Thursday, December 4 2025 17:46
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Zakharova: Yerevan disregarded ethical standards by disclosing OSCE  Minsk Group Co-Chairs` working documents

Zakharova: Yerevan disregarded ethical standards by disclosing OSCE  Minsk Group Co-Chairs` working documents

ArmInfo.Yerevan has disregarded ethical standards by disclosing the working materials of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs, and especially the correspondence of the heads of state, without proper coordination with the parties involved, as stated by Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria  Zakharova during a weekly briefing on December 4. She was asked to comment on the nearly complete package of documents on the  Nagorno-Karabakh conflict settlement negotiation process released by the Armenian government.

Zakharova acknowledged that since the Armenian authorities have done  it, Moscow has the right to comment. "It seems to me that all the  published documents somewhat undermine the arguments that official  Yerevan is trying to promote. The published UN and OSCE documents, in  the development and adoption of which Russia played an active role,  convincingly confirm that for three decades, our country, both in its  national capacity and as a co-chair of the Minsk Group, has made  consistent efforts to achieve a political and diplomatic settlement  of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, and much has been accomplished,"  she said.

According to her, the Russian position has always been based on  finding a reasonable balance between the following two components:  respect for the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan and ensuring the  rights and interests of the indigenous Karabakh population in  accordance with generally recognized international principles and  standards. Zakharova added that, as the journalist quoted, Moscow has  never conducted negotiations regarding the recognition of Artsakh's  independence or its annexation to Armenia. The diplomat also touched  on the statements made by Russian OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chair Igor  Popov in the media in 2021, recalling that the Russian mediator, with  facts in hand, refuted Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's  assertion in his article "The Origins of the 44-Day War" that  Russia's settlement proposals amounted to the return of seven  districts to Azerbaijan "just like that," without addressing the  status of Karabakh.

"In reality, everything was somewhat different, if not the opposite.  This can be easily verified by carefully reading the draft  declaration on the first phasee and further steps of the  Nagorno-Karabakh settlement published on the Armenian government's  website, as well as the draft statement by Russia, the United States,  and France in support of the aforementioned declaration and the  corresponding draft UN Security Council resolution," she noted.

According to her, these documents were discussed during  Armenian-Azerbaijani negotiations even before the change of power in  Yerevan in May 2018. "Neither side rejected them, although full  agreement was not reached," she continued. According to Zakharova,  negotiations were held regularly until 2018-2019, when the Pashinyan  administration effectively interrupted substantive dialogue. She  recalled that Yerevan then began to talk about international  recognition of Artsakh's independence as Armenia's priority:  Pashinyan made statements to that effect in March and August 2019 in  Stepanakert, including the famous "Artsakh is Armenia, that's it."  She recalled that this was followed by the 44-day war of 2020, which  was stopped thanks to the efforts of the Russian Federation.

"Recently, it's not the Russian Federation's position that has  changed, but Armenia's, or rather its leadership's position, and it  has changed radically," Zakharova said, pointing out the Prague  agreements of October 6, 2022, when Pashinyan recognized  Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan, without regard for the  interests of the people living in those territories. "Yes, these  documents show that there were opportunities for settlement, and they  were missed. But that's not our fault," she concluded.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.
Issues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in YerevanIssues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in Yerevan
A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.
Criminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal AffairsCriminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal Affairs
Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine                Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine            
First Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream LaunchedFirst Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream Launched
Rate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency ExchangeRate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency Exchange
The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.
An Armenian version of the American drama An Armenian version of the American drama "Closer" will be filmed in Yerevan.
Human rights activist: Human rights activist: "Protecting the rights of the people of Artsakh is a matter of the rights of all Armenians."
Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.
Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.
One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.
A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.
ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.
Pashinyan and the Slovenian Foreign Minister discussed further deepening relations between Armenia and the European Union.Pashinyan and the Slovenian Foreign Minister discussed further deepening relations between Armenia and the European Union.
The Metsamor community will be returned 0.12 hectares of land, according to the prosecutor`s office.The Metsamor community will be returned 0.12 hectares of land, according to the prosecutor`s office.
Karen Arustamyan became a member of the Audit Chamber of ArmeniaKaren Arustamyan became a member of the Audit Chamber of Armenia
I see no grounds for dismissing the governor of Shirak — PMI see no grounds for dismissing the governor of Shirak — PM
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
It won`t come down to snap elections: Pashinyan on a new possible solution for adopting a new ConstitutionIt won`t come down to snap elections: Pashinyan on a new possible solution for adopting a new Constitution
Armenia’s Ombudsman: Parliament Should Be a Platform for Democratic Discussions, Not a “Battlefield”Armenia’s Ombudsman: Parliament Should Be a Platform for Democratic Discussions, Not a “Battlefield”
Opposition politician: The brawl in Armenia’s parliament demonstrated that the Civil Contract faction is facing a legitimacy crisisOpposition politician: The brawl in Armenia’s parliament demonstrated that the Civil Contract faction is facing a legitimacy crisis
The Prime Minister congratulated People`s Artist of Armenia Svetlana Navasardyan on her anniversaryThe Prime Minister congratulated People`s Artist of Armenia Svetlana Navasardyan on her anniversary
Gagik Khachatryan`s arrest has been extended for another two monthsGagik Khachatryan`s arrest has been extended for another two months
Armenian citizens who have not completed compulsory military service will be eligible to work as police officers or rescuers.Armenian citizens who have not completed compulsory military service will be eligible to work as police officers or rescuers.
Registration deadlines for medicinal products will be shortened in Armenia.Registration deadlines for medicinal products will be shortened in Armenia.
Lilit Stepanyan has become the governor of Armenia`s Kotayk region.Lilit Stepanyan has become the governor of Armenia`s Kotayk region.
Armenia is interested in expanding cooperation with India in the context of joining the Nagoya Protocol.Armenia is interested in expanding cooperation with India in the context of joining the Nagoya Protocol.
On November 1, Armenia will officially begin accepting applications and issuing new biometric passports and identification cards.On November 1, Armenia will officially begin accepting applications and issuing new biometric passports and identification cards.
Armenian Justice Minister: The text of the new Constitution will be published in NovemberArmenian Justice Minister: The text of the new Constitution will be published in November
A ruling party MP provoked a brawl in the Armenian parliament: a verbal altercation escalated into a fight.A ruling party MP provoked a brawl in the Armenian parliament: a verbal altercation escalated into a fight.
Representatives of the Armenian Ombudsman visited a convict who has been on hunger strike for 44 daysRepresentatives of the Armenian Ombudsman visited a convict who has been on hunger strike for 44 days
Artur Javadyan has been relieved of his post as Ambassador-at-Large.Artur Javadyan has been relieved of his post as Ambassador-at-Large.
Armenia`s Ministry of Internal Affairs: The co-founder of Luding was summoned to the police as part of an investigationArmenia`s Ministry of Internal Affairs: The co-founder of Luding was summoned to the police as part of an investigation
Meeting Held with the Deputy Foreign Minister for Economic Diplomacy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Islamic Republic of IranMeeting Held with the Deputy Foreign Minister for Economic Diplomacy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Zakharova called the Armenian leadership`s reaction to the EAEU report hasty and even aggressive.Zakharova called the Armenian leadership`s reaction to the EAEU report hasty and even aggressive.
Deputy Speaker to Armenia’s Foreign Minister: When my colleagues say, “Let’s sign a peace treaty,” you start talking about constitutional changesDeputy Speaker to Armenia’s Foreign Minister: When my colleagues say, “Let’s sign a peace treaty,” you start talking about constitutional changes
Pashinyan: We are moving toward establishing relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan in order to overcome the status of an outpostPashinyan: We are moving toward establishing relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan in order to overcome the status of an outpost
Foreign Minister: The issue of prisoners is constantly on our agendaForeign Minister: The issue of prisoners is constantly on our agenda
The Armenian Ombudsman and the head of the EU civilian mission discussed human rights issues.The Armenian Ombudsman and the head of the EU civilian mission discussed human rights issues.
Peace has already been established, despite the absence of a signed treaty - Ararat MirzoyanPeace has already been established, despite the absence of a signed treaty - Ararat Mirzoyan
Former Minister of Justice: Amending the Armenian Constitution based on a misinterpretation of the Declaration of Independence is a dead endFormer Minister of Justice: Amending the Armenian Constitution based on a misinterpretation of the Declaration of Independence is a dead end
Digital Future and Sustainable Development: IDBank`s Chairman of the Management Board in an Interview with ForbesDigital Future and Sustainable Development: IDBank`s Chairman of the Management Board in an Interview with Forbes
The head of the Armenian Ministry of Environment discussed prospects for environmental cooperation with representatives of Switzerland, India, and Qatar.The head of the Armenian Ministry of Environment discussed prospects for environmental cooperation with representatives of Switzerland, India, and Qatar.
A tent camp for reservist training is being built at one of the Ministry of Defense`s training grounds with EPF funding.A tent camp for reservist training is being built at one of the Ministry of Defense`s training grounds with EPF funding.
It is important that the Armenian Armed Forces are under the control of civil society - Prime MinisterIt is important that the Armenian Armed Forces are under the control of civil society - Prime Minister
A A "School for the Development of Excellence for Teachers Teaching Subjects in Russian in Armenia" has opened in Yerevan.
Pashinyan: Local government elections demonstrate a crisis within the oppositionPashinyan: Local government elections demonstrate a crisis within the opposition
Pashinyan expressed condolences to Spain over the deaths in the Toledo train collision.Pashinyan expressed condolences to Spain over the deaths in the Toledo train collision.
The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament does not believe that the opposition will oppose the will of the Armenian people in the adoption of a new Constitution.The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament does not believe that the opposition will oppose the will of the Armenian people in the adoption of a new Constitution.
A Center for Iranian Studies and Geopolitical Analysis will open in Armenia.A Center for Iranian Studies and Geopolitical Analysis will open in Armenia.
The property of former NA Chairman Artur Baghdasaryan has been seized.The property of former NA Chairman Artur Baghdasaryan has been seized.
The Office of the Ombudsman for the Artsakh Republic`s Heritage Issues called on UNESCO to take concrete action to protect the cultural heritage of Artsakh.The Office of the Ombudsman for the Artsakh Republic`s Heritage Issues called on UNESCO to take concrete action to protect the cultural heritage of Artsakh.
Armenia and Slovenia signed a Memorandum of Understanding to expand political dialogue.Armenia and Slovenia signed a Memorandum of Understanding to expand political dialogue.
Pashinyan and the Saudi Arabian prince emphasized the importance of establishing peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan.Pashinyan and the Saudi Arabian prince emphasized the importance of establishing peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
Discussions on the candidacy of a member of the RA Audit Chamber have begun in the National Assembly of ArmeniaDiscussions on the candidacy of a member of the RA Audit Chamber have begun in the National Assembly of Armenia
Visa liberalization with the EU now depends more on Armenia - MirzoyanVisa liberalization with the EU now depends more on Armenia - Mirzoyan
KHACHKAR STUDIOS PUBLISHES WEEK #7 OF WEEKLY T•A•P REPORTING ACROSS 26 PILOTSKHACHKAR STUDIOS PUBLISHES WEEK #7 OF WEEKLY T•A•P REPORTING ACROSS 26 PILOTS
Read more



Commented
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.
The participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassiesThe participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassies
Expert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and EastExpert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and East
The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.
The Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behaviorThe Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behavior
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place
Political scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and strugglePolitical scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and struggle