Arminfo.info



 Tuesday, October 27 2020 17:40

Richard Giragosian: The Azerbaijani column`s advance is driven more  by political objectives in Baku than military science

Richard Giragosian: The Azerbaijani column`s advance is driven more  by political objectives in Baku than military science

ArmInfo.One month into a massive military offensive for Nagorno-Karabakh and hours into a failed US-brokered truce, Azerbaijan is facing a crucial choice that could define the  war's outcome, famous Armenian-Americanpolitical scientists Richard  Giragosian writes in his article published in Asia Times.

Azerbaijani troops, having advanced on the open terrain along the Iranian border,  have the momentum and appear to be fast approaching the strategic  Lachin corridor. But with its troops overstretched and the Karabakh  defenders having retreated to the forested high ground, Baku is at a  crossroads. The choice is one of following military logic and sound  strategy or opting instead for a decision with greater political and  diplomatic dividends. But Azerbaijan can't have it both ways.   Military logic suggests a choice of focusing on targeting the Lachin  corridor, the critical lifeline between Karabakh and Armenia. Any  success in cutting off the Lachin lifeline would be devastating,  endangering the resupply and flow of reinforcements to Karabakh and  subjecting the Karabakh Armenians to a months-long siege.  Yet for an  Azerbaijani populace eager for full control of Karabakh itself, that  would not be enough, as such a choice would be neither politically  palatable nor sufficient in the face of dangerously high expectations  for complete victory.

And that leaves the second choice: a turn away from the Lachin  corridor for an attack on the city of Shushi within Karabakh itself.   The capture of the historic cultural center of Shushi, known to  Azerbaijanis as Shusha, would offer significant political rewards for  the government of President Ilham Aliyev. It would also enhance  Baku's diplomatic bargaining power in any future negotiations.  Yet  such a move would also incur tremendous military losses and usher in  a new, even more intense period of guerrilla warfare as Karabakh  forces would hold an advantage in mobility and surprise in an  insurgency-style campaign against the Azerbaijani forces.  Given the  over-extended vulnerability and strained supply routes for the  Azerbaijani forces in the field for a month already, that may be an  especially risky decision.

Already, the Azerbaijani column - its advance driven more by  political objectives in Baku than military science - is inherently  vulnerable due to stretched supply lines and broken lines of  communication. This defiance of Clausewitzian military science may be  tempting in order to rush the advance and seize more territory, but  Baku is dangerously ignoring essential limitations and necessities.

In addition, the Azerbaijani attacking column is increasingly spread  much too thin, with no rear-guard deployment of units or men capable  of holding the territorial gains they have achieved in areas south of  Karabakh.

This weakness will only return as a looming challenge for the  Azerbaijani attackers as any counter-attacks by the Karabakh Armenian  forces will face little resistance and could offer a much-needed  element of tactical surprise and "out-flanking" of exposed  Azerbaijani units.  Winter is now fast approaching, meaning any  further Azerbaijani combat operations will be especially difficult if  not impossible in the coming weeks due to low visibility and  impassable snow-covered mountainous terrain.

A second, often overlooked factor in the strategic context is the  operational doctrine and combat experience of the Karabakh Armenian  side. In the major past confrontations, most notably the initial  Karabakh war of the early 1990s and the five-day war of April 2016,  the Karabakh Armenians were initially losing before regrouping and  securing victories based on counter-attacks and repelling invasions.

This historical pattern offers another advantage for the Karabakh  defensive position beyond the already important edge of terrain and  topography, suggesting the real burden is on the attackers.  Beyond  the daily reports of severe losses, high casualties and an  increasingly costly tactical campaign to both seize territory and  defend positions, it may be too early to discount the Karabakh  Armenian defenders.

After a weeks-long consistent Azerbaijani advance, a successful and  orderly retreat by the Karabakh forces allowed them to reposition and  regroup for a secondary defensive line based on the defenders'  advantages of terrain and topography.  After suffering serious losses  in equipment and nearly 1,000 casualties, their counter-attacks and  stubborn resistance have begun to turn the tide of battle.

In recent days, the new defensive positions succeeded in halting the  Azerbaijani advance to within roughly 25 kilometers of the  strategically vital Lachin corridor, the sole highway connection  between Karabakh and Armenia.

At the same time, the retreat into the mountains and forests have  allowed the Karabakh forces to launch small unit attacks against the  more exposed Azerbaijani infantry and armored support.  And with such  forested and mountainous terrain, the Azerbaijani advantage of an air  threat from their formidable Turkish and Israeli military drones will  be significantly diminished.  Yet with President Aliyev having  promising full victory, the prospect of stopping short of either  Lachin or Shushi could risk political suicide.

Against this backdrop, even tripartite diplomatic engagement has  fallen short. Moscow, in an attempt to demonstrate its diplomatic  dominance, sought to force an agreement on the Armenian and  Azerbaijani foreign ministers in a hastily arranged meeting on  October 9.  Backed by France and the United States, the two other  co-chairing nations of the Organization for Security and Cooperation  in Europe's (OSCE) so-called Minsk Group, this Russian initiative was  initially seen as a potent assertion of diplomatic power.

Yet both Azerbaijan and Turkey showed uncharacteristic courage in  resisting what they saw as Russian bluff and bluster, and the  Azerbaijani offensive continued unencumbered.

Such open and outright defiance of Russia stems from an Azerbaijani  determination fortified by an unprecedented level of direct Turkish  military and diplomatic support. Azerbaijani military gains in  territory and tactical success against the Karabakh Armenian  defenders have only deepened their reluctance to abide by a  ceasefire.

In the wake of that rather surprising rebuke, a second diplomatic  initiative was launched. This time it was France, in a round of  American- style, shuttle diplomacy, with an emissary of French  President Emmanuel Macron flying into Yerevan and on to Baku for a  series of meetings with each side on October 15-16.  Despite  accolades for innovation and initiative, that second effort at  securing a ceasefire also fell short.

Emboldened by territorial gains and encouraged by popular domestic  support rare for his authoritarian rule, President Aliyev flouted his  newfound victories and echoed Turkish complaints of the OSCE Minsk  Group, suggesting a greater role for Ankara in the mediation at the  expense of Paris.

And in the weakest and least promising round of diplomatic  engagement, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo met separately with the  Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers in Washington on October  23.

This belated American gesture was largely doomed from the start, and  was as much a move to show geopolitical relevance as to boost an  embattled Trump administration in the waning days of a contested  presidential election campaign.

While the US did succeed in securing an agreement to abide by yet  another cessation of hostilities, it already appeared to break down  within an hour of implementation.

Conflict mediation is never an easy task, dependent on a degree of  sincere political will among the parties to the conflict, and in  nearly all cases, a degree of conflict fatigue. In the case of  Nagorno-Karabakh, war-time diplomacy has failed, with dynamic  developments on the battlefield now driving the situation. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenian leadership deliberately leads Armenian-Russian relations to  collapse - LavrovArmenian leadership deliberately leads Armenian-Russian relations to  collapse - Lavrov
ECHR accepts complaints in cases of Armen Ashotyan and Artur  Danielyan for preliminary proceedings ECHR accepts complaints in cases of Armen Ashotyan and Artur  Danielyan for preliminary proceedings 
Freedom House ranks Artsakh Not Free after Azerbaijani occupation; it  losses 40 points at onceFreedom House ranks Artsakh Not Free after Azerbaijani occupation; it  losses 40 points at once
"Europeans for Artsakh" platform outlines Artsakh`s interests  protecting vector 
Government  allocates about AMD1.4 billion to properly organize 100th  anniversary events of Sergey Parajanov, Charles AznavourGovernment  allocates about AMD1.4 billion to properly organize 100th  anniversary events of Sergey Parajanov, Charles Aznavour
France expresses readiness to consider UFAR`s development and  expansion agenda within Academic City project France expresses readiness to consider UFAR`s development and  expansion agenda within Academic City project 
Armenia to send 30 tons of humanitarian aid to Gaza StripArmenia to send 30 tons of humanitarian aid to Gaza Strip
No No "governments in exile" for Armenia`s premier 
Armenia is turning into extremely dangerous instrument in the hands  of the West - Maria Zakharova Armenia is turning into extremely dangerous instrument in the hands  of the West - Maria Zakharova 
Former Nagorno-Karabakh president calls on France to expert pressure  on Azerbaijan Former Nagorno-Karabakh president calls on France to expert pressure  on Azerbaijan 
Housing programme for forcibly displaced people to be presented next  month - vice-premier Housing programme for forcibly displaced people to be presented next  month - vice-premier 
40+10 assistance programme for forcibly displaced people to be  extended until end 2024 40+10 assistance programme for forcibly displaced people to be  extended until end 2024 
CSTO Sec Gen on Armenia`s participation in CSTO work CSTO Sec Gen on Armenia`s participation in CSTO work 
Meeting in Brussels is to focus on Armenia`s economic resilience -  U.S. Department of State Meeting in Brussels is to focus on Armenia`s economic resilience -  U.S. Department of State 
Upcoming high-level meeting in Brussels not directed against any  third party - Armenia`s foreign office  Upcoming high-level meeting in Brussels not directed against any  third party - Armenia`s foreign office  
World has experience in development of even failed states - Artak  Zakaryan World has experience in development of even failed states - Artak  Zakaryan 
Zakharova: information on Azerbaijan`s arms supplies to Ukraine is  carefully checkedZakharova: information on Azerbaijan`s arms supplies to Ukraine is  carefully checked
Russian Foreign Ministry: France`s actions are hindering  implementation of Azerbaijan-Armenia agreements Russian Foreign Ministry: France`s actions are hindering  implementation of Azerbaijan-Armenia agreements 
Russian Foreign Ministry: Anything that will benefit the people of  Armenia is only welcomedRussian Foreign Ministry: Anything that will benefit the people of  Armenia is only welcomed
Gnel Sanosyan: Upon completion of demarcation and delimitation  process, there will be no unresolved problemsGnel Sanosyan: Upon completion of demarcation and delimitation  process, there will be no unresolved problems
Statements by Alen Simonyan are carte blanche for aggression:  Opposition MPStatements by Alen Simonyan are carte blanche for aggression:  Opposition MP
Armenia does not join  CSTO PA delegations heads  statement  condemning violent terrorist attack in Crocus City HallArmenia does not join  CSTO PA delegations heads  statement  condemning violent terrorist attack in Crocus City Hall
NA Speaker: I would like to meet with a person who can prove on a map  that the four villages of Tavush belong to ArmeniaNA Speaker: I would like to meet with a person who can prove on a map  that the four villages of Tavush belong to Armenia
National Assembly Speaker: there were no political overtones in my  meeting with Svetlana TikhanovskayaNational Assembly Speaker: there were no political overtones in my  meeting with Svetlana Tikhanovskaya
Armenian PM, French parliamentarians discuss processes in South  Caucasus Armenian PM, French parliamentarians discuss processes in South  Caucasus 
Baku irritated by Pashinyan`s upcoming meeting with Blinken and Von  der LeyneBaku irritated by Pashinyan`s upcoming meeting with Blinken and Von  der Leyne
French delegation inspects security in Sotk mine French delegation inspects security in Sotk mine
Offering Armenia EU candidate status makes its pivot to West  irreversible - report Offering Armenia EU candidate status makes its pivot to West  irreversible - report 
AraratBank places its 27th issue of dollar bondsAraratBank places its 27th issue of dollar bonds
Armenian MP meet with Danish counterparts  Armenian MP meet with Danish counterparts  
Surrender of Tavush villages to destroy locals` ecosystem - expert Surrender of Tavush villages to destroy locals` ecosystem - expert 
Renowned Swiss-American lutenist to perform in Armenia  Renowned Swiss-American lutenist to perform in Armenia  
Azerbaijan uses military-political leaders of Artsakh in captivity to  achieve its propaganda goals - statementAzerbaijan uses military-political leaders of Artsakh in captivity to  achieve its propaganda goals - statement
No details of upcoming meeting between Armenia`s premier, U.S. Sec of  State, European Commission president No details of upcoming meeting between Armenia`s premier, U.S. Sec of  State, European Commission president 
People of Nagorno-Karabakh determined to return to their homeland -  Leevon KocharyanPeople of Nagorno-Karabakh determined to return to their homeland -  Leevon Kocharyan
Armenian committed to peace and stability in South Caucasus Armenian committed to peace and stability in South Caucasus 
Tatoyan Foundation, together with other human rights organizations,  publishes joint report on torture committed by Azerbaijan against  ArmeniansTatoyan Foundation, together with other human rights organizations,  publishes joint report on torture committed by Azerbaijan against  Armenians
Mirzoyan: Armenia considers Argentina as reliable partner in South  AmericaMirzoyan: Armenia considers Argentina as reliable partner in South  America
French Ambassador: The right of Artsakh people to return to their  homeland has been violatedFrench Ambassador: The right of Artsakh people to return to their  homeland has been violated
State Dept on US policy principles in relations with ArmeniaState Dept on US policy principles in relations with Armenia
Slander aimed at removing National Democratic Pole from political  arena: party responds to IC Slander aimed at removing National Democratic Pole from political  arena: party responds to IC 
Armenian diplomat to EU special rep: Aliyev regime is gearing up for  new aggression against Armenia, as he faced no consequences for last  onesArmenian diplomat to EU special rep: Aliyev regime is gearing up for  new aggression against Armenia, as he faced no consequences for last  ones
ICLaw presents cases of 8 Armenian servicemen to UN Working Group on  Enforced DisappearancesICLaw presents cases of 8 Armenian servicemen to UN Working Group on  Enforced Disappearances
Following Armenian foreign office, references to Artsakh `disappear`  from president`s websiteFollowing Armenian foreign office, references to Artsakh `disappear`  from president`s website
Sati Spivakova and the Moscow Theater of Nations soon in YerevanSati Spivakova and the Moscow Theater of Nations soon in Yerevan
CSTO Secretary General calls for creation of tools to counter  terrorismCSTO Secretary General calls for creation of tools to counter  terrorism
No discussions yet held on the issue of Armenia`s new Constitution -  minister No discussions yet held on the issue of Armenia`s new Constitution -  minister 
Establishment of lasting peace and stability in South Caucasus  Armenia`s top priority - Nikol Pashinyan Establishment of lasting peace and stability in South Caucasus  Armenia`s top priority - Nikol Pashinyan 
Azerbaijan should end the intimidation and harassment of journalists  and civil society activists - Dunja MijatovicAzerbaijan should end the intimidation and harassment of journalists  and civil society activists - Dunja Mijatovic
Armenia`s minister of justice on reforms in judicial system Armenia`s minister of justice on reforms in judicial system 
Armenian expert on Azerbaijan`s policy of misappropriation of  Armenian heritage Armenian expert on Azerbaijan`s policy of misappropriation of  Armenian heritage 
Incident with ex-minister of defense followed by numerous dismissals  - minister Incident with ex-minister of defense followed by numerous dismissals  - minister 
Russia is going through a rather difficult period in relations with  friendly, fraternal Armenia - Russian presidential spokesman Russia is going through a rather difficult period in relations with  friendly, fraternal Armenia - Russian presidential spokesman 
Azerbaijan creates artificial grounds for military aggression against  Armenia - Arman Tatoyan Azerbaijan creates artificial grounds for military aggression against  Armenia - Arman Tatoyan 
Armenian FM takes part in presentation of book Armenian FM takes part in presentation of book "Armenian Buenos  Aires" 
Threats against Armenia in Azerbaijani media channels unacceptable -  Toivo KlaarThreats against Armenia in Azerbaijani media channels unacceptable -  Toivo Klaar
Opposition MP: Threatening people with war is not the mission of  country`s leaderOpposition MP: Threatening people with war is not the mission of  country`s leader
Roundtable on geopolitical developments in South Caucasus held at  Belgian SenateRoundtable on geopolitical developments in South Caucasus held at  Belgian Senate
Andranik Tevanyan: Political struggle is the only guarantee of  success, a chance not to turn real Armenia into historical oneAndranik Tevanyan: Political struggle is the only guarantee of  success, a chance not to turn real Armenia into historical one
Vahagn Khachaturyan Vahagn Khachaturyan "closes" book of condolences at Russian Embassy  in Yerevan
Read more



Commented