Thursday, September 24 2026 20:08
Alexandr Avanesov

An international law expert responded to the statement of the Azerbaijani Human Rights Commissioner.

An international law expert responded to the statement of the Azerbaijani Human Rights Commissioner.

ArmInfo. International law specialist and lawyer Siranush Sahakyan responded to the statement by Azerbaijan's Human Rights Commissioner, Sabina Aliyeva.

The lawyer's statement, in particular, notes that on September 19, 2026, the office of the Azerbaijani Human Rights Commissioner called the questions raised by Ruben Vardanyan regarding himself and other Armenian prisoners held in Umbaki "groundless." This response is notable not so much for what it answers as for what it avoids. Specifically, a number of complaints are simply omitted from the response: lack of video communication; access to education; regular ICRC access; visits with family; letters and parcels; diplomatic or consular access; the humanitarian visit proposed by Veronika Zonabend. The silence about family visits and the proposed humanitarian visit is telling. The office claims that contact with the family is being facilitated. Since her arrest, not a single family visit has taken place. The only existing contact is by telephone, and not even for everyone. Requests to facilitate Veronika Zonabend's visit were sent to the Commissioner's office in June and July. They remain unanswered. Meanwhile, Azerbaijani media openly suggest that if she comes to Baku, she could be arrested. This is what "contact with the family is being facilitated" means in practice.

"On other issues, the answer is given to a question no one asked. The notary service provided to Arayik Harutyunyan does not explain why Ruben Vardanyan cannot issue his own powers of attorney. Books are not responding to a complaint about a newspaper subscription. The medical examination does not confirm that the specific diagnostic tests Vardanyan requested were performed or that their results were communicated to him. Where the Commissioner's version of events diverges from the facts presented by Vardanyan, the lack of documentation is conspicuous. The office claims that every call to the 916 hotline was responded to in a timely manner. Vardanyan was allowed one such call—on June 19. No confirmation of this response was provided. Neither were substantive responses to written requests sent on his behalf provided. If weekly calls are truly available to every prisoner, why does Ludwig Mkrtchyan wait anywhere from one and a half to more than two months for the next call? Call logs could answer this question immediately. Vardanyan repeatedly sought access to a notary to draw up powers of attorney or access to forms to sign them himself. Neither was granted. Therefore, on August 20, a lawsuit was filed with the Baku Administrative Court, which was only recently registered. From June to August, at least six written requests were sent to the Commissioner's Office—requests for medical examinations, videoconferencing, the 916 hotline, meetings with the Commissioner, and visits with family. None of them received a response. The same applies to access to a defense attorney. A local lawyer was repeatedly denied access to Vardanyan. On September 16, access was denied due to the absence of the facility's director. On September 19, the Commissioner announced that prisoners' rights were being ensured. On September 22, access to a defense attorney was again denied for the same reason. Consequently, the case had to be taken to court: a lawsuit was filed against the facility's administration for the denial of access. The Commissioner also relies heavily on visits conducted by her office. The uncomfortable irony, however, is that the very institution that cites these visits as evidence of effective oversight has already been criticized by the UN Committee against Torture for failing to “effectively perform its functions” in responding to credible allegations of serious violations—a failure that the Committee said “demonstrates a lack of independence.” If Ruben Vardanyan’s allegations are truly “baseless,” the answer is simple: produce documentation for every Armenian prisoner in Umbaki—records of family visits, consular access, telephone call logs, written responses to their inquiries, notarial records, and records of access to an independent lawyer. "A categorical denial, no matter how resolute, is not proof," Siranush Sahakyan noted, adding as a postscript that the prisoners' request for a meeting with the Commissioner, conveyed by Ruben Vardanyan, remains unanswered. As do—inconveniently—the questions her statement still leaves unanswered.

 

It should be noted that the exact number of Armenian prisoners of war and hostages held in Azerbaijani prisons remains unknown. Experts estimate the number to be several hundred. Today, Azerbaijani authorities confirm the presence of 19 Armenians in their custody. Among those held in Azerbaijani captivity are eight former and current members of the military-political leadership of Artsakh. These are the former presidents of Artsakh Arkady Ghukasyan, Bako Sahakyan, Arayik Harutyunyan, former Foreign Minister Davit Babayan, as well as Parliament Speaker Davit Ishkhanyan, former Commander of the Artsakh Defense Army, General Levon Mnatsakanyan, General David Manukyan, and former State Minister Ruben Vardanyan. In February, a Baku puppet court sentenced Arayik Harutyunyan, David Babayan, David Ishkhanyan, David Manukyan, and Levon Mnatsakanyan to life imprisonment on trumped-up charges, and Bako Sahakyan, Arkady Ghukasyan, and Ruben Vardanyan to 20 years in prison. The so-called court sentenced the remaining Artsakh residents to up to 15 years in prison.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Pashinyan: Armenia did not join the Declaration adopted at the EPC summit because it contains references to NATOPashinyan: Armenia did not join the Declaration adopted at the EPC summit because it contains references to NATO
Pashinyan stated his intention to get rid of the parliamentary opposition in order to adopt a new Constitution of Armenia.Pashinyan stated his intention to get rid of the parliamentary opposition in order to adopt a new Constitution of Armenia.
The Chair of the Armenian National Assembly’s Foreign Relations Committee Discussed Prospects for Deepening Cooperation with Bundestag DeputiesThe Chair of the Armenian National Assembly’s Foreign Relations Committee Discussed Prospects for Deepening Cooperation with Bundestag Deputies
The Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Germany held talks in YerevanThe Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Germany held talks in Yerevan
The Union of Communities of Armenia and NALAG signed a memorandum of cooperationThe Union of Communities of Armenia and NALAG signed a memorandum of cooperation
Armenia and Azerbaijan are at the stage of forming working groups on transboundary water management – Prime MinisterArmenia and Azerbaijan are at the stage of forming working groups on transboundary water management – Prime Minister
Armenia’s Ministry of Justice proposed raising the maximum compensation for insult to 3 million drams, and for defamation to 6 million.Armenia’s Ministry of Justice proposed raising the maximum compensation for insult to 3 million drams, and for defamation to 6 million.
Minister: By March 2027, the number of centers issuing new passports and ID cards will increase to 23Minister: By March 2027, the number of centers issuing new passports and ID cards will increase to 23
Turkish Defense Minister: Turkey and Azerbaijan are expanding military cooperationTurkish Defense Minister: Turkey and Azerbaijan are expanding military cooperation
Russia’s Prosecutor General’s Office handed over to Armenia a man accused of murder and illegal weapons possession.Russia’s Prosecutor General’s Office handed over to Armenia a man accused of murder and illegal weapons possession.
Armenia and the Netherlands held inter-ministerial political consultationsArmenia and the Netherlands held inter-ministerial political consultations
IDBank to Present a Unified Ecosystem Concept at DigiTec 2026IDBank to Present a Unified Ecosystem Concept at DigiTec 2026
Pashinyan Appoints New Head of Armenia’s Unified Social ServicePashinyan Appoints New Head of Armenia’s Unified Social Service
Armenia’s Defense Minister Discussed Defense Cooperation with Partners from India and SwedenArmenia’s Defense Minister Discussed Defense Cooperation with Partners from India and Sweden
The Prime Minister of Armenia and Germany’s Foreign Minister discussed prospects for developing cooperation in the field of green energyThe Prime Minister of Armenia and Germany’s Foreign Minister discussed prospects for developing cooperation in the field of green energy
Germany’s Foreign Minister Honored the Memory of the Holy Martyrs of the Armenian GenocideGermany’s Foreign Minister Honored the Memory of the Holy Martyrs of the Armenian Genocide
Prime Minister: Regarding the TRIPP project, the Armenian and American sides are entering the stage of its practical implementationPrime Minister: Regarding the TRIPP project, the Armenian and American sides are entering the stage of its practical implementation
When History Finds Its Voice: A Documentary Film on the 100-Year Journey of the National Philharmonic Orchestra Was Presented in YerevanWhen History Finds Its Voice: A Documentary Film on the 100-Year Journey of the National Philharmonic Orchestra Was Presented in Yerevan
The Office of the Ombudsman for the Cultural Heritage of Artsakh called on international organizations to condemn the distortion of the historical identity of Amaras Monastery.The Office of the Ombudsman for the Cultural Heritage of Artsakh called on international organizations to condemn the distortion of the historical identity of Amaras Monastery.
The UN General Assembly adopted a resolution on cooperation with the CISThe UN General Assembly adopted a resolution on cooperation with the CIS
Armenia’s Interior Minister presented the country’s experience in preventing violence at the 9th Global Forum in Iceland.Armenia’s Interior Minister presented the country’s experience in preventing violence at the 9th Global Forum in Iceland.
Pashinyan Bids Farewell to Japan’s Ambassador, Who Is Completing His Mission in ArmeniaPashinyan Bids Farewell to Japan’s Ambassador, Who Is Completing His Mission in Armenia
Representatives of the Representatives of the "Combat Brotherhood" order held a protest outside the Armenian government, presenting their position on key issues of the national agenda.
MP: Armenia Needs to Introduce a Comprehensive Security and Defense SystemMP: Armenia Needs to Introduce a Comprehensive Security and Defense System
The ICRC has summed up its efforts to locate people missing in the Karabakh conflict zoneThe ICRC has summed up its efforts to locate people missing in the Karabakh conflict zone
Armenia’s Ombudsman and Switzerland’s Ambassador Discussed the Rights of Armenian Prisoners of War Detained in BakuArmenia’s Ombudsman and Switzerland’s Ambassador Discussed the Rights of Armenian Prisoners of War Detained in Baku
Khachkar Studios 26 Pilots: 98% Growth Performance Track Record - Week #10 - 17 Nov 2026Khachkar Studios 26 Pilots: 98% Growth Performance Track Record - Week #10 - 17 Nov 2026
Papikyan Participated in the Schuman Security and Defense Conference in BrusselsPapikyan Participated in the Schuman Security and Defense Conference in Brussels
Marla Blow Joins the Aurora Prize Selection CommitteeMarla Blow Joins the Aurora Prize Selection Committee
“Mother Armenia”: A prisoner with serious mental health problems was transferred from Tevanyan’s cell“Mother Armenia”: A prisoner with serious mental health problems was transferred from Tevanyan’s cell
Issues concerning the provision of legal assistance between Armenia and Iran in criminal proceedings were discussed in TehranIssues concerning the provision of legal assistance between Armenia and Iran in criminal proceedings were discussed in Tehran
People’s Artist of Armenia Hakob Azizyan has died at the age of 88People’s Artist of Armenia Hakob Azizyan has died at the age of 88
Cardinal Claudio Gugerotti expressed concern about tensions between the Armenian authorities and the ChurchCardinal Claudio Gugerotti expressed concern about tensions between the Armenian authorities and the Church
Armenia’s Parliament Ratified Article 11 of the revised European Social CharterArmenia’s Parliament Ratified Article 11 of the revised European Social Charter
In Armenia, the air temperature will remain unchanged, but it will be rainyIn Armenia, the air temperature will remain unchanged, but it will be rainy
Meeting of the Foreign Ministers of Turkmenistan and PakistanMeeting of the Foreign Ministers of Turkmenistan and Pakistan
Armenia and Germany held consultations on defense issuesArmenia and Germany held consultations on defense issues
Armenia will support Diallo`s candidacy in the 2027 FIFA presidential elections.Armenia will support Diallo`s candidacy in the 2027 FIFA presidential elections.
Developing Communications and Economic Cooperation: Armenian Foreign Minister Summarizes His Brussels VisitDeveloping Communications and Economic Cooperation: Armenian Foreign Minister Summarizes His Brussels Visit
Lawyer: The court rejected the investigator`s motion to extend the house arrest of Gor Ambartsumyan, the brother of the former mayor of Masis.Lawyer: The court rejected the investigator`s motion to extend the house arrest of Gor Ambartsumyan, the brother of the former mayor of Masis.
Lawyer: The decision to arrest Samvel Karapetyan has been appealed to a higher court.Lawyer: The decision to arrest Samvel Karapetyan has been appealed to a higher court.
A State Duma deputy discussed the development of Armenian-Russian dialogue with representatives of the Republican Party of Armenia (RPA).A State Duma deputy discussed the development of Armenian-Russian dialogue with representatives of the Republican Party of Armenia (RPA).
More than 700,000 trout fry have been released into Lake Sevan, according to the Armenian Ministry of Environment.More than 700,000 trout fry have been released into Lake Sevan, according to the Armenian Ministry of Environment.
Mirzoyan and Kos discussed the implementation of the Armenia-EU strategic agendaMirzoyan and Kos discussed the implementation of the Armenia-EU strategic agenda
Samvel Karapetyan: Samvel Karapetyan: "Strong Armenia" will not allow the Armenian government to change the Constitution
Azerbaijan expert: Former Secretary of Armenia`s Security Council admits concessions to Azerbaijan lead to new escalationAzerbaijan expert: Former Secretary of Armenia`s Security Council admits concessions to Azerbaijan lead to new escalation
Armenian citizens will be able to join the Police and Rescue Services without military service.Armenian citizens will be able to join the Police and Rescue Services without military service.
The public The public "verbal battle" between the Yerevan mayor and Pashinyan`s wife is gaining momentum.
Ministry of Internal Affairs: One of the priorities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs is the prevention of crimes against minors and the protection of their rightsMinistry of Internal Affairs: One of the priorities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs is the prevention of crimes against minors and the protection of their rights
Ruben Rubinyan: We have nothing against Russia and its railways – we just don’t want to end up in railway isolationRuben Rubinyan: We have nothing against Russia and its railways – we just don’t want to end up in railway isolation
The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament discussed prospects for cooperation in healthcare and high technology with the Indian Ambassador.The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament discussed prospects for cooperation in healthcare and high technology with the Indian Ambassador.
Vrezh Kasuni: We are moving in the right directionVrezh Kasuni: We are moving in the right direction
The head of the Armenian Ministry of Defense left for a working visit to BrusselsThe head of the Armenian Ministry of Defense left for a working visit to Brussels
The investigation presented details of the case involving an Azerbaijani looter and rapist.The investigation presented details of the case involving an Azerbaijani looter and rapist.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs: The terms of the contract with the company that provides vehicle towing services will change starting in 2027The Ministry of Internal Affairs: The terms of the contract with the company that provides vehicle towing services will change starting in 2027
Mother Armenia is sounding the alarm: A person with mental disabilities has been transferred to Andranik Tevanyan`s cell.Mother Armenia is sounding the alarm: A person with mental disabilities has been transferred to Andranik Tevanyan`s cell.
The German Foreign Minister called for preventing the strengthening of Russia`s influence in the South CaucasusThe German Foreign Minister called for preventing the strengthening of Russia`s influence in the South Caucasus
The PAP press secretary raised the issue of political freedoms and human rights in Armenia at a forum in MoscowThe PAP press secretary raised the issue of political freedoms and human rights in Armenia at a forum in Moscow
Avanesyan: The introduction of a licensing system for medical workers in Armenia will be a key component of healthcare reformAvanesyan: The introduction of a licensing system for medical workers in Armenia will be a key component of healthcare reform
The head of the Ministry of Education and Science convened a meeting on the commercialization of scientific resultsThe head of the Ministry of Education and Science convened a meeting on the commercialization of scientific results
Read more



Commented