Arminfo.info




 Tuesday, September 27 2022 13:04

There is no such political force in the world that could force  Azerbaijan to give up its claims to Nagorno- Karabakh.- Analyst

There is no such political force in the world that could force  Azerbaijan to give up its claims to Nagorno- Karabakh.- Analyst

ArmInfo.The West cannot achieve independence for the Karabakh Armenians, rather, it is counting on the long-term game.

As soon as Yerevan gives up Nagorno-Karabakh, it will no longer need Russia, also because of the accumulated disappointment. Deprived  of the role of protector, Moscow is likely to lose out in the  competition of mediators during the post-war normalization. Political  analyst Alexander Atasuntsev, states this in an article, published in  the online publication of the Carnegie Endowment Garnegie Endowment  for International Peace,.

The author notes that the war between Russia and Ukraine, although  its scale overshadowed other conflicts in the post-Soviet space, did  not make them less acute. Rather, on the contrary, it strengthened  the desire to take advantage of exceptional circumstances. The  fighting between Azerbaijan and Armenia that broke out in early  September is a vivid example of such an attempt. Taking advantage of  the fact that Moscow's forces are now distracted, Baku is  energetically trying to get Yerevan's consent to settle the Karabakh  conflict on Azerbaijani terms as soon as possible. This undermines  Russia's authority, threatening Moscow's already shattered positions  in the Caucasus.

In a situation where the internationally recognized territory of  Armenia was attacked, of the two possible roles - a mediator and a  guarantor of security - Moscow has chosen the first one, although  this is no longer the Karabakh issue. While the United States, France  and a number of other countries unequivocally condemned Azerbaijan's  aggression, Russia called on both sides to respect the ceasefire.

As the analyst notes, after gaining independence in 1991, Armenia  tried to ensure its protection by Russia.  The country joined the  CSTO, hosted a Russian military base, signed a separate Treaty of  Friendship, Cooperation and Mutual Assistance with Moscow. At one  time, that alliance seemed more indestructible than the friendship  between Russia and Belarus. Armenia was surrounded by enemies -  Turkey and Azerbaijan - and only a Russian shield could cover it.

In 2020, during the lost war for Nagorno-Karabakh, Armenians expected  help from Moscow, but they had no clear reasons why they should get  it. Yerevan itself has never recognized the independence of Nagorno-  Karabakh, de jure agreeing that it is the territory of Azerbaijan.  Why did Moscow have to fight for this unrecognized land?

However, the outcome of the war changed Russia's position in the  region - it began to turn from an arbitrator into just one of the  mediators. More than two thousand Russian peacekeepers deployed in  Karabakh did not help - they have become nominal rather than real  protection of the Armenian population of the region. Two years after  their deployment, they still don't even have a clear mandate to  regulate the use of weapons. In fact, their real ability to contain  Azerbaijan is measured only by Russia's authority.

Nevertheless, Atasuntsev believes, even after the victory in 2020,  the territory of Armenia proper remained a red line for the  Azerbaijanis, which they did not dare to cross. This has been the  case up to the current crisis.

In particular, the article notes that the past summer showed that  Moscow is not ready to defend the strict implementation of even a  tripartite statement that stopped the war in 2020. This became  finally clear during the previous escalation in early August, when  Baku demanded that the Armenians hurry up with the construction of  their section of the new road connecting Armenia and Karabakh,  bypassing Lachin. And it delivered an ultimatum through Russian  peacekeepers: either the Armenians leave Lachin, or Baku will force  them to do so.

In September, against the backdrop of Russia's retreat near Kharkov,  Azerbaijan attacked the territory of Armenia itself. It is possible  that Baku realized that everything, except for the Ukrainian front,  is now secondary for Moscow.

Therefore, Moscow is trying to delay the resolution of the conflict.  The parties have a Russian draft peace treaty, which proposes to draw  an interim result, delimit the border, and leave the Karabakh issue  until calmer times. But this predictably does not suit Azerbaijan,  which is now in a strong position.

Baku believes that the Nagorno-Karabakh issue was closed in November  2020, when the Azerbaijanis won a quick but bloody war at the cost of  thousands of lives. And even ensuring the rights of the Armenian  population of the region is now an internal affair of Azerbaijan.  From Baku's point of view, Karabakh Armenians are no different from  other national minorities in the country, such as the Talysh or  Lezgins.

The Armenian authorities would like the agreement with Baku to be  more like a peace treaty, rather than unconditional surrender - for  Nikol Pashinyan, this is a matter of political survival. But Yerevan  does not have the opportunity to achieve some kind of autonomous  status for Karabakh through diplomacy. It can only be won back, while  neither the authorities nor society are ready for a new war in  Armenia.

It is hard to believe that Azerbaijan's goals are more ambitious and  that it wants to cut a corridor to Nakhichevan by force. Not only  because of the unpredictable consequences, starting with  international sanctions and ending with the threat of a military  clash with Russia. But also because then Baku will violate the  principle of territorial integrity, which it has defended all these  years, seeking the return of Karabakh.  Azerbaijan has tried to be  consistent on this issue, even to the extent of supporting the  territorial integrity of Ukraine against Russia.  There is no such  political force in the world that could force Azerbaijan to give up  its claims to Nagorno- Karabakh. The United States, even taking into  account the visit of Speaker of the House of Representatives Nancy  Pelosi to Armenia, is limited to only words of support.  Armenian  resistance is fading. Before the 2020 war, Yerevan argued that the  Nagorno-Karabakh Republic could not be part of Azerbaijan. After the  defeat, such announcements were made only from Stepanakert.  Now  referring to Karabakh, Yerevan only voices the protection of the  rights of local Armenians. This looks like a willingness to discuss  autonomy within Azerbaijan. 

READ ALL COMMENTS

Юрий
США, даже с учетом визита в Армению спикера Палаты представителей Нэнси Пелоси, ограничиваются только словами поддержки. Не факт, что в итоге ограничатся только словами, нужно немного подождать, чтобы судить окончательно. Хотя и словами не так уж мало. Ведь кое-кто и слов-то не говорит. Так что все познается в сравнении.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Azerbaijan disregards ICJ ruling - Yeghisheh KirakosyanAzerbaijan disregards ICJ ruling - Yeghisheh Kirakosyan
Armenia`s defense office refutes Azerbaijan`s disinformation Armenia`s defense office refutes Azerbaijan`s disinformation 
Azerbaijan preparing genocide of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians and new  aggression against ArmeniaAzerbaijan preparing genocide of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians and new  aggression against Armenia
Upcoming Armenian, Russian FMs` talks to build up allied relations -  Moscow Upcoming Armenian, Russian FMs` talks to build up allied relations -  Moscow 
Zangezur corridor nothing but Turkic ideological project with  Anglo-Saxon geopolitical interests - Armen AshotyanZangezur corridor nothing but Turkic ideological project with  Anglo-Saxon geopolitical interests - Armen Ashotyan
Konstantin Zatulin critical of Russian Federation vice-speaker over   visit to Armenia`s Tsakhkadzor Konstantin Zatulin critical of Russian Federation vice-speaker over   visit to Armenia`s Tsakhkadzor 
Baku is accusing Yerevan of obstructing adoption of OSCE resolution  against IranBaku is accusing Yerevan of obstructing adoption of OSCE resolution  against Iran
Armenia at crossroads, both geographically and politically - Anders  Fogh RasmussenArmenia at crossroads, both geographically and politically - Anders  Fogh Rasmussen
Armenia`s premier meets with president Armenia`s premier meets with president 
European Parliament`s recommendation to impose sanctions against  Azerbaijani government officials important contribution to efforts to  prevent genocide in Artsakh European Parliament`s recommendation to impose sanctions against  Azerbaijani government officials important contribution to efforts to  prevent genocide in Artsakh 
Yerevan mayor resigns Yerevan mayor resigns 
Armenian FM meets with CSTO Sec Gen, highlights targeted response to  Azerbaijani against Armenia Armenian FM meets with CSTO Sec Gen, highlights targeted response to  Azerbaijani against Armenia 
Azerbaijani NPG members visit Armenian prisoners in Baku Azerbaijani NPG members visit Armenian prisoners in Baku 
Armenia`s premier, CSTO Sec Gen discuss situation on  Armenian-Azerbaijani border  Armenia`s premier, CSTO Sec Gen discuss situation on  Armenian-Azerbaijani border  
Cooperation between Armenia and Russia strengthens security in South  Caucasus.Cooperation between Armenia and Russia strengthens security in South  Caucasus.
Far fewer Azerbaijani provocations on Armenia`s border after  deployment of EU mission Far fewer Azerbaijani provocations on Armenia`s border after  deployment of EU mission 
Ruben Vardanyan`s  teams prepared analysis-containing statement on  genocide threat to Nagorno- Karabakh Armenians Ruben Vardanyan`s  teams prepared analysis-containing statement on  genocide threat to Nagorno- Karabakh Armenians 
Armenian Security Council Secretary, CSTO Secretary General discuss  situation on Armenian-Azerbaijani front lineArmenian Security Council Secretary, CSTO Secretary General discuss  situation on Armenian-Azerbaijani front line
Pashinyan confirms Yerevan`s readiness to ensure implementation of  Armenian-Irish potential to greatest extentPashinyan confirms Yerevan`s readiness to ensure implementation of  Armenian-Irish potential to greatest extent
Border guard who instigated his comrade-in-arms to commit suicide was  arrestedBorder guard who instigated his comrade-in-arms to commit suicide was  arrested
British Ambassador: London supports international efforts for  peaceful settlement of Nagorno-Karabakh conflictBritish Ambassador: London supports international efforts for  peaceful settlement of Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
Former head of Vladimir Gasparyan`s security service accused of  legalizing his and his boss` illegal income Former head of Vladimir Gasparyan`s security service accused of  legalizing his and his boss` illegal income 
Yerevan accuses Azerbaijani President of torpedoing negotiations on  normalizing relations and preparing for another aggressionYerevan accuses Azerbaijani President of torpedoing negotiations on  normalizing relations and preparing for another aggression
Will Russia intervene in case of Azerbaijan`s aggression against  Artsakh? Russian Foreign Ministry`s responseWill Russia intervene in case of Azerbaijan`s aggression against  Artsakh? Russian Foreign Ministry`s response
Arsen Torosyan: Deputy ministers do not have functions on which  charge against Yerevan Deputy Mayor is basedArsen Torosyan: Deputy ministers do not have functions on which  charge against Yerevan Deputy Mayor is based
Major General Grigory Khachaturov to be arrestedMajor General Grigory Khachaturov to be arrested
Number of Armenian NGOs condemn attacks on mass media and Aravot.am in particularNumber of Armenian NGOs condemn attacks on mass media and Aravot.am in particular
Armenia, Iraq discuss issues on bilateral agendaArmenia, Iraq discuss issues on bilateral agenda
Armenia, Iraq to expand cooperation in educational and cultural sectorsArmenia, Iraq to expand cooperation in educational and cultural sectors
CSTO Secretary General got acquainted with consequences of  Azerbaijani aggression in JermukCSTO Secretary General got acquainted with consequences of  Azerbaijani aggression in Jermuk
CSTO Secretary General arrives in YerevanCSTO Secretary General arrives in Yerevan
Yerevan will soon present its comments on Baku`s next proposalsYerevan will soon present its comments on Baku`s next proposals
Rasmussen: EU should significantly increase number of members of its  civilian mission in ArmeniaRasmussen: EU should significantly increase number of members of its  civilian mission in Armenia
Armenia to employ international mechanisms to prevent genocide in  Nagorno-Karabakh Armenia to employ international mechanisms to prevent genocide in  Nagorno-Karabakh 
Situation on Karabakh line of contact continues to be very tense -  Oliver Varhelyi,Situation on Karabakh line of contact continues to be very tense -  Oliver Varhelyi,
Leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan should use historic opportunity to  solve Nagorno-Karabakh conflict - Oliver VarhelyiLeaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan should use historic opportunity to  solve Nagorno-Karabakh conflict - Oliver Varhelyi
Armenian MP warns international partners of build-up of Azerbaijani  troop on Armenian, Artsakh borders  Armenian MP warns international partners of build-up of Azerbaijani  troop on Armenian, Artsakh borders  
Armenia`s premier a liar - Russian MPArmenia`s premier a liar - Russian MP
Ararat Mirzoyan presents Armenia`s vision on Armenia-Azerbaijan  normalization process to Brazilian AmbassadorArarat Mirzoyan presents Armenia`s vision on Armenia-Azerbaijan  normalization process to Brazilian Ambassador
Problems related to desertification discussed in YerevanProblems related to desertification discussed in Yerevan
David Gyurjinyan appointed Acting Rector of Brusov State UniversityDavid Gyurjinyan appointed Acting Rector of Brusov State University
Enemy forces fired on Artsakh winegrowersEnemy forces fired on Artsakh winegrowers
MFA: Stepanakert strongly rejects Azerbaijan`s attempts to distort  essence of Karabakh conflict and present it as internal issueMFA: Stepanakert strongly rejects Azerbaijan`s attempts to distort  essence of Karabakh conflict and present it as internal issue
European Parliament adopts Zeljana Zovko`s report on EU-Azerbaijan  relationsEuropean Parliament adopts Zeljana Zovko`s report on EU-Azerbaijan  relations
Catherine Colonna: France is undoubtedly the country most committed  to protecting ArmeniansCatherine Colonna: France is undoubtedly the country most committed  to protecting Armenians
Bulgarian MEP: Yet again in their history, Armenians are subjected to  genocideBulgarian MEP: Yet again in their history, Armenians are subjected to  genocide
Minister: All regional police departments to be liquidated in ArmeniaMinister: All regional police departments to be liquidated in Armenia
Papikyan: Armenian armed forces are armed as much as resources allowPapikyan: Armenian armed forces are armed as much as resources allow
Armenian, Artsakh defense departments refute enemy disinformationArmenian, Artsakh defense departments refute enemy disinformation
Armenia hosting Francophonie DaysArmenia hosting Francophonie Days
Armenia`s defense minister determined to accomplish taskArmenia`s defense minister determined to accomplish task
Haifa City Council recognizes Armenian Genocide Haifa City Council recognizes Armenian Genocide 
Development of Armenia`s military doctrine to follow approval of  national security strategy - minister Development of Armenia`s military doctrine to follow approval of  national security strategy - minister 
CE Sec Gen responds to Armenian MP`s alarm over police ill-treatment  of minorsCE Sec Gen responds to Armenian MP`s alarm over police ill-treatment  of minors
U.S. National Security Advisor, Chief Advisor to President of Turkey  discuss situation in South CaucasusU.S. National Security Advisor, Chief Advisor to President of Turkey  discuss situation in South Caucasus
Germany concerned over instability on Armenian-Azerbaijani border -  Olaf ScholzGermany concerned over instability on Armenian-Azerbaijani border -  Olaf Scholz
Commander of United Group of Forces Tigran Parvanyan dismissed  Commander of United Group of Forces Tigran Parvanyan dismissed  
Alen Simonyan: Armenia is interested in developing mutually  beneficial cooperation with friendly India in various directionsAlen Simonyan: Armenia is interested in developing mutually  beneficial cooperation with friendly India in various directions
Former NATO Secretary General was personally convinced of  non-functioning of the Berdzor corridorFormer NATO Secretary General was personally convinced of  non-functioning of the Berdzor corridor
Former NATO Secretary General on situation around Artsakh: Europe  cannot turn a blind eye to the humanitarian crisis at its bordersFormer NATO Secretary General on situation around Artsakh: Europe  cannot turn a blind eye to the humanitarian crisis at its borders
Read more



Commented