Wednesday, August 28 2024 17:24
Marianna Mkrtchyan

"Hay Dat" published a detailed ethnic cleansing case study report

"Hay Dat" published a detailed ethnic cleansing case study report

ArmInfo. The Center for International and Comparative Law under the auspices of the Armenian  Legal Center, operating in the "Hay Dat" system, published a detailed report addressing the recent ethnic cleansing in Artsakh, which is due to Azerbaijan's long-standing anti- Armenian discriminatory policy.

As reported by the Central Office of the ARF Dashnaktsutyun "Hay Dat"  Bureau, the report argues that the siege of Artsakh, the military  offensive, and the subsequent forced displacement were not isolated  incidents, but rather the culmination of deeply entrenched  institutional policies against Armenians.  The report distinguishes  between the concepts of "ethnic cleansing" and "genocide", noting  that while genocide is defined as the intent to destroy a group in  whole or in part, ethnic cleansing involves the forcible removal of a  group from a specific area through violence and terror.  "In the case  of Artsakh, the European Parliament and various experts have  classified the events as ethnic cleansing, some extending this  classification to the crime of genocide, due to the harsh conditions  and the threat of systematic extermination," the ARF said in a  statement.

It also noted that the evidence presented in the report shows that  Azerbaijan's policies, including the blockade and military  operations, reflect a deliberate attempt to eradicate the Armenian  presence in Artsakh. "In 2022  the blockade that began in December  created dire conditions, restricting the flow of essential goods and  services, resulting in severe shortages of food, medicine and fuel.  The resulting humanitarian crisis led to widespread malnutrition,  poor health and disruption of education and health services," the ARF  recalled

The report details how Azerbaijani forces targeted agricultural  operations and hindered local food production, exacerbating the  suffering of the Armenian population.

"The military offensive that began in September 2023 exacerbated the  crisis. The report documents how the attack, which began with intense  fighting and widespread damage to civilian infrastructure, led to  significant civilian casualties and serious disruptions to evacuation  efforts. Reports of war crimes, including torture and mutilation of  Armenian civilians, highlight the brutality of the attack and the  significance of such actions in the forced displacement of the  Armenian population from Artsakh," the report continues.  The report  also highlights the ongoing destruction of Armenian cultural and  religious sites by Azerbaijani authorities, systematically erasing  Armenian traces. 

"This destruction includes the destruction of churches, historical  monuments and khachkars, as well as the manipulation of the nature of  monuments to eliminate Armenian cultural traces. The report includes  satellite images and documents from organizations such as Caucasus  Heritage Watch, which shows the extent of cultural destruction that  has been condemned by international bodies such as UNESCO and the  European Parliament. The report highlights that this cultural  destruction and the impact of the blockade reflects a broader pattern  of anti-Armenian sentiment in Azerbaijani society," the ARF stated.   Moreover, the report notes that the treatment of Armenians under  Azerbaijani rule, including the politically motivated detention of  Artsakh political leaders and the continued glorification of  anti-Armenian violence, reflects a disregard for international human  rights standards. 

"It emphasizes that the systematic denial of Armenian cultural  identity and the destruction of cultural heritage sites is an  integral part of Azerbaijan's broader strategy to eliminate the  Armenian presence in Artsakh." the report says. 

In the final part, the report calls for international action to  eliminate these violations, emphasizing the need to support the  displaced Armenian population 

It also suggests that the destruction of Armenian cultural heritage,  along with gross human rights violations and institutional  discrimination in Azerbaijan, poses a continuing threat to Artsakh  Armenians and underscores the urgency of international intervention  to prevent further atrocities and support the restoration of Armenian  rights and heritage.  The report is available at the following link:  https://iclaw.am/downloads/Artsakh-Nagorno-Karabakh-A-  Case-Study-in-Ethnic-Cleansing.pdf .

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Khachkar Studios’ Masterclass #3 Now Available in Three LanguagesKhachkar Studios’ Masterclass #3 Now Available in Three Languages
Acba Bank is the Market Maker for EBRD Bonds in ArmeniaAcba Bank is the Market Maker for EBRD Bonds in Armenia
The Constitutional Court of Armenia has recognized the framework agreement on the TRIPP project as being in accordance with the Constitution.The Constitutional Court of Armenia has recognized the framework agreement on the TRIPP project as being in accordance with the Constitution.
Pashinyan: The referendum on joining the EU or maintaining membership in the EAEU has already been held twice indirectlyPashinyan: The referendum on joining the EU or maintaining membership in the EAEU has already been held twice indirectly
The head of the Armenian Ministry of Justice: The draft of the new Constitution currently contains a reference to the AACThe head of the Armenian Ministry of Justice: The draft of the new Constitution currently contains a reference to the AAC
Lawyer: Criminal case against former MP Martun Grigoryan sent to courtLawyer: Criminal case against former MP Martun Grigoryan sent to court
Prime Minister: Matenadaran has recorded Gandzasar`s Armenian origins – I consider it pointless to continue discussing this topic.Prime Minister: Matenadaran has recorded Gandzasar`s Armenian origins – I consider it pointless to continue discussing this topic.
The Promise Institute for Human Rights will host a discussion on the issue of Armenian prisoners of war held in BakuThe Promise Institute for Human Rights will host a discussion on the issue of Armenian prisoners of war held in Baku
RA Prime Minister: The TRIPP project will operate under Armenia`s jurisdictionRA Prime Minister: The TRIPP project will operate under Armenia`s jurisdiction
Only in 2029 will the PISA study results show how effective our work has been — head of the MONKSOnly in 2029 will the PISA study results show how effective our work has been — head of the MONKS
Opposition Figure: We Expect Artsakh Lawmakers, Despite Threats from the Armenian Authorities, to Elect a New Speaker of the Artsakh ParliamentOpposition Figure: We Expect Artsakh Lawmakers, Despite Threats from the Armenian Authorities, to Elect a New Speaker of the Artsakh Parliament
Prime Minister: all the people’s money stolen down to the last luma will be returned to the peoplePrime Minister: all the people’s money stolen down to the last luma will be returned to the people
Lavrov: Russia does not intend to sponsor Armenia’s membership in the EULavrov: Russia does not intend to sponsor Armenia’s membership in the EU
Pashinyan: Armenia’s agricultural sector is experiencing a decline this year, which has its reasonsPashinyan: Armenia’s agricultural sector is experiencing a decline this year, which has its reasons
Security Council Secretary: The Armenian side did not raise the issue of withdrawing the 102nd Russian military base stationed in GyumriSecurity Council Secretary: The Armenian side did not raise the issue of withdrawing the 102nd Russian military base stationed in Gyumri
Ishkhan Sagatelyan: The withdrawal of the 102nd Russian base will be another adventure leading Armenia to new threatsIshkhan Sagatelyan: The withdrawal of the 102nd Russian base will be another adventure leading Armenia to new threats
Issues concerning the expansion of interparliamentary relations between Armenia and Georgia discussed in YerevanIssues concerning the expansion of interparliamentary relations between Armenia and Georgia discussed in Yerevan
President of the Republic of Armenia and Swiss Ambassador Discussed Possibilities for Applying Swiss Experience in ForestryPresident of the Republic of Armenia and Swiss Ambassador Discussed Possibilities for Applying Swiss Experience in Forestry
Staff of the Ombudsman’s Office, with the participation of representatives of state bodies, discussed the problems of arranging meetings between parents deprived of their liberty and their children.Staff of the Ombudsman’s Office, with the participation of representatives of state bodies, discussed the problems of arranging meetings between parents deprived of their liberty and their children.
Ishkhan Saghatelyan: ARFD will participate in local self-government elections despite pressure from the authorities on opposition candidatesIshkhan Saghatelyan: ARFD will participate in local self-government elections despite pressure from the authorities on opposition candidates
Armenia and Greece Discussed Cooperation in EducationArmenia and Greece Discussed Cooperation in Education
Ishkhan Saghatelyan: Pashinyan’s party is implementing a program of “denationalization” of Armenia and the Armenian peopleIshkhan Saghatelyan: Pashinyan’s party is implementing a program of “denationalization” of Armenia and the Armenian people
Former Artsakh Culture Ministers Demand That Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sport Publicly Assess Azerbaijan’s Policy Toward Armenian Heritage in the Occupied NKRFormer Artsakh Culture Ministers Demand That Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sport Publicly Assess Azerbaijan’s Policy Toward Armenian Heritage in the Occupied NKR
Armenia’s Ministry of Environment: Working meetings of the COP17 delegation began in MontrealArmenia’s Ministry of Environment: Working meetings of the COP17 delegation began in Montreal
Armenian Historian: People Like Magdalena Grono Should Be Kept Away from the Thresholds of Armenian ShrinesArmenian Historian: People Like Magdalena Grono Should Be Kept Away from the Thresholds of Armenian Shrines
The Strong Armenia party plans to create a tourist center in Tigranashen — MPThe Strong Armenia party plans to create a tourist center in Tigranashen — MP
The Armenian kyokushin karate team won 16 medals in AnapaThe Armenian kyokushin karate team won 16 medals in Anapa
Azerbaijani studies expert: Armenia’s Foreign Ministry could use the ICC against Aliyev’s Armenophobic statementsAzerbaijani studies expert: Armenia’s Foreign Ministry could use the ICC against Aliyev’s Armenophobic statements
IDBank in Monaco: Armenian Financial Innovation on a Prestigious International StageIDBank in Monaco: Armenian Financial Innovation on a Prestigious International Stage
In Armenia, the investigation into a high-profile criminal case involving an attempt to illegally collect 1.6 billion drams from the state-owned company Armenicum CJSC has been completedIn Armenia, the investigation into a high-profile criminal case involving an attempt to illegally collect 1.6 billion drams from the state-owned company Armenicum CJSC has been completed
Ruling party MP: If Azerbaijan fires, one should not expect a retaliatory shot; it will not bring peace to ArmeniaRuling party MP: If Azerbaijan fires, one should not expect a retaliatory shot; it will not bring peace to Armenia
The Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Discussed Bilateral Agenda Issues with Georgia’s AmbassadorThe Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Discussed Bilateral Agenda Issues with Georgia’s Ambassador
Armenia reaffirmed its commitment to cooperation with international organizations on issues related to enforced disappearancesArmenia reaffirmed its commitment to cooperation with international organizations on issues related to enforced disappearances
Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly: I urge the media to adopt and follow self-regulation mechanismsDeputy Speaker of the National Assembly: I urge the media to adopt and follow self-regulation mechanisms
Armenian passport mobility index falls to 79 points — Passport Reports reportArmenian passport mobility index falls to 79 points — Passport Reports report
Arpine Sargsyan familiarized herself with the work of the forensic medical department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of GeorgiaArpine Sargsyan familiarized herself with the work of the forensic medical department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Georgia
Yerevan and Berlin align on the bilateral cooperation agendaYerevan and Berlin align on the bilateral cooperation agenda
Gohar Meloyan: TRIPP is being implemented in a way that ensures Armenia has less involvement and minimal revenueGohar Meloyan: TRIPP is being implemented in a way that ensures Armenia has less involvement and minimal revenue
Jerusalem Patriarchate: A lasting peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan must not be achieved at the cost of desecrating Artsakh’s Armenian cultural heritageJerusalem Patriarchate: A lasting peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan must not be achieved at the cost of desecrating Artsakh’s Armenian cultural heritage
Armenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Advocates the Full and Effective Involvement of Women in Peace and Security ProcessesArmenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Advocates the Full and Effective Involvement of Women in Peace and Security Processes
The Prosecutor’s Office Demands the return of the former kindergarten building to the Voskevan CommunitThe Prosecutor’s Office Demands the return of the former kindergarten building to the Voskevan Communit
NKR Defense Army Officer: When war deprives you of your homeland and you are then continually intimidated with war, it means you are still in a state of warNKR Defense Army Officer: When war deprives you of your homeland and you are then continually intimidated with war, it means you are still in a state of war
The Ministry of Defense discussed cooperation between the RA Armed Forces and the Kansas National Guard.The Ministry of Defense discussed cooperation between the RA Armed Forces and the Kansas National Guard.
The All-Armenian Fund The All-Armenian Fund "Hayastan" approved new strategic development directions
The next meeting of the Supreme Spiritual Council began in the Mother See of EtchmiadzinThe next meeting of the Supreme Spiritual Council began in the Mother See of Etchmiadzin
By 2030, at least four Armenian universities should be among the top 500 – Zhanna AndreasyanBy 2030, at least four Armenian universities should be among the top 500 – Zhanna Andreasyan
Fidan: Türkiye expects a new phase of regional cooperation to begin in the South CaucasusFidan: Türkiye expects a new phase of regional cooperation to begin in the South Caucasus
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Zakharova: Moscow’s position on the need for Armenia to hold a plebiscite on the EU has not changedZakharova: Moscow’s position on the need for Armenia to hold a plebiscite on the EU has not changed
Opposition Figure: Change of Power in Armenia Will Happen Fairly QuicklyOpposition Figure: Change of Power in Armenia Will Happen Fairly Quickly
Ara Zohrabyan reappointed rector of the Academy of Advocates of ArmeniaAra Zohrabyan reappointed rector of the Academy of Advocates of Armenia
Zakharova on the campaign against the AAC: Those participating in the persecution of the church will be cursed for centuriesZakharova on the campaign against the AAC: Those participating in the persecution of the church will be cursed for centuries
The court hearing in the case of Narek Karapetyan and Aleksan Aleksanyan did not take placeThe court hearing in the case of Narek Karapetyan and Aleksan Aleksanyan did not take place
ASPU and RAU opened a joint Scientific and Methodological Laboratory of the Russian LanguageASPU and RAU opened a joint Scientific and Methodological Laboratory of the Russian Language
Taking the Oath in a New Way: Amendments to the Law “On the Structure and Activities of the Government” AdoptedTaking the Oath in a New Way: Amendments to the Law “On the Structure and Activities of the Government” Adopted
Larger communities of Vanadzor and Ararat will be established in ArmeniaLarger communities of Vanadzor and Ararat will be established in Armenia
Issues of expanding relations between Armenia and Germany discussed in YerevanIssues of expanding relations between Armenia and Germany discussed in Yerevan
Tensions flared again in the RA National AssemblyTensions flared again in the RA National Assembly
Azerbaijani expert to EU special representative: No one in Azerbaijan’s history has called this part of the country “Eastern Zangezur”Azerbaijani expert to EU special representative: No one in Azerbaijan’s history has called this part of the country “Eastern Zangezur”
Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly: Maintaining a Russian base in Armenia is quite expensiveDeputy Speaker of the National Assembly: Maintaining a Russian base in Armenia is quite expensive
Read more



Commented
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place
Political scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and strugglePolitical scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and struggle
Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.
Zakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itselfZakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itself
Putin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent characterPutin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent character
Putin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic UnionPutin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic Union
Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.
Aram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  ParliamentAram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  Parliament
Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs 
 "In Baku, we gave a worthy rebuff to the false claims regarding the  past and present of our people" – Former Artsakh Parliament Speaker  from Baku captivity 
NA Vice Speaker candidate  believes his wife`s salary as director of  HayPost is the lowest in the company`s historyNA Vice Speaker candidate  believes his wife`s salary as director of  HayPost is the lowest in the company`s history