Russia cannot recognize the independence of Nagorno-Karabakh. But,  in my opinion, without Russia and Armenia, there would be no  Nagorno-Karabakh Republic at all," the political scientist said.

At the same time, he drew attention to the fact that the US position  on this issue is unequivocal since they recognize Azerbaijan's  sovereignty over Nagorno-Karabakh. The Russian Federation has a more  flexible position on this issue. "Russian peacekeepers at the moment  ensure the vital activity, the very existence of the unrecognized  NKR," he said.

The expert did not agree with the statement that the United States  and Russia have a similar position on the issue of Artsakh, namely  that it is Azerbaijani land. He assured that Russia's position is  more complicated, and it says that the issue of the status of the NKR  should be resolved through negotiations and a referendum, which  should be held on the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, when a peaceful  settlement is reached. "And this is a very serious difference from  the position of the US and the EU," the international expert added.

He once again drew attention to the fact that official Yerevan does  not have a clear position on the issue of Nagorno-Karabakh. "Armenia  did not recognize the independence of the NKR, did not recognize it  as part of its territory. Look, during the 44-day war, Armenian  volunteers, who arrived, including from Russia, participated as part  of the Armenian army, but unofficially. It was not possible to fully  declare the mobilization, and the Armenian leadership did not want to  be drawn into the conflict, because this would no longer mean a  conflict between Nagorno-Karabakh and Azerbaijan, but would mean a  conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan," Voitolovsky noted.

To the  remark that Russia did not express a clear position in  connection with the Azerbaijani aggression against Armenia, the  expert assured that Moscow will be the only one to show assistance to  Yerevan in that cas Responding to the thesis that the Azerbaijani  Armed Forces did not go further during the September escalation,  because they were stopped by America's position, which Washington  officially announced, Voitolovsky retorted: "What do you think, if  America once supported Turkey and allowed Azerbaijan to act  completely definitely in Nagorno-Karabakh, why is the US suddenly  changing its position now?  After all, Turkey is a loyal member of  the North Atlantic Alliance. Azerbaijan is an ally of Turkey. Being  an ally of Turkey, Azerbaijan is de facto becoming NATO's entry point  to the South Caucasus."

At the same time, he stressed that alliance is a two-way road. "If  before the developments of 2020 and the current developments, Armenia  had taken a clearer position on Crimea, then I believe that the  position of the Russian leadership on Nagorno-Karabakh was much  firmer both in 2020 and now. But, Armenia did not do this. If Armenia  at one time had agreed to cooperation in the field of air and missile  defense, which the Russian side had repeatedly proposed, but it did  not do so. Yes, there is a framework agreement between the parties.  But, it could be filled with real content in terms of arms supplies  and military equipment, and in terms of joint systems," he said.  To  the clarifying question of the presenter about < was the Armenian  side against it?>, the expert answered in the affirmative. " The  Armenian side, both during the previous and current administrations,  but above all, during the previous administration (under Serzh  Sargsyan - ed. note), refused Russian proposals. Therefore, alliance  is a two-way road," the political scientist noted.  He once again  assured that " Russia cares about what happens to Armenia ", and that  is why, it proposes a long, difficult process, where solutions will  be worked out that suit both Yerevan and Baku, while taking into  account the interests and security of the population of Nagorny  Karabakh.

READ ALL COMMENTS

Юрий
Если бы до событий 2020 года, и нынешних событий Армения заняла более четкую позицию по поводу Крыма, то полагаю, что позиция российского руководства по поводу Нагорного Карабаха была гораздо тверже как в 2020 года, так и сейчас - Это ключевая фраза эксперта, выдающая его с головой. Его волнуют только российские интересы и его не волнует, что предложенный им шаг поставил бы Армению в положение конфликта со всем миром, тогда как Россия боится пойти ради Армении на конфликт с одним Азербайджаном. Карты этих экспертов биты.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
American senator calls on U.S. administration to impose sanctions  against AzerbaijanAmerican senator calls on U.S. administration to impose sanctions  against Azerbaijan
German Foreign Minister: UN visit to Nagorno-Karabakh needs to take  place without delayGerman Foreign Minister: UN visit to Nagorno-Karabakh needs to take  place without delay
 14 people died on Stepanakert-Goris road - RA Minister of Health 14 people died on Stepanakert-Goris road - RA Minister of Health
There are practically no Armenians left in Nagorno-KarabakhThere are practically no Armenians left in Nagorno-Karabakh
ANCA calls for immediate action to cut off all military aid to  Azerbaijan and impose sanctions against that countryANCA calls for immediate action to cut off all military aid to  Azerbaijan and impose sanctions against that country
France sends medical equipment and medicines to Armenia for needs of  those displaced from Nagorno Karabakh France sends medical equipment and medicines to Armenia for needs of  those displaced from Nagorno Karabakh 
Cyprus considers hosting some refugees from Nagorno-KarabakhCyprus considers hosting some refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh
Because of ethnic cleansing policy of Azerbaijan already about 90.000  persons have been displaced from Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia - NA  Standing Committee ChairBecause of ethnic cleansing policy of Azerbaijan already about 90.000  persons have been displaced from Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia - NA  Standing Committee Chair
Armenia appeals to International Court of Justice to indicate  provisional measures against AzerbaijanArmenia appeals to International Court of Justice to indicate  provisional measures against Azerbaijan
About 93 thousand residents have already left ArtsakhAbout 93 thousand residents have already left Artsakh
Azerbaijani State Security Service arrests Major General David  ManukyanAzerbaijani State Security Service arrests Major General David  Manukyan
Third round of Stepanaker-Baku negotiations ended in YevlakhThird round of Stepanaker-Baku negotiations ended in Yevlakh
Media reports: Azerbaijan detains Armenian generals Levon  Mnatsakanyan and Arshavir GharamyanMedia reports: Azerbaijan detains Armenian generals Levon  Mnatsakanyan and Arshavir Gharamyan
Idram and VIVA Fund for Armenians of ArtsakhIdram and VIVA Fund for Armenians of Artsakh
Nagorno Karabakh Armenians` rights and security must be  internationally guaranteed - Alen Simonyan Nagorno Karabakh Armenians` rights and security must be  internationally guaranteed - Alen Simonyan 
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker: I am not surprised that Turkiye,  Azerbaijan and Russia are often using the same rhetoricArmenia`s Parliament Speaker: I am not surprised that Turkiye,  Azerbaijan and Russia are often using the same rhetoric
MEPs set to condemn Azerbaijan`s latest unjustified attack against  ArtsakhMEPs set to condemn Azerbaijan`s latest unjustified attack against  Artsakh
There are no tendencies for increased tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani  border yet - RA Deputy Defense Minister There are no tendencies for increased tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani  border yet - RA Deputy Defense Minister 
French MP Anne-Laurence Petel severely critical of key EU structures French MP Anne-Laurence Petel severely critical of key EU structures 
Lebanese Armenians hold protest in front of Azerbaijani Embassy in  Beirut Lebanese Armenians hold protest in front of Azerbaijani Embassy in  Beirut 
Decree dissolving Republic of Artsakh signed as a result of  Azerbaijan`s aggression - Artak BeglaryanDecree dissolving Republic of Artsakh signed as a result of  Azerbaijan`s aggression - Artak Beglaryan
U.S. Department of State spokesperson refrains from commenting on the  Artsakh president`s decree dissolving Republic of ArtsakhU.S. Department of State spokesperson refrains from commenting on the  Artsakh president`s decree dissolving Republic of Artsakh
Less than 40,000 Armenians remain in Nagorno-Karabakh Less than 40,000 Armenians remain in Nagorno-Karabakh 
Canada provides $2.5 mln in humanitarian assistance funding ICRC to  address urgent needs of forcibly displaced people from  Nagorno-Karabakh Canada provides $2.5 mln in humanitarian assistance funding ICRC to  address urgent needs of forcibly displaced people from  Nagorno-Karabakh 
EU watches as Azerbaijan achieves the goal of ethnic cleansing -  German MPEU watches as Azerbaijan achieves the goal of ethnic cleansing -  German MP
USAID administrator USAID administrator "spent more on photographers for her visit to  Armenia than on USAID programs in Artsakh" - ANCA
Spain to allocate EUR 1 million to help refugees from  Nagorno-KarabakhSpain to allocate EUR 1 million to help refugees from  Nagorno-Karabakh
U.S. to deploy  response team in South CaucasusU.S. to deploy  response team in South Caucasus
AMD 100,000 to be allocated to each of those forcibly displaced from  Artsakh - PMAMD 100,000 to be allocated to each of those forcibly displaced from  Artsakh - PM
Armenia`s CEC approves lists of political forces in Yerevan Council  of EldersArmenia`s CEC approves lists of political forces in Yerevan Council  of Elders
Nothing should distract from issue of providing Armenians of Artsakh  with decent life in Armenia - Armenia`s 1st President Nothing should distract from issue of providing Armenians of Artsakh  with decent life in Armenia - Armenia`s 1st President 
Anahit Manasyan: Information about kidnapping of our citizens by  Azerbaijan has been sent to international partnersAnahit Manasyan: Information about kidnapping of our citizens by  Azerbaijan has been sent to international partners
Armenian opposition resumes protestsArmenian opposition resumes protests
Armenia`s decision to ratify Rome Statute to have most negative  consequences for Armenian-Russian relations - Russian Foreign OfficeArmenia`s decision to ratify Rome Statute to have most negative  consequences for Armenian-Russian relations - Russian Foreign Office
Opinion: Russian peacekeepers to remain on Nagorno-Karabakh territory  at least until 2025Opinion: Russian peacekeepers to remain on Nagorno-Karabakh territory  at least until 2025
Over 70 thousand people have already been forcibly displaced from  Artsakh to ArmeniaOver 70 thousand people have already been forcibly displaced from  Artsakh to Armenia
Former Artsakh State Minister is free and safeFormer Artsakh State Minister is free and safe
Armenians have suffered continuous ethnic cleansing and genocide -  Nassim TalebArmenians have suffered continuous ethnic cleansing and genocide -  Nassim Taleb
Mass media on EU sanctions against Azerbaijan amid ethnic cleansing  in Nagorno-Karabakh - `Sanctions looks unlikely`Mass media on EU sanctions against Azerbaijan amid ethnic cleansing  in Nagorno-Karabakh - `Sanctions looks unlikely`
Kremlin: Armenia is acting extremely hostile towards Russia as it  plans to accede to Rome StatuteKremlin: Armenia is acting extremely hostile towards Russia as it  plans to accede to Rome Statute
Serzh Sargsyan: For me, Artsakh`s chapter will never be closedSerzh Sargsyan: For me, Artsakh`s chapter will never be closed
Search operations in Nagorno-Karabakh: remains of 11 people found Search operations in Nagorno-Karabakh: remains of 11 people found 
Ministry of Health of Armenia calls on citizens to donate bloodMinistry of Health of Armenia calls on citizens to donate blood
Azerbaijan must guarantee the rights of ethnic Armenians in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Morris Tidball-BinzAzerbaijan must guarantee the rights of ethnic Armenians in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Morris Tidball-Binz
There will be no more Armenians left in Nagorno Karabakh in coming  days - Armenia`s premier There will be no more Armenians left in Nagorno Karabakh in coming  days - Armenia`s premier 
Armenia intends to ratify Rome Statute of International Criminal  CourtArmenia intends to ratify Rome Statute of International Criminal  Court
Baku arbitrarily detains Armenians at checkpoints. Issue should be  resolved properly - PashinyanBaku arbitrarily detains Armenians at checkpoints. Issue should be  resolved properly - Pashinyan
Armenia proposes to Russia to conclude bilateral agreement regarding  Rome Statute - KirakosyanArmenia proposes to Russia to conclude bilateral agreement regarding  Rome Statute - Kirakosyan
Mel Gibson on situation in Artsakh: We are witnessing modern genocideMel Gibson on situation in Artsakh: We are witnessing modern genocide
Armenian government to allocate AMD 360 million to regional  administrations for needs of Nagorno- Karabakh forced migrantsArmenian government to allocate AMD 360 million to regional  administrations for needs of Nagorno- Karabakh forced migrants
Yerevan applies to ECHR with request to protect Ruben Vardanyan`s  rightsYerevan applies to ECHR with request to protect Ruben Vardanyan`s  rights
96 US Senate and House lawmakers call on Biden Administration to  sanction Azerbaijani leaders for Artsakh blockade and attacks 96 US Senate and House lawmakers call on Biden Administration to  sanction Azerbaijani leaders for Artsakh blockade and attacks 
Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) to cease to exist from January  1, 2024  Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) to cease to exist from January  1, 2024  
Nagorno-Karabakh presidential advisor ready to turn himself in to  Azerbaijani law-enforcersNagorno-Karabakh presidential advisor ready to turn himself in to  Azerbaijani law-enforcers
CE Committee of Ministers holds extensive discussion on Azerbaijan`s  military attack on Nagorno- KarabakhCE Committee of Ministers holds extensive discussion on Azerbaijan`s  military attack on Nagorno- Karabakh
Over 65,000 people flee Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia Over 65,000 people flee Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia 
People fleeing Nagorno-Karabakh because attacked by Azerbaijani  military - Edmon Marukyan  People fleeing Nagorno-Karabakh because attacked by Azerbaijani  military - Edmon Marukyan  
Armenian premier, French president have telephone conversation Armenian premier, French president have telephone conversation 
Public Voice party`s condition acceptable for Hayk Marutyan Public Voice party`s condition acceptable for Hayk Marutyan 
FMs of Armenia, Turkey discuss current regional developmentsFMs of Armenia, Turkey discuss current regional developments
Read more



Commented