Arminfo.info



 Monday, July 13 2020 10:45
David Stepanyan

Analyst: Re-Islamization of Hagia Sophia due to Erdogan`s hatred for  Ataturk

Analyst: Re-Islamization of Hagia Sophia due to Erdogan`s hatred for  Ataturk

ArmInfo. All the recent actions of Turkish President Recep Erdogan regarding the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul are dictated by two reasons. A similar opinion was expressed by ArmInfo Azerbaijani analyst Rauf Mirkadyrov.

On July 10, the Turkish State Council overturned the decision of the  Kemal Ataturk government of 1934, which assigned the status of a  museum to Hagia Sophia. According to the decree of Recep Erdogan, the  cathedral will now become a mosque.

"Firstly, he needs to mobilize and rally his own social base, which  as a whole is a conservative nationalist, poorly educated part of the  population with low incomes. Until now, Erdogan has managed to  achieve this goal by providing this part of the population with  socio-economic and political benefits and "As you know, the Turkish  economy is in a deep crisis, and not only because of the coronavirus  epidemic. Accordingly, Erdogan no longer has the opportunity to  ensure the loyalty of his electorate solely by handouts of a socio-  economic nature," he said.

It is precisely this impossibility that Mirkadyrov determines the use  by Erdogan of a map of contradictions between Christians and Muslims,  given the fact that Hagia Sophia is an important symbol for the  Christian world, especially for Orthodox and Turkish Muslims.  Erdogan's similar move, according to the analyst's estimation, is  win-win from the point of view of the internal political struggle.  The Turkish president was well aware that the Christian, especially  the Orthodox world, would take this decision with hostility and that  political points could be gained from this.

Mirkadyrov considers the second point in history around the  Islamization of Hagia Sophia to be Erdogan's hatred of everything  republican and secular in Turkey, in general, and Ataturk in  particular. According to the analyst, Erdogan today is speculating on  the historical past of Turkey and on the ideals of neo- Ottomanism.  Stressing that Hagia Sophia, which had been converted centuries ago  into a mosque, received the status of a museum in 1934 by a  strong-willed decision of Ataturk. It is no coincidence that, in his  opinion, Erdogan's recent decision to demolish the beautiful Istanbul  Ataturk International Airport looks like it.

"At the same time, I want to emphasize that religion, including  religious churches, are becoming the object of political speculation  everywhere. For example, in Switzerland, where I live, it was  forbidden to build mosques with minarets. For the reason that they  spoil the architectural appearance of Swiss cities I can give an  example from the history of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations. In  Armenia, a mosque in Yerevan is called Persian with tenacity worthy  of better use. However, a mosque cannot be Persian or Azerbaijani.  Mosques are Shiite or Sunni. So, such speculations are about religion  and religious feelings today, unfortunately, is a common occurrence  throughout the world, "the Azerbaijani analyst summed up.

The construction of the Hagia Sophia was completed in 537. Built by  decree of the Byzantine emperor Justinian the First, the cathedral  was the largest religious building of Christianity. Hagia Sophia is  also known for the fact that it was there that the church split and  Orthodoxy began its birth from there - it was there that the  Patriarch of Constantinople was renounced from the Roman Church. In  1453, after the capture of Constantinople by the Turks, Sultan Mehmet  II ordered to turn the church into a mosque. After almost 600 years,  Hagia Sophia again changed its status, becoming a museum on the  orders of Ataturk. In 1985, UNESCO included the cathedral in the list  of historical cultural monuments.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Aliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, ArmeniaAliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, Armenia
Armenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperationArmenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperation
Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official 
Closing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  AghdamClosing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  Aghdam
Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  
India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism 
Armenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in TavushArmenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in Tavush
May One procession to take place in Yerevan May One procession to take place in Yerevan 
Armenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s bordersArmenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s borders
Contract serviceman injured in demining operations in TavushContract serviceman injured in demining operations in Tavush
Armenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc MelenchonArmenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc Melenchon
Driver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roadsDriver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roads
France is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  DevinazFrance is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  Devinaz
Ruben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strikeRuben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strike
20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 
Freedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  TsitsernakaberdFreedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  Tsitsernakaberd
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners 
Current situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - SpeakerCurrent situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - Speaker
European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29
"We are waiting!", Russian side expects Pashinyan`s participation in  EAEU summit
Protests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizensProtests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizens
Legitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA SpeakerLegitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA Speaker
Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?
Vladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levelsVladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levels
Yeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupierYeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupier
Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`
Political analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary electionsPolitical analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary elections
U.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-AzerbaijanU.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-Azerbaijan
If left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. KennedyIf left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. Kennedy
Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan 
Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan 
Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge 
Situation in Tavush remains tenseSituation in Tavush remains tense
Armenia plans to open consulate general in TabrizArmenia plans to open consulate general in Tabriz
Summer conscription starts in Armenia Summer conscription starts in Armenia 
Armenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schoolsArmenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schools
Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert 
French PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian GenocideFrench PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide
Six Combat Brotherhood members released Six Combat Brotherhood members released 
Actions of disobedience start in Armenia Actions of disobedience start in Armenia 
Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square 
On April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of UruguayOn April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of Uruguay
British MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian QuarterBritish MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian Quarter
President of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgottenPresident of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgotten
Nikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanityNikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanity
Turkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman EmpireTurkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman Empire
Russian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian peopleRussian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian people
Abkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian peopleAbkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian people
Support for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to TsitsernakaberdSupport for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to Tsitsernakaberd
`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire
Turkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideTurkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
Ruben Vardanyan: Ruben Vardanyan: "Now I understand that principles and values are  much more important than life"
Syrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian GenocideSyrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian Genocide
Jonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian GenocideJonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian Genocide
Pan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram IPan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram I
Armenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideArmenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide
In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on  western democracies to recognize it In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on western democracies to recognize it
Armenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in VarnaArmenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in Varna
Read more



Commented