Friday, August 22 2025 12:04
Marianna Mkrtchyan

No talks about epoch of peace possible now - expert 

No talks about epoch of peace possible now - expert 

ArmInfo.  It is impossible to talk about an era of peace as of today. This is how orientalist Sergey Melkonyan commented on the results of the Armenian-Azerbaijani summit in Washington.

Speaking about what Armenia received from the August 8 summit in  Washington, the expert stated that the initialing of the peace treaty  allows postponing a potential escalation, but not canceling it.  According to him, the prospect of opening the border with Turkey has  also been outlined, although there may be more problems than benefits  here.

Touching on what Azerbaijan received, Melkonyan noted that first of  all, this is the dissolution of the OSCE Minsk Group - the  legalization of the closure of the "Karabakh issue". "Yerevan and  Baku have already sent a joint statement to the OSCE. However, the  procedure remains unclear: should the co-chairs (Russia, the United  States and France) send a corresponding appeal.

In addition, the cancellation of Section 907 of the Freedom Support  Act is a de facto opening of the door to military-technical  cooperation between the United States and Azerbaijan. Exclusive  conditions for the road to Nakhichevan: Baku received another  document, which outlines "unhindered" access to its exclave"

Based on this, we can conclude that Azerbaijan has already received  specific benefits, while Armenia can only be content with prospects  (reduced risk of escalation in the near future and possible opening  of communications)," Melkonyan emphasized.

Speaking about the consequences for Russia, the expert noted that the  creation of a new status quo continues in the South Caucasus without  Russia's participation and without taking into account its interests.   However, he is sure that it is too early to say that Moscow has  completely left the region - options for possible participation in  the future configuration remain.

"At the same time, it is possible talk about the loss of Russia's  monopoly in the processes, which means the need to find a new model  of competition and cooperation with regional and extra-regional  actors," the orientalist added.

The expert also outlined the consequences for Iran, noting that the  concluded deal is a challenge to the interests of the Islamic  Republic. "The potential placement of American companies in close  proximity to the northern borders will lead to more active  involvement of Tehran to mitigate potential risks. In this case,  Iran, like Russia, was left out of the formation of new contours of  the region," he is sure.

Melkonyan believes that the growth of Turkey's influence after these  agreements, taking into account the current dynamics, is obvious.  "Ankara is getting prospects to become a key regional actor in the  South Caucasus. Whether it will be able to realize the advantage will  depend on many factors (how TRIPP will be implemented and whether it  will be implemented at all; whether the agreement in Washington will  lead to a partial or complete opening of the border with Armenia,  etc.)," the orientalist added.

At the same time, he noted that Armenia had actually made two more  concessions. "Firstly, Armenia's position was previously based on the  fact that it was ready to provide a road for Azerbaijan to  Nakhichevan on the same terms that Iran provided within the framework  of the "Araz Corridor". However, now we see that the conditions are  completely different: Azerbaijan has unhindered access through Iran  and there will definitely be no American companies on this  communication line, as envisaged in the TRIPP framework.  Secondly,  Armenia had previously stated that it was ready to submit a statement  on the dissolution of the Minsk Group in parallel with the signing of  a peace treaty. As a result, Yerevan did not receive a signed peace  treaty, but has already submitted a statement on the dissolution of  the MG," the expert noted.

According to him, Armenia will additionally need to review the  actions of the EU observation mission, which must leave the  Armenian-Azerbaijani border, in accordance with the initialed  agreement. He suggested that the mission may remain in a different  format.

"In this case, Armenia will become the most internationalized country  in the region, since European observers, Russian border guards, a  Russian military base and an American company will be located on its  territory. Yerevan will also be obliged to change the Constitution  (which already violates Article 4 of the initialed agreement on  non-interference in each other's internal affairs). Considering that,  according to various polls, 600,000 votes in support of changing the  Constitution at the request of Azerbaijan are not collected, the  signing of the peace treaty will be postponed for a long time,"  Melkonyan noted.

At the same time, the orientalist noted that the only concession for  Baku can be considered the initialing of the document, since there is  no additional benefit for Azerbaijan (except for creating an  opportunity for qualitative growth in relations with the United  States).

"However, given that the statement itself and the initialed document  are a declaration of intent and do not oblige Azerbaijan to anything  in fact, Baku is free to act within the framework of the existing  "modus operandi" - to demand new concessions from Armenia. The issue  of the so-called "enclaves" may be on the agenda in the future.

In addition, as was said, in addition to the 2020 Statement, Baku  receives another document providing for unhindered access to  Nakhchivan. Thus, in the event of a change in the regional and  international situation that leads to the disruption of this project,  Azerbaijan will receive additional legitimacy to open the road by  force," the expert believes.

"It is impossible to talk about an era of peace as of today. Until  Azerbaijan decides to implement the following points, which are an  important element of the conflict, it is impossible to talk about the  peaceful intentions of the Azerbaijani side or the approach of peace:  the return of Armenian prisoners held in Baku; de-occupation of the  territory of Armenia (more than 200 km2 captured in 2021-2022); the  realization of the rights of the forcibly expelled residents of  Nagorno-Karabakh; maintaining on Baku's agenda expansionist projects  such as the so-called "Western Azerbaijan", which pose a threat to  the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Armenia," the  orientalist concluded.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
The most reliable tool for combating disinformation is direct dialogue with the public, Pashinyan said.The most reliable tool for combating disinformation is direct dialogue with the public, Pashinyan said.
The Strong Armenia Party will hold a rally in the name of justice.The Strong Armenia Party will hold a rally in the name of justice.
Samvel Karapetyan: Arsen`s fight for a dignified Armenia will continueSamvel Karapetyan: Arsen`s fight for a dignified Armenia will continue
Macron and Pashinyan met at the Elysee Palace.Macron and Pashinyan met at the Elysee Palace.
The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament discussed the bilateral relations agenda with the Indian Ambassador.The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament discussed the bilateral relations agenda with the Indian Ambassador.
Amsterdam called for an international investigation into the death in pretrial detention of a Strong Armenia activist.Amsterdam called for an international investigation into the death in pretrial detention of a Strong Armenia activist.
IDBank at the UBA Regional Conference: From Travel Solutions to Business OpportunitiesIDBank at the UBA Regional Conference: From Travel Solutions to Business Opportunities
35% Discount for the 35th Anniversary on Selected IDBank Cards35% Discount for the 35th Anniversary on Selected IDBank Cards
Lavrov: Armenia will not be expelled from the CSTOLavrov: Armenia will not be expelled from the CSTO
Lavrov: Armenia has not submitted a request to withdraw from the CSTO and the EAEU.Lavrov: Armenia has not submitted a request to withdraw from the CSTO and the EAEU.
Pashinyan`s wife reminded the mayor of Yerevan of his direct responsibilities for the capital`s development.Pashinyan`s wife reminded the mayor of Yerevan of his direct responsibilities for the capital`s development.
Following the meeting of the Armenian-Iranian intergovernmental commission, a memorandum of understanding was signedFollowing the meeting of the Armenian-Iranian intergovernmental commission, a memorandum of understanding was signed
Mher Grigoryan: The Armenian authorities confirm their readiness to continue constructive and institutional dialogue with the Armenia-EU civil society platformMher Grigoryan: The Armenian authorities confirm their readiness to continue constructive and institutional dialogue with the Armenia-EU civil society platform
The Armenian Ombudsman has launched an investigation into the death in pretrial detention of the Strong Armenia candidate for mayor of Stepanavan.The Armenian Ombudsman has launched an investigation into the death in pretrial detention of the Strong Armenia candidate for mayor of Stepanavan.
The consolidated opposition called the death of the Strong Armenia candidate in Stepanavan a settling of scores.The consolidated opposition called the death of the Strong Armenia candidate in Stepanavan a settling of scores.
The Turkish minister announced the completion of work to open border crossings with Armenia.The Turkish minister announced the completion of work to open border crossings with Armenia.
MP: India is a key country for Armenia in terms of further development of bilateral relationsMP: India is a key country for Armenia in terms of further development of bilateral relations
The Armenian authorities intend to establish legal mechanisms for the protection of copyright and related rightsThe Armenian authorities intend to establish legal mechanisms for the protection of copyright and related rights
The head of the Armenian Ministry of Justice doubted that it would be possible to complete discussions on the draft of the new Constitution by the end of the yearThe head of the Armenian Ministry of Justice doubted that it would be possible to complete discussions on the draft of the new Constitution by the end of the year
Armenia`s Justice Minister on the death of a Stepanavan mayoral candidate: Arrest is an exceptional measure, and the number of alternative preventive measures exceeds 3,000Armenia`s Justice Minister on the death of a Stepanavan mayoral candidate: Arrest is an exceptional measure, and the number of alternative preventive measures exceeds 3,000
Armenia notes the importance of improving the legislative framework for protecting children`s rightsArmenia notes the importance of improving the legislative framework for protecting children`s rights
ANC: Arsen Gevorkyan is another victim of the campaign unleashed by Nikol Pashinyan`s ANC: Arsen Gevorkyan is another victim of the campaign unleashed by Nikol Pashinyan`s "regime" against democratic and civil liberties in Armenia.
Ardshinbank Presents Financial and Digital Solutions for Business Development in GyumriArdshinbank Presents Financial and Digital Solutions for Business Development in Gyumri
Armenia notes the importance of establishing direct professional contacts with China`s judicial systemArmenia notes the importance of establishing direct professional contacts with China`s judicial system
The Investigative Committee of Armenia has completed the preliminary investigation into the murder of three people.The Investigative Committee of Armenia has completed the preliminary investigation into the murder of three people.
Oppositionist: Court softens pretrial detention for prisoner who spent 56 days on hunger strikeOppositionist: Court softens pretrial detention for prisoner who spent 56 days on hunger strike
CIS Secretary General: Armenia did not notify the CIS of its plans to leave the organizationCIS Secretary General: Armenia did not notify the CIS of its plans to leave the organization
The air temperature in Armenia will increase by 4-6 degreesThe air temperature in Armenia will increase by 4-6 degrees
Armenia`s first president discharged from hospital after successful surgeryArmenia`s first president discharged from hospital after successful surgery
Converse Bank Expands Its International Capabilities Through Cooperation with Citibank N.A.Converse Bank Expands Its International Capabilities Through Cooperation with Citibank N.A.
High Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs to visit TurkeyHigh Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs to visit Turkey
Opposition figures blamed the government led by Pashinyan for the death of a Strong Armenia representative in prison.Opposition figures blamed the government led by Pashinyan for the death of a Strong Armenia representative in prison.
"Strong Armenia": Pashinyan’s government bears responsibility for yet another opposition figure’s death in custody
The first theatrical production of the poem The first theatrical production of the poem "Country of the Fathers" by Russian composer Georgy Sviridov, based on the lyrics of Avetik Isahakyan, will premiere in Armenia
The Strong Armenia candidate for the post of head of the Stepanavan community died in prison.The Strong Armenia candidate for the post of head of the Stepanavan community died in prison.
The RPA deputy chairman called on the Armenian side to demand the resignation of BSEC Secretary General Asaf Hajiyev for political biasThe RPA deputy chairman called on the Armenian side to demand the resignation of BSEC Secretary General Asaf Hajiyev for political bias
The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the Vice President of Iran discussed prospects for cultural cooperation.The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the Vice President of Iran discussed prospects for cultural cooperation.
Srbuhi Galyan: Holding the CIS Justice Ministers` Summit in Yerevan opens up new opportunities for strengthening and developing legal cooperationSrbuhi Galyan: Holding the CIS Justice Ministers` Summit in Yerevan opens up new opportunities for strengthening and developing legal cooperation
The head of the Russian Ministry of Justice: We must act as architects of a legal framework aimed at strengthening the rule of law.The head of the Russian Ministry of Justice: We must act as architects of a legal framework aimed at strengthening the rule of law.
The preliminary investigation into the criminal case on violation of voting secrecy has been completed – Investigative CommitteeThe preliminary investigation into the criminal case on violation of voting secrecy has been completed – Investigative Committee
A meeting of the Council of Ministers of Justice of the CIS countries is taking place in YerevanA meeting of the Council of Ministers of Justice of the CIS countries is taking place in Yerevan
Orientalist: In 2026, Baku made special efforts to achieve greater diplomatic effect on the issue of victory over ArtsakhOrientalist: In 2026, Baku made special efforts to achieve greater diplomatic effect on the issue of victory over Artsakh
Purmohammadi honored Loris Cheknavoryan at the Blue Mosque in YerevanPurmohammadi honored Loris Cheknavoryan at the Blue Mosque in Yerevan
Yerevan highly appreciates Iran`s principled position on the issue of Armenia`s sovereignty and territorial integrity.Yerevan highly appreciates Iran`s principled position on the issue of Armenia`s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
The foreign ministers of Armenia and Estonia discussed prospects for developing bilateral economic relationsThe foreign ministers of Armenia and Estonia discussed prospects for developing bilateral economic relations
Levon Ter-Petrosyan, Robert Kocharyan, and Serzh Sargsyan were and remain the main enemies of Armenia`s independence, says the speaker of parliamentLevon Ter-Petrosyan, Robert Kocharyan, and Serzh Sargsyan were and remain the main enemies of Armenia`s independence, says the speaker of parliament
The Prime Minister of Armenia arrived in France on a working visitThe Prime Minister of Armenia arrived in France on a working visit
Documents of International Events Held in Avaza Published at the United NationsDocuments of International Events Held in Avaza Published at the United Nations
MFA: Relations between Armenia and Estonia are developing on the basis of strong political commitmentMFA: Relations between Armenia and Estonia are developing on the basis of strong political commitment
The Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia announced the initiation of criminal proceedings in connection with the brawl in parliament.The Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia announced the initiation of criminal proceedings in connection with the brawl in parliament.
Grono: For the European Union, the importance of the South Caucasus is undeniableGrono: For the European Union, the importance of the South Caucasus is undeniable
The Russian Ambassador honored the memory of Russian pilots killed by the enemy on the day the 44-day war around Artsakh ended.The Russian Ambassador honored the memory of Russian pilots killed by the enemy on the day the 44-day war around Artsakh ended.
Armenia and India have coordinated their scientific and educational cooperation agenda.Armenia and India have coordinated their scientific and educational cooperation agenda.
ANC Deputy Chairman: Under the guise of the idea of creating a Fourth Republic, an attempt is being made to abandon the principle of historical continuityANC Deputy Chairman: Under the guise of the idea of creating a Fourth Republic, an attempt is being made to abandon the principle of historical continuity
"Strong Armenia": Agreeing to a constitutional referendum at Baku`s request is a retreat from the principles of independence
Armenia and Iran have synchronized their watches on the political and economic cooperation agendaArmenia and Iran have synchronized their watches on the political and economic cooperation agenda
Pashinyan and the Iranian Vice President exchanged views on the process of unblocking regional transport routes and the opportunities this createsPashinyan and the Iranian Vice President exchanged views on the process of unblocking regional transport routes and the opportunities this creates
Amid public discontent, Armenian authorities abandoned the idea of abolishing funeral benefitsAmid public discontent, Armenian authorities abandoned the idea of abolishing funeral benefits
On the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day war in 2020, the Artsakh Public Council presented its demands to the Armenian government and the Russian EmbassyOn the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day war in 2020, the Artsakh Public Council presented its demands to the Armenian government and the Russian Embassy
Mane Tandilyan: Under Pashinyan`s rule, Armenian prisoners of war have no chance of returningMane Tandilyan: Under Pashinyan`s rule, Armenian prisoners of war have no chance of returning
Read more



Commented