Monday, May 22 2023 23:01
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Political scientist: In the near future, three numbers will become  the subject of complex dramatic reflections in Armenian national  narratives

Political scientist: In the near future, three numbers will become  the subject of complex dramatic reflections in Armenian national  narratives

ArmInfo.In the near future, three numbers (one eight and two sixes) will become the subject of  complex dramatic reflections in Armenian national narratives. According to Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, Nagorno-Karabakh is included in the area of territorially integral Azerbaijan - 86.6 thousand square km. This is how the Russian political scientist Sergei Markedonov commented on the statements of the Prime Minister  of the Republic of Armenia at a press conference.

"Now the easiest thing would be to accuse this politician of national  betrayal (which, in fact, is happening in real time "here and now"),  as well as start building conspiracy theories about who and when  started the process of "surrendering Artsakh". It is much more  difficult to try to present a systematic analysis of the  "de-Karabakhization" of post-Soviet Armenia. Within the framework of  one comment, this, of course, is impossible. But it is possible and  necessary to outline the key points," the expert noted.  At the same  time, he stated that Pashinyan did not indicate any sensation on the  penultimate Monday of the outgoing spring. Markedonov recalled that  the thesis on mutual recognition of the territorial integrity of  Armenia and Azerbaijan within the borders of the Armenian and  Azerbaijani SSR (which implies Baku's sovereignty over the Karabakh  land) has been publicly voiced by both the prime minister and his  associates for at least a year.

"However, one didn't have to be Cassandra to predict this trend after  the second Karabakh war lost by Armenia. November 2020 became the  breaking point of the former status quo. And Yerevan was not (and is  not) the beneficiary of the new regional order.

You can blame Russia as much as you want for the lack of assistance  to its ally (and such criticism is not unfounded, to be honest), but  no one else has unambiguously taken the side of Armenia. Tweets and  public actions do not count, as well as exotic initiatives of  congressmen on the "recognition of democratic Artsakh". This means  that Pashinyan (and any other name in his place) does not have  external support for the implementation of the "Armenian  reconquista". We are just stating the facts," the Russian political  scientist stressed.

The expert also pointed to the fact that inside Armenia the idea of  "surrendering Artsakh" is unpopular, as evidenced by all opinion  polls.

"However, the sociology of numbers cannot accurately convey the gap  between the declaration "Karabakh is ours" and the readiness to  defend it at the risk of life. In 2020-2022 there were several waves  of protests.  However, they did not become massive, and  Nagorno-Karabakh leaders (Vazgen Manukyan and Robert Kocharyan) who  formed the opposition front, did not wake up Armenia, as it was in  1988-1989. The people in the mass are tired of the conflict. Should  they be scolded for this? And who has the right to do this?  People  sometimes get tired of wars so that they are ready for a "obscene  peace". There are plenty of examples of this. The same way,  the  Serbs and Montenegrins demonstrated their "humility" recently? And  Pashinyan could just be a kind of second edition of Duvalier, but he  held early elections and won them.  "With the result that allowed him  to form a homogeneous government. Let's say there were violations and  administrative resources. But where are the uprisings and public  discontent? The army front did not even pull on an operetta coup.  Pashinyan, of course, is not Bulgakov's Colonel Turbin. But he could  exclaim like that hero: "The people are not with us, gentlemen!"  "Although in his election program-2021 all the points about  supporting the self-determination of Nagorno-Karabakh were present.  But, as we have already said, there is a considerable distance  between the declaration and implementation," he said.

In this regard, he stated that within Armenia there is nothing  comparable to the rise of 1988-1989 on the wave of "miatsum", however  fatigue from the Karabakh burden is obvious. The political scientist  added that it may be pleasant or nauseating, but the facts are what  they are. Externally, Yerevan also does not have strong support for  the "reconquista".

"Will Moscow's restraint be the beginning of the decline of the  Russian presence in the Caucasus? Let's not rush to answer. The loss  of Kars, Ardagan or Artvin did not lead to the withdrawal of Soviet  Russia (and then the USSR) from the Caucasus region. But let's be  honest, national traumas and phobias were formed not excluded, and  the Karabakh story, it is possible, can become something similar.  Note that all decisions regarding Nagorno-Karabakh are difficult.  They will not and simply cannot be unambiguous, just as the decisions  on Strasbourg, Burgenland, Lvov and Vilna were not one-dimensional  and unambiguous " he concluded.

READ ALL COMMENTS

Юрий
Люди, бывает, устают от войн так, что готовы и на похабный мир. Да, но история учит, что после каждого похабного мира война возобновляется. Этого не понимают в Азербайджане, России, да и в самой Армении понимают не все. Но будущим поколениям придется объяснять, кто сдал Арцах и обрек его на гибель. Ведь на этот раз не турок с ятаганом пришел, как было в истории с Карсом, и не большевики сговорились с турками, а сами власти Армении все сдали. Будущим поколениям это не понравится, и, возможно, передышка, которую якобы так хочет уставший народ, скоро закончится.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
MFA: Relations between Armenia and Estonia are developing on the basis of strong political commitmentMFA: Relations between Armenia and Estonia are developing on the basis of strong political commitment
The Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia announced the initiation of criminal proceedings in connection with the brawl in parliament.The Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia announced the initiation of criminal proceedings in connection with the brawl in parliament.
Grono: For the European Union, the importance of the South Caucasus is undeniableGrono: For the European Union, the importance of the South Caucasus is undeniable
The Russian Ambassador honored the memory of Russian pilots killed by the enemy on the day the 44-day war around Artsakh ended.The Russian Ambassador honored the memory of Russian pilots killed by the enemy on the day the 44-day war around Artsakh ended.
Armenia and India have coordinated their scientific and educational cooperation agenda.Armenia and India have coordinated their scientific and educational cooperation agenda.
ANC Deputy Chairman: Under the guise of the idea of creating a Fourth Republic, an attempt is being made to abandon the principle of historical continuityANC Deputy Chairman: Under the guise of the idea of creating a Fourth Republic, an attempt is being made to abandon the principle of historical continuity
"Strong Armenia": Agreeing to a constitutional referendum at Baku`s request is a retreat from the principles of independence
Armenia and Iran have synchronized their watches on the political and economic cooperation agendaArmenia and Iran have synchronized their watches on the political and economic cooperation agenda
Pashinyan and the Iranian Vice President exchanged views on the process of unblocking regional transport routes and the opportunities this createsPashinyan and the Iranian Vice President exchanged views on the process of unblocking regional transport routes and the opportunities this creates
Amid public discontent, Armenian authorities abandoned the idea of abolishing funeral benefitsAmid public discontent, Armenian authorities abandoned the idea of abolishing funeral benefits
On the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day war in 2020, the Artsakh Public Council presented its demands to the Armenian government and the Russian EmbassyOn the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day war in 2020, the Artsakh Public Council presented its demands to the Armenian government and the Russian Embassy
Mane Tandilyan: Under Pashinyan`s rule, Armenian prisoners of war have no chance of returningMane Tandilyan: Under Pashinyan`s rule, Armenian prisoners of war have no chance of returning
"Strong Armenia": Aliyev demonstratively "opened" the hospital built by Samvel Karapetyan in Stepanakert
Pashinyan: We are not pretending to fight corruption, we are truly fighting corruptionPashinyan: We are not pretending to fight corruption, we are truly fighting corruption
The Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs honored the memory of police officers who died defending their homeland in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zoneThe Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs honored the memory of police officers who died defending their homeland in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone
Switzerland announced the launch of a new project to support the development of local government in ArmeniaSwitzerland announced the launch of a new project to support the development of local government in Armenia
“Strong Armenia”: November 9 should become a day not only of remembrance, but also of political and state responsibility“Strong Armenia”: November 9 should become a day not only of remembrance, but also of political and state responsibility
The Armenian Parliament announces a competition for the nomination of candidates for the position of member of the European Committee for the Prevention of TortureThe Armenian Parliament announces a competition for the nomination of candidates for the position of member of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture
NDP: November 9 is not just a day of remembrance, but another frontier in the struggleNDP: November 9 is not just a day of remembrance, but another frontier in the struggle
Diplomat: TRIPP opens commercial opportunities for American companies and advances US strategic interests in the South CaucasusDiplomat: TRIPP opens commercial opportunities for American companies and advances US strategic interests in the South Caucasus
The state program for providing housing to Karabakh residents is in the active phase of its implementation.The state program for providing housing to Karabakh residents is in the active phase of its implementation.
Shoigu: The situation in the South Caucasus is showing a tendency to improveShoigu: The situation in the South Caucasus is showing a tendency to improve
Armenia`s referendum on joining the European Union must precede the filing of a membership applicationArmenia`s referendum on joining the European Union must precede the filing of a membership application
On the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day enemy aggression against Artsakh, citizens visit On the 6th anniversary of the end of the 44-day enemy aggression against Artsakh, citizens visit "Yerablur"
President of Turkmenistan Participates in the Aqaba Process SummitPresident of Turkmenistan Participates in the Aqaba Process Summit
Russian Ambassador: The concession agreement for Armenian railways was drawn up on unprecedentedly favorable terms for ArmeniaRussian Ambassador: The concession agreement for Armenian railways was drawn up on unprecedentedly favorable terms for Armenia
Russian Ambassador: The Russian side is ready to continue military-technical cooperation with ArmeniaRussian Ambassador: The Russian side is ready to continue military-technical cooperation with Armenia
Ombudsman: The Office of the Human Rights Defender determines its own areas of activityOmbudsman: The Office of the Human Rights Defender determines its own areas of activity
Russian Ambassador: The process of reformulating Armenia`s strategic guidelines cannot but raise the question of finding new balancesRussian Ambassador: The process of reformulating Armenia`s strategic guidelines cannot but raise the question of finding new balances
The Russian Foreign Ministry: Yerevan is once again attempting to shift responsibility for its decisions to CSTO countries.The Russian Foreign Ministry: Yerevan is once again attempting to shift responsibility for its decisions to CSTO countries.
Zakharova responded to Alen Simonyan`s attempts to shift responsibility for the developments in the Karabakh conflict zone to Russia.Zakharova responded to Alen Simonyan`s attempts to shift responsibility for the developments in the Karabakh conflict zone to Russia.
There are closed roads in Armenia, and the Upper Lars checkpoint is also closed.There are closed roads in Armenia, and the Upper Lars checkpoint is also closed.
Precipitation and a sharp cold snap are expected in Armenia on November 9.Precipitation and a sharp cold snap are expected in Armenia on November 9.
The Armenian Foreign Minister left for a working visit to Estonia.The Armenian Foreign Minister left for a working visit to Estonia.
Alen Simonyan has embarked on a search for dark spots in Armenian history in an attempt to justify the current authorities` inability to reach an agreement with the enemyAlen Simonyan has embarked on a search for dark spots in Armenian history in an attempt to justify the current authorities` inability to reach an agreement with the enemy
Security Council Secretary: Armenia will never oppose Iran in implementing TRIPPSecurity Council Secretary: Armenia will never oppose Iran in implementing TRIPP
The editor-in-chief of Oragir.News was beaten in Yerevan after a road accidentThe editor-in-chief of Oragir.News was beaten in Yerevan after a road accident
Pashinyan hopes that Armenia will have visa-free travel to the EU by 2029Pashinyan hopes that Armenia will have visa-free travel to the EU by 2029
The Hay Dat party called on UN Security Council members to reject Feridun Sinirlioglu`s candidacy for the post of UN Secretary-General.The Hay Dat party called on UN Security Council members to reject Feridun Sinirlioglu`s candidacy for the post of UN Secretary-General.
The Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs reported the prevention of a contract killing.The Armenian Ministry of Internal Affairs reported the prevention of a contract killing.
State Minister: Artsakh authorities welcome the initiative of Armenian political forces to create a national unionState Minister: Artsakh authorities welcome the initiative of Armenian political forces to create a national union
The 2nd Interuniversity Debate Championship kicked off in Yerevan.The 2nd Interuniversity Debate Championship kicked off in Yerevan.
Yerevan, Baku, and Washington announced the creation of technical planning groups to advance TRIPP.Yerevan, Baku, and Washington announced the creation of technical planning groups to advance TRIPP.
India confirmed the delivery of 1,000 Pinaka guided missiles to Armenia.India confirmed the delivery of 1,000 Pinaka guided missiles to Armenia.
Armenia and Georgia have resumed work on state border delimitation commissions.Armenia and Georgia have resumed work on state border delimitation commissions.
Armenia and the United States discussed the implementation of international experience in emergency management.Armenia and the United States discussed the implementation of international experience in emergency management.
Kazinyan: If the new Constitution is not a demand of Baku, why can`t the authorities make peace before amendments are made to it?Kazinyan: If the new Constitution is not a demand of Baku, why can`t the authorities make peace before amendments are made to it?
The relevant ministries of Armenia and Cyprus signed a memorandum of understanding on cooperation in the fields of education, sports, and youth.The relevant ministries of Armenia and Cyprus signed a memorandum of understanding on cooperation in the fields of education, sports, and youth.
The head of the Cadastre Committee of Armenia avoided answering the question of whether the territory of the village of Tigranashen is part of the territory of the Armenian state.The head of the Cadastre Committee of Armenia avoided answering the question of whether the territory of the village of Tigranashen is part of the territory of the Armenian state.
Ruben Vardanyan`s wife stated her readiness to travel to Baku as soon as access to Armenian prisoners and security conditions are agreed upon.Ruben Vardanyan`s wife stated her readiness to travel to Baku as soon as access to Armenian prisoners and security conditions are agreed upon.
MPG: More than 50% of respondents supported holding early parliamentary elections in ArmeniaMPG: More than 50% of respondents supported holding early parliamentary elections in Armenia
Poll: Nearly half of respondents in Armenia have a negative view of Pashinyan`s public assessments of the churchPoll: Nearly half of respondents in Armenia have a negative view of Pashinyan`s public assessments of the church
Representatives of Armenian football fan movements have proposed Gevorg Ghazaryan as a candidate for the post of FFA President.Representatives of Armenian football fan movements have proposed Gevorg Ghazaryan as a candidate for the post of FFA President.
Kremlin: Yerevan de facto does not participate in the CSTOKremlin: Yerevan de facto does not participate in the CSTO
Representatives of Mother Armenia spoke to the Canadian Embassy`s advisor about the country`s domestic political situationRepresentatives of Mother Armenia spoke to the Canadian Embassy`s advisor about the country`s domestic political situation
Pashinyan at the Inter-Armenian Summit: Today, Armenia is rethinking its relations with the DiasporaPashinyan at the Inter-Armenian Summit: Today, Armenia is rethinking its relations with the Diaspora
MPG Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assessed the launch of AmulsarMPG Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assessed the launch of Amulsar
Poll: Most respondents in Armenia did not support the authorities` response to the incident with the Azerbaijani in Shaki, but supported the woman`s behaviorPoll: Most respondents in Armenia did not support the authorities` response to the incident with the Azerbaijani in Shaki, but supported the woman`s behavior
The overwhelming majority of respondents in Armenia expressed concern about non-combat deaths in the armyThe overwhelming majority of respondents in Armenia expressed concern about non-combat deaths in the army
Vladimir Vardanyan has been elected Chairman of the Constitutional Court of ArmeniaVladimir Vardanyan has been elected Chairman of the Constitutional Court of Armenia
Read more



Commented
Drmeyan: The ECHR rejected Azerbaijan`s appeal in the case of Artsakh Defense Army Major Hayk ToroyanDrmeyan: The ECHR rejected Azerbaijan`s appeal in the case of Artsakh Defense Army Major Hayk Toroyan
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.
The participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassiesThe participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassies
Expert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and EastExpert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and East
The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.
The Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behaviorThe Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behavior
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide