Arminfo.info


 Monday, September 27 2021 13:24
David Stepanyan

Artsakh catastrophe was prepared not only by external forces, but  also by internal ones

Artsakh catastrophe was prepared not only by external forces, but  also by internal ones

ArmInfo. Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, former Foreign Minister of Artsakh Arman Melikyan, in an interview with ArmInfo, shares his vision of  the latest geopolitical trends in the South Caucasus. He also  analyzes the latest processes around Armenia in the light of the main  regional and extra-regional geopolitical players.

- Based on the current activity of the main geopolitical players in  the South Caucasus: Russia, Turkey and Iran, one gets the impression  of the impending change in the post-war status quo, formed as a  result of the 44-day war. Moreover, we are talking about changes on  the scale of the entire region, and not only in relations between  Armenia and Azerbaijan. A characteristic background of everything  that is happening is the lack of information from the Armenian  government about the ongoing and future processes. Please, share your  assessment of what is happening and, most importantly, the possible  prospects for current processes.

-The breakdown of the status quo established in 1994 in Artsakh  following the 44-day war and subsequent trilateral agreements should  be considered in the context of advancing the global process of  reformatting Eurasia. In this case, the overlapping of interests and  the resulting close interaction of a number of states in the region  and influential extra-regional forces led to disastrous consequences  for Artsakh and the Republic of Armenia. This catastrophe was  prepared not only by external forces, but also by internal ones - the  absolute helplessness, incapacity of the Armenian political  leadership and military command in organizing and conducting  hostilities indicates that the Armenian side lost long before the  start of hostilities at the end of September 2020. The reason for  this was the absolute lack of understanding of the essence and  direction of the current regional and global processes and, as a  consequence, the inability to identify and adequately assess the  risks they generate for the Armenian vital interests. Moreover, the  Armenian leadership ignored all warnings regarding the likelihood of  such risks and the necessity and possibilities of neutralizing them.   As for the motives and the imposition of efforts necessary for the  interaction of external forces, they have many levels. For  Azerbaijan, the war provided an opportunity to take control of about  10,000 square kilometers of territory previously controlled by the  authorities and the Artsakh Defense Army. For Turkey, the war opened  an era of a full-scale military presence on the territory of  Azerbaijan with the prospect of absorbing the latter through a  possible "Anschluss", which will mean a gradual transformation of the  South Caucasus into NATO territory, and at the same time a consistent  strengthening of Turkey's positions in the countries of post-Soviet  Central Asia. For Israel, the next stage of the operation to  neutralize hostile regimes has come - in this case, after the  "neutralization" of Iraq, Libya, Syria and the partial collapse of  the foundations of Egyptian statehood, it is the turn of the  elimination of the Iranian theocratic regime. I hasten to say that  this is a description of only part of the interests of some of the  participants involved and only a small part of the current process of  political reformatting of the continent.

- Are the Turkish intentions of Armenian Prime Minister Pashinyan an  independent initiative or is it part of the implementation of Russian  communication initiatives from November 9, 2020 and January 11, 2021?   And  what cost their implementation may have for Armenia?

- The Russian side has been openly conducting a constant dialogue  with Ankara for five years about the possibilities of normalizing  Armenian-Turkish relations and unblocking regional communications. Of  course, the most important precondition for moving in this direction  was the settlement of the Artsakh problem. At some point, some  Russian political and expert circles introduced the formula  "territories in exchange for a reduction in tension on the line of  contact ". Based on the foregoing, it can be argued that Russian  approaches to unblocking communications and linking the process to  the Artsakh problem were voiced long before Pashinyan came to power.   Nevertheless, Nikol Pashinyan will bear the responsibility for any  decisions made today by the Armenian leadership in the field of  Armenian-Turkish relations, the opening of communications or  corridors and for any of their consequences.

-Based on the statements made during the meetings of the Prime  Ministers of Armenia and Georgia and the Prime Minister of Georgia  with the President of Turkey, we have to state Georgia's interest in  the current processes with the participation of Armenia, Turkey, and,  not in last place, Azerbaijan. Can it be noted that this interest is  by no means limited to mediation?  What can Georgia get from the  unblocking of the region, which benefits mainly from the Armenian,  Turkish and Azerbaijani transit through its own territory?

-Possibly, Georgia proceeds from the fact that parallel to the  radical strengthening of the military-political positions of Turkey  in Azerbaijan, the role and influence of Russia in the South Caucasus  as a whole will decrease, and it would be good to take advantage of  this. And this can be used, for example, if Tbilisi can successfully  replace Moscow in the process of establishing a positive political  dialogue to begin with between the leaderships of Turkey and Armenia.   At the same time, it is important to note that influential  non-regional players - world centers of power - will be interested in  such a replacement.

-Do you consider it possible to harmonize and simultaneously  implement transport and communication projects "North-South" and  "East-West" - (Meghri corridor) or are they two fundamentally  contradictory geopolitical projects?

- I would not particularly focus on communications now - they can  only indicate certain contours of real or possible influence in  relation to any territory and at the same time not work in a free  mode. Only deciphering the real interests and intentions of the  initiators of the global reformatting and determining the appetites  of their "assistants" on the ground will make it possible to  distinguish false, deceitful actions from steps aimed at achieving  their true goals.

- It is already known that the main topic of the Sochi meeting  between Putin and Erdogan on September 29 will be Syria, in general,  and Idlib, in particular. Are Syria and Artsakh part of the same  chain in the Russian-Turkish contradictions, or are they  fundamentally different cases? And in this light, can we expect  changes in the settlement of the conflict over Artsakh if an  agreement is reached between Moscow and Ankara on the issue of  northern Syria?

-I am not inclined to directly link Syria and Artsakh in the context  of Russian-Turkish relations.  However, let's not forget that it was  after the crisis that erupted as a result of the destruction of a  Russian military aircraft by the Turks and the demonstrative murder  of a pilot that an unexpected honeymoon began in Russian-Turkish  relations. Apparently, it was this period at the same time that  created the basis for voicing Russian initiatives to normalize  Armenian-Turkish relations, and even in connection with the solution  of the Artsakh issue.   

-The last month has become a period, accompanied by mutual threats,  periodic verbal duels between various secondary representatives of  the authorities of Iran and Azerbaijan. All this is accompanied by  the accumulation of the Iranian military on the border with  Azerbaijan. What is wrong today in the relations between Baku and  Tehran, does Israel play a role in this, and what is Iran seeking  from Azerbaijan?   

- For Israel, the overthrow of the theocratic regime in Iran is an  existential issue.  In this light, the conduct of intelligence  activities directed against Iran from the territory of Azerbaijan has  been and will continue.  By the way, it is possible that, for a long  period of time, reconnaissance drones purchased by Azerbaijan, having  completed their tasks in the sky of Artsakh, then flew into the  airspace of Iran. It seems that Tehran understands the threat to  itself arising from Israel's actions and the risks arising from its  close military cooperation with Azerbaijan. In my opinion, Tehran  missed the time and opportunity to effectively counter the emerging  threat from the north. Most likely, the development of an unfavorable  situation around Iran should seriously concern China as well.  Apparently it will not take long to wait for the denouement.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Samvel Karapetyan sues blogger Roman Baghdasaryan demanding retraction and payment of 6 million dramsSamvel Karapetyan sues blogger Roman Baghdasaryan demanding retraction and payment of 6 million drams
Zhanna Andreasyan: RA government  prioritizes development of Armenian StudiesZhanna Andreasyan: RA government  prioritizes development of Armenian Studies
Court`s decision to arrest NA deputy Artur Sargsyan to be appealed- lawyerCourt`s decision to arrest NA deputy Artur Sargsyan to be appealed- lawyer
Artur Sargsyan arrested for 2 monthsArtur Sargsyan arrested for 2 months
ARF members, Russian State Duma representatives discuss regional security issuesARF members, Russian State Duma representatives discuss regional security issues
RA Prime Minister arrives in UAE on working visitRA Prime Minister arrives in UAE on working visit
RA MFA: There can be no agreement on  RA MFA: There can be no agreement on  "Zangezur corridor"
Zakharova comments on information about Azerbaijan selling weapons to UkraineZakharova comments on information about Azerbaijan selling weapons to Ukraine
Oppositionist: It is necessary to integrate Artsakh residents in Armenia in order to move away from the principle of Oppositionist: It is necessary to integrate Artsakh residents in Armenia in order to move away from the principle of "no man, no problem"
Starting January 1, citizenship  services for both obtaining and terminating citizenship will be digitized- MIAStarting January 1, citizenship  services for both obtaining and terminating citizenship will be digitized- MIA
A decision to arrest a member of the National Assembly to be made within the next  2-3 hours - lawyerA decision to arrest a member of the National Assembly to be made within the next  2-3 hours - lawyer
Armenia, Iran  Defense Ministers discuss regional security issuesArmenia, Iran  Defense Ministers discuss regional security issues
Prosperous Armenia Party  leader  interrogated by  Anti-Corruption CommitteeProsperous Armenia Party  leader  interrogated by  Anti-Corruption Committee
Oppositionist: Pashinyan  repressing the opposition to show Aliyev and Erdogan his loyalty to the agreements made with them Oppositionist: Pashinyan  repressing the opposition to show Aliyev and Erdogan his loyalty to the agreements made with them 
AAC followers from all over the world form Pan-Armenian Council for  the Protection of the Armenian ChurchAAC followers from all over the world form Pan-Armenian Council for  the Protection of the Armenian Church
Armenia, Greece discuss recent developments in  South CaucasusArmenia, Greece discuss recent developments in  South Caucasus
Zakharova: Armenian side was offered concrete steps on  stop listsZakharova: Armenian side was offered concrete steps on  stop lists
Briefing on Swiss Peace Initiative for Artsakh  in US CongressBriefing on Swiss Peace Initiative for Artsakh  in US Congress
Lawyer: Nowadays, any political process in Armenia is accompanied by  interference from the state apparatusLawyer: Nowadays, any political process in Armenia is accompanied by  interference from the state apparatus
Armenia to tighten criminal liability for attacks on doctorsArmenia to tighten criminal liability for attacks on doctors
Armenia`s Deputy FM, UN official exchange views on UN80 initiativeArmenia`s Deputy FM, UN official exchange views on UN80 initiative
Court discussing MP`s arrestCourt discussing MP`s arrest
Armenian premier, Azerbaijani president to meet in Abu Dhabi Armenian premier, Azerbaijani president to meet in Abu Dhabi 
Civil Contract party board meeting take place Civil Contract party board meeting take place 
Judge`s decision on Samvel Karapetyan case one more incitement to legal absurdity - lawyer Judge`s decision on Samvel Karapetyan case one more incitement to legal absurdity - lawyer 
U.S. Sec of State mentioned Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization `for a  reason` - Tammy BruceU.S. Sec of State mentioned Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization `for a  reason` - Tammy Bruce
Azerbaijan`s government plan to take control of Armenia under  humanitarian disguise being executed - Arman Tatoyan Azerbaijan`s government plan to take control of Armenia under  humanitarian disguise being executed - Arman Tatoyan 
Expecting 2026 elections amid promises given to external forces  extremely risky - opposition MPExpecting 2026 elections amid promises given to external forces  extremely risky - opposition MP
Tashir Pizza allowed to resume operation in Abovyan Tashir Pizza allowed to resume operation in Abovyan 
Armenian premier sends congratulatory message to president of Argentina Armenian premier sends congratulatory message to president of Argentina 
Law-enforcers confiscate large batch of drugs Law-enforcers confiscate large batch of drugs 
Aliyev regime continues destroying Artsakh Armenians` property in Stepanakert Aliyev regime continues destroying Artsakh Armenians` property in Stepanakert 
Situation surrounding ENA has political implication - Tashir Situation surrounding ENA has political implication - Tashir 
Armenia`s authorities seeking to neutralize all rivals and form  atmosphere of fear - expert Armenia`s authorities seeking to neutralize all rivals and form  atmosphere of fear - expert 
Armenian authorities prove quality of all before unlawfulness -  Larisa Alaverdyan Armenian authorities prove quality of all before unlawfulness -  Larisa Alaverdyan 
Forest fire prevention discussed at RA Ministry of Interior Forest fire prevention discussed at RA Ministry of Interior 
Washington hopes for peace deal between Armenia, Azerbaijan soon Washington hopes for peace deal between Armenia, Azerbaijan soon 
Aram I calls for putting end to destructive atmosphere in Armenia Aram I calls for putting end to destructive atmosphere in Armenia 
Artur Sargsyan stripped of his parliamentary immunityArtur Sargsyan stripped of his parliamentary immunity
Political scientist: Pashinyan`s government acknowledges that it is  impossible to simultaneously oppose two non-agreement-capable  opposition centersPolitical scientist: Pashinyan`s government acknowledges that it is  impossible to simultaneously oppose two non-agreement-capable  opposition centers
World Council of Churches expresses deep concern regarding recent  developments involving the Armenian Apostolic ChurchWorld Council of Churches expresses deep concern regarding recent  developments involving the Armenian Apostolic Church
Armenian Deputy FM participates in the Special Session of the  Assembly of States Parties to the Rome Statute on the Review of the  Draft Amendments on the Crime of AggressionArmenian Deputy FM participates in the Special Session of the  Assembly of States Parties to the Rome Statute on the Review of the  Draft Amendments on the Crime of Aggression
Armenian Ombudsperson signals a violation of lawyers` right to access  their clients in the preliminary investigation bodyArmenian Ombudsperson signals a violation of lawyers` right to access  their clients in the preliminary investigation body
 RA Prime Minister visits Kotayk branch of  SOS Children`s Villages RA Prime Minister visits Kotayk branch of SOS Children`s Villages
Jerusalem`s Armenian Quarter  most targeted by anti- Christian  incidents in Israel - ReportJerusalem`s Armenian Quarter  most targeted by anti- Christian  incidents in Israel - Report
Narek Karapetyan: Authorities want to start a pre-planned process  against Tashir GroupNarek Karapetyan: Authorities want to start a pre-planned process  against Tashir Group
Armenia officially joins UN Countering Terrorism Travel Program Armenia officially joins UN Countering Terrorism Travel Program 
Vice Speaker: The government must respond to threats, otherwise it  will lead to chaosVice Speaker: The government must respond to threats, otherwise it  will lead to chaos
No detainees from among ENA staff members - acting CEONo detainees from among ENA staff members - acting CEO
War in Armenia - politician War in Armenia - politician 
Armenian law-enfrocers publicly ordered to attack AAC - lawyerArmenian law-enfrocers publicly ordered to attack AAC - lawyer
Swiss MPs to present peace initiative on return to Artsakh in  Washington Swiss MPs to present peace initiative on return to Artsakh in  Washington 
RA Human Rights Defender condemns squabble in NA RA Human Rights Defender condemns squabble in NA 
Russian-Armenian businessman files slander claims against Armenian  premier, deputy head of RA premier`s staff Russian-Armenian businessman files slander claims against Armenian  premier, deputy head of RA premier`s staff 
Everyone expected this - Narek Karapetyan Everyone expected this - Narek Karapetyan 
Armenia`s Investigative Committee investigating major embezzlement  cases Armenia`s Investigative Committee investigating major embezzlement  cases 
ENA Board chairman brought to ENA head office ENA Board chairman brought to ENA head office 
Tensions in Armenia`s parliamentTensions in Armenia`s parliament
AraratBank participated in the WEPs regional experience-sharing workshopAraratBank participated in the WEPs regional experience-sharing workshop
Ruling force`s action illegal - Arman TatoyanRuling force`s action illegal - Arman Tatoyan
Read more



Commented