
ArmInfo. Avetik Chalabyan, coordinator of the Hayakve movement, called on the opposition to come up with a legislative initiative aimed at tightening the criteria for using arrest as a preventive measure.
He made this proposal during a hearing in the Armenian parliament, drawing attention to the gaps in Article 118 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Armenia ("Specifics of the Legality of Arrest" - ed.). According to him, these gaps allow the current leadership, abusing the judicial system's dependence on political power, to widely use arrest as a preventive measure.
The coordinator of the Hayakve movement emphasized that the current legislative regulation essentially contradicts Article 73 of the Armenian Constitution, which enshrines the requirement for legal certainty in legislative norms. In his opinion, it is the lack of clear and unambiguous criteria that creates the conditions for the widespread use of arrest as a preventive measure. In this regard, he recalled that the parliamentary opposition holds one-fifth of the total number of MPs, which gives it the right to appeal to the Constitutional Court of Armenia with a demand to review the constitutionality of this article. "Furthermore, the opposition can come forward with a legislative initiative aimed at tightening the criteria for applying arrest, which would prevent the courts from resorting to this preventive measure without proper grounds. Today, we have the opportunity, without waiting for a change in power, to try to influence the resolution of such issues," Chalabyan noted.
He recalled that Article 118 stipulates that arrest is applied by a court decision in the cases and in the manner prescribed by law; arrest can only be chosen in cases where alternative preventive measures are insufficient to ensure the proper behavior of the accused; The need for arrest must be justified by the investigator or prosecutor and receive appropriate justification in the court decision. "At first glance, it seems that the content of this norm provides sufficient guarantees for the proportionate use of arrest. However, in practice, this is not the case. We see how courts, under political pressure, resort to arrest everywhere, despite the fact that the law expressly provides for its use only in exceptional cases," Chalabyan noted.
According to him, one of the main reasons for the current situation is the lack of clear criteria for assessing the risks of inappropriate behavior by the accused. In addition, as Chalabyan noted, court decisions often do not contain a justification for the chosen preventive measure. He also recalled that the current Criminal Procedure Code of Armenia provides for a number of alternative preventive measures, each of which is less strict than arrest, and when choosing a measure, priority should be given to more lenient measures, which Armenian society does not see in practice. "Unfortunately, the law does not establish clear criteria that the court should use when refusing to apply alternative preventive measures. The court is also not obligated to justify any verdict, and the law does not establish clear criteria for the proportionality of the chosen preventive measure. As a result, arrest can be applied even in cases of minor or moderate crimes, whereas in a number of other countries, more lenient preventive measures are preferred in such cases, and arrest is ruled out altogether. The law also does not provide for any procedural procedure in cases of a political nature," the opposition figure noted.
As an example, Chalabyan cited his own case, the materials of which, according to him, indicated that other preventive measures were unable to ensure his proper behavior. At the same time, as the movement coordinator noted, no explanation was given as to why these measures were insufficient.