Arminfo.info



 Wednesday, December 25 2019 12:37
David Stepanyan

Diplomat: Delving into the ICG report, which is a scrupulously and  cautiously laid smelly heap, is simply disgusting

Diplomat: Delving into the ICG report, which is a scrupulously and  cautiously laid smelly heap, is simply disgusting

ArmInfo. The ICG's new report could be ignored if the activities of this expert organization in the field of "studying" and "analyzing" the process of resolving the  Artsakh- Azerbaijani conflict did not have its sad background. A  similar opinion was expressed to ArmInfo by Ambassador Extraordinary  and Plenipotentiary, former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Artsakh  Arman Melikyan, commenting on the latest report of the International  Crisis Group "Digging out of the Deadlock in Nagorno-Karabakh".

"This background started in 2005, when the first report of the ICG on  this subject was published. We should remember that it was this  report that created the necessary basis for the subsequent drafting  of the deadlock negotiation agenda, called the Madrid Principles. In  their first report, ICG experts thoughtfully and skillfully  manipulated information, fitting the description of the  characteristics of the conflict to the political patterns necessary  for the customers. Experts from Armenia and Azerbaijan, but not from  Artsakh, were also involved. Their participation was intended to  create the impression of a balanced outcome document, however, in the  preparation of the final version of the report, the opinion does not  seem to have been taken into account ",  he said.

According to Melikyan, even cursory reading of the report allows us  to talk about maintaining the style and focus of the first report.  For example, the report says that about 400,000 Azerbaijanis left the  territories currently controlled by the authorities of the Artsakh  Republic during the war, and another 40,000 - "the territory of  Nagorno-Karabakh itself." In addition, hundreds of thousands of  people - Azerbaijanis and Armenians - were forced to leave Armenia  and Azerbaijan, respectively.

Thus, according to his estimates, like it was an afterthought, the  authors of the report emphasize the specific number of Azerbaijanis  who left the war zone as a result of the war unleashed by Azerbaijan  against Artsakh, hiding the number of Armenians expelled from this  country. They are silent that there were more than half a million of  such people and about 400,000 people found shelter in Armenia and  Artsakh.

 "Or, for example, it is said that at the end of the war in  Stepanakert, a government of self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh was  established which positioned itself as independent", although it is  known that the NKR proclaimed its independence before and not after  the outbreak of a full-scale war. I think that if you delve into, you  can find a lot of such frauds and flaws, however delving into this so  scrupulously and cautiously laid smelly heap is simply disgusting,  "Melikyan emphasized.

Thus, the diplomat notes that the ICG is working in the same  direction - the Artsakh people are required to surrender the  territories around the former Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region, to  allow international peacekeeping military contingent to their  territory, and to stop building and settling in the territories to be  surrendered. In exchange for this, Baku, perhaps, will not initiate  claims against Armenia in international judicial instances and will  begin to reflect on what could be the consequences of giving the  Artsakh Armenians the right to self-government.

"Official Yerevan, however, should seriously consider its own further  actions in connection with the publication of the report. Most  likely, the joint meeting of the Security Councils of the RA and the  AR convened on Sunday was intended to somehow coherently respond to  the publication. The statements were announced that rejected the  decisions imposed on us, but, as before, we don't seem to have our  own plan of action in the framework of the political negotiation  process. While there should be one, "Melikyan concluded.

Headquartered in Brussels, the International Crisis Group (ICG) is an  independent, non-profit, multinational organization that brings  together about 80 employees on five continents. The organization  analyzes the situation on the ground and actively advocates for the  prevention and containment of deadly conflicts. Based on the  information and assessments conducted on the ground, the ICG  publishes analytical reports that provide practical recommendations  addressed to key international political decision-makers .

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Azerbaijan, Armenia confirm their participation in negotiations in  AlmatyAzerbaijan, Armenia confirm their participation in negotiations in  Almaty
Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting has not yet been determined due to  lack of response from Armenia to this proposalArmenian, Azerbaijani FMs meeting has not yet been determined due to  lack of response from Armenia to this proposal
Omer Celik: Turkiye to monitor developments around Azerbaijan -  Armenia border agreement Omer Celik: Turkiye to monitor developments around Azerbaijan -  Armenia border agreement 
Peacekeepers` withdrawal from Karabakh continuesPeacekeepers` withdrawal from Karabakh continues
Mirzoyan told Al-Jazeera about Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization,  relations with Russia and expressed his position on situation in Gaza  StripMirzoyan told Al-Jazeera about Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization,  relations with Russia and expressed his position on situation in Gaza  Strip
Europe Nostra Vice President to visit ArmeniaEurope Nostra Vice President to visit Armenia
Acba Bank to start public placement of its next USD, AMD bonds on May  2Acba Bank to start public placement of its next USD, AMD bonds on May  2
Participation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and DevelopmentParticipation of the delegation of Turkmenistan in the 57th session of the UN Commission on Population and Development
MP: As a result of border delimitation Armenia to receive state  border to protect its sovereigntyMP: As a result of border delimitation Armenia to receive state  border to protect its sovereignty
Hungary blocks European Peace Facility`s support project for Armenia Hungary blocks European Peace Facility`s support project for Armenia 
RAU rector`s office term extended by 4 yearsRAU rector`s office term extended by 4 years
"5165" movement calls on all healthy forces of Armenia to unite for   salvation of motherland
Investigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in KirantsInvestigative Committee comments on beating of servicemen who  attended protests in Kirants
Italian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in YerevanItalian orchestra ROMA SINFONIETTA to perfom Ennio Morricone`s famous  compositions in Yerevan
Armenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movementArmenia`s government making unilateral concessions in Azerbaijan`s  favor - Tavush for the Motherland movement
Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed Armenia`s new rep to UNESCO appointed 
Border delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sectionsBorder delimitation supposed to settle problems on other border  sections
Armenia`s minister of defense hosts member of French Senate  CommitteesArmenia`s minister of defense hosts member of French Senate  Committees
Armenia`s authorities have nothing in common with Armenian people -  opposition MPArmenia`s authorities have nothing in common with Armenian people -  opposition MP
Leaflets calling for supporting Tavush residents distributed in  Armenia`s capital Leaflets calling for supporting Tavush residents distributed in  Armenia`s capital 
Armenia`s territories gradually surrendered under the guise of Armenia`s territories gradually surrendered under the guise of "pilot  border delimitation" - opposition MP
All-Armenian Council of Diplomats proposes solutions to end crisis in  Armenia All-Armenian Council of Diplomats proposes solutions to end crisis in  Armenia 
Statement by Armenia`s Ministry of Justice shameful - Arman Tatoyan Statement by Armenia`s Ministry of Justice shameful - Arman Tatoyan 
Armenia`s government comments on results of premier`s meeting with  residents of village of KirantsArmenia`s government comments on results of premier`s meeting with  residents of village of Kirants
Journalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protestsJournalistic organizations expressed outrage at unjustified  aggression and cruelty of RA law enforcement officers against media  covering protests
Idram and IDBank at Career City FestIdram and IDBank at Career City Fest
"Shirak for Motherland" movement holds  car rally in Gyumri in  support of Tavush residents 
As of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, AzerbaijanAs of April 29, 2024, 35 border posts have been installed between  Armenia, Azerbaijan
"Mother Armenia" bloc calls on students to stand up in support of  Tavush residents
European Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiativesEuropean Commission Director General travels to South Caucasus to  launch new initiatives
Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush Armenia`s Justice Ministry issues statement regarding  Armenian-Azerbaijani border delimitation in Tavush 
Opposition MP files complaint against police Opposition MP files complaint against police 
When organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiatorWhen organizing Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Almaty,  Kazakhstan`s authorities will not act as negotiator
Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008Armenia`s Prosecutor`s Office intends to reclassify actions of   defendants in case of March 1, 2008
"Tavush for the Motherland " demands from Armenian law enforcement  agencies to investigate report accusing Bagrat Srbazan of committing  crime
Oppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to thatOppositionist: Turks seizing our lands step by step; Armenia`s  current authorities contribute to that
One of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - TatoyanOne of main problems of authorities` policy is to oppose history of  Armenian people - Tatoyan
Armenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of QatarArmenian FM holds talks with Speaker of the Shura Council of Qatar
One person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MPOne person, not Republic of Armenia protected now - opposition MP
Charles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich MazmanianCharles Aznavour a person of cosmic scale - Mkrtich Mazmanian
Azerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in KazakhstanAzerbaijani, Armenian FMs to meet in Kazakhstan
Disobedience actions continue in Armenia Disobedience actions continue in Armenia 
Shift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  BalayanShift in Armenia s foreign policy not threat to Moscow - Tigran  Balayan
Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border Armenian premier. U.S. Sec of State discuss delimitation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border 
U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president U.S. Sec of State holds phone talks with Armenia`s premier,  Azerbaijani president 
Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert Degradation of Tavush could start within 10 days - expert
Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  Prime Minister`s Cup must more and more closely linked with education  - Nikol Pashinyan  
Russia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesmanRussia for further Armenian-Azerbaijani contacts - presidential spokesman
Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert Meeting of high-ranking officials of Armenia and Turkey took place in Tbilisi: the authorities are conducting negotiations behind Armenian people - expert 
Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman Armenia`s leader forced into surrendering Homeland`s territories - clergyman 
Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen Opposition MP critical of government over prosecution of servicemen 
Armenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s DayArmenia`s premier addresses message on Citizen`s Day
Russian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victimsRussian embassy in Armenia reports events in commemoration of  Armenian Genocide victims
Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched Servicemen join protesters in Tavush: criminal investigation launched 
"Azerbaijan Sanctions Review Act" requires State Department to report on applicability of Magnitsky Act sanctions against Azerbaijani officials.
Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized Law-enforcers use special means in Kirants: five hospitalized 
Int`l pressure must continue - David VardanyanInt`l pressure must continue - David Vardanyan
28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan28 border posts have already been established between Armenia,  Azerbaijan
Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway Actions of disobedience continue throughout country: MP Artur  Khachatryan detained by brute force on Sevan-Yerevan highway 
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Read more



Commented