Arminfo.info


 Tuesday, June 20 2023 16:31
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Russian expert voices Pashinyan`s motives for turning to second  Karabakh war history 

Russian expert voices Pashinyan`s motives for turning to second  Karabakh war history 

ArmInfo.Russian political scientist Sergei Markedonov voiced the motives of the Prime Minister  of the Republic of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan for turning to the history of the second Karabakh war.

The expert announced that the Prime Minister of Armenia is once again  bringing the topic of the results of the second Karabakh war to the  public spotlight.

"A politician is not a historian. It is unlikely that Pashinyan is  professionally engaged with the problems of source studies. Does he  have a different motivation? What is it? Is it accidental that his  "June theses" appeared here and now? And will there be political  consequences from their pronunciation," the political scientist  asked.

In this vein, he stated that it cannot be said that on June 20, 2023,  Nikol Pashinyan discovered something fundamentally new in the  empiricism of the second Karabakh war (and the process of peaceful  settlement of the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict as a whole).

"Russian President Vladimir Putin has repeatedly spoken about Russian  mediation, options for a ceasefire, while his viewing angle was much  larger. Robert Kocharyan's readiness for Baku's concessions and the  responsibility of the second president of Armenia for withdrawing the  unrecognized NKR from the peace process, his opponents have been  talking for years since 1999. There is no particular novelty in  Pashinyan's words today. The question arises: what is the point of  reopening these wounds now?", Markedonov continued.

According to the political scientist, Armenia faces the most  difficult challenges and prospects for making decisions in the  spectrum between unpleasant and terrible. Markedonov added that a  return to the status quo 1994-2020 is impossible, even the ardent  opponents of the prime minister understand this.

"There are no military resources and a critical mass of public  support. External players are also not eager to implement the  maximalist plans of Yerevan of the past years. Hence the  inevitability of unpopular decisions and the desire to find  consistent narratives that the Armenian society and politicians could  accept, even if in the bitter pills format. Hence the active  promotion of theses about the inevitability of concessions and  defeats," the Russian expert is convinced.

At the same time, Markedonov wonders if Pashinyan is engaged in  political presentism, shifting responsibility to his predecessors,  Russia?  "Yes, of course, he is a politician, not a scientist. He  wants to maintain his power in these specific conditions. It is hard  to deny that he is also guilty of creating them. But for the sake of  objectivity, we must admit other" fathers of defeat ". There is  always a problem with this, because usually "defeat is an orphan",  and "triumph has many parents"!

In conclusion, the political scientist expressed his conviction that  the Armenian society and the political class as a whole will have to  discuss complex systemic things more than once beyond the conflict  between Nikol Vovayevich and Robert Sedrakovich.

"With the understanding that it is not only a personal factor, dreams  and wishes determine the political agenda. And this conversation,  obviously, is not for one month or even one year," Markedonov summed  up.

It should be noted that RA Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan today gave  public testimony to the parliamentary Inquiry Committee for Studying  the Circumstances of the Hostilities Unleashed on September 27, 2020  (44-day war), . The parliamentary opposition stated that it did not  intend to participate in this "show". In his speech, the Prime  Minister of Armenia directly or indirectly tried to shift the  responsibility for the current situation to the previous authorities  in the person of the second President Robert Kocharyan, during whose  governance Artsakh was removed from the negotiating table. Moreover,  he repeated the already repeatedly voiced thesis, allegedly that it  was Robert Kocharyan who tried to surrender Meghri to Azerbaijan.  Accusations were also made against Armenia's ally, Russia, in the  context of the signing of a tripartite statement on a ceasefire in  the zone of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.  However, on none of the  voiced accusations, the Armenian prime minister presented convincing  evidence, everything was limited by his perception of the issue.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Ameriabank Raises USD 50 Million from OPEC Fund for International Development to boost SME Financing in ArmeniaAmeriabank Raises USD 50 Million from OPEC Fund for International Development to boost SME Financing in Armenia
CIS Secretary General: Stabilizing post-election situation in Armenia  appears likelyCIS Secretary General: Stabilizing post-election situation in Armenia  appears likely
Armenian court lifts travel restriction for Father Garegin Arsenyan,  abbot of Saint George Monastery in MughniArmenian court lifts travel restriction for Father Garegin Arsenyan,  abbot of Saint George Monastery in Mughni
Armenia reports increase in female drug addiction casesArmenia reports increase in female drug addiction cases
AraratBank Summarizes 2025 Results at the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders AraratBank Summarizes 2025 Results at the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders 
Proposed Kond district reconstruction model combines historical  preservation,economic development, and cultural vitalityProposed Kond district reconstruction model combines historical  preservation,economic development, and cultural vitality
Mane Tandilyan: Legitimacy concerns regarding Nikol Pashinyan to  escalate, creating new challenges for ArmeniaMane Tandilyan: Legitimacy concerns regarding Nikol Pashinyan to  escalate, creating new challenges for Armenia
In Armenia, 52.7% of registered drug trafficking cases are solved –  MIAIn Armenia, 52.7% of registered drug trafficking cases are solved –  MIA
Tbilisi to host Armenian Culture  Days in JulyTbilisi to host Armenian Culture  Days in July
Armenian Ex- FM: Government`s reliance on security structures creates  a serious legitimacy problem Armenian Ex- FM: Government`s reliance on security structures creates  a serious legitimacy problem 
Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan and Georgia are working on the creation of a unified long-term tariff model within the development of the Middle CorridorKazakhstan, Azerbaijan and Georgia are working on the creation of a unified long-term tariff model within the development of the Middle Corridor
Another charge to be brought against Vardan Ghukasyan, currently  under arrestAnother charge to be brought against Vardan Ghukasyan, currently  under arrest
Lawyer: Court of Cassation refuses to hear Prosecutor General`s  appeal regarding the detention of Aragatsotn Diocese clergyLawyer: Court of Cassation refuses to hear Prosecutor General`s  appeal regarding the detention of Aragatsotn Diocese clergy
RA vice-premier: With active participation of U.S., Armenia and South  Caucasus enter new era of peace and stabilityRA vice-premier: With active participation of U.S., Armenia and South  Caucasus enter new era of peace and stability
Armenia, UK discuss continued development of Armenia-UK military  cooperationArmenia, UK discuss continued development of Armenia-UK military  cooperation
European Union to continue its support to Armenia-Azerbaijan peace  process - Magdalena GronoEuropean Union to continue its support to Armenia-Azerbaijan peace  process - Magdalena Grono
Constitutional Court of Armenia begins hearing opposition forces`  applicationConstitutional Court of Armenia begins hearing opposition forces`  application
20th meeting of Council of Justice Ministers of CIS member states to  be held in Yerevan in November20th meeting of Council of Justice Ministers of CIS member states to  be held in Yerevan in November
Converse Bank and ADB expand access to MSME and sustainable finance in ArmeniaConverse Bank and ADB expand access to MSME and sustainable finance in Armenia
Expert:  Main task of containing Azerbaijan is in hands of Armenian  societyExpert:  Main task of containing Azerbaijan is in hands of Armenian  society
Politician: Coordinated opposition actions to neutralize government s  goals are vital for release of political prisonersPolitician: Coordinated opposition actions to neutralize government s  goals are vital for release of political prisoners
Meeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with Representatives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of UkraineMeeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with Representatives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine
Turkey s Special Representative for Normalization of Turkish-Armenian  Relations congratulates Ruben Rubinyan on his nomination for post of  RA NA SpeakerTurkey s Special Representative for Normalization of Turkish-Armenian  Relations congratulates Ruben Rubinyan on his nomination for post of  RA NA Speaker
Israel is preparing to officially recognize Armenian GenocideIsrael is preparing to officially recognize Armenian Genocide
Government seeks full control over citizens` phones in ArmeniaGovernment seeks full control over citizens` phones in Armenia
Catholicosate of Great House of Cilicia reports wounded and missing  Armenians in wake of earthquake in VenezuelaCatholicosate of Great House of Cilicia reports wounded and missing  Armenians in wake of earthquake in Venezuela
Armenia, USA sign Joint Statement on AI Opportunity Partnership at  Donald Trump U.S.  Institute of PeaceArmenia, USA sign Joint Statement on AI Opportunity Partnership at  Donald Trump U.S.  Institute of Peace
Pashinyan sent a congratulatory message to the Prime Minister of Slovenia.Pashinyan sent a congratulatory message to the Prime Minister of Slovenia.
The former mayor of Masis has been released from house arrest.The former mayor of Masis has been released from house arrest.
A member of the NS from the ruling party has put forward his candidacy for the post of deputy speaker of parliament.A member of the NS from the ruling party has put forward his candidacy for the post of deputy speaker of parliament.
Ruben Rubinyan: the trust of my fellow party members obliges me to a great deal.Ruben Rubinyan: the trust of my fellow party members obliges me to a great deal.
Pashinyan: As a result of a secret ballot, Ruben Rubinyan was elected as the candidate for the post of Speaker of the National Assembly.Pashinyan: As a result of a secret ballot, Ruben Rubinyan was elected as the candidate for the post of Speaker of the National Assembly.
The Prosecutor General’s Office has submitted a request to the Central Election Commission to strip the leader of the “Prosperous Armenia” party, Gagik Tsarukyan, of his immunity.The Prosecutor General’s Office has submitted a request to the Central Election Commission to strip the leader of the “Prosperous Armenia” party, Gagik Tsarukyan, of his immunity.
Head of the Ministry of Justice: the results of the parliamentary elections held in Armenia confirmed the country`s commitment to democratic values and constitutional processes.Head of the Ministry of Justice: the results of the parliamentary elections held in Armenia confirmed the country`s commitment to democratic values and constitutional processes.
A rally will be held on June 26 outside the building of the Constitutional Court of Armenia in defense of the votes of Armenian citizens.A rally will be held on June 26 outside the building of the Constitutional Court of Armenia in defense of the votes of Armenian citizens.
The second session of consultations on security and defense between Armenia and the EU took place in Brussels.The second session of consultations on security and defense between Armenia and the EU took place in Brussels.
Lawyer: we consider the decision of the Criminal Appeals Court to be bold.Lawyer: we consider the decision of the Criminal Appeals Court to be bold.
A Museum of Armenian Carpet Art will open in Garni.A Museum of Armenian Carpet Art will open in Garni.
Iranian cinematographer Mahmoud Kalari will head the jury of the regional competition at the Iranian cinematographer Mahmoud Kalari will head the jury of the regional competition at the "Golden Apricot" film festival.
An Armenian court changed the preventive measure to house arrest for the legendary Artsakh intelligence officer, a member of An Armenian court changed the preventive measure to house arrest for the legendary Artsakh intelligence officer, a member of "Strong Armenia."
National Assembly deputy: while the authorities negotiate to find new markets, Armenian businessmen are suffering huge losses.National Assembly deputy: while the authorities negotiate to find new markets, Armenian businessmen are suffering huge losses.
An appellate court lifted the house arrest of the head of the Shirak Diocese.An appellate court lifted the house arrest of the head of the Shirak Diocese.
Armenia’s Largest QR Payment Systems to Collaborate: ArcaQR – IdramNetArmenia’s Largest QR Payment Systems to Collaborate: ArcaQR – IdramNet
A closing ceremony for the military exercises A closing ceremony for the military exercises "Eagle‑Partner‑2026" was held at the "Zar" training center.
Vardevanyan: During the election processes in Armenia, more than 200 people were charged.Vardevanyan: During the election processes in Armenia, more than 200 people were charged.
It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier 
Pashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alonePashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alone
JICA delegation discussed prospects for cooperation in Lake Sevan  protection with Armenian sideJICA delegation discussed prospects for cooperation in Lake Sevan  protection with Armenian side
Civil Contract party to hold secret ballot today to elect NA speakerCivil Contract party to hold secret ballot today to elect NA speaker
Armenian law enforcers conducting search at apartment of Gyumri  Council of Elders member Karen SimonyanArmenian law enforcers conducting search at apartment of Gyumri  Council of Elders member Karen Simonyan
Second stage of renovation work gets underway at Tsitsernakaberd  Memorial ComplexSecond stage of renovation work gets underway at Tsitsernakaberd  Memorial Complex
Artsakh`s Cultural Ombudsman criticizes Turkmenistan`s President for  visiting occupied NKRArtsakh`s Cultural Ombudsman criticizes Turkmenistan`s President for  visiting occupied NKR
Two members of ARF youth movement detainedTwo members of ARF youth movement detained
Yerevan`s hopes for maintaining its previous relations with Moscow  while continuing its current policies empty - Russian MPYerevan`s hopes for maintaining its previous relations with Moscow  while continuing its current policies empty - Russian MP
Narek Karapetyan calls on Strong Armenia supporters to gather at  Tashir Arena on June 26 and discuss their next steps after the  electionsNarek Karapetyan calls on Strong Armenia supporters to gather at  Tashir Arena on June 26 and discuss their next steps after the  elections
Candidate for RA NA from Strong Armenia party reported continued  political persecution against members of his familyCandidate for RA NA from Strong Armenia party reported continued  political persecution against members of his family
Criminal case against son-in-law of PAP leader sent to courtCriminal case against son-in-law of PAP leader sent to court
Azerbaijan using prisoners and hostages to send message to entire  displaced population - ANC-UKAzerbaijan using prisoners and hostages to send message to entire  displaced population - ANC-UK
Silaev: Armenia s participation in the conference on Ukraine s reconstruction is a deliberate challenge to Moscow aimed at winning Brussels` approval.Silaev: Armenia s participation in the conference on Ukraine s reconstruction is a deliberate challenge to Moscow aimed at winning Brussels` approval.
Zatulin: Pashinyan seeks to prove his pro‑Western credentials by taking part in the forum on Ukraine.Zatulin: Pashinyan seeks to prove his pro‑Western credentials by taking part in the forum on Ukraine.
Read more



Commented
It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier 
Pashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alonePashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alone
Moscow sees situation with Armenia as attempt to attack  Russia-involving integration associations - Russian presidential aidMoscow sees situation with Armenia as attempt to attack  Russia-involving integration associations - Russian presidential aid
Zakharova: Armenia views relations with Russia as tool for  financially securing reorientation toward EUZakharova: Armenia views relations with Russia as tool for  financially securing reorientation toward EU
The Armenian Minister of Justice and the EU Ambassador discussed visa liberalization issues for Yerevan.The Armenian Minister of Justice and the EU Ambassador discussed visa liberalization issues for Yerevan.
Azerbaijan`s aggressive plans against Armenia became possible in wake  of Pashinyan`s decisions on Artsakh - expert Azerbaijan`s aggressive plans against Armenia became possible in wake  of Pashinyan`s decisions on Artsakh - expert 
Zakharova: Russia sent a note of protest to Armenia over the act of  vandalism at the Zakharova: Russia sent a note of protest to Armenia over the act of  vandalism at the "Mother Armenia" memorial in Gyumri
Samvel Karapetyan proposes creating a post-election opposition coalitionSamvel Karapetyan proposes creating a post-election opposition coalition
Artsakh`s Cultural Heritage Ombudsman called on Moscow to respond to  destruction of WWII monuments by Azerbaijan in occupied NKRArtsakh`s Cultural Heritage Ombudsman called on Moscow to respond to  destruction of WWII monuments by Azerbaijan in occupied NKR
Prosecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert KocharyanProsecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert Kocharyan
Dutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agendaDutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agenda
 Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power
RA Security Council Sec, Assistant to President of Azerbaijan hold  negotiations in Dilijan RA Security Council Sec, Assistant to President of Azerbaijan hold  negotiations in Dilijan 
CEC Neutralizes PAP: Three Political Forces to Enter Armenian Parliament Following Election VoteCEC Neutralizes PAP: Three Political Forces to Enter Armenian Parliament Following Election Vote
Elections in Armenia were accompanied by unprecedented pressure on  opposition, RF MFA spokesperson claims Elections in Armenia were accompanied by unprecedented pressure on  opposition, RF MFA spokesperson claims