Arminfo.info


 Friday, January 30 2026 11:01
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Judicial interference in church governance in Armenia raises serious  constitutional and legal concerns - Amsterdam and Partners

Judicial interference in church governance in Armenia raises serious  constitutional and legal concerns - Amsterdam and Partners

ArmInfo.The law firm Amsterdam and Partners LLP expresses serious concern regarding recent developments in Armenia related to judicial and political  interference in the internal governance of the Armenian Apostolic Holy Church (AACC).

The law firm's statement emphasizes that the use of a secular court  to review ecclesiastical decisions of the Mother See of Etchmiadzin,  particularly in matters of church discipline, represents a profound  deviation from the constitutional order of Armenia and from  established European legal norms governing the separation of church  and state.

"This case arose from the removal of Bishop Gevorg Saroyan from his  position as head of the Masyatsotn Diocese by the See of Holy  Etchmiadzin. Instead of pursuing the legal remedies provided by  Church canon law, Bishop Saroyan initiated proceedings in a secular  court, challenging the Church's internal decision. On January 27, the  Church officially defrocked him for violating his vow of obedience  and for referring a sacred ecclesiastical dispute to a secular court.  Despite this, Vice-President of the Armenian Parliament Ruben  Rubinyan publicly declared the Church's decision "invalid," declared  that the defrocked cleric "remains a bishop," and launched personal  attacks against His Holiness Catholicos Karekin II, downplaying his  spiritual authority and calling him an "opposition politician,"  Amsterdam & Partners recalled.

It is emphasized that the most serious problem is not rhetorical, but  institutional: a secular court was asked to rule on disciplinary  cases against the Catholicos, the highest spiritual authority of the  Armenian Apostolic Holy Church. Such judicial review is fundamentally  incompatible with the 2015 Constitution of the Republic of Armenia.  Article 17(1) guarantees freedom of religion, and Article 17(2)  explicitly provides that "religious organizations shall be separated  from the state." Article 18(1) goes further, recognizing and  protecting the exclusive mission of the Armenian Apostolic Holy  Church as the national church, playing a central role in the  spiritual life, culture, and national identity of the Armenian  people.  "These provisions are reinforced by the Armenian Law on  Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations, which prohibits  state interference in the internal affairs of religious organizations  and explicitly prohibits state bodies or officials from exercising  authority over church structures. It is important to note that  Armenian legislation does not merely symbolically recognize the  Armenian Apostolic Holy Church; it affirms its self-governance," the  law firm emphasized.

Amsterdam & Partners notes that the decision to defrock a bishop lies  at the very core of this sacred authority. Allowing secular courts to  overturn or review such decisions would deprive these constitutional  guarantees of any practical meaning. "This principle is neither new  nor unique to Armenia. In European constitutional systems, secular  courts have consistently refrained from considering internal matters  of religious discipline and doctrine. The courts of Germany, France,  Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom have repeatedly affirmed that  disputes concerning the status of clergy, ordination, or discipline  fall outside the jurisdiction of civil courts, except in narrowly  defined cases concerning purely civil rights. The European Court of  Human Rights has also ruled that state interference in the internal  governance of churches violates Article 9 of the European Convention  on Human Rights, which protects the autonomy of religious communities  as an integral element of freedom of religion," the statement  continues.

In this vein, it is emphasized that, against this legal backdrop, any  attempt by Armenian courts or political authorities to invalidate the  ecclesiastical decisions of Holy Etchmiadzin constitutes a blatant  violation of the Armenian Constitution, Armenia's domestic  legislation, and its binding international obligations.

Amsterdam & Partners LLP expressed their conviction that the  Investigative Committee of Armenia's initiation of criminal  proceedings against the Armenian Apostolic Church and the Catholicos  is part of a broader pattern of behavior by Prime Minister Nikol  Pashinyan's government aimed at undermining the autonomy of the  Armenian Apostolic Church and the authority of the Catholicos, which  directly contradicts Armenia's constitutional framework and  international obligations guaranteeing freedom of religion or belief.  "The law firm Amsterdam & Partners LLP will raise these issues at the  upcoming International Religious Freedom Summit, scheduled for  February 2-3, where the firm will call on Armenian state institutions  to immediately cease judicial and political interference in the  internal governance of the Armenian Apostolic Church, respect the  constitutional separation of church and state, and bring state  practices into line with both Armenian law and European democratic  standards," the firm concluded.

On January 29, it was reported that the Investigative Committee of  Armenia had opened a criminal investigation into the failure to  enforce a court decision, following an order by His Holiness Karekin  II, Catholicos of All Armenians, on the advice of the Supreme  Spiritual Council, to defrock the former head of the Masyatsotn  Diocese of the See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Gevorg Saroyan.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenia and Ghana express their willingness to enhance bilateral  relationsArmenia and Ghana express their willingness to enhance bilateral  relations
GRECO commends Armenia`s implementation of anti-corruption  recommendations within  MIAGRECO commends Armenia`s implementation of anti-corruption  recommendations within  MIA
Office of Robert Kocharyan: Prosecutor General`s Office appeal to the  CEC is a continuation of the Office of Robert Kocharyan: Prosecutor General`s Office appeal to the  CEC is a continuation of the "Lawlessness" at the airport
Armenian team wins 8 gold, 12 silver, and 7 bronze medals at  6th  International Applied Biology OlympiadArmenian team wins 8 gold, 12 silver, and 7 bronze medals at  6th  International Applied Biology Olympiad
Prosecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert KocharyanProsecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert Kocharyan
SCO Secretary General: Armenia making progress in improving and  modernizing all spheres of public life, ensuring high rates of  economic development and strengthening its international reputationSCO Secretary General: Armenia making progress in improving and  modernizing all spheres of public life, ensuring high rates of  economic development and strengthening its international reputation
Dutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agendaDutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agenda
Political analyst: While Pashinyan pledges peace with Azerbaijan,  Baku continues  promoting the Political analyst: While Pashinyan pledges peace with Azerbaijan,  Baku continues  promoting the "Western Azerbaijan" project
Armenia moves to introduce remote judicial hearingsArmenia moves to introduce remote judicial hearings
Moscow, Ankara discuss situation in  South CaucasusMoscow, Ankara discuss situation in  South Caucasus
 The model for reinstating driver`s licenses for citizens deprived of  their right to drive will be changed in Armenia - draft law The model for reinstating driver`s licenses for citizens deprived of  their right to drive will be changed in Armenia - draft law
Defense Minister Suren Papikyan meets with French counterpart in  ParisDefense Minister Suren Papikyan meets with French counterpart in  Paris
 Italian Prime Minister: Normalization of relations between Yerevan  and Baku is an important opportunity for stability and prosperity not  only for Armenia but also for the entire region Italian Prime Minister: Normalization of relations between Yerevan  and Baku is an important opportunity for stability and prosperity not  only for Armenia but also for the entire region
Karapetyan: Ruling party lacks mandates for constitutional referendumKarapetyan: Ruling party lacks mandates for constitutional referendum
 Pashinyan: It is Armenia`s legitimate right to deprive the opposition  formed after the 9th convocation parliamentary elections of future  political activity Pashinyan: It is Armenia`s legitimate right to deprive the opposition  formed after the 9th convocation parliamentary elections of future  political activity
``Do not trust your eyes’’: IDBank warns about fraud using deepfakes``Do not trust your eyes’’: IDBank warns about fraud using deepfakes
NA Deputy Speaker: Pashinyan  actually serves his fourth termNA Deputy Speaker: Pashinyan  actually serves his fourth term
Yerevan to host second Academy for Conductors by Vasily Petrenko Yerevan to host second Academy for Conductors by Vasily Petrenko 
Political Scientist: US geoeconomic activity in Armenia is taking on  the character of resource colonizationPolitical Scientist: US geoeconomic activity in Armenia is taking on  the character of resource colonization
RPA Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, without securing popular support,  simply stole mandates from Prosperous Armenia on live televisionRPA Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, without securing popular support,  simply stole mandates from Prosperous Armenia on live television
Up to 30% idcoin at pools: Idram&IDBankUp to 30% idcoin at pools: Idram&IDBank
Armenia wants to introduce residency requirement for participation in  elections - MPArmenia wants to introduce residency requirement for participation in  elections - MP
 RA Deputy Prime Minister: Around AMD 48bln spent on resolving housing  problems of forcibly displaced persons RA Deputy Prime Minister: Around AMD 48bln spent on resolving housing  problems of forcibly displaced persons
Bruno Delbonnel - Guest of Honor at 23rd Golden Apricot Film FestivalBruno Delbonnel - Guest of Honor at 23rd Golden Apricot Film Festival
RA Deputy FM participates in 52nd Session of BSEC Council of Foreign  MinistersRA Deputy FM participates in 52nd Session of BSEC Council of Foreign  Ministers
Armenia bloc: Even under threat of arrest, Robert Kocharyan returned to countryArmenia bloc: Even under threat of arrest, Robert Kocharyan returned to country
Armenia and Greece discussed opportunities to expand parliamentary cooperationArmenia and Greece discussed opportunities to expand parliamentary cooperation
Opinion: Armenia entering not era of peace, but era of competing logistics regimesOpinion: Armenia entering not era of peace, but era of competing logistics regimes
Akanates questions RA CEC assertion that annulment of voting results at three polling stations did not affect election resultsAkanates questions RA CEC assertion that annulment of voting results at three polling stations did not affect election results
ARF: Hajiyev`s visit to Armenia to result in Armenian premier fulfilling Azerbaijan`s latest demandsARF: Hajiyev`s visit to Armenia to result in Armenian premier fulfilling Azerbaijan`s latest demands
Wings of Unity: Ruling party did not actually receive support reflected in officially announced election resultsWings of Unity: Ruling party did not actually receive support reflected in officially announced election results
RA Anti-Corruption Committee proposes banning parties involved in bribery from participating in next electionsRA Anti-Corruption Committee proposes banning parties involved in bribery from participating in next elections
U.S.-Armenia joint exercise  EAGLE PARTNER 2025 to take place in  Armenia from June 17- 25U.S.-Armenia joint exercise  EAGLE PARTNER 2025 to take place in  Armenia from June 17- 25
Armenian FM holds bilateral meetings with Dutch and Slovenian  counterparts in LuxembourgArmenian FM holds bilateral meetings with Dutch and Slovenian  counterparts in Luxembourg
Erdogan welcomes US- Iran agreement  Erdogan welcomes US- Iran agreement  
Armenian Ambassador, British official discuss recent developments in   South Caucasus Armenian Ambassador, British official discuss recent developments in   South Caucasus 
RPA: Official results of the so-called June 7 elections are null and  void; they do not reflect the will of the Armenian peopleRPA: Official results of the so-called June 7 elections are null and  void; they do not reflect the will of the Armenian people
Neonaturalism: The HandArt theaterNeonaturalism: The HandArt theater
``Teach For Armenia`` is the June beneficiary of the ``Power of One Dram````Teach For Armenia`` is the June beneficiary of the ``Power of One Dram``
Naryshkin: Yerevan will make a mistake by relying on Naryshkin: Yerevan will make a mistake by relying on "western aid"
Armenian, German FMs discuss bilateral agendaArmenian, German FMs discuss bilateral agenda
Two Two "Strong Armenia" bloc parliamentary candidates detained, four  others wanted
RA Prosecutor`s Office  disputing ownership of  land plot in  TsaghkadzorRA Prosecutor`s Office  disputing ownership of  land plot in  Tsaghkadzor
Armenia`s inspection body launches case regarding streams of  yellowish water that overflowed in Kapan during heavy rainArmenia`s inspection body launches case regarding streams of  yellowish water that overflowed in Kapan during heavy rain
Armenia to tighten control over destruction of expired medicinesArmenia to tighten control over destruction of expired medicines
Political analyst: In light of new realities, Yerevan may propose  advancing peace process with Baku without constitutional referendumPolitical analyst: In light of new realities, Yerevan may propose  advancing peace process with Baku without constitutional referendum
Papikyan participates in Eurosatory 2026 defense exhibition in ParisPapikyan participates in Eurosatory 2026 defense exhibition in Paris
Marta Kos to visit Armenia on July 5Marta Kos to visit Armenia on July 5
Finance Minister: Political forces engaged in vote buying have  absolutely no right to complainFinance Minister: Political forces engaged in vote buying have  absolutely no right to complain
 Lawyer: Armenian authorities detain father of fallen serviceman and   opposition candidate on fabricated charges Lawyer: Armenian authorities detain father of fallen serviceman and   opposition candidate on fabricated charges
Man who desecrated Mother Armenia memorial in Gyumri arrested Man who desecrated Mother Armenia memorial in Gyumri arrested 
Ruben Vardanyan`s wife announces organization of international  women`s humanitarian delegation to visit BakuRuben Vardanyan`s wife announces organization of international  women`s humanitarian delegation to visit Baku
Opposition MP raises question of footage from Zvartnots specially  protected zone ended up at Pashinyan family newspaper`s disposalOpposition MP raises question of footage from Zvartnots specially  protected zone ended up at Pashinyan family newspaper`s disposal
 Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power
Yerevan City Hall presents alternative routes during Kyiv Bridge  repairsYerevan City Hall presents alternative routes during Kyiv Bridge  repairs
RA CEC issues lengthy statement regarding its refusal to schedule  re-runs at three polling stationsRA CEC issues lengthy statement regarding its refusal to schedule  re-runs at three polling stations
Romanian Ambassador, Armenia`s Chief Rescue Officer advocate for  development of Armenian-Romanian cooperationRomanian Ambassador, Armenia`s Chief Rescue Officer advocate for  development of Armenian-Romanian cooperation
Narek Karapetyan: Armenian opposition faces difficult and unfair  fightNarek Karapetyan: Armenian opposition faces difficult and unfair  fight
RA ex-FM: Authorities do not become democratic just because they  speak language of WestRA ex-FM: Authorities do not become democratic just because they  speak language of West
Armenia harshly criticized Grigoryan`s meeting with Hajiyev in  Dilijan, opposition MP claims Armenia harshly criticized Grigoryan`s meeting with Hajiyev in  Dilijan, opposition MP claims 
Read more



Commented