Arminfo.info



 Friday, January 26 2024 13:12
Marianna Mkrtchyan

By initiating Constitutional reforms, Armenian leadership gives up  fundamental foundations of Armenian political identity of  `third  republic` - Opinion

By initiating Constitutional reforms, Armenian leadership gives up  fundamental foundations of Armenian political identity of  `third  republic` - Opinion

ArmInfo.By initiating Constitutional reforms, the Armenian leadership   gives up the fundamental foundations of the Armenian post-Soviet national-state project and the political identity of the "third republic". This is  how Russian political scientist Sergei Markedonov commented on the intention of the current authorities of Armenia to completely change the Constitution of the country.

The expert stated that the discussion about constitutional reform in  Armenia received additional impetus, while the focus was not on the  problems of internal changes, but on issues of Armenian foreign  policy identity.

"According to the head of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the  Republic Ararat Mirzoyan, Azerbaijan sees certain problems in the  formulations of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence  of Armenia. And although the minister further stated that "there is  no provision on the Constitution of Armenia in the draft peace  agreement," the very mention of the objections of official Baku  caused significant socio-political interest," noted Markedonov.

In this vein, he drew attention to the fact that the provisions of  the Declaration of Independence of Armenia dated August 23, 1990 and  earlier became the subject of foreign policy discussions. "Today, the  times of "football diplomacy" have already been thoroughly forgotten.  Meanwhile, after the Constitutional Court of Armenia on January 12,  2010 recognized the Armenian-Turkish protocols as complying with the  Basic Law of the country, the Turkish leadership de facto refused to  ratify the above-mentioned document. The reason for this decision  became paragraph 11 of the Declaration, which mentioned "Western  Armenia" (Ankara regarded this as a demonstration of Armenia's  territorial claims).

Years have passed, the military-political status quo has radically  changed in the conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia, and now Prime  Minister Nikol Pashinyan, in his congratulatory message on the  occasion of the 33rd anniversary of the adoption of the Declaration  of Independence of Armenia, especially emphasized that Ni, especially  emphasized that the document, which at one time proclaimed a new  republic based on the act of "reunification of the Armenian SSR and  Nagorno-Karabakh," laid down "confrontation with the regional  environment " and "constant conflicts with neighbors. "Soon after  this, the final destruction of the unrecognized NKR (or Artsakh, as  they preferred to call it in Armenia) and the de- Armenization of  this de facto entity took place. In such conditions, Azerbaijan  received additional trump cards to establish such a peace that will  ensure its exclusive interests both in the Caucasus region and in the  international arena," the Russian political scientist noted.

At the same time, he drew attention to the fact that the significance  of the issue of the Declaration and the Basic Law of Armenia should  not be limited only to the geopolitical format and, first of all,  concerns the fundamental foundations of the Armenian post-Soviet  national-state project and the political identity of the "third  republic."

"The struggle for the self-determination of the Armenians of  Nagorno-Karabakh has been the basis of Armenia's national  state-building since the end of the 1980s and for a long time. At one  time, it was the "miatsum", that is, the struggle for "their own  Artsakh" that broke the communist-dissident dichotomy in the Armenian  SSR and Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region (NKAO), it united  representatives of the party-economic nomenklatura and "anti-Soviet"  activists. In this way, Armenia's path to independence differed from  both the Georgian and Baltic projects. It was based on the idea of  establishing a state with the formula of the Armenian SSR + NKAO to  ensure the interests and survival of the Armenian ethnic group,  rather than the struggle against the "Soviet Empire," Markedonov  added.

According to him, today the world is witnessing the ignorance of this  fundamental goal by the Armenian political elite. At the same time,  the initiatives of Nikol Pashinyan and his team both in the  international arena and within the country do not cause a powerful  protest opposition movement, which strongly contrasts with the  political culture of late and post-Soviet Armenia, which grew out of  mass protests.

"In this regard, the question arises as to what volume and scale of  "de-Karabakhization" will take place. It is naive to assume that  unprecedented foreign policy concessions will not in any way affect  internal and identitarian processes. Especially when the  ethno-political conflict was a system-shaping one for the country.

Very often the process of "de-Karabakhization" is compared with the  problem of the loss of Kosovo for Serbia. The process of  "de-kosovization" for the Serbian national project has indeed gone  too far. But there is a nuance! Belgrade still does not recognize the  independence of the former Serbian autonomous region.  Yerevan  officially recognized the sovereignty of Baku over Karabakh/Artsakh.  Devilish difference!", Markedonov summed up.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenia, Jordan against any changes in status quo of Old City of  Jerusalem Armenia, Jordan against any changes in status quo of Old City of  Jerusalem 
Turkish president, Georgian premier support peace in South Caucasus Turkish president, Georgian premier support peace in South Caucasus 
UJA draws international attention to violence against journalists UJA draws international attention to violence against journalists 
Gnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attemptsGnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attempts
Idram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperationIdram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperation
During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.
Bagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in ArmeniaBagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in Armenia
Five Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in YerevanFive Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in Yerevan
Residents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisionsResidents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisions
Armenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in StrasbourgArmenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in Strasbourg
Investigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in KirantsInvestigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in Kirants
Azerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 monthsAzerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 months
Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? 
Garnik Danielyan: Garnik Danielyan: "In this transition period,  Bagrat Srbazan is the  most acceptable candidate for premier post for me"
Mher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithmMher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithm
Armenia joins Oviedo ConventionArmenia joins Oviedo Convention
Border passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitationBorder passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitation
EU pursuing its own interests in South Caucasus - expert EU pursuing its own interests in South Caucasus - expert 
Russian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  AffairsRussian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  Affairs
Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests 
CSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  GalstanyanCSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  Galstanyan
Azerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leadersAzerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leaders
Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart 
Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections 
Police opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movementPolice opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movement
Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger 
This is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in AzerbaijanThis is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in Azerbaijan
Prime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefullyPrime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefully
Police chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD eventPolice chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD event
Bagrat Srbazan announces number of meetingsBagrat Srbazan announces number of meetings
Thousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet TheaterThousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet Theater
Poll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in ArmeniaPoll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in Armenia
FMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollarsFMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollars
Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  "Tavush for Motherland" movement
RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava 
Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House 
Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova 
Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces 
The Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for ArmeniaThe Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for Armenia
Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations 
Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  
Police to block roads during EBRD forum in Yerevan Police to block roads during EBRD forum in Yerevan 
Azatazen organization issues statement on illegal detention of  co-founder, his comradesAzatazen organization issues statement on illegal detention of  co-founder, his comrades
Slovakia supports Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization Slovakia supports Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization 
Last year`s September events did not happen out of nowhere: Armenian  authorities recognized Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan - Russian Deputy  FMLast year`s September events did not happen out of nowhere: Armenian  authorities recognized Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan - Russian Deputy  FM
Inclusive dialogue within Inclusive dialogue within "3+3" platform and countering of  extra-regional forces` geopolitical dictatorship key to the  prosperity of South Caucasus - Mikhail Galuzin
Armenia, India to establish joint working group on bilateral defense cooperationArmenia, India to establish joint working group on bilateral defense cooperation
Tavush for Motherland movement will hold  protest rally on Freedom  Square tomorrowTavush for Motherland movement will hold  protest rally on Freedom  Square tomorrow
Azerbaijan is playing cat and mouse game with Armenia and the world -  analystAzerbaijan is playing cat and mouse game with Armenia and the world -  analyst
One of participants in peaceful protests in Yerevan suffered broken  leg due to disproportionate actions of Red Berets - StatementOne of participants in peaceful protests in Yerevan suffered broken  leg due to disproportionate actions of Red Berets - Statement
France, Civil Aviation Committee of Armenia sign technical  cooperation agreementFrance, Civil Aviation Committee of Armenia sign technical  cooperation agreement
Protection of Armenia`s borders with Iran and Turkiye will continue to be entrusted to Russian border guardsProtection of Armenia`s borders with Iran and Turkiye will continue to be entrusted to Russian border guards
Baku -Yerevan intensive negotiations resumed since Feb, Bayramov  saysBaku -Yerevan intensive negotiations resumed since Feb, Bayramov  says
President of Azerbaijan urges dissolution of OSCE MGPresident of Azerbaijan urges dissolution of OSCE MG
Beyond Filmmaking. PARAJANOV and FASHION Beyond Filmmaking. PARAJANOV and FASHION 
What is happening today on Yerevan`s streets implementation of  already introduced methods of struggle - clergyman What is happening today on Yerevan`s streets implementation of  already introduced methods of struggle - clergyman 
Armenian authorities launched psychological, moral and physical terror against their own people - clergyman Armenian authorities launched psychological, moral and physical terror against their own people - clergyman 
Actions of Actions of "red berets" against citizens during acts of civil disobedience clearly punitive in nature - Arman Tatoyan 
UN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflictsUN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflicts
Russian border guards leave Nerkin HandRussian border guards leave Nerkin Hand
Read more



Commented