Arminfo.info


 Friday, February 3 2023 20:46
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Opinion: Turkey`s upcoming elections are Recep Tayyip Erdogan`s last  decisive political battle 

Opinion: Turkey`s upcoming elections are Recep Tayyip Erdogan`s last  decisive political battle 

ArmInfo. The upcoming elections in Turkey are the last decisive political battle for Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Dean of the Faculty of Oriental Studies at Yerevan  State University, Turkologist Ruben Melkonyan, shares a similar  opinion.

Thus, giving an assessment of the forthcoming parliamentary and  presidential elections in Turkey this year, the expert stated that  presumably on May 14 parliamentary and presidential elections are  expected in Turkey.

In this vein, he drew attention to the fact that a number of opinions  are circulating in the political and expert field about the results,  significance and consequences of the relevant elections. At the same  time, Melkonyan analyzed the upcoming electoral processes in Turkey  from the point of view of political symbolism, presenting his  Turkological observations.

"This is the last and decisive political battle for Turkish President  Erdogan, for victory, in which he is ready to take any step: from an  overdose of populism and the use of administrative resources to  violations, pressures and the manifestation of sentimental emotions.  These elections will be a symbolic and practical confirmation of the  political line and style of Erdogan, who has been in politics since  the 1990s and has ruled Turkey since 2002," the Turkologist is  convinced.

The expert believes that the Kemal Turkish Republic established in  1923 has every chance to turn into the Erdogan Turkish Republic on  its 100th anniversary. According to him, and if in 1923 it chose the  model of a secular state and the ideology of secularism, then in 2023  this is a classic example of a state with an ideology of  conservatism, rich in religious / Islamic elements.

"Erdogan has prepared for the elections in political, methodological  and financial terms. Turkey, which is in financial and economic  problems, has received quite a lot of money from some Arab countries  and now, shortly before the elections, they are being used to  increase pensions, alleviate the credit burden of citizens and ensure  other similar manifestations of "financial populism"," Melkonyan  said.

At the same time, he stressed that over the years Erdogan has  mastered the synthesis of rhetoric and populism, and in fact today he  has no competitor in the political field of Turkey, who can use  political, religious, street, literary and artistic speech and  provided it possibilities.

"Despite his age and state of health, Erdogan continues to be a  figure whose speech has a natural "political fire", in contrast to  the opposition, who either do not have this fire, or it is artificial  or half-extinguished.  Erdogan skillfully plays on various emotions  of Turkish society, among of which, of course, the religious one is  the most noticeable. However, sentimentalism and emotionalism is also  manifested in these elections, the most striking example of which is  the statement that the President of Turkey asks the people to vote  for him for the last time," the Turkologist added.

Referring to the date chosen for the upcoming elections, Melkonyan  recalled that in 1950, the opposition and the semi-hidden supporter  of the rise of Islam in Turkey, the Democratic Party, won the  multi-party parliamentary elections held on May 14. In other words,  he continued, on May 14, 1950, political Islam defeated secularism or  Kemalism for the first time, and Adnan Menderes, whom the current  President Erdogan considers one of his political teachers, became the  Prime Minister of Turkey.

"Menderes has a sad and tragic end. In 1960, after a military coup in  Turkey, he was arrested and some time later hanged. Menderes is  considered the "martyr of political Islam" of the Republic of Turkey,  as well as the first politician who defeated the secular ideology of  Ataturk. In addition, his image is shrouded in a veil of mythology  and an "innocent political martyr", which after his death, and  especially in today's Turkey, dominates the social-political  perception and is one of the important factors giving rise to the  said emotionality," the Turkologist said.

In his opinion, the political heir and successor of Menderes,  Erdogan, wants to symbolically organize elections on May 14, seeking  to ensure the final victory of the Islamic political line over the  Kemalist one, secular Turkey and to consolidate Erdogan's Turkey  instead of Ataturk's Turkey. At the same time, the Turkologist  believes that Erdogan will thus try to enlist the votes of those who  supported the political line of Menderes. "Roughly speaking, the  image of Menderes will also work for Erdogan in these elections," the  expert added.

Regarding Erdogan's rivals, Melkonyan stated that at the moment an  opposition format has developed in Turkey, which consists of 6  opposition parties that are trying to nominate a single candidate.

"The members of Republican People's Party are considered to be the  main ones. Party's leader is Kemal K?l?cdaroglu and he leader of the  youth wing is the current Mayor of Istanbul, Ekrem Imamoglu. The  Mayor of Istanbul is a really interesting political figure, a good  speaker, well versed in the tools of populism, is popular among the  inhabitants of Istanbul. However, naturally, lacking the political  experience to compete with the grand master of Turkey's political  system, Erdogan, as well as the administrative resources accumulated  in his hands, Imamoglu, could pose a real threat, or at least cause  extreme tension for the ruling team in the elections.

In my opinion, this issue can have two solutions: either Imamoglu  does not run and gives way to the chairman of the party,  K?l?cdaroglu, and prepares for the next elections, or he runs and  immediately faces specific political persecution. And another  potential opposition presidential candidate, Kemal K?l?cdaroglu, is  inferior to Erdogan in a number of aspects and is an easier opponent  for him, but, despite this, he can collect the votes of the  opposition and especially the stable electorate of Kemal, which will  not reach a critical level, " the expert believes.

Touching on who the West will support, Melkonyan noted the importance  of taking into account two important circumstances that cannot be  ignored.

"Firstly, today's Turkey is significantly different from the Turkey  of the 20th century, where the influence and desire of the West could  be decisive. And secondly, the factor known as Western support  already sounds very old-fashioned in the case of today's Turkey,  which has reached a serious level self-sufficiency in many political  and geopolitical issues. Therefore, the visits of Turkish opposition  to Western countries and their veil of secrecy are manifestations of  eternal nostalgia for the past , now non-existent political  situation," the Turkologist believes.

According to him, Erdogan focuses and puts emphasis on symbols and  symbolic dates not only on current political issues, but also, so to  speak, on his political heritage.

"And Armenia? This question should be answered very succinctly: the  policy of the Turkish state towards the state of Armenia and the  Armenians is built and based on hostile, negative ideas, with  practical steps and policies resulting from this. Therefore,  regardless of who is the president Turkey and the ruling authorities  cannot expect any serious and positive breakthrough in relation to  Armenia, everything else is delusion wrapped in ignorance and  self-deception," Melkonyan is convinced.

In this vein, he recalled that none of the Turkish presidents over  the past 30 years has agreed to open the borders with Armenia.  "During this entire period, the Armenian-Turkish border did not open,  Armenian- Turkish relations were not regulated, Turkey's support for  Azerbaijan did not decrease, but increased, Turkey's struggle against  the international recognition of the Armenian Genocide did not stop.  The only difference in the approaches of the Turkish presidents to  Armenia are wild fluctuations the level of aggressiveness of  rhetoric, which never had and have no any connection with the current  policy," the expert summed up.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
"Mother Armenia" board member detained for two months
IDBank warns of scam calls impersonating pension fundsIDBank warns of scam calls impersonating pension funds
Narek Karapetyan: Refusing mandates would lead to authoritarianismNarek Karapetyan: Refusing mandates would lead to authoritarianism
Meeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with U.S. SenatorMeeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with U.S. Senator
Samvel Karapetyan: We are consistently implementing our secret plan  to remove Pashinyan from powerSamvel Karapetyan: We are consistently implementing our secret plan  to remove Pashinyan from power
RA MFA: Armenia ready to continue contributing to initiatives aimed  at resolving humanitarian issues in LebanonRA MFA: Armenia ready to continue contributing to initiatives aimed  at resolving humanitarian issues in Lebanon
Council of Europe: Armenia has yet to make asset recovery a key  policy goal despite significant effortsCouncil of Europe: Armenia has yet to make asset recovery a key  policy goal despite significant efforts
ARF: Parliamentary elections in Armenia will remain in our history as  elections held under unprecedented conditions of state terrorARF: Parliamentary elections in Armenia will remain in our history as  elections held under unprecedented conditions of state terror
Samvel Karapetyan accuses OSCE of supporting Government`s stance  against the churchSamvel Karapetyan accuses OSCE of supporting Government`s stance  against the church
Pashinyan pledges protection for Araratcement employees Pashinyan pledges protection for Araratcement employees 
Armenia, Greece discuss opportunities to strengthen economic  relationsArmenia, Greece discuss opportunities to strengthen economic  relations
Armenia`s Consul General in Batumi meets head of Georgia`s  Constitutional Court Armenia`s Consul General in Batumi meets head of Georgia`s  Constitutional Court 
Minister of High-Tech Industry Mkhitar Hayrapetyan to exit CabinetMinister of High-Tech Industry Mkhitar Hayrapetyan to exit Cabinet
Prime Minister: Accepting Prime Minister: Accepting "control equals ownership" means abandoning  occupied territories near Jermuk
Large-scale tax evasion revealed at property owned by Gagik Tsarukyan Large-scale tax evasion revealed at property owned by Gagik Tsarukyan 
Former Artsakh Parliament Speaker issues another message from Baku  prisonFormer Artsakh Parliament Speaker issues another message from Baku  prison
Prosecutor`s Office seeks return of protected natural area held by  former Minister of EnvironmentProsecutor`s Office seeks return of protected natural area held by  former Minister of Environment
Investigative Committee  petitions court to arrest  Aregnaz ManukyanInvestigative Committee  petitions court to arrest  Aregnaz Manukyan
 Another earthquake hits Armenia Another earthquake hits Armenia
A little corner of France in Hrazdan, with the partnership of Converse SMEA little corner of France in Hrazdan, with the partnership of Converse SME
Nikol Pashinyan goes on 20-day vacationNikol Pashinyan goes on 20-day vacation
Prime Minister Pashinyan threatens dismissals over construction  violations in public infrastructurePrime Minister Pashinyan threatens dismissals over construction  violations in public infrastructure
 RA premier forms group to review proper organization of summer  vacations for children from vulnerable families RA premier forms group to review proper organization of summer  vacations for children from vulnerable families
 Law enforcers acted within their authority - RA premier  Law enforcers acted within their authority - RA premier 
Sports infrastructure of Yerevan`s Hrazdan stadium to be renovatedSports infrastructure of Yerevan`s Hrazdan stadium to be renovated
Ararat Cement plant employees holding a protest following plant`s  shutdownArarat Cement plant employees holding a protest following plant`s  shutdown
 Strong Armenia: Bloc members not elected to parliament to be involved  in party-building efforts Strong Armenia: Bloc members not elected to parliament to be involved  in party-building efforts
Armenia, Russia reach a number of agreementsArmenia, Russia reach a number of agreements
RA premier congratulates president of Argentina on Independence Day RA premier congratulates president of Argentina on Independence Day 
Yerevan to host 3rd International Congress of Armenian StudiesYerevan to host 3rd International Congress of Armenian Studies
Housing built with RA government`s financial assistance cannot be  seizedHousing built with RA government`s financial assistance cannot be  seized
 Smokers in Armenia who quit to be eligible for state bonus Smokers in Armenia who quit to be eligible for state bonus
 Kyiv Bridge to be reopened for traffic ahead of schedule Kyiv Bridge to be reopened for traffic ahead of schedule
 My conscience is clear - Gagik Tsarukyan My conscience is clear - Gagik Tsarukyan
Wolf attacks people in Armenia`s SyunikWolf attacks people in Armenia`s Syunik
 Azerbaijan completes its part of work to finalize peace agreement  with Armenia - Azerbaijani FM Azerbaijan completes its part of work to finalize peace agreement  with Armenia - Azerbaijani FM
Iranian president calls for comprehensive strengthening of relations  with ArmeniaIranian president calls for comprehensive strengthening of relations  with Armenia
RA Deputy FM confirmsYerevan`s readiness to assist Lebanon in  overcoming humanitarian crisisRA Deputy FM confirmsYerevan`s readiness to assist Lebanon in  overcoming humanitarian crisis
 RF MFA critical of appointment of Artsrun Hovhannisyan as head of RA  National Defense Research University RF MFA critical of appointment of Artsrun Hovhannisyan as head of RA  National Defense Research University
Law-enforcers raid Mother Armenia party member Aregnaz Manukyan`s  homeLaw-enforcers raid Mother Armenia party member Aregnaz Manukyan`s  home
Pashinyan: Recent elections have revealed new challengesPashinyan: Recent elections have revealed new challenges
The Global Fame of Akhal-Teke Horses Continues to GrowThe Global Fame of Akhal-Teke Horses Continues to Grow
CEC returns petitions for criminal prosecution and arrest of several  parliamentary candidates to the Prosecutor General`s OfficeCEC returns petitions for criminal prosecution and arrest of several  parliamentary candidates to the Prosecutor General`s Office
EU  discusses  with Armenia and Azerbaijan the best way to support  regional connectivity – GronoEU  discusses  with Armenia and Azerbaijan the best way to support  regional connectivity – Grono
Human rights activist Ruben Melikyan  dismissed from YSUHuman rights activist Ruben Melikyan  dismissed from YSU
Animal rights activist sounds alarm: Pets from Tsarukyan`s private  zoo risk starvation due to law enforcement actionsAnimal rights activist sounds alarm: Pets from Tsarukyan`s private  zoo risk starvation due to law enforcement actions
Armenian MP at OSCE PA: Ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh   revealed the inadequacy of collective responseArmenian MP at OSCE PA: Ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh   revealed the inadequacy of collective response
France, Canada and Germany unveil their programs for France, Canada and Germany unveil their programs for "Golden Apricot"  Film Festival
Veronika Zonabend: This is a matter of a fundamental human right — to  know what is happening to those we love and be able to send them  words of supportVeronika Zonabend: This is a matter of a fundamental human right — to  know what is happening to those we love and be able to send them  words of support
Idram is the general partner of the Idram is the general partner of the "Towards Conscious Parenting 2026" annual conference 
Armenia faces systemic issues regarding the use of physical force,  Ombudsperson comments on Tsarukyan`s detention Armenia faces systemic issues regarding the use of physical force,  Ombudsperson comments on Tsarukyan`s detention 
 OSCE Secretary General promises assistance to  Armenian authorities  in removing  Catholicos of All Armenians OSCE Secretary General promises assistance to  Armenian authorities  in removing  Catholicos of All Armenians
Iranian ambassador comments on situation surrounding PAP leaderIranian ambassador comments on situation surrounding PAP leader
 Sev Ohanyan Guest of Honor at Golden Apricot Film Festival Sev Ohanyan Guest of Honor at Golden Apricot Film Festival
RA Prosecutor General`s Office demanding auction for real estate  owned by late General Manvel Grigoryan`s family to be invalidatedRA Prosecutor General`s Office demanding auction for real estate  owned by late General Manvel Grigoryan`s family to be invalidated
EU delivers two remotely operated mine-clearing vehicles to ArmeniaEU delivers two remotely operated mine-clearing vehicles to Armenia
Julfalakyan: What Armenian authorities did to Gagik Tsarukyan  disgustingJulfalakyan: What Armenian authorities did to Gagik Tsarukyan  disgusting
Former MP: Anyone can become victim of lynching if one person`s  insatiable appetite so desiresFormer MP: Anyone can become victim of lynching if one person`s  insatiable appetite so desires
Expert: Armenian society falls into security trap of totalitarianismExpert: Armenian society falls into security trap of totalitarianism
 Gagik Tsarukyan`s property on Lake Sevan to be returned to Armenia Gagik Tsarukyan`s property on Lake Sevan to be returned to Armenia
Read more



Commented