Arminfo.info





 Monday, October 8 2018 11:21
David Stepanyan

Tevan Poghosyan: None of the political forces act to overcome the challenges facing Armenia

Tevan Poghosyan: None of the political forces act to overcome the challenges facing Armenia

ArmInfo.In an interview with ArmInfo, the director of the International Center for Human Development Tevan Poghosyan comments on the latest domestic political events in the country. He emphasizes the need for political dialogue and the development of consensus as the only way out of the domestic political crisis, discusses the possible consequences for Armenia of the refusal of the opposing forces from a mutually acceptable compromise.

 

 

Mr. Poghosyan,  the essence of the events that took place on October 2 in Yerevan, is well known.  In what light do you view these events, in particular, their possible consequences? 

The processes that crowned the evening voting in parliament on October 2 began early in the morning. In my opinion, we are talking about negotiations in which the Republican Party tried to somehow strengthen its position before starting, in fact, a political bargaining with the “Civil Contract”. In my opinion, political bargaining has long been an integral part of a very conventional political culture in Armenia. And under negotiations we, unfortunately, practically always mean bargaining, and not some fundamental interests of the parties, parties or the state. In this light, the Republicans apparently thought that by inventing the draft law “On Amendments to the Law on the Regulation of the National Assembly”, they thereby create a counterbalance to Pashinyan’s intentions to organize early elections in December of this year. The interest of “Prosperous Armenia” and the ARF in all this undertaking, apparently, should be sought from the results of the elections to the Yerevan Council of Elders. Today, the PA and the ARF in the parliament , respectively, 31 and 7 deputies. The elections in Yerevan showed the PA the prospect of being represented in the parliament of the next convocation by a faction of at most 8 or 10 deputies, and ARFD with a large zero. Hence the need for another political bargaining and , as a consequence, the emergence of this bill. In response to this, the second bidder , instantly demonstrated his own capabilities in the form of tens of thousands of people at the walls of parliament.

Thus, I personally perceive October 2 as the day of the failure of the perception of reality, in my opinion, still consisting in principled negotiations regarding the interests of development, and not bidding. Yes, some conversations will continue, but these will not be real negotiations of political forces. These will be statements, presentations of my own positions, which I personally perceive, rather, as a monologue. Meanwhile, the development of a political consensus in Armenia remains a pressing need. Whatever the consensus.

 

For example, in the matter of holding  the extraordinary parliamentary elections in the country? 

In my opinion, early elections in Armenia are simply necessary today. And the sooner they pass, the better it will be for all of us. But this also requires the availability of alternatives in these elections, between which the voter could choose. Otherwise, we will see a repeat of the September vote of confidence in the Prime Minister in Yerevan. I have no doubt in this. 

 

And what do you see as negative prospects for such a vote of confidence?

In how its results may be used . For example, the repetition of the mistakes of predecessors, since 1991 , accompanied by the collapse of the big ruling party of the ANM. And you can make the right conclusions and bring the decision-making process from one room, relatively speaking, to the people, in various discussion formats. In other words, Nikol Pashinyan has mechanisms for changing the situation and avoiding repetition of the sad previous experience at hand, it only remains to use them correctly. As an adviser to the president, I can mention his last few addresses to the people with a welcome culture of making joint decisions through negotiations and dialogue. Including   the circulation after the events of October 2. 

 

You noted the presence of bargaining and trade  between the ruling political force and the RPA-ARF-PA troika. And what, actually, do they still want to receive from him these parliamentary forces? 

First of all, I would add that bargaining is not only between them, other political associations are also involved in it. Simply, there is a public and non-public part. As for the troika, in my opinion, they need seats in parliament and political participation. 

 

How, through the provision of “quotas,” as it  was done previously? 

By delaying the existing uncertain situation . The whole question is in their interest. Are they in the development of the country or limited solely to holding the chair? Delaying this uncertainty increases their chances, at the same time giving hope for the deterioration of the situation in Armenia and, accordingly, a decrease in Pashinyan’s rating.

 

By the way, if they succeed in extending all this  to May 8, the Constitution allows the parliament to express a vote of no confidence to the Prime Minister ... 

Of course, one  can only imagine what alternative of political bargaining will be opened up to parliamentary forces if they can reach out until May.

 

 

Name two scenarios: the most negative and the most positive, with which this whole situation can be crowned. 

The most positive is the development of a joint decision to find a way out of this rather difficult situation. At its best, the political forces signed a joint communique. Finally, we must learn to live together, especially in the light of the big internal and, most importantly, external challenges facing Armenia. Therefore, I hope very much that the result of such negotiations will be precisely the consensus of the political forces around holding early elections as early as possible. At least this year. As for the negative scenario, I would like to note that in the event of delaying the existing domestic political confrontation, we will not have a single guarantee of what it can all lead to. Especially when one of the parties feels in this confrontation driven into a corner . A weak, cornered beast always starts to scratch. And I do not know what it means and where it can lead us. From this point of view, the use of a systems approach, planning and forecasting scenarios opens up quite alarming prospects. The actions of none of the Armenian political forces to resolve the numerous challenges facing Armenia are not directed. For me, any scenario that does not lead us towards jointly overcoming these challenges is destructive and problematic. History proves that we can only resist and overcome all these challenges jointly. Accordingly, any scenario of the internal political development of the situation for me is projected onto the future exclusively within this framework. Life will not end after the snap elections.

 

Do you accept the scenario when the existing parliament will still vote for the Prime Minister’s candidature?

 I do not even want to consider such a scenario. Everything is possible in the world, but that is not the question. The question is how to avoid this negative scenario for the whole of Armenia. After all, it understands both sides. We understand that when a very dissatisfied mass of people gather somewhere, it can lead to anything. We know that Nikol Pashinyan has the opportunity to gather this mass, if someone didn’t believe in it, then on October 2 he could clearly see it. Therefore, the possibilities of the parties are known and therefore I consider it unproductive to consider and to trump their potential negative consequences. It is necessary to get together and search together, jointly develop a fundamentally new, positive way out of the situation. As an expert, I can say that the best way out of the situation is a joint, agreed decision on early elections. And these elections should be held as soon as possible. This is not the only way, but it is the most correct way. And the fact that people today can directly influence the choice of politicians in determining the vector of this political path is only positive for me. I have always dreamed of the appearance in Armenia of mechanisms allowing the people to convey their opinions, their discontent, to the top. And the main thing is that the leaders listen to this opinion.


News
Pashinyan: Azerbaijan wants not the settlement of the Karabakh  conflict, but the unconditional surrender of ArtsakhPashinyan: Azerbaijan wants not the settlement of the Karabakh  conflict, but the unconditional surrender of Artsakh
Enemy forces fire at Martuni region of Karabakh from Enemy forces fire at Martuni region of Karabakh from "Grad" and  "Smerch" 
Iran: West lacks necessary determination to help find a settlement to  conflict in Nagorno-KarabakhIran: West lacks necessary determination to help find a settlement to  conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh
President of Karabakh: The security and rights of our people are not  subject to compromisePresident of Karabakh: The security and rights of our people are not  subject to compromise
Stepanyan: The density of fire along the entire line of the front in  Artsakh has sharply increased since 5:00pmStepanyan: The density of fire along the entire line of the front in  Artsakh has sharply increased since 5:00pm
Arman Maralchyan appointed Commander of Border Guard Troops of  NSS  of Armenia Arman Maralchyan appointed Commander of Border Guard Troops of  NSS  of Armenia 
Armenian Defense Ministry: Heavy battles are going on in the  southeast of ArtsakhArmenian Defense Ministry: Heavy battles are going on in the  southeast of Artsakh
Armenian President expressed his gratitude to Austria for support to  Armenian side in Artsakh issueArmenian President expressed his gratitude to Austria for support to  Armenian side in Artsakh issue
Enemy forces targeted village of Avetaranots: 1civilian killed and  two woundedEnemy forces targeted village of Avetaranots: 1civilian killed and  two wounded
Lavrov and Dendias discussed situation in Karabakh conflict zoneLavrov and Dendias discussed situation in Karabakh conflict zone
Azerbaijani-Turkish propaganda breaks records in stupidityAzerbaijani-Turkish propaganda breaks records in stupidity
Kremlin welcomes any steps that can stop  conflict in  Nagorno-KarabakhKremlin welcomes any steps that can stop  conflict in  Nagorno-Karabakh
 Austrian Rotax has stopped supplying engines to Turkey Austrian Rotax has stopped supplying engines to Turkey
Aliyev has a new headache: Where do Armenians get so much money for  armaments?Aliyev has a new headache: Where do Armenians get so much money for  armaments?
Turkish UAVs continue reconnaissance flights near Armenian-Turkish  state borderTurkish UAVs continue reconnaissance flights near Armenian-Turkish  state border
Enemy lost 600 armored vehicles and 6 TOS rocket launchers during the  days of hostilitiesEnemy lost 600 armored vehicles and 6 TOS rocket launchers during the  days of hostilities
German-Armenian Bar Association calls to file a criminal case against  Azerbaijan for committing war crimes against ArtsakhGerman-Armenian Bar Association calls to file a criminal case against  Azerbaijan for committing war crimes against Artsakh
Political scientist: The outcome of the war is still decided at the  front, and not in the USA, Russia or FrancePolitical scientist: The outcome of the war is still decided at the  front, and not in the USA, Russia or France
Political strategist: the United States demonstrates its No. 1 status  with the Third ArmisticePolitical strategist: the United States demonstrates its No. 1 status  with the Third Armistice
Artsakh women and children held a protest in front of the EU  building in Yerevan, demanding recognition of the independence of the  NKRArtsakh women and children held a protest in front of the EU  building in Yerevan, demanding recognition of the independence of the  NKR
Premier: Despite local provocations, the ceasefire is generally  respectedPremier: Despite local provocations, the ceasefire is generally  respected
973 new cases of coronavirus detected in Armenia today973 new cases of coronavirus detected in Armenia today
Premier: We expect the international community to apply the  Premier: We expect the international community to apply the  "secession for the sake of salvation" formula in relation to  Nagorno-Karabakh
Artsakh President`s Press Secretary: We were not provided with an  alternativeArtsakh President`s Press Secretary: We were not provided with an  alternative
Armenian Defense Ministry urged to introduce clear parameters to  maintain the ceasefire and begin the exchange of prisoners of war and  bodies.Armenian Defense Ministry urged to introduce clear parameters to  maintain the ceasefire and begin the exchange of prisoners of war and  bodies.
Enemy forces attacked settlements of ArtsakhEnemy forces attacked settlements of Artsakh
RA Prime Minister: Armenian side will observe ceasefireRA Prime Minister: Armenian side will observe ceasefire
The Armed Forces of Azerbaijan, grossly violating the ceasefire  agreement for humanitarian purposes, fired at the northeastern combat  positions of the Armenian forces from artilleryThe Armed Forces of Azerbaijan, grossly violating the ceasefire  agreement for humanitarian purposes, fired at the northeastern combat  positions of the Armenian forces from artillery
Another statement of the Artsakh Foreign Ministry on the destructive  actions of the Turkish-Azerbaijani tandem circulated in the OSCEAnother statement of the Artsakh Foreign Ministry on the destructive  actions of the Turkish-Azerbaijani tandem circulated in the OSCE
Armenian Foreign Minister told US congressmen about the current  situation in the Karabakh conflict zoneArmenian Foreign Minister told US congressmen about the current  situation in the Karabakh conflict zone
Diplomatic scandal between Turkey and France is gaining new momentumDiplomatic scandal between Turkey and France is gaining new momentum
Nikol Pashinyan: Clarification of the status of Artsakh and  implementation of the right to self- determination is still a  priority for us.Nikol Pashinyan: Clarification of the status of Artsakh and  implementation of the right to self- determination is still a  priority for us.
Armenian MPs called on colleagues from France to promote  international recognition of ArtsakhArmenian MPs called on colleagues from France to promote  international recognition of Artsakh
Mayilian sent a letter of gratitude to MP of New South WalesMayilian sent a letter of gratitude to MP of New South Wales
Deputy Speaker of Armenian Parliament told the  details of meeting  with French MPsDeputy Speaker of Armenian Parliament told the  details of meeting  with French MPs
Iran continues to check the combat readiness of its troops amid  aggravation in  Karabakh conflict zoneIran continues to check the combat readiness of its troops amid  aggravation in  Karabakh conflict zone
Mnatsakanyan met with representatives of Armenian community  institutions in WashingtonMnatsakanyan met with representatives of Armenian community  institutions in Washington
Armenia ignored Israel`s offer of humanitarian aidArmenia ignored Israel`s offer of humanitarian aid
Consular Section of Russian Embassy in Armenia suspends reception of  citizens due to worsening situation with COVID-19Consular Section of Russian Embassy in Armenia suspends reception of  citizens due to worsening situation with COVID-19
French parliamentarians upon arriving in Armenia visited to  French parliamentarians upon arriving in Armenia visited to  "Tsitsernakaberd"
Prosecutor General`s Office of Armenia presented factual data of  participation of Turkish military forces in aggression unleashed by  Azerbaijan against ArtsakhProsecutor General`s Office of Armenia presented factual data of  participation of Turkish military forces in aggression unleashed by  Azerbaijan against Artsakh
Mnatsakanyan calls on Azerbaijan to refuse from its maximalist  approach in Karabakh settlement Mnatsakanyan calls on Azerbaijan to refuse from its maximalist  approach in Karabakh settlement 
Frank Pallone urged US to apply sanctions against AzerbaijanFrank Pallone urged US to apply sanctions against Azerbaijan
Brigadier General: IRGC Ground Force has been active in the border  region, monitoring border developmentsBrigadier General: IRGC Ground Force has been active in the border  region, monitoring border developments
23 people died in Armenia over the past day from Covid-1923 people died in Armenia over the past day from Covid-19
State Emergency Service of Artsakh: Azerbaijan continued shelling of  Armenian settlements at nightState Emergency Service of Artsakh: Azerbaijan continued shelling of  Armenian settlements at night
U.S. Embassy in Baku warns of terrorist threatU.S. Embassy in Baku warns of terrorist threat
Artsakh MFA: Azerbaijan is openly and ostentatiously undermining the  efforts of international mediators to end the aggression against the  Republic of ArtsakhArtsakh MFA: Azerbaijan is openly and ostentatiously undermining the  efforts of international mediators to end the aggression against the  Republic of Artsakh
Member of the House of Representatives of the Dutch Parliament calls  on the authorities to stop Turkey and AzerbaijanMember of the House of Representatives of the Dutch Parliament calls  on the authorities to stop Turkey and Azerbaijan
Casualties of Azerbaijani army amounted to 6,614 people Casualties of Azerbaijani army amounted to 6,614 people 
Arsen Torosyan: 800 citizens infected with cornavirus are in critical  conditionArsen Torosyan: 800 citizens infected with cornavirus are in critical  condition
 RA Ministry of Defense: Artsakh Defense Army units destroyed enemy  TOS-1A RA Ministry of Defense: Artsakh Defense Army units destroyed enemy  TOS-1A
Ministry of Defense: Armenian doctors successfully operated on a  seriously wounded Azerbaijani soldierMinistry of Defense: Armenian doctors successfully operated on a  seriously wounded Azerbaijani soldier
Forecast: The successes of the Armenian army will make Aliyev to  return to the negotiating tableForecast: The successes of the Armenian army will make Aliyev to  return to the negotiating table
Sean Penn: Sean Penn: "As too many of us sit on our butts, Armenians are being  slaughtered by Erdogan"
Despite world`s silence: Armenians in different parts of the world  hold peaceful actions in support of ArtsakhDespite world`s silence: Armenians in different parts of the world  hold peaceful actions in support of Artsakh
Karabakh Emergency Service: The enemy used the Smerch MLRS against  the civilian populationKarabakh Emergency Service: The enemy used the Smerch MLRS against  the civilian population
Over 50 U.S. House members call for U.S. sanctions on president  Aliyev; Azerbaijani Leaders for war crimes committed in ArtsakhOver 50 U.S. House members call for U.S. sanctions on president  Aliyev; Azerbaijani Leaders for war crimes committed in Artsakh
President of Armenia: Recent events once again testify to the unity of the Armenian people, its qualities of self-organizationPresident of Armenia: Recent events once again testify to the unity of the Armenian people, its qualities of self-organization
@wargonzo: Turkey has deployed 1,200 special forces to Karabakh@wargonzo: Turkey has deployed 1,200 special forces to Karabakh
Read more



Commented