Arminfo.info



 Wednesday, May 8 2019 17:45
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Moscow`s dual approach to Yerevan and Baku as a litmus test of the  real state of bilateral relations

Moscow`s dual approach to Yerevan and Baku as a litmus test of the  real state of bilateral relations

ArmInfo.On May 6, the Russian  Ministry of Foreign Affairs published a report "On the situation with  the glorification of Nazism, the spread of neo-Nazism and other  practices that contribute to the escalation of modern forms of  racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance,"  the official presentation of which took place today and which  contains formulations not causing only bewilderment, but also  "laughter through tears."

So, studying the report on the part of  Azerbaijan, a number of questions arise. In particular, the report  points out that "Azerbaijan has practically no manifestations of  neo-Nazism, racism, racial discrimination and xenophobia, and the  leadership of Azerbaijan positions its country as a state of tolerant  living for representatives of various nations and religions." 

Such formulations addressed to dynastic Azerbaijan are not only  biased, but also distort the real situation in this area in  Azerbaijan, and the situation recorded by the Russian Foreign  Ministry and promulgated and commented by the official representative  of the Russian Foreign Ministry Maria Zakharova a few months earlier.  It was about the inadmissibility of the detention and expulsion of  Russian citizens on a national basis from Azerbaijan. Zakharova  qualified these actions of the Azerbaijani authorities against  Russian citizens of Armenian origin as a gross violation of the  rights of Russian citizens. "It is not the first time that we are  faced with a discriminatory ethnic policy towards citizens of the  Russian Federation. According to the Foreign Ministry, last year  (2018) there were at least 16 cases of denial of entry into  Azerbaijan on ethnic grounds. At the same time, Russian citizens were  detained for hours at the airport, then forcibly expelled from the  country. There was no official reason, "Ms. Zakharova criticized the"  tolerance "of the authorities of the AR at one of her briefings  earlier this year. Meanwhile, these circumstances apparently did not  completely embarrass the authors of the above report, who devoted a  whole "ode" to how well foreigners live in Azerbaijan.

Meanwhile, studying the report on the part of Armenia, one encounters  the dual formulation of "no obvious attempts to rehabilitate Nazism,  no splashes of neo-Nazi sentiment in Armenia." This formulation  leaves room for serious reflection, since, despite the fact that  Armenia is a mono-national state, there were still no manifestations  in the directions already mentioned above. However, continuing to  study the report, you begin to understand "where the dog is buried."  The authors of the report, in particular, note that the former ruling  Republican Party of Armenia has taken steps to perpetuate the memory  of "such an ambiguous nationalist political figure like Garegin  Nzhdeh, in respect of whom there is information about cooperation  with the Third Reich."

It is noteworthy that already the former vice-speaker of the National  Assembly of Armenia Eduard Sharmazanov, referring to the attacks of  the Russian side on this topic, has repeatedly stressed that Nzhde is  a national hero of the Armenian people, as well as Alexander Nevsky,  Alexander Suvorov, Marshal Kutuzov, Bagration are national heroes of  the fraternal Russian of the people: "And as a historian I want to  emphasize that Garegin Nzhdeh had no relation to fascism and Nazism.  Nzhde spent his whole life fighting for the freedom of Armenia. Nzhde  was not a Nazi, he is a patriot of the Armenian people and  speculation and this issue is inappropriate and unacceptable. "

Sharmazanov then reminded the Russian side that in 1939, USSR Foreign  Minister Vyacheslav Molotov signed a non-aggression agreement with  Germany, but no one considers him a fascist and nationalist.   "Everyone realizes that this agreement was signed from the interests  of the USSR and the Soviet people in order to prevent a possible  attack by fascist Germany. The same was true in the case of Nzhdeh,  he collaborated with Germany, and in case of her victory prevented a  possible attack on Armenia by an ally Berlin Turkey, "- said  Sharmazanov.

The report of the Russian Foreign Ministry also paid attention to the  Sasna Tsrer party, which is presented as a nationalist party. It also  indicates the presence of isolated cases of racism and xenophobia in  Armenia.  "Manifestations of racism and xenophobia in Armenia are  sporadic. Occasional cases of hostility by the Armenian population to  visitors from Iran and India are noted, most of which are related to  the inappropriate behavior of foreigners themselves. At the end of  2018. RA Human Rights Defender A.Tatoyan stated the increasing use of  the Internet to spread xenophobic sentiments in Armenia, motivating  this by aggravating the internal political situation in the country  on the eve of the parliamentary elections, " the  reports'  authors  state. 

Whatever it is, but in Armenia you will not meet announcements in the  press or in public places about renting an apartment to anyone, but  not , although such a nationality,  unlike the "Caucasian" one, does exist.

The manifestation of such double standards in drafting the report  raises many questions and, unfortunately, makes you think about the  quality of the Armenian-Russian relations, or about serious  procedural inconsistencies in the apparatus of the Russian Foreign  Ministry, or about the banal "caviar" diplomacy that also penetrated  thick walls of a grand "Stalinist skyscraper" on Smolensk Square.  We  also note that ArmInfo's attempts to get comments from a number of  Armenian political analysts on the content of the report were  extremely unsuccessful. Moreover, the agency deliberately refused  calls to pro- Western experts. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Actions of disobedience in Yerevan Actions of disobedience in Yerevan 
Bagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figureBagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figure
Bagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrowBagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrow
Another nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identityAnother nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identity
Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility 
Europe Day celebrations started in YerevanEurope Day celebrations started in Yerevan
Will Pashinyan be impeached?Will Pashinyan be impeached?
Armenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go furtherArmenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go further
IC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knivesIC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knives
Ruben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lotRuben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lot
Russian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian peopleRussian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian people
Bagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premierBagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premier
Police detain activist over violence against policeman Police detain activist over violence against policeman 
Clergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justiceClergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justice
Bagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FMBagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FM
Armenia makes it through to European Grand FinalArmenia makes it through to European Grand Final
Russian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic WarRussian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic War
Our struggle is for justice - clergyman Our struggle is for justice - clergyman
Parliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premierParliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premier
Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader 
"Five Human Rights Defenders" Initiative ready to support students
Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s 
Bagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resignBagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resign
Bagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time  to make decisionBagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time to make decision
Armenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian  counterpartArmenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian counterpart
Refrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police  chief urgesRefrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police chief urges
After power shift, all people who participated in so-called  delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik ChalabyanAfter power shift, all people who participated in so-called delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik Chalabyan
Varuzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush,  and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik.  The choice is yoursVaruzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush, and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik. The choice is yours
"Five Human Rights Defenders" initiative to provide legal assistance to citizens dismissed for participating in peaceful rally
Armenia remains CSTO member: Source in OrganizationArmenia remains CSTO member: Source in Organization
Putin, Pashinyan agree on withdrawal of Russian troops from Armenia`s  several regionsPutin, Pashinyan agree on withdrawal of Russian troops from Armenia`s several regions
Armenian citizens gather in various parts of Yerevan to march to  Republic SquareArmenian citizens gather in various parts of Yerevan to march to Republic Square
Peskov urges not to exaggerate existing difficulties in  Russian-Armenian relations Peskov urges not to exaggerate existing difficulties in Russian-Armenian relations
Power change in Armenia realistic if opposition acts right - Levon ZurabyanPower change in Armenia realistic if opposition acts right - Levon Zurabyan
Catholicos of All Armenians addresses message on Victory and Peace DayCatholicos of All Armenians addresses message on Victory and Peace Day
Procession of Immortal Regiment starts in YerevanProcession of Immortal Regiment starts in Yerevan
Decision to stop Russian border guards` activities in Zvartnots confirmed at top level - ruling forceDecision to stop Russian border guards` activities in Zvartnots confirmed at top level - ruling force
Tavush for the Motherland movement heads for YerevanTavush for the Motherland movement heads for Yerevan
Artsakh leadership visits Yerablur pantheonArtsakh leadership visits Yerablur pantheon
Armenia`s law-enforcement and security authorities issue warning to Tavush for Motherland movement Armenia`s law-enforcement and security authorities issue warning to Tavush for Motherland movement 
79th anniversary of victory in Great Patriotic War celebrated in Armenia79th anniversary of victory in Great Patriotic War celebrated in Armenia
Armenian premier, Russian president hold talks in MoscowArmenian premier, Russian president hold talks in Moscow
“By Your Side”: IDBank`s new support program for displaced Artsakh citizens“By Your Side”: IDBank`s new support program for displaced Artsakh citizens
Some media outlets refuse to give coverage of Armenian premier`s  press conference Some media outlets refuse to give coverage of Armenian premier`s  press conference 
No Azerbaijani military personnel in Kirants No Azerbaijani military personnel in Kirants 
U.S. Department of State withdraws comment on Armenian and  Azerbaijani FMs` upcoming meeting in AlmatyU.S. Department of State withdraws comment on Armenian and  Azerbaijani FMs` upcoming meeting in Almaty
Is there penalty for spitting in face? Prosecutor General explainsIs there penalty for spitting in face? Prosecutor General explains
Yerevan, Budapest agree to open embassies in capitals of two  countriesYerevan, Budapest agree to open embassies in capitals of two  countries
Tavush movement returns our national dignity, Vazgen ManukyanTavush movement returns our national dignity, Vazgen Manukyan
ANCA: Biden & Blinken, having aided Azerbaijan in committing genocide in Artsakh, are now helping Aliyev consolidate his crimeANCA: Biden & Blinken, having aided Azerbaijan in committing genocide in Artsakh, are now helping Aliyev consolidate his crime
Opinion: Armenian, Azerbaijani leaderships are in hurry to sign final peace treatyOpinion: Armenian, Azerbaijani leaderships are in hurry to sign final peace treaty
Nikol Pashinyan does not attend Victory Parade in Moscow eitherNikol Pashinyan does not attend Victory Parade in Moscow either
Pashinyan`s office responds to Bagrat SrbazanPashinyan`s office responds to Bagrat Srbazan
Szijjarto: as part of its EU Presidency, Budapest will look for additional opportunities to assist Yerevan and Baku in normalizing relationsSzijjarto: as part of its EU Presidency, Budapest will look for additional opportunities to assist Yerevan and Baku in normalizing relations
Armenia`s chief diplomat is cautiously optimistic about upcoming  meeting with his Azerbaijani counterpart in AlmatyArmenia`s chief diplomat is cautiously optimistic about upcoming  meeting with his Azerbaijani counterpart in Almaty
ANC Australia says no to forces inside Armenia and external who  believe peace to be achieved by further concessionsANC Australia says no to forces inside Armenia and external who  believe peace to be achieved by further concessions
Ruling MPs are busy inciting hatred, and prosecutor`s office is  silent - comment from oppositionistRuling MPs are busy inciting hatred, and prosecutor`s office is  silent - comment from oppositionist
Alen Simonyan: Power shift in Armenia is possible only with results  of 2026 NA electionsAlen Simonyan: Power shift in Armenia is possible only with results  of 2026 NA elections
US Ambassador to Azerbaijan visits occupied ShushiUS Ambassador to Azerbaijan visits occupied Shushi
ANCA supports Tavush for the Motherland movement ANCA supports Tavush for the Motherland movement 
Read more



Commented