Arminfo.info


 Wednesday, January 29 2020 15:32
David Stepanyan

The link between the suicides of former security officials should be  the primary version of law enforcement officers 

The link between the suicides of former security officials should be  the primary version of law enforcement officers 

ArmInfo.Political analyst, member of the Public Council under the Head of Police of Armenia Saro Saroyan in an interview with ArmInfo comments on the recent deaths of  former security officials, some of the nuances of the work of  domestic intelligence services. He shares his own vision of  overcoming new threats and challenges to the national security of  Armenia, representing a point of view regarding the effectiveness and  appropriateness of the recently adopted amendments to various laws of  the country.

- Since its independence, a number of murders of high ranked  officials occurred in Armenia, moreover, almost all criminal cases  remained undisclosed to this day. After the change of power in the  country, already two security officials died under similar  circumstances: Hayk Harutyunyan and Georgi Kutoyan. And Ashot  Karapetyan, the former chief of the Yerevan Police, was blown up by  gas in Russia. The authorities, apparently, are leading the case to  suicide, society tends to see a single chain in all these deaths.  What is your vision of the situation?

The situation is really very complex, considering that the political  transformations that began in 2018 were not only not completed, but  turned out to be even more complicated. And the deaths of former  security officials in the last period in fact give rise to many  versions. At the same time, a large part of society is not convinced  by the assertion of the current administration regarding the absence  of facts in favor of a single chain of these deaths. Even if we  accept the official version of the suicide of these individuals -  carriers of classified information, it is obvious that various  political reasons are the basis of the facts of their death. It is  also obvious that there are very serious domestic and foreign  political circles uninterested in disseminating, even destroying,  information owned by the deceased. 

At the same time, the lack of a degree of professionalism among the  Armenian special services allowing them to stop serious security  challenges faced by our country is a long-known fact. 

Armenia has faced October 27, March 1, the overthrow of the  constitutional order, the April War, the uprising against the  dictatorship, the Velvet Revolution, etc. There was fertile ground  for all these events:  usurpation of power, thousands of crimes,  criminal inaction, omissions, systemic corruption, shattering the  foundations of our statehood, the activity of external forces, etc. 

All this seems to be the result of the activities of our special  services not at full capacity, or rather the result of their  inaction. The mere absence of disclosing cases of wiretapping of the  director of the NSS and the loss of critical documents already  indicates the complete absence of special services in Armenia as an  institution. And the suicide of the former director of the NSS in  itself, as an illogical and abnormal phenomenon, was another proof of  the truth I presented. In such a situation, the possibility of  simulating suicides and suicides under pressure and threats, which in  essence are political killings, was expected. The current situation  already demonstrates that the link between suicides should not be  ruled out, moreover it should be considered as the main version  during investigation by law enforcement agencies.

- The nuances of the work of the special services have been largely  discussed in the context of the bill recently adopted to provide the  Police with the opportunity to wiretap citizens in the open mode. The  former Head of the NSS main department on protecting constitution and   public order and anti- terrorism Tigran Barseghyan in an interview  revealed many of the NSS's methods of work to the public.  It seems  that in our country people talk about the work of special services  too openly.  Does this come from the interests of our society and the  state?

The concentration of public attention on the special services is a  natural and irresistible phenomenon. This is facilitated by the  formal existence of national security bodies in the country, their  absence in a meaningful sense, periodic new challenges to the  national security of Armenia, the interest of external and internal  forces in its destabilization, a change in the political system, as  well as an increase in the dependence of the country's political  leadership.

This state of affairs is the result of a lack of security among  citizens, but never of the usual curiosity or artificial influence on  society in the matter of the NSS. This is precisely the reason for  the decision to grant the Police the right to listen on their own.  Naturally, if it were not for the lack of security, this right would  never have been granted to other state body. The NSS would meet the  entire demand.

At the same time, I want to note that today attention is focused not  on the legitimate and secret methods and means of the special  services, which would be abnormal and unacceptable, but on their  fruitless, often very dangerous activities. I am convinced that the  public should be demanding in relation to ensuring their own security  by the state. And in a situation when former heads of the Police and  the National Security Service commit suicide one after another,  society is simply obliged to react very sharply.

- In recent years, an influx of citizens of India, Iran, and Arab  countries professing Islam has been observed in Armenia. According to  some reports, these people are already behaving aggressively in  certain episodes. And this is in conditions when some of our  compatriots - citizens of Armenia are Muslims. It is appropriate to  recall that a soldier of the 102nd Russian Military Base was killed  in Gyumri by an Armenian Muslim. In your opinion, does such an influx  of representatives of the "Islamic Renaissance" into Armenia create  additional problems for our security and the volume of work for our  special services?

You have just mentioned a new challenge, the presence of which I  recently spoke about. Migration today has thrown down the glove to  stability of the state and public order on a global scale. Some  supranational organizations and even states, for example, Turkey,  which is neighboring with us, adapt migration to serve their own  interests. Europe today in fact suffers from migration.

In this light, it is natural that small, 2-3 million societies, such  as our, facing the threats posed by migration, are pretty helpless.  You noted only one component of this threat - the factor of religion.  Meanwhile, there are many similar factors. A single migrant can  spread a virus that exceeds the damage done by thousands of migrants.  And the state should be ready to withstand all this. And in the  absence of special services, it makes no sense to talk about the  degree of our resistance to such challenges.

We can only entrust our own security to the superpowers that ensure  the protection of our borders, operating secret biological  laboratories on our territory, etc. The world has long lived in the  supremacy of special services. And the criteria for assessing the  independence and sovereignty of a state come from the degree of  consistency of its special services, or the degree of its dependence  on the special services of other countries.

- On January 22, parliament approved a bill that introduces criminal  liability - up to 10 years in prison for belonging to the highest  caste of the criminal hierarchy in relation to "thieves in law." In  this light what are the perspectives of the fight against thieves, in  your opinion? Is a single law sufficient, or are deeper processes  necessary?

Thieves' mores are a consequence of our culture. The culture, we  inherited from the USSR. Among our compatriots from the Diaspora,  possibly other elements of criminal culture, but never thieves mores,  exist.  In this sense, the introduction of some punitive and  protective, formal legislative mechanisms is an important step,  however not the main one. It is impossible to replace culture with  laws. And deep changes in us are possible only as a result of a  change in the value system. And this is possible through the  promotion of universal and national values, education, training, the  exchange of experience, the introduction of a different lifestyle.

It is impossible to get rid of thieves' concepts in today's  conditions when TV shows demonstrate thieves 'morals and criminal  environment, TV soap operas cultivate human vices, human  manifestations of inequality as a life credo. However, everything is  not so bad. There is also a reason for optimism.  Compared with other  societies in the post-Soviet space, the situation in Armenia looks  much better. Due to hospitality, mutual assistance, sympathy and  empathy that lie more deeply in us, thieves mores violate our public  life only partially. For example, many of our young people today live  the dream of achieving good luck in creating new types of robots,  rather than striving to take a place in the thieves' world. I am  convinced that if a clear, comprehensive state policy is pursued,  vicious thieves' morals can be uprooted and sent to landfill.

According to the draft amendments to the law "On Public Service"  adopted by the parliament in the second and final reading, the age  limit for advisers to state leaders in Armenia has been reduced from  30 to 25 years. How can such a rejuvenation of our leadership affect  the work of government agencies, including the country's top  leadership?  In general, these legislative adjustments are the result  of certain thinking. The velvet revolution has become a reality  primarily thanks to youth. This made it possible to build trust and  sympathy among us regarding youth. At the same time, spinning, this  snowball collected a lot of garbage and dirt. As a result, today we  have reached the point when illogical, unreasonable, and often  dangerous decisions are often made. And certain young people are  entrusted with areas in which they cannot even express themselves.  Neglect of social experience always leads to negative consequences.  And there is a significant difference between a person appointed to  the same position at 25 or 45 years old.  I am convinced that many  officials or lawmakers would make more effective and problem-free  decisions if they had a richer life experience. Obviously, the  process of involving young people in different positions is the  result of political convictions and thinking of the country's  leadership. In particular, the management of a number of areas of  intellectual, but not experienced and, therefore, dependent, youth is  considered the safest. Than specialized, but strong-willed  specialists. Such a policy, of course, has negative consequences.   Over time, this snowball may well collect all the associated garbage,  dirtying even clean snow. I hope that such a policy will be abandoned  after all.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
AGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unityAGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unity
Representatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All ArmeniansRepresentatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All Armenians
Kallas promised Pashinyan EU supportKallas promised Pashinyan EU support
Swiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-KarabakhSwiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-Karabakh
ARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptableARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptable
Azerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFAAzerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFA
MFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against IranMFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against Iran
Samvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorshipSamvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorship
After  After  "velvet revolution" Pashinyan tripled RA National Security  Service`s funding  
NA Member: Processes  in Armenia are its internal affairNA Member: Processes  in Armenia are its internal affair
Lavrov: If Armenia turns away from its allies, it will hardly benefit  the Armenian peopleLavrov: If Armenia turns away from its allies, it will hardly benefit  the Armenian people
Armenian MPs held several meetings in  U.S.Armenian MPs held several meetings in  U.S.
Zakharova: Our diplomats in Baku unable to contact Russian citizensZakharova: Our diplomats in Baku unable to contact Russian citizens
Kremlin: Membership in CSTO guarantees certain benefits, but the  decision is only up to YerevanKremlin: Membership in CSTO guarantees certain benefits, but the  decision is only up to Yerevan
Mirzoyan: Armenia, EU signal  important achievements in bilateral  relationsMirzoyan: Armenia, EU signal  important achievements in bilateral  relations
Mirzoyan, Kallas signed agreement on establishing framework for  Armenia`s participation in  EU crisis management operationsMirzoyan, Kallas signed agreement on establishing framework for  Armenia`s participation in  EU crisis management operations
Kallas: EU excited about peace process between Yerevan and Baku and  hopes for a swift resolutionKallas: EU excited about peace process between Yerevan and Baku and  hopes for a swift resolution
NA Vice Speaker, Iranian Ambassador discuss developments in South  Caucasus and  Middle EastNA Vice Speaker, Iranian Ambassador discuss developments in South  Caucasus and  Middle East
Customer Appreciation Day at IDBankCustomer Appreciation Day at IDBank
Poland met about 85% of Armenia`s requests for legal assistance - RA  Prosecutor GeneralPoland met about 85% of Armenia`s requests for legal assistance - RA  Prosecutor General
Mirzoyan calls on Lavrov not to interfere Mirzoyan calls on Lavrov not to interfere "in  internal affairs" of  Armenia
Samvel Karapetyan`s another message from pre-trial detention centerSamvel Karapetyan`s another message from pre-trial detention center
Two clergymen in one cell to wiretapping - lawyer Two clergymen in one cell to wiretapping - lawyer 
Attacks on Armenian church arouse concern - Russian FMAttacks on Armenian church arouse concern - Russian FM
Clergyman`s lawyers explain his position on nomination for Armenia`s  premiershipClergyman`s lawyers explain his position on nomination for Armenia`s  premiership
AraratBank Joins BAFT AssociationAraratBank Joins BAFT Association
Head of the European office of ARF calls on Kaja Kallas to visit  Mother See of EtchmiadzinHead of the European office of ARF calls on Kaja Kallas to visit  Mother See of Etchmiadzin
Armenian Community of Bulgaria condemns attacks on Armenian church Armenian Community of Bulgaria condemns attacks on Armenian church 
1937 back in Armenia - Bagrat Galstanyan 1937 back in Armenia - Bagrat Galstanyan 
Cathedral of Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin to host prayer service  all week for release of prisoners, consolation of grieving and peace  in homelandCathedral of Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin to host prayer service  all week for release of prisoners, consolation of grieving and peace  in homeland
Armenian FM not to take part in CSTO Council of Foreign Ministers`  meeting in KyrgyzstanArmenian FM not to take part in CSTO Council of Foreign Ministers`  meeting in Kyrgyzstan
EU High Rep holding negotiations in Yerevan EU High Rep holding negotiations in Yerevan 
Azerbaijan has never been Russia`s strategic partner - Konstantin  Zatulin Azerbaijan has never been Russia`s strategic partner - Konstantin  Zatulin 
Watchful eye of Sauron-Erdogan in Baku, cowardly bleating of freaks  in power in Yerevan and Russia`s silence: Armenians expelled from  their places of thousand-year residence in Nagorno-Karabakh - analyst Watchful eye of Sauron-Erdogan in Baku, cowardly bleating of freaks  in power in Yerevan and Russia`s silence: Armenians expelled from  their places of thousand-year residence in Nagorno-Karabakh - analyst 
French president`s statement encourages establishment of dictatorship  in Armenia - ARD rep French president`s statement encourages establishment of dictatorship  in Armenia - ARD rep 
French president voices support for reforms in Armenia French president voices support for reforms in Armenia 
 Patriarch of Moscow and All Rus` congratulates Aram I on 30th  anniversary of his enthronement Patriarch of Moscow and All Rus` congratulates Aram I on 30th  anniversary of his enthronement
Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem condemns incident at the Mother  See of Holy EtchmiadzinArmenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem condemns incident at the Mother  See of Holy Etchmiadzin
IEC supports Samvel Karapetyan, President of Tashir Group of  Companies IEC supports Samvel Karapetyan, President of Tashir Group of  Companies 
Andranik Simonyan appointed head of National Security Service of  ArmeniaAndranik Simonyan appointed head of National Security Service of  Armenia
Armenia Prime Minister  suggests putting an end to the use of vulgar  language in publicArmenia Prime Minister  suggests putting an end to the use of vulgar  language in public
David Ananyan: The ultimate goal of this political play is clear: the  Patriarch and the AACDavid Ananyan: The ultimate goal of this political play is clear: the  Patriarch and the AAC
Mekhitarist Order of Venice supports AAC and  Catholicos of All  ArmeniansMekhitarist Order of Venice supports AAC and  Catholicos of All  Armenians
Minors detained during events at Mother See of Echmiadzin  -  Ombudsman`s OfficeMinors detained during events at Mother See of Echmiadzin  -  Ombudsman`s Office
In U.S., NA MPs presented details of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace processIn U.S., NA MPs presented details of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process
Swedish Ambassador: Leaving Armenia with good memoriesSwedish Ambassador: Leaving Armenia with good memories
RA Prosecutor`s Office presents evidence of Archbishop Mikael  Ajapahyan`s guiltRA Prosecutor`s Office presents evidence of Archbishop Mikael  Ajapahyan`s guilt
Earthquake  recorded in ArmeniaEarthquake  recorded in Armenia
Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan arrested for two months - lawyerArchbishop Mikael Ajapahyan arrested for two months - lawyer
Armenian security forces continue repressionsArmenian security forces continue repressions
Russia closely following the situation in Armenian EchmiadzinRussia closely following the situation in Armenian Echmiadzin
Armenia`s National Security Service  recalls security considerationsArmenia`s National Security Service  recalls security considerations
Mother See of Holy Echmiadzin: June 27 of this year will be  remembered as a day of national disgraceMother See of Holy Echmiadzin: June 27 of this year will be  remembered as a day of national disgrace
Sati Spivakova: Stop Sati Spivakova: Stop "the witch hunt"! Don`t block the road leading  to the Temple!
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin: The behavior exhibited by the law  enforcement officers at the spiritual center of all  Armenians-particularly the use of force against citizens-is  deplorable and unacceptableMother See of Holy Etchmiadzin: The behavior exhibited by the law  enforcement officers at the spiritual center of all  Armenians-particularly the use of force against citizens-is  deplorable and unacceptable
ANC strongly condemns  security forces` attack on Holy EtchmiadzinANC strongly condemns  security forces` attack on Holy Etchmiadzin
Mikheil Saakashvili states that Armenia has already signed a peace  agreementMikheil Saakashvili states that Armenia has already signed a peace  agreement
Pashinyan s latest accusation against Elseti is another liePashinyan s latest accusation against Elseti is another lie
Diplomats: An open war  declared against our national identityDiplomats: An open war  declared against our national identity
Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan "surrendered" to the Investigative  Committee
Read more



Commented