Arminfo.info



 Monday, October 7 2019 12:36
Marianna Mkrtchyan

The case of Lapshin versus Azerbaijan in the ECHR passed to a  decisive stage

The case of Lapshin versus Azerbaijan in the ECHR passed to a  decisive stage

ArmInfo. The trial in the  European Court of Human Rights on charges of the Azerbaijani  authorities in organizing an attempted murder of a Russian-Israeli  traveler, blogger and journalist Alexander Lapshin has entered a  decisive stage. This was announced by the blogger himself on his  Facebook page.

"Friends, I'm in a hurry to share the fact that the court accused the  Azerbaijani authorities of organizing an attempted murder has moved  to a decisive stage. The procedure called" communication "(in the  common law is called" the debate of the parties ") has ended. My  lawyers have filed a package of documents with evidence of the  commission of crimes by Azerbaijanis The opposing side presented its  objections. On Friday 04.10.2019 the case was referred to the ECHR  panel of judges in Strasbourg for a decision. Neither I personally,  nor my lawyers, nor numerous politicians from a number of countries  and human rights defenders who have given me the most serious support  this year in all matters. Azerbaijan will lose this process, the  whole question is only what formulations the court will select,  "Lapshin wrote, citing two versions of the ECtHR's formulations - or  organizing an attempt for murder by the Azerbaijani authorities, or  the inability of the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure the security  and observance of the legitimate rights of a person under their  jurisdiction.

At the same time, the journalist is convinced that this process will  go down in history as a precedent in a number of parameters:  "Firstly, for the first time, it is an attempt to kill a tourist  organized by the state's special services because of his trip to  Nagorno-Karabakh. Secondly, for the first time by the persecution of  a foreign citizen the head of state (Ilham Aliyev) personally took  responsibility for taking all responsibility for my life and health,  I mean both the "dirty deal" with the head of Belarus, Alexander  Lukashenko, and Aliyev's comments at all stages of the arena 100,  trial and release. Never before in history has the head of a state  humiliated himself to explain and comment on the arrest of an  individual citizen. Thirdly, the Azerbaijani authorities committed a  record number of falsifications, gross errors, contradictory  statements and outright lies. According to lawyers conducting cases  at the ECHR in Strasbourg, states usually try to look in court with  dignity and not be caught in falsification of documents. Azerbaijanis  managed to get at least three times on this: a fake letter of thanks  to Aliyev that I never wrote (since I was in a coma on these dates in  the intensive care unit after the attack), allegations that I didn't  receive letters and statements because of the "postman's disease"  (mail trackers they say the opposite is what everyone got) and  finally injuries recorded by Israeli experts indicating an attack,  not a suicide. Unlike the Israelis, without even the slightest  investigation and expert examination, the head of Azerbaijan, Ilham  Aliyev, fearfully declared on the day of the attack on me September  11, 2017: "Lapshin hanged himself, but we saved him ...", the blogger  wrote.

At the same time, he pointed out that there was not only a criminal  component (attempted murder) in this trial, but also an important  political factor. Lapshin is convinced of the importance of setting a  precedent that prosecution of bloggers, journalists, and individuals  visiting any region of the world as tourists should not be  encouraged. "It is important to show that Azerbaijan is neither  capable of an adequate court, nor of respecting the rights of those  arrested, nor of preserving their life and health, and therefore  should not be extradited to this country. My precedent should create  maximum difficulties for the Baku authorities in any future attempt  to prosecute journalists and Also, brutal physical violence against a  tourist just for his trip to Nagorno-Karabakh should show that any  negotiations on a future settlement of the Karabakh issue should take  into account the risks that if Baku gains control of the region, then  the ethnic Armenians will face a brutal massacre, compared with which  the pogroms in Baku and Sumgait seem like a trifle, but if the  assassination is not directed by Ilham Aliyev, but by the warring  clans inside the country's leadership, the question asks how much  Aliyev is capable of to control the situation inside Azerbaijan. And  is it possible to consider President Aliyev as a reliable partner in  the negotiation process, "Lapshin concluded.

It should be noted that Alexander Lapshin became widely known in  public circles after he was arrested in Minsk in 2016 at the request  of the Azerbaijani authorities and extradited to Baku due to a visit  to Nagorno- Karabakh. Lapshin visited Nagorno-Karabakh in 2011 and  2012, after which Azerbaijan was blacklisted by people who are  prohibited from entering the country. Nevertheless, Alexander Lapshin  was able to visit Baku in June 2016, having entered Azerbaijan with  his Ukrainian passport, which included "Alexander" instead of  "Alexander", because of which the Azerbaijani border guards could not  recognize the blacklisted person in Lapshin .

The extradition in February 2017 of a blogger from Minsk to Baku  caused tension between Armenia and Belarus, and also became the topic  of the foreign policy agenda in Israel and Russia. Russian Foreign  Minister Sergei Lavrov said that Russia is categorically against the  extradition of a blogger to Azerbaijan, as well as against the  criminalization of visits by Russians to certain regions of the  world. Also, Israel protested in connection with the extradition of  Lapshin. As a result, five states were drawn into and involved in an  international scandal surrounding the blogger.  A court in Baku  sentenced Lapshin to three years in prison. Three months after that,  on September 11, 2017, Ilham Aliyev signed a decree to pardon  Alexander Lapshin, after which he was able to fly from Baku to Tel  Aviv. At the beginning of 2018, Alexander Lapshin filed a lawsuit  against Azerbaijan in the European Court of Human Rights, in which he  accused Azerbaijan of attempted murder, torture, illegal  imprisonment. On December 15, 2018, the ECHR notified Lapshin's  lawyers that he had begun communication with the Azerbaijani  authorities, having decided that the evidence presented about the  attempted murder in a Baku prison, the infliction of grievous bodily  harm and torture was enough to initiate proceedings against  Azerbaijan. On July 3, 2019, the Azerbaijani authorities filed their  objections to Lapshin's lawsuit.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Aliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, ArmeniaAliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, Armenia
Armenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperationArmenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperation
Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official 
Closing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  AghdamClosing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  Aghdam
Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  
India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism 
Armenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in TavushArmenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in Tavush
May One procession to take place in Yerevan May One procession to take place in Yerevan 
Armenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s bordersArmenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s borders
Contract serviceman injured in demining operations in TavushContract serviceman injured in demining operations in Tavush
Armenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc MelenchonArmenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc Melenchon
Driver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roadsDriver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roads
France is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  DevinazFrance is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  Devinaz
Ruben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strikeRuben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strike
20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 
Freedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  TsitsernakaberdFreedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  Tsitsernakaberd
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners 
Current situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - SpeakerCurrent situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - Speaker
European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29
"We are waiting!", Russian side expects Pashinyan`s participation in  EAEU summit
Protests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizensProtests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizens
Legitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA SpeakerLegitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA Speaker
Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?
Vladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levelsVladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levels
Yeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupierYeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupier
Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`
Political analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary electionsPolitical analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary elections
U.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-AzerbaijanU.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-Azerbaijan
If left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. KennedyIf left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. Kennedy
Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan 
Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan 
Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge 
Situation in Tavush remains tenseSituation in Tavush remains tense
Armenia plans to open consulate general in TabrizArmenia plans to open consulate general in Tabriz
Summer conscription starts in Armenia Summer conscription starts in Armenia 
Armenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schoolsArmenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schools
Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert 
French PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian GenocideFrench PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide
Six Combat Brotherhood members released Six Combat Brotherhood members released 
Actions of disobedience start in Armenia Actions of disobedience start in Armenia 
Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square 
On April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of UruguayOn April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of Uruguay
British MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian QuarterBritish MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian Quarter
President of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgottenPresident of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgotten
Nikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanityNikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanity
Turkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman EmpireTurkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman Empire
Russian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian peopleRussian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian people
Abkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian peopleAbkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian people
Support for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to TsitsernakaberdSupport for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to Tsitsernakaberd
`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire
Turkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideTurkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
Ruben Vardanyan: Ruben Vardanyan: "Now I understand that principles and values are  much more important than life"
Syrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian GenocideSyrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian Genocide
Jonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian GenocideJonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian Genocide
Pan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram IPan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram I
Armenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideArmenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide
In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on  western democracies to recognize it In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on western democracies to recognize it
Armenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in VarnaArmenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in Varna
Read more



Commented