Arminfo.info





 Saturday, December 1 2018 16:38
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Alexander Krylov: Supporters of turning the CSTO into an influential organization are interested in the soonest overcoming of "Khachaturov`s incident."

Alexander Krylov: Supporters of turning the CSTO into an influential organization are interested in the soonest overcoming of "Khachaturov`s incident."

ArmInfo. Supporters of the transformation of the CSTO into an influential collective security organization are interested in overcoming the “casus with Khachaturov” as soon as possible, the President of the Scientific Society of Caucasus Studies, expert in the IMEMO RAS named after E.M. Primakov Alexander Krylov said.

Mr. Krylov, recently a round table on Caucasian issues took place in Yerevan. Who organized it and what are the results?

Indeed, on November 26-27, 2018, we held a Russian-Armenian round table “2018: WATERSHED YEAR FOR THE SOUTH CAUCASUS?” The round table was organized by the Scientific Society of Caucasus Studies in partnership with the Russian NGO Dialogue and our permanent Armenian partners - the Institute of Oriental Studies of the NAS RA and the Institute of the Caucasus.

 

Could you tell about the Scientific Society of Caucasus Studies?

 

The Scientific Society of Caucasus Studies was established in 2010, its goal is to comprehensively study the Caucasus in its close relationship with global development, to popularize scientific knowledge and achievements of modern Caucasian studies. The Society holds various scientific events; the round table held in Yerevan is the 15th in a row in eight years. Conferences were held in Vladikavkaz, Moscow, Rostov-on-Don, Paris, Pyatigorsk, Stavropol, Sukhum and Tskhinval. The round table “2018: WATERSHED YEAR FOR THE SOUTH CAUCASUS?” is the fifth event organized by the Society in Armenia. This event, like many other projects, was carried out in the framework of cooperation with the “Dialogue” NGO headed by Yury Ludvigovich Navoyan, who was among the founders of our society. At present, we are posting materials of the round table at the same time on the sites of the Society and the “Dialog” organization. We highly appreciate the attention paid to our event by the Armenian leadership. The Secretary of the Security Council of the Republic of Armenia Armen Grigoryan welcomed the participants of the event, then the meeting of the Russian participants with the President of Armenia Armen Sarkissian took place. During the meeting that lasted more than an hour with the President of the Republic of Armenia, we were able to discuss a wide range of various problems, including many problems in our bilateral relations. The friendly atmosphere of this meeting made a great impression on the Russian participants.

During the round table, many problems in relations between Armenia and Russia were discussed. Are these problems becoming more complex?

Relations between different states can not be ideal, without any problems. However, our bilateral relations are facing too many problems. At the same time, which is especially sad, security problems are also increasing. That is even in the field in which the common interests of the two countries are obvious. Therefore, during the round table, we paid special attention to the discussion of this problem, a report analyzing this issue under the title “Problems of Regional Security of the South Caucasus” was made by the permanent participant of our conference Vagharshak Harutyunyan.

 

 

To what extent does the incident related to Khachaturov continue to play its role?

 

 

In the context of the current domestic political situation, the problem of approving the new CSTO Secretary General has acquired a crucial importance for Armenia. In many ways, it becomes decisively important from the point of view of regional security and the future prospects of integration projects in the post-Soviet space. Therefore, we paid so much attention to this issue, not only during the round table, but also during discussions with experts and representatives of various political forces. As a result, the situation is as follows. The refusal to comply with the CSTO Charter for each of the member states of the three-year quota for the CSTO Secretary General is perceived by Armenia as discrimination of its own state and representatives of different political forces have common approach on this issue. It seems that there is complete unanimity in society on this issue. The same unanimity is observed in the support of the candidate nominated by Armenia for the post of Secretary General Vagharshak Harutyunyan. Nikol Pashinyan's choice in favor of this candidate seems to me quite reasonable: Harutyunyan was among those who set up the CSTO, he more than anyone else is aware of all the problems of this organization. He has never been involved in high-profile scandals, so all the concerns expressed about the possible repetition of "Khachaturov's incident" have no basis. Harutyunyan is considered a pro-Russian politician in Armenia, but even those political forces that are principled opponents of an alliance with Russia have not criticized this candidate.

 

 

Such unanimity in the context of the upcoming elections and the acute confrontation of various political forces can be explained only by the fact that Harutyunyan's appointment to the post of CSTO Secretary General is viewed by all political forces as crucial from the point of view of Armenia’s security interests. It will testify to the ability of Russia to protect the interests of its ally in the Caucasus and will testify to the effectiveness of the CSTO in ensuring the security of Armenia as a member state of this organization. Obviously, if this does not happen, it will cause an extremely negative reaction in Armenia. In the context of the upcoming elections, Pashinyan cannot agree to the appointment of the Belarusian representative as the CSTO Secretary General, Acting Secretary General Valery Semerikov's headship for another year and a half. So, if the leaders of the Republic of Belarus and the Republic of Kazakhstan continue to insist on the “Belarusian option”, and Pashinyan does not agree to any option other than Armenian, then the situation will become a stalemate. This means that negotiations on this issue can continue until the expiration of the Armenian quota - that is, another year and a half.

 

Obviously, neither the CSTO, nor the EEU, or Russian-Armenian relations will benefit from this situation. The best way out would be to make a decision based on the current norms of the CSTO Charter, which assigns to each of the member states a three-year quota for the post of the CSTO Secretary General. And all the difficulties that have arisen because of the "Khachaturov's incident" can be solved in the future by amending the Charter of the CSTO. Otherwise, a completely ridiculous situation may arise already with the Belarusian representative on the post of secretary general if his term expires ahead of schedule. If you follow the current logic of Alexander Lukashenko and Nursultan Nazarbayev, who supports him, it turns out that if a Belarusian representative for some reason the next day after being approved for the position of the Secretary General, ceases his authority, the post immediately should pass to the representative of Kazakhstan. And what if the same problem arises with him? It turns out an obvious nonsense that leads many experts to the conviction that the actions of Lukashenko and Nazarbayev are dictated by the fact that they act as lobbyists for the interests of Azerbaijan, which is not among the members of the CSTO. It is obvious that supporters of the transformation of the CSTO into an influential and efficient collective security organization are interested in the soonest overcoming of the "Khachaturov incident." The results of the CSTO summit, which will be held on December 6 in St. Petersburg, will show whether they enjoy the predominant influence in the CSTO.


News
An extraordinary meeting of the Security Council of Armenia was held  under Pashinyan`s chairmanship An extraordinary meeting of the Security Council of Armenia was held  under Pashinyan`s chairmanship 
Armen Sarkissian: Ankara`s actions in the Caucasus could also pose a  threat to the EUArmen Sarkissian: Ankara`s actions in the Caucasus could also pose a  threat to the EU
Civil Aviation Committee:The humanitarian aid from the US delivered to ArmeniaCivil Aviation Committee:The humanitarian aid from the US delivered to Armenia
Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Estonia discussed  situation in  KarabakhForeign Ministers of Armenia and Estonia discussed  situation in  Karabakh
Lavrov indicated where to look for answers to questions on the  Karabakh settlementLavrov indicated where to look for answers to questions on the  Karabakh settlement
Participants of  Participants of  "Don t be silent!" action met with UN Resident  Coordinator in Armenia
Yerevan denies Baku`s statement of an alleged attempt by Armenian  forces to strike the oil pipelineYerevan denies Baku`s statement of an alleged attempt by Armenian  forces to strike the oil pipeline
Arshak Martirosyan: Azerbaijan is forcing mercenaries from Syria to  active hostilitiesArshak Martirosyan: Azerbaijan is forcing mercenaries from Syria to  active hostilities
Representative of Armenia to  ECHR: The   principle of Representative of Armenia to  ECHR: The   principle of " Remedial  secession " is nothing more than the right of the people to  self-determination
During the days of hostilities, the enemy lost 195 UAVs and 566  armored vehiclesDuring the days of hostilities, the enemy lost 195 UAVs and 566  armored vehicles
Deputy Foreign Minister: Russian side expresses its position  to  Turkey that the involvement of Syrian militants in the Karabakh  conflict is unacceptableDeputy Foreign Minister: Russian side expresses its position  to  Turkey that the involvement of Syrian militants in the Karabakh  conflict is unacceptable
Tehran voiced red line for Yerevan and Baku in connection with  escalation in KarabakhTehran voiced red line for Yerevan and Baku in connection with  escalation in Karabakh
Mayor of Paris: If the only solution to the current conflict is the  recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh, we should not hesitateMayor of Paris: If the only solution to the current conflict is the  recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh, we should not hesitate
Speaker of Turkish Parliament arrives in Baku after Foreign MinisterSpeaker of Turkish Parliament arrives in Baku after Foreign Minister
Artsakh President and German Bundestag Deputies Discussed Situation  in NKRArtsakh President and German Bundestag Deputies Discussed Situation  in NKR
MP Sasun Mikaelyan wounded in ArtsakhMP Sasun Mikaelyan wounded in Artsakh
View from Moscow: The time for statements is over, it`s time for  actionView from Moscow: The time for statements is over, it`s time for  action
Hauts-de-Seine Department called on the French President and  Government to support Artsakh against the background of Azerbaijani  aggressionHauts-de-Seine Department called on the French President and  Government to support Artsakh against the background of Azerbaijani  aggression
Media: More than a thousand militants from Syria were transferred to  the zone of the Karabakh conflictMedia: More than a thousand militants from Syria were transferred to  the zone of the Karabakh conflict
Emergency Situations Ministry dispatched 40 trucks with humanitarian  aid to Artsakh since October 1Emergency Situations Ministry dispatched 40 trucks with humanitarian  aid to Artsakh since October 1
As a result of attacks by enemy UAVs in Gegharkunik region, 2 schools  were damagedAs a result of attacks by enemy UAVs in Gegharkunik region, 2 schools  were damaged
Forecast: Only Moscow`s proposed new order can create a reality in  which Russia will remain in the South CaucasusForecast: Only Moscow`s proposed new order can create a reality in  which Russia will remain in the South Caucasus
Council of Europe warns of humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-KarabakhCouncil of Europe warns of humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh
Resolution on Turkey`s exclusion from NATO presented to the US House  of RepresentativesResolution on Turkey`s exclusion from NATO presented to the US House  of Representatives
ANCA tries to block US arms sales to TurkeyANCA tries to block US arms sales to Turkey
Yerevan accuses Baku of unwillingness to observe humanitarian  ceasefire and attempt to mislead the international communityYerevan accuses Baku of unwillingness to observe humanitarian  ceasefire and attempt to mislead the international community
Donald Trump to Armenians: You have a strong spirit of patriotismDonald Trump to Armenians: You have a strong spirit of patriotism
RA Ministry of Defense: The heaviest battles are in the southern  direction of the frontRA Ministry of Defense: The heaviest battles are in the southern  direction of the front
RA Prime Minister: Success in war can be achieved if everyone  concentrates around this taskRA Prime Minister: Success in war can be achieved if everyone  concentrates around this task
RA FM: Armenia is committed to strengthening the ceasefire and  peaceful settlement of the Karabakh conflictRA FM: Armenia is committed to strengthening the ceasefire and  peaceful settlement of the Karabakh conflict
RA President: Turkey cannot be a mediator, since it openly supports  AzerbaijanRA President: Turkey cannot be a mediator, since it openly supports  Azerbaijan
RA Foreign Minister: Only decisive efforts of the international  community can counteract Turkey`s expansionist policyRA Foreign Minister: Only decisive efforts of the international  community can counteract Turkey`s expansionist policy
World Union of Jewish Students calls on Israel to immediately stop  all arms supplies to AzerbaijanWorld Union of Jewish Students calls on Israel to immediately stop  all arms supplies to Azerbaijan
Bundestag deputies: There are corrupt deputies in the European  Parliament, so the Artsakh issue is not raised thereBundestag deputies: There are corrupt deputies in the European  Parliament, so the Artsakh issue is not raised there
EU condemns continued fighting in Karabakh following ceasefire  declarationEU condemns continued fighting in Karabakh following ceasefire  declaration
Bundestag lawmakers call on the international community to apply tough sanctions against Turkey and AzerbaijanBundestag lawmakers call on the international community to apply tough sanctions against Turkey and Azerbaijan
Armenians of France demand to recognize the independence of ArtsakhArmenians of France demand to recognize the independence of Artsakh
Erdogan arms Azerbaijanis to carry out new Armenian Genocide - interview with Corriere della SeraErdogan arms Azerbaijanis to carry out new Armenian Genocide - interview with Corriere della Sera
UN Secretary General condemned attacks on settlements in Nagorno-Karabkh conflict zoneUN Secretary General condemned attacks on settlements in Nagorno-Karabkh conflict zone
RA Foreign Minister had a telephone conversation with the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security PolicyRA Foreign Minister had a telephone conversation with the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy
Zohrab Mnatsakanyan spoke about the violation of the humanitarian truce of the Azerbaijani Armed ForcesZohrab Mnatsakanyan spoke about the violation of the humanitarian truce of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces
Christian human rights activists call on Trump administration to  impose sanctions on TurkeyChristian human rights activists call on Trump administration to  impose sanctions on Turkey
Turkish President mixes up the addresses of arms suppliesTurkish President mixes up the addresses of arms supplies
Armenian Foreign Ministry Spokesperson response to European External  Action ServiceArmenian Foreign Ministry Spokesperson response to European External  Action Service
Armenians of Barcelona hold a protest actionArmenians of Barcelona hold a protest action
RA Ministry of Health alarms: Bodies left unattended along the entire  Contact Line may become transmitting of  outbreaks and epidemicsRA Ministry of Health alarms: Bodies left unattended along the entire  Contact Line may become transmitting of  outbreaks and epidemics
A number of servicemen of Artsakh Defense Army were presented to high  state awardsA number of servicemen of Artsakh Defense Army were presented to high  state awards
Senator of Canada: Erdogan is a classic autocrat, and Western  democracies have their heads buried in the sandSenator of Canada: Erdogan is a classic autocrat, and Western  democracies have their heads buried in the sand
EU ready to assist Armenia`s healthcare systemEU ready to assist Armenia`s healthcare system
RA MFA: The Aliyev clan, which has become an instrument of Turkish  expansion in the region, is only concerned about maintaining its own  powerRA MFA: The Aliyev clan, which has become an instrument of Turkish  expansion in the region, is only concerned about maintaining its own  power
Armenian Foreign Ministry: Azerbaijan violates ceasefire agreement  for the second timeArmenian Foreign Ministry: Azerbaijan violates ceasefire agreement  for the second time
Adviser: The ceasefire announced since midnight is indefiniteAdviser: The ceasefire announced since midnight is indefinite
French President: This truce must be unconditional and strictly  enforced by both sidesFrench President: This truce must be unconditional and strictly  enforced by both sides
Artsakh Human Rights Defender`s Office updated information on the  consequences of Azerbaijan`s crimes against the peaceful population  of ArtsakhArtsakh Human Rights Defender`s Office updated information on the  consequences of Azerbaijan`s crimes against the peaceful population  of Artsakh
The enemy once again violated the ceasefire agreementThe enemy once again violated the ceasefire agreement
Stepanakert confirms readiness to observe the humanitarian truce on a reciprocal basisStepanakert confirms readiness to observe the humanitarian truce on a reciprocal basis
Two cities of France recognized the independence of ArtsakhTwo cities of France recognized the independence of Artsakh
Yerevan and Baku agreed on a humanitarian truce as of October 18th, 00h00Yerevan and Baku agreed on a humanitarian truce as of October 18th, 00h00
Armenians continue protest actions in different parts of the world because of Azerbaijan`s aggression against Artsakh: In Israel, it ended with an Azerbaijani provocationArmenians continue protest actions in different parts of the world because of Azerbaijan`s aggression against Artsakh: In Israel, it ended with an Azerbaijani provocation
Visit of Armenian Foreign Minister to USA is under protocol preparationVisit of Armenian Foreign Minister to USA is under protocol preparation
Read more



Commented