Arminfo.info




 Monday, November 7 2016 16:59
David Stepanyan

Ruben Shugaryan: The time has come for settlement of Karabakh conflict based on Responsibility to Protect and Remedial Recognition norms

Ruben Shugaryan: The time has come for settlement of Karabakh conflict based on Responsibility to Protect and Remedial Recognition norms

In an interview with ArmInfo, Ruben Shugaryan, former deputy foreign minister of Armenia, former Armenian Ambassador to the U.S., Professor at the U.S.  Tufts University's Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, shares his views about the Armenian policy towards the Karabakh conflict settlement following the April aggression of Azerbaijan. He also speaks of the latest changes in the international law, and substantiates the need to adjust Armenia’s foreign policy and national security doctrine to the global, geopolitical trends.

 

You had worked at the Armenian Foreign Ministry for a long time. Would you outline the real limits of possible concessions of the Karabakh conflict parties on the path to the settlement?  

 

I think the Karabakh problem has undergone certain evolution. In the early 1990s the key achievement of Armenia was internationalization of the intermediary efforts in the conflict settlement process. Unlike Georgia that "had two and a half conflicts on its territory", we were able to put the Karabakh peace process under the OSCE auspices. Over the past few years, the process has inter alia seen failures and disappointments. However, at that time we managed to create a negotiation format and to institutionalize the entire negotiation practice by balancing it through the presence of three permanent members of the UN Security Council - the United States, France, and Russia. Moreover, today the Karabakh problem is the only platform, where the U.S. and Russia are still cooperating somehow. We should understand that amid the complicated relations between the big countries, they always need one or two issues to cooperate on.  This allows them to rise to more or less digestible level of discussion of more global issues. Therefore, the US and Russia also consider the Karabakh problem as a toehold for creation of future formats. Armenian diplomacy has always tried to find a compromise in the U.S.- Russia relations to prevent the Karabakh problem from turning into a stumbling block between Washington and Moscow. As for France, the representative of the European Union, it always represents itself whatever the outcome.    

                           

Do you think the “April war” unleashed by Azerbaijan has brought more tangible changes and prospects to the negotiation process?

 

After the April war the settlement process has undergone quite tangible transformations. If prior to April the whole process had been based on certain principles, for example "Madrid" principles, in April Azerbaijan stepped across the dangerous line. Right after that Armenia on the highest level started to voice the possibility of recognizing Artsakh. In my opinion, the issue of recognition is rather complicated, given our participation in the negotiation process, one of the final goals of which is to determine the status of Artsakh. Azerbaijan regularly attempts to present the Karabakh conflict as a religious one and transfer it from the OSCE to the UN format. It was especially obvious during the April events when duplicating the ISIS's actions Baku was trying to play the card of religion and Islamic solidarity. I can point out a lot of similarities between today's Azerbaijan and the ISIS, for instance, the targeted violent actions by Azerbaijani military men against civilians in Artsakh.

 

Was it done deliberately? What was it aimed at?

 

It was aimed at frightening and sending a certain alarm to other countries. At the negotiations, Armenia needs to present not the facts of the conflict but its changed essence, which became evident in April when Azerbaijan overstepped all the possible moral and ethical lines. This was also done before April – Baku glorified Ramil Safarov, Ilham Aliyev threatened to shoot down the civil planes intending to land in Stepanakert Airport. The new international norm ‘Responsibility to Protect’ is a consensus solution presented by Kofi Annan and developed later by President of International Crisis Group Gareth John Evans. Another term 'Remedial Recognition' has recently become quite popular in the political language, the meaning of which is recognition, sovereignty and secession for survival. Today the issue of Karabakh should not be discussed within the principles of territorial integrity or people's right to self-determination. After Azerbaijan's April aggression, this issue has become an issue of physical survival for Karabakh people. By the way, Kosovo was recognized for the sake of survival, as after "Kosovo Liberation Army" was defeated by Serbs the international community came to the conclusion that there is no other solution. The same did not happen in Karabakh as the NKR Defense Army won Azerbaijan. It was the victory of defending Karabakh people against the aggressor Azerbaijan that has led to a paradoxical situation and maintenance of status quo till today.

 

In other words, have the aggressor and the victim swapped places especially in the light of Baku's regular claims about "one million of refugees and 20% of occupied territories"?

 

Certainly, they have. Due to the April aggression and Baku's intentionally uncovered threats, which were prevented only due to unprecedented consolidation of Armenian people, Yerevan has the chance to put things in the right place. The settlement process should remain within the OSCE, but the focuses should be shifted according to the international norm of "Remedial Recognition". I think that today the time has come to present Armenia's foreign policy regarding Karabakh in the humanitarian context.

 

Should Armenia be the first to officially recognize Artsakh in order to successfully put Remedial Recognition in practice?

 

I do not rule out Armenia's recognition of Artsakh under certain circumstances, but I think the recognition should not be the result of patriotic emotions of various political forces. Certainly, it is necessary to prepare for recognition and it is necessary to have the entire relevant legal package for that. It is also necessary to prepare certain countries for that. There are prerequisites for such recognition in many countries, even in the United States, though they are not at the federal level. Seven US states have already recognized Artsakh. This figure is not small. The recognition does not only irritate Azerbaijan, but also contains a message to the US Government. As regards Europe, France has a balanced approach within the OSCE. I think much can be done in Germany, where the situation has tangibly changed after the recognition of the Armenian Genocide, as well as in Scandinavian and small European countries, which give high priority to humanitarian issues. By recognizing the Genocide, any country subconsciously admits a possible balanced line in the Karabakh issue. In this light, Armenia itself should decide to which of these two issues to give higher priority. I think Armenia's key problem to be resolved is the Karabakh problem, especially with a view to prevent a new war. At the same time, it is necessary to take steps in the South American countries as well, for instance, Uruguay, Argentina, etc.

 

Germany’s example makes us think about the reasons preventing our lobby from changing priorities…

 

I think the Armenian lobby should change its priorities first of all following serious consultations with the Armenian Government. Lobbying is quite a delicate issue, but it is possible to change the list of priorities. We should be realists and we should understand that today it is impossible to raise the issue of the NKR recognition at the US Congress. At the same time, it is certainly possible to raise the issue of remedial recognition of Nagorno- Karabakh's right to self-determination, especially given that this issue completely fits into the current situation around Karabakh. This should be well thought out and this needs a serious job, including recommendations from Armenia.

 

The issue of cession of Artsakh territories is still relevant today. Today it is supplemented by the issue of deployment of Russian peacekeepers in the conflict zone and final conservation of the conflict without any status determination. Does this scenario meet Armenia’s interests and first of all the Karabakh people? What threats is it fraught with?  

 

Why Russian peacekeepers?

 

Russia has been strongly insisting on it.

 

Russia's intention to deploy its own peacekeepers in Karabakh does not mean at all that Russia will manage to do that. In my point of view, the settlement plan, which might work in 1998 cannot be used now and not only because the situation has changed. What I have always been concerned over in all the "Madrid", "Prague" and "Kazan" principles is not so much ceding territories as the issue of holding a referendum without defining its exact date. The issue of referendum is quite formal given that Azerbaijan's Constitution envisages its holding exclusively on the entire of its territory. There is a tendency of changing the term referendum with the term plebiscite in the negotiation process. This is absolutely unacceptable because the latter lacks the legal force of the referendum.

 

The publicized negotiation agenda on Karabakh suggests an impression that the negotiations will end up with cession of the districts and deployment of peacekeepers while everything else will be put off for an indefinite term…

 

I hope this impression will turn out to be wrong, but I cannot state the opposite for sure. I can only say that deployment of peacekeepers may be possible only when the exact schedule of settlement all the issues included in the negotiation agenda is developed. At the same time, deployment of peacekeepers of not only Russia but any other country is inadmissible, especially at the current stage. Our main mistake is the opinion that there should be certain limits for our position, whereas our position should be very flexible, in conformity to geopolitical changes. In 1998 we were dictating from the stronger side, but now that Azerbaijan tries to become that stronger side, we should radically change our position on Nagorno Karabakh…

 

By retrieving the role of the aggression victim due to Azerbaijan’s efforts…

 

Exactly. In the South Ossetian conflict Russia has applied in a unilateral manner the international standard of "Responsibility to Protect". And it is obvious that Moscow possesses a certain logical resource for justification of this position, though Russia didn't reach total adjudication like, for instance, Kosovo did. Russia tried to present the situation around Crimea in the same manner, but faced a total fiasco. Therefore, Armenia should stand back from the stereotypes and fears that by changing its stand on Nagorno Karabakh, Armenia could appear as unprincipled. We should understand that there should be a compromise anyway and that it is impossible to reach it without giving anything. At the same time, the main goal of Armenia should be to ensure independence of Nagorno Karabakh and its compulsory common border with Armenia, not only through the Lachin District - taking into consideration the expansion of possible shelling of the highway linking Armenia to Artsakh.

 

Is the prospect of a consensus on Karabakh an advantage or disadvantage for the Armenian sides?

 

The Nagorno Karabakh problem should be resolved by the two opposing sides, not by any mediators. Armenia and Azerbaijan should clearly understand that the settlement of the problem fully meets their own interests. I always get very much surprised when reading interviews form Armenia, comprising statements that the Nagorno Karabakh problem is already settled and the official settlement is something that we don't need at all. But the things are not like that. In the National Security Doctrine of Armenia, which, should be updated time to time by the way, Azerbaijan is mentioned everywhere. Meanwhile, in the unpublished part of the Azerbaijani Doctrine, Armenia, as a threat, holds only the third place, because Iran and Russia are much more serious threats for Azerbaijan than Armenia. That testifies to the existence of strategic thinking in Azerbaijan, while Armenia stays at the same level. Our Doctrine is written pretty well and professionally, but it is outmoded and we need to change it. Anyway, we should have two doctrines - close and open. Just to be on the safe side.


News
There are approximately 300 people still missing from the  Nagorno-Karabakh conflict escalation in 2020: ICRCThere are approximately 300 people still missing from the  Nagorno-Karabakh conflict escalation in 2020: ICRC
Simonyan, Bregadze discuss introduction of Mobile Justice House  experience in ArmeniaSimonyan, Bregadze discuss introduction of Mobile Justice House  experience in Armenia
U.S. committed to continuing close cooperation with Armenia on  justice, rule of law and strengthening democratic institutions:  AmbassadorU.S. committed to continuing close cooperation with Armenia on  justice, rule of law and strengthening democratic institutions:  Ambassador
Russian Foreign Ministry: Russia plans to hold specialized contacts  on the issue of demarcation and delimitation of the  Armenian-Azerbaijani borderRussian Foreign Ministry: Russia plans to hold specialized contacts  on the issue of demarcation and delimitation of the  Armenian-Azerbaijani border
Eduard Aghajanyan: There is no final decision on the candidacy for  the presidencyEduard Aghajanyan: There is no final decision on the candidacy for  the presidency
Justice Minister will head council of Constitutional Reforms: There  are representatives of NGOs in Council, but no representatives of   parliamentary oppositionJustice Minister will head council of Constitutional Reforms: There  are representatives of NGOs in Council, but no representatives of   parliamentary opposition
Eduard Aghajanyan: Recognition of the genocide has never been a  precondition for normalizing relations with TurkeyEduard Aghajanyan: Recognition of the genocide has never been a  precondition for normalizing relations with Turkey
The head of Turkmenistan took part in the first India-Central Asia summitThe head of Turkmenistan took part in the first India-Central Asia summit
Putin gratefully accepted Erdogan`s invitation to visit Turkey:  PeskovPutin gratefully accepted Erdogan`s invitation to visit Turkey:  Peskov
Forecast: The results of the U.S.-Russia talks can concretize the  future of the OSCE Minsk GroupForecast: The results of the U.S.-Russia talks can concretize the  future of the OSCE Minsk Group
Sharp increase in incidence of Sharp increase in incidence of "omicron" strain in Armenia 
Armenia`s government to continue supporting forcibly displaced  Artsakh residents Armenia`s government to continue supporting forcibly displaced  Artsakh residents 
Cross-stone commemorating Artsakh war heroes set up on ARMENAL  premises  Cross-stone commemorating Artsakh war heroes set up on ARMENAL  premises  
President`s statement answers questions about his resignation - Tevan  Poghosyan President`s statement answers questions about his resignation - Tevan  Poghosyan 
2,556 new COVID cases in Armenia 2,556 new COVID cases in Armenia 
Agnes Khamoyan: Robert Kocharyan will not run for president of  ArmeniaAgnes Khamoyan: Robert Kocharyan will not run for president of  Armenia
Expert: It is entirely in Armenia`s interests to put aside the  Expert: It is entirely in Armenia`s interests to put aside the  "Sevres romanticism"
 Forecast: Attempts to transfer the security of the post-Soviet space  to NATO will only increase the level of tension in the conflict Forecast: Attempts to transfer the security of the post-Soviet space  to NATO will only increase the level of tension in the conflict
Sweden ready to assist Armenia`s democratic progress Sweden ready to assist Armenia`s democratic progress 
Mnatsakan Safaryan appointed Deputy Foreign Minister of ArmeniaMnatsakan Safaryan appointed Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia
Armenia`s health minister, Iranian ambassador discuss cooperation in  health sector  Armenia`s health minister, Iranian ambassador discuss cooperation in  health sector  
Open borders between Armenia and EU will further develop our  partnership - Ararat MirzoyanOpen borders between Armenia and EU will further develop our  partnership - Ararat Mirzoyan
Armenia`s premier COVID-positive Armenia`s premier COVID-positive 
Armenian FM visits University of Luxembourg Armenian FM visits University of Luxembourg 
1,931 new COVID cases in Armenia 1,931 new COVID cases in Armenia 
RA presidential staff issues statement on article by Hetq.am news  website RA presidential staff issues statement on article by Hetq.am news  website 
The President of Turkmenistan took part in the high-level meeting The President of Turkmenistan took part in the high-level meeting "China - Central Asia"
RA Armed Forces replenished with new helicoptersRA Armed Forces replenished with new helicopters
Transparency International: Armenia is ahead of its EAEU partners in  the Corruption Perception IndexTransparency International: Armenia is ahead of its EAEU partners in  the Corruption Perception Index
Deputy Minister of Education: After graduating from school in  Armenia, schoolchildren can realize their abilities by a maximum of  57%.Deputy Minister of Education: After graduating from school in  Armenia, schoolchildren can realize their abilities by a maximum of  57%.
Rumors about possible withdrawal of the Russian base from Gyumri are  currently unfounded: MP from Civil ContractRumors about possible withdrawal of the Russian base from Gyumri are  currently unfounded: MP from Civil Contract
NSS of Armenia to check publication on foreign citizenship of Armen  SarkissianNSS of Armenia to check publication on foreign citizenship of Armen  Sarkissian
Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression: Cases of physical  violence against the media have tripled in 2021Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression: Cases of physical  violence against the media have tripled in 2021
Political scientist: The tense international situation around Ukraine  allows Armenia to gain time for the process of clarifying its borders  with AzerbaijanPolitical scientist: The tense international situation around Ukraine  allows Armenia to gain time for the process of clarifying its borders  with Azerbaijan
Moscow`s goal is its military presence in all South Caucasus states -  Giro Manoyan Moscow`s goal is its military presence in all South Caucasus states -  Giro Manoyan 
Opposition parliamentary factions to discuss presidential candudateOpposition parliamentary factions to discuss presidential candudate
1,332 news COVID cases in Armenia1,332 news COVID cases in Armenia
Ameriabank. The Largest Taxpayer among Armenian Banks  According to the Results of Year 2021Ameriabank. The Largest Taxpayer among Armenian Banks According to the Results of Year 2021
Not a single shot fired in Armenia in 2018 - premier Not a single shot fired in Armenia in 2018 - premier 
Armenian FM to visit LuxembourgArmenian FM to visit Luxembourg
Armenia could take part in diplomatic forum in Turkey - premier  Armenia could take part in diplomatic forum in Turkey - premier  
A telephone conversation took place between the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan Rashid Meredov and the Minister for External Affairs of the Republic of India Subrahmanyam Jaishankar.A telephone conversation took place between the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan Rashid Meredov and the Minister for External Affairs of the Republic of India Subrahmanyam Jaishankar.
A telephone conversation took place between the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan Rashid Meredov and the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Shah Mahmood QureshiA telephone conversation took place between the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan Rashid Meredov and the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Shah Mahmood Qureshi
Pashinyan is against returning to presidential or semi-presidential  form of governmentPashinyan is against returning to presidential or semi-presidential  form of government
Pashinyan: It is impossible to develop an export-oriented economy  with closed bordersPashinyan: It is impossible to develop an export-oriented economy  with closed borders
Nikol Pashinyan considers Ilham Aliyev`s public threats to be Nikol Pashinyan considers Ilham Aliyev`s public threats to be "mirror  reflection" of Armenia`s statements
Nikol Pashinyan on proposals submitted to Baku to de-escalate  situation on borderNikol Pashinyan on proposals submitted to Baku to de-escalate  situation on border
Pashinyan: We have formulated a package of proposals, but the  copyright does not belong to usPashinyan: We have formulated a package of proposals, but the  copyright does not belong to us
Pashinyan: Authorities should make decisions that will allow the  establishment of Pashinyan: Authorities should make decisions that will allow the  establishment of "political harmony" between the President, the  National Assembly and the Government
NA ruling faction candidate elected new Human Rights Defendern of  ArmeniaNA ruling faction candidate elected new Human Rights Defendern of  Armenia
Ministry of Health: The process of identifying the bodies of  servicemen is completedMinistry of Health: The process of identifying the bodies of  servicemen is completed
Toivo Klaar: EU considers new areas of cooperation with ArmeniaToivo Klaar: EU considers new areas of cooperation with Armenia
Azerbaijani Defense Minister to visit IranAzerbaijani Defense Minister to visit Iran
Vardan Toghanyan, who is completing his mission as Ambassador of  Armenia to Russia, made appealVardan Toghanyan, who is completing his mission as Ambassador of  Armenia to Russia, made appeal
Toivo Klaar: If necessary, the EU is ready to assist in the issue of  delimitation and demarcation of the borders of Armenia and AzerbaijanToivo Klaar: If necessary, the EU is ready to assist in the issue of  delimitation and demarcation of the borders of Armenia and Azerbaijan
YLC of Australia recognizes Republic of Artsakh, Armenian Assyrian,  Greek Genocides YLC of Australia recognizes Republic of Artsakh, Armenian Assyrian,  Greek Genocides 
EU fully supports normalization of relations between Armenia and  TurkeyEU fully supports normalization of relations between Armenia and  Turkey
Armenia`s ex-minister of defense to remain under arrestArmenia`s ex-minister of defense to remain under arrest
President`s resignation attempt to prevent domestic and foreign  political processes - Stepan DanielyanPresident`s resignation attempt to prevent domestic and foreign  political processes - Stepan Danielyan
Georgia could act as transit country for Armenia`s integration into  NATO - Amiran KhevtsurianiGeorgia could act as transit country for Armenia`s integration into  NATO - Amiran Khevtsuriani
Read more



Commented