Arminfo.info


 Wednesday, May 8 2019 17:45
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Moscow`s dual approach to Yerevan and Baku as a litmus test of the  real state of bilateral relations

Moscow`s dual approach to Yerevan and Baku as a litmus test of the  real state of bilateral relations

ArmInfo.On May 6, the Russian  Ministry of Foreign Affairs published a report "On the situation with  the glorification of Nazism, the spread of neo-Nazism and other  practices that contribute to the escalation of modern forms of  racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance,"  the official presentation of which took place today and which  contains formulations not causing only bewilderment, but also  "laughter through tears."

So, studying the report on the part of  Azerbaijan, a number of questions arise. In particular, the report  points out that "Azerbaijan has practically no manifestations of  neo-Nazism, racism, racial discrimination and xenophobia, and the  leadership of Azerbaijan positions its country as a state of tolerant  living for representatives of various nations and religions." 

Such formulations addressed to dynastic Azerbaijan are not only  biased, but also distort the real situation in this area in  Azerbaijan, and the situation recorded by the Russian Foreign  Ministry and promulgated and commented by the official representative  of the Russian Foreign Ministry Maria Zakharova a few months earlier.  It was about the inadmissibility of the detention and expulsion of  Russian citizens on a national basis from Azerbaijan. Zakharova  qualified these actions of the Azerbaijani authorities against  Russian citizens of Armenian origin as a gross violation of the  rights of Russian citizens. "It is not the first time that we are  faced with a discriminatory ethnic policy towards citizens of the  Russian Federation. According to the Foreign Ministry, last year  (2018) there were at least 16 cases of denial of entry into  Azerbaijan on ethnic grounds. At the same time, Russian citizens were  detained for hours at the airport, then forcibly expelled from the  country. There was no official reason, "Ms. Zakharova criticized the"  tolerance "of the authorities of the AR at one of her briefings  earlier this year. Meanwhile, these circumstances apparently did not  completely embarrass the authors of the above report, who devoted a  whole "ode" to how well foreigners live in Azerbaijan.

Meanwhile, studying the report on the part of Armenia, one encounters  the dual formulation of "no obvious attempts to rehabilitate Nazism,  no splashes of neo-Nazi sentiment in Armenia." This formulation  leaves room for serious reflection, since, despite the fact that  Armenia is a mono-national state, there were still no manifestations  in the directions already mentioned above. However, continuing to  study the report, you begin to understand "where the dog is buried."  The authors of the report, in particular, note that the former ruling  Republican Party of Armenia has taken steps to perpetuate the memory  of "such an ambiguous nationalist political figure like Garegin  Nzhdeh, in respect of whom there is information about cooperation  with the Third Reich."

It is noteworthy that already the former vice-speaker of the National  Assembly of Armenia Eduard Sharmazanov, referring to the attacks of  the Russian side on this topic, has repeatedly stressed that Nzhde is  a national hero of the Armenian people, as well as Alexander Nevsky,  Alexander Suvorov, Marshal Kutuzov, Bagration are national heroes of  the fraternal Russian of the people: "And as a historian I want to  emphasize that Garegin Nzhdeh had no relation to fascism and Nazism.  Nzhde spent his whole life fighting for the freedom of Armenia. Nzhde  was not a Nazi, he is a patriot of the Armenian people and  speculation and this issue is inappropriate and unacceptable. "

Sharmazanov then reminded the Russian side that in 1939, USSR Foreign  Minister Vyacheslav Molotov signed a non-aggression agreement with  Germany, but no one considers him a fascist and nationalist.   "Everyone realizes that this agreement was signed from the interests  of the USSR and the Soviet people in order to prevent a possible  attack by fascist Germany. The same was true in the case of Nzhdeh,  he collaborated with Germany, and in case of her victory prevented a  possible attack on Armenia by an ally Berlin Turkey, "- said  Sharmazanov.

The report of the Russian Foreign Ministry also paid attention to the  Sasna Tsrer party, which is presented as a nationalist party. It also  indicates the presence of isolated cases of racism and xenophobia in  Armenia.  "Manifestations of racism and xenophobia in Armenia are  sporadic. Occasional cases of hostility by the Armenian population to  visitors from Iran and India are noted, most of which are related to  the inappropriate behavior of foreigners themselves. At the end of  2018. RA Human Rights Defender A.Tatoyan stated the increasing use of  the Internet to spread xenophobic sentiments in Armenia, motivating  this by aggravating the internal political situation in the country  on the eve of the parliamentary elections, " the  reports'  authors  state. 

Whatever it is, but in Armenia you will not meet announcements in the  press or in public places about renting an apartment to anyone, but  not , although such a nationality,  unlike the "Caucasian" one, does exist.

The manifestation of such double standards in drafting the report  raises many questions and, unfortunately, makes you think about the  quality of the Armenian-Russian relations, or about serious  procedural inconsistencies in the apparatus of the Russian Foreign  Ministry, or about the banal "caviar" diplomacy that also penetrated  thick walls of a grand "Stalinist skyscraper" on Smolensk Square.  We  also note that ArmInfo's attempts to get comments from a number of  Armenian political analysts on the content of the report were  extremely unsuccessful. Moreover, the agency deliberately refused  calls to pro- Western experts. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armen Ashotyan: Presence of political prisoners in Armenia   acknowledged by  several international organizations Armen Ashotyan: Presence of political prisoners in Armenia   acknowledged by  several international organizations 
Customer Appreciation Day - This Time at IDBank’s “Erebuni” Branch             Customer Appreciation Day - This Time at IDBank’s “Erebuni” Branch            
RA President: Armenian authorities  interested in deepening,  strengthening, and developing relations with EgyptRA President: Armenian authorities  interested in deepening,  strengthening, and developing relations with Egypt
Nikol Pashinyan, Lithuanian Prime Minister discuss strategic  partnershipNikol Pashinyan, Lithuanian Prime Minister discuss strategic  partnership
Khandanyan does not rule out Azerbaijani gas supplies to Armenia Khandanyan does not rule out Azerbaijani gas supplies to Armenia 
Where did the 57 square kilometers of Armenia`s sovereign territory  go? NA Speaker responds to opposition MP`s  question Where did the 57 square kilometers of Armenia`s sovereign territory  go? NA Speaker responds to opposition MP`s  question 
Sargis Khandanyan sees no political obstacles to implementing TRIPP  projectSargis Khandanyan sees no political obstacles to implementing TRIPP  project
Expert: Real peace unattainable until Armenia-Azerbaijan agreement is  signed and ratifiedExpert: Real peace unattainable until Armenia-Azerbaijan agreement is  signed and ratified
Prime Minister dismisses another Deputy MinisterPrime Minister dismisses another Deputy Minister
Sargis Khandanyan: No reason  to reactivate our CSTO membershipSargis Khandanyan: No reason  to reactivate our CSTO membership
 Sharmazanov: Actions must serve Armenia, not out of spite toward  Russia Sharmazanov: Actions must serve Armenia, not out of spite toward  Russia
Pashinyan: Armenian authorities interested in advancing new  initiatives aimed at deepening ties with Arab countriesPashinyan: Armenian authorities interested in advancing new  initiatives aimed at deepening ties with Arab countries
Georgia deports 113 foreign nationals, including Armenian citizensGeorgia deports 113 foreign nationals, including Armenian citizens
RA premier dismisses deputy minister of labor and social affairsRA premier dismisses deputy minister of labor and social affairs
Armenia, Ukraine agree to continue developing bilateral cooperationArmenia, Ukraine agree to continue developing bilateral cooperation
Australia highly appreciates Armenia`s historic progress towards  comprehensive peace with Azerbaijan - premier Australia highly appreciates Armenia`s historic progress towards  comprehensive peace with Azerbaijan - premier 
RA, Ukrainian FMs hold telephone conversationRA, Ukrainian FMs hold telephone conversation
RA MP`s lawyers deny client revealed classified documents to money RA MP`s lawyers deny client revealed classified documents to money 
Candidate for Chair of NA Committee on State and Legal Affairs sees  problems with citizens` personal dataCandidate for Chair of NA Committee on State and Legal Affairs sees  problems with citizens` personal data
RA Ministry of Justice`s Probation Service staff member charged with  embezzlementRA Ministry of Justice`s Probation Service staff member charged with  embezzlement
 Pashinyan needs spectacle to conceal his steps to satisfy  Azerbaijani-Turkish demands - opposition rep  Pashinyan needs spectacle to conceal his steps to satisfy  Azerbaijani-Turkish demands - opposition rep 
 Criminal case against Catholicos of All Armenians transferred to  Judge Serzh Rushanyan Criminal case against Catholicos of All Armenians transferred to  Judge Serzh Rushanyan
RF MFA: Armenia must decide on holding referendum on EU or EAEU by  December 2026RF MFA: Armenia must decide on holding referendum on EU or EAEU by  December 2026
U.S., Armenia, Azerbaijan issue joint statement on one-year  anniversary ofWhite House Peace SummitU.S., Armenia, Azerbaijan issue joint statement on one-year  anniversary ofWhite House Peace Summit
NA continues debate on candidacy for Defense and Security Committee  chairman NA continues debate on candidacy for Defense and Security Committee  chairman 
TRIPP`s proximity to Iranian border could slow its implementation -  expert TRIPP`s proximity to Iranian border could slow its implementation -  expert 
 RF MFA: EU is making efforts to divide EAEU countries RF MFA: EU is making efforts to divide EAEU countries
Earthquake in ArmeniaEarthquake in Armenia
Armenia, Rwanda ready to strengthen political dialogue and  cooperation Armenia, Rwanda ready to strengthen political dialogue and  cooperation 
New appointments at Ministries of Environment and HealthNew appointments at Ministries of Environment and Health
Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople expresses solidarity with   Catholicos of All Armenians and clergymenArmenian Patriarchate of Constantinople expresses solidarity with   Catholicos of All Armenians and clergymen
Results of the Junius Tournament Announced: The Next Round Ahead         Results of the Junius Tournament Announced: The Next Round Ahead        
Kapan stadium in Armenia proposed for priority public interest statusKapan stadium in Armenia proposed for priority public interest status
Hakan Fidan: Ankara supports peace efforts  between Armenia and  AzerbaijanHakan Fidan: Ankara supports peace efforts  between Armenia and  Azerbaijan
Narek Karapetyan outlines priorities when selecting parliamentary  committeesNarek Karapetyan outlines priorities when selecting parliamentary  committees
The majority`s backing will not create political constraints on my  opposition role: Aram Vardevanyan on his election as Deputy  Parliament SpeakerThe majority`s backing will not create political constraints on my  opposition role: Aram Vardevanyan on his election as Deputy  Parliament Speaker
Investigative Committee report: Kasakh community land caseInvestigative Committee report: Kasakh community land case
Distribution of Parliamentary Committee chairmanships finalizedDistribution of Parliamentary Committee chairmanships finalized
PM  Pashinyan signs a number of  staff decisionsPM  Pashinyan signs a number of  staff decisions
Oppositionist: Political responsibility from all regional states is needed to unblock Armenia`s communicationsOppositionist: Political responsibility from all regional states is needed to unblock Armenia`s communications
RA NA Parliamentary Ethics Committee to be formed RA NA Parliamentary Ethics Committee to be formed 
Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs 
Number of seats in each of NA committees redistributed Number of seats in each of NA committees redistributed 
Ruben Vardanyan`s wife is awaiting contact with RA MFA to organize  women`s humanitarian visit to BakuRuben Vardanyan`s wife is awaiting contact with RA MFA to organize  women`s humanitarian visit to Baku
Aram Vardevanyan elected RA NA Vice SpeakerAram Vardevanyan elected RA NA Vice Speaker
Construction of new building for Yeghegnadzor Fire and Rescue Squad  to be completed soonConstruction of new building for Yeghegnadzor Fire and Rescue Squad  to be completed soon
Russia extradites fraudster to Armenia Russia extradites fraudster to Armenia 
Who and why is sacrificing RA National Security Service`s reputation?  - expert Who and why is sacrificing RA National Security Service`s reputation?  - expert 
The heat will subside for a few days: The Hydrometeorological Center has released a new weather forecastThe heat will subside for a few days: The Hydrometeorological Center has released a new weather forecast
RA NA continues to debate candidacy of third vice-speaker nominated  by Strong Armenia blocRA NA continues to debate candidacy of third vice-speaker nominated  by Strong Armenia bloc
RA premier attends closing ceremony of Army Games in TavushRA premier attends closing ceremony of Army Games in Tavush
RA premier, U.S. president hold phone conversationRA premier, U.S. president hold phone conversation
French MFA: Authorities of Armenia and Azerbaijan have taken bold  steps to achieve tangible peaceFrench MFA: Authorities of Armenia and Azerbaijan have taken bold  steps to achieve tangible peace
Mecca Joint Defense Agreement could have turning point for Middle  EastMecca Joint Defense Agreement could have turning point for Middle  East
Not all problems resolved yet, but peace established - Ruben Rubinyan Not all problems resolved yet, but peace established - Ruben Rubinyan 
HAY DAT condemns Trump administration`s intention to circumvent  sanctions against BakuHAY DAT condemns Trump administration`s intention to circumvent  sanctions against Baku
RA premier`s address on August 8 shameful and dangerous - expert RA premier`s address on August 8 shameful and dangerous - expert 
 Armenian premier, Azerbaijani president hold telephone talk  Armenian premier, Azerbaijani president hold telephone talk 
RA Investigative Committee announces solving of contract killing:  ex-premier`s son detained RA Investigative Committee announces solving of contract killing:  ex-premier`s son detained 
August 8, 2025, milestone, and Armenia`s history can be divided into  period before and after it - RA premier August 8, 2025, milestone, and Armenia`s history can be divided into  period before and after it - RA premier 
Read more



Commented