Thursday, October 4 2018 14:01
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Armenian political analyst: Despite the new political situation,  absence of any real and constructive opposition in parliament will  only do harm

Armenian political analyst: Despite the new political situation,  absence of any real and constructive opposition in parliament will  only do harm

ArmInfo. New political  reality of Armenia is irreversible. A similar point of view is shared  by Director of the Center for Regional Studies, an associate expert  of the "Ukrainian Prism" Foreign Policy Council, Richard Giragosian.

Thus, an Armenian expert in his column in the "European Truth",  analyzing the recent events in Armenia, noted that an unexpected and  dramatic political crisis in the country made the issue of early  elections relevant.

In his conviction, the split in relations between the parliament and  Nikol Pashinyan's government caused a crisis that quickly turned into  open confrontation, as a result of which the "Republican Party",  which previously held the power and still has a majority in the  Armenian parliament, along with MPs from "Prosperous Armenia "and  ARF" Dashnaktsutyun " parties changed the procedure for the  dissolution of parliament and the election of the Prime Minister.

In this light, the political analyst recalled that Armenia in the  past has repeatedly experienced serious crises, from the forced  resignation of former President Levon Ter-Petrosyan to a terrorist  attack on parliament.  "But there is reason to say that the country  again approached a turning point in its political history. For the  Armenian government, these events came as a surprise, especially  given that Prosperous Armenia and Dashnaktsutyun, two parties that  supported the new law, had played a crucial role in May in the  election of Pashinyan to the post of prime minister, supporting his  candidacy in the wake of popular protests. But if you take into  account the high stakes of today's Armenian policy, this step brings  fewer surprises. It gives the former party in power, "Republican  party ", a chance to keep parliament under control and stop the  processes that will lead to a political defeat in case of early  parliamentary elections. This is a desperate step, and the former  ruling coalition has every reason for despair. Recently, they  witnessed a confident victory of Pashinyan's supporters in the  municipal elections in Yerevan, which confirmed the steady popularity  of both the Prime Minister of Armenia and his young government. The  results of these elections have demonstrated how the former political  elite is dying, "Giragosian noted.

At the same time, the expert believes that at least two political  lessons should be drawn from the current parliamentary crisis: first,  all doubts have disappeared that the current Armenian parliament does  not reflect the new political reality and the country needs a new  composition of the representative body, which can only be formed  through new, free and fair elections. "And the second lesson is that  in case of new elections in Armenia, the former pro-government  parties -" Republicans "," Prosperous "and" Dashnaks "- may not even  overcome the passing barrier and not enter the new parliament - they  are too discredited and deeply unpopular. Although, despite the new  political reality, the absence of any real and constructive  opposition will only do harm, because any government needs  constructive criticism and those who are able to hold it accountable  for the policy being pursued. Considering that the Pashinyan  government is an inexperienced and only gaining political maturity,  one-party governance is especially dangerous. Pashinyan, who once in  fact was the only critic of the authorities, knows better than  anybody else how lack of accountability creates a temptation for any  politician, "noted the analyst.

Giragosian is convinced that the current situation creates certain  risks for both the current and the former government. Thus, for  Republicans and their political allies (who have already left the new  government), the fact that they lose political legitimacy, and their  popularity keeps falling, creates a real risk of political demise.  "But there are risks for Pashinyan too, and they are even more  serious. It was planned that the next step in political  transformation of Armenia would be Pashinyan's "technical"  resignation from the post of prime minister, while simultaneously  blocking the nomination of any candidates of his rivals for two  weeks. Under the current legislation, this should start the process  of dissolving parliament and holding extraordinary elections, but now  there is no certainty that Pashinyan's opponents in parliament will  fulfill such a plan. Indeed following this plan of  not nominating  any candidate for the post of prime minister after the government's  resignation, will mean that they have decided to take an  unprecedented action of political suicide, which is unlikely. In case  they nominate a candidacy for prime minister's post, this will make  Pashinyan to mobilize his supporters and again bring the  demonstrators to the streets to complete the Armenian "velvet  revolution", the expert added.

The Armenian analyst believes that the consequences of these  processes are far from being positive and, in fact, there is a  struggle for legitimacy in Armenia. Giragosian noted that for the  government, its legitimacy comes from the "people's mandate", which  determines its popularity, and the strength of street protests.  "And  for the discredited political elite of the past, which has lost  public support due to corruption and the lack of free elections, its  legitimacy is based on imitated democracy through control of  parliament, even if it does not reflect the moods of voters. Despite  the difficult situation, one can state that the new political reality  of Armenia is irreversible. Former government and pro-government  parties are increasingly consistent with the term "former" and with  each step closer to the line, after which only brief references of  them in the political history of the country will remain ", -  concluded the analyst.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenia`s Ombudsman responded to the Shirak region governor`s statements without pointing fingers.Armenia`s Ombudsman responded to the Shirak region governor`s statements without pointing fingers.
Artsvik Minasyan elected as a member of the Competition and Consumer Protection CommissionArtsvik Minasyan elected as a member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission
IDBank Supports the Reconstruction of the Spandaryan Canal: Commemorative Plaque Dedicated to the Project SignedIDBank Supports the Reconstruction of the Spandaryan Canal: Commemorative Plaque Dedicated to the Project Signed
IDBank and Idram Presented Several Environmental Initiatives at COP17IDBank and Idram Presented Several Environmental Initiatives at COP17
Representatives of the Strong Armenia faction discussed the domestic political situation in the country with the Canadian Ambassador.Representatives of the Strong Armenia faction discussed the domestic political situation in the country with the Canadian Ambassador.
Heritage on the brawl in the Armenian parliament: The Armenian government`s political arsenal is practically exhaustedHeritage on the brawl in the Armenian parliament: The Armenian government`s political arsenal is practically exhausted
Pashinyan discussed youth involvement in public administration.Pashinyan discussed youth involvement in public administration.
The Foreign Ministries of Armenia and India held political consultationsThe Foreign Ministries of Armenia and India held political consultations
Alen Simonyan will travel to Moscow to attend a meeting of CIS Security Council Secretaries.Alen Simonyan will travel to Moscow to attend a meeting of CIS Security Council Secretaries.
Opposition factions in the Armenian parliament have nominated a former member of the National Assembly for the position of member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission.Opposition factions in the Armenian parliament have nominated a former member of the National Assembly for the position of member of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission.
Anna Grigoryan: The authorities` proposal to join the process of adopting a new Constitution is unacceptable for the opposition Anna Grigoryan: The authorities` proposal to join the process of adopting a new Constitution is unacceptable for the opposition "Armenia" faction
The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament: If the opposition is convinced that the Armenian people are against the new Constitution, let them put the issue to a referendum.The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament: If the opposition is convinced that the Armenian people are against the new Constitution, let them put the issue to a referendum.
“Strong Armenia”: Azerbaijan cannot be a guarantor of peace for Armenia“Strong Armenia”: Azerbaijan cannot be a guarantor of peace for Armenia
Armenia and Slovenia discussed opportunities for the consistent development of relationsArmenia and Slovenia discussed opportunities for the consistent development of relations
Regular Yerevan-Sofia-Yerevan flights will begin on November 7, 2026 – Bulgarian EmbassyRegular Yerevan-Sofia-Yerevan flights will begin on November 7, 2026 – Bulgarian Embassy
The Supreme Judicial Council will consider the issue of disciplinary action against the judge who recused himself in the case of the Catholicos of All Armenians.The Supreme Judicial Council will consider the issue of disciplinary action against the judge who recused himself in the case of the Catholicos of All Armenians.
The Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia held discussions with the Coordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental ActivitiesThe Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia held discussions with the Coordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental Activities
The lawyers for the former head of the State Revenue Committee: Gagik Khachatryan needs urgent hospitalization, but remains under arrest.The lawyers for the former head of the State Revenue Committee: Gagik Khachatryan needs urgent hospitalization, but remains under arrest.
An oncologist from Armenia has announced his candidacy for the post of WHO Director-GeneralAn oncologist from Armenia has announced his candidacy for the post of WHO Director-General
Deputy Prime Minister: The process of visa liberalization is an important area for expanding contacts, mobility, and ties between Armenian citizens and EU countriesDeputy Prime Minister: The process of visa liberalization is an important area for expanding contacts, mobility, and ties between Armenian citizens and EU countries
Ten people have been detained in connection with a criminal case initiated by the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia on cases of bribery and bribery.Ten people have been detained in connection with a criminal case initiated by the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia on cases of bribery and bribery.
Specially protected natural areas, including green zones, cannot be privately owned, says the Prosecutor GeneralSpecially protected natural areas, including green zones, cannot be privately owned, says the Prosecutor General
Discussions on the candidacy of a member of the Commission for the Protection of Competition and Consumer Interests began at a plenary session of the Armenian Parliament.Discussions on the candidacy of a member of the Commission for the Protection of Competition and Consumer Interests began at a plenary session of the Armenian Parliament.
ARFD Delegation Discussed Prospects for Bilateral Cooperation in Russia’s State DumaARFD Delegation Discussed Prospects for Bilateral Cooperation in Russia’s State Duma
«Here’s the screenshot, the money has been transferred»: IDBank warns of fake payment scams«Here’s the screenshot, the money has been transferred»: IDBank warns of fake payment scams
A magnitude 2.6 earthquake struck ArmeniaA magnitude 2.6 earthquake struck Armenia
The Working Visit of the President of Turkmenistan to the Republic of Turkiye Has BegunThe Working Visit of the President of Turkmenistan to the Republic of Turkiye Has Begun
An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.An attempt to smuggle an undeclared shipment of gold was prevented at the Georgian-Armenian border.
Issues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in YerevanIssues of the pastoral and national mission of the Armenian Apostolic Church were discussed in Yerevan
A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.A conference dedicated to the 150th anniversary of Hrachya Acharyan`s birth was held at UNESCO headquarters in Paris.
Criminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal AffairsCriminal police officers discovered a large shipment of drugs – the Ministry of Internal Affairs
Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine                Digital Architecture for a Sustainable Future: IDBank`s Article in Regional Post Magazine            
First Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream LaunchedFirst Steps in Your Career with IDBank: 16th Cycle of IDream Launched
Rate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency ExchangeRate.Trading. New Digital Culture of Currency Exchange
The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.The National Assembly of Armenia will hold an extraordinary session on the evening of October 29.
An Armenian version of the American drama An Armenian version of the American drama "Closer" will be filmed in Yerevan.
Human rights activist: Human rights activist: "Protecting the rights of the people of Artsakh is a matter of the rights of all Armenians."
Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.Former Justice Minister: Instead of removing Pashinyan, Armenia`s opposition is teaching the public to be content with responses to the government`s actions.
Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.Azimuth Airlines is preparing a backup aircraft after the Yerevan-Mineralnye Vody flight returned to its departure airport due to a technical issue.
One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.One person died and another was hospitalized in a collapse at a sewer line site, according to Yerevan City Hall.
A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.A member of the Artsakh Public Council: COP17 was supposed to be a platform for raising the legal issues of Artsakh residents.
ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.ANC Deputy Chairman: Pashinyan, seeing that the opposition is adamant on advancing Aliyev`s constitution, decided to break them with brute force.
Pashinyan and the Slovenian Foreign Minister discussed further deepening relations between Armenia and the European Union.Pashinyan and the Slovenian Foreign Minister discussed further deepening relations between Armenia and the European Union.
The Metsamor community will be returned 0.12 hectares of land, according to the prosecutor`s office.The Metsamor community will be returned 0.12 hectares of land, according to the prosecutor`s office.
Karen Arustamyan became a member of the Audit Chamber of ArmeniaKaren Arustamyan became a member of the Audit Chamber of Armenia
I see no grounds for dismissing the governor of Shirak — PMI see no grounds for dismissing the governor of Shirak — PM
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
It won`t come down to snap elections: Pashinyan on a new possible solution for adopting a new ConstitutionIt won`t come down to snap elections: Pashinyan on a new possible solution for adopting a new Constitution
Armenia’s Ombudsman: Parliament Should Be a Platform for Democratic Discussions, Not a “Battlefield”Armenia’s Ombudsman: Parliament Should Be a Platform for Democratic Discussions, Not a “Battlefield”
Opposition politician: The brawl in Armenia’s parliament demonstrated that the Civil Contract faction is facing a legitimacy crisisOpposition politician: The brawl in Armenia’s parliament demonstrated that the Civil Contract faction is facing a legitimacy crisis
The Prime Minister congratulated People`s Artist of Armenia Svetlana Navasardyan on her anniversaryThe Prime Minister congratulated People`s Artist of Armenia Svetlana Navasardyan on her anniversary
Gagik Khachatryan`s arrest has been extended for another two monthsGagik Khachatryan`s arrest has been extended for another two months
Armenian citizens who have not completed compulsory military service will be eligible to work as police officers or rescuers.Armenian citizens who have not completed compulsory military service will be eligible to work as police officers or rescuers.
Registration deadlines for medicinal products will be shortened in Armenia.Registration deadlines for medicinal products will be shortened in Armenia.
Lilit Stepanyan has become the governor of Armenia`s Kotayk region.Lilit Stepanyan has become the governor of Armenia`s Kotayk region.
Armenia is interested in expanding cooperation with India in the context of joining the Nagoya Protocol.Armenia is interested in expanding cooperation with India in the context of joining the Nagoya Protocol.
On November 1, Armenia will officially begin accepting applications and issuing new biometric passports and identification cards.On November 1, Armenia will officially begin accepting applications and issuing new biometric passports and identification cards.
Armenian Justice Minister: The text of the new Constitution will be published in NovemberArmenian Justice Minister: The text of the new Constitution will be published in November
A ruling party MP provoked a brawl in the Armenian parliament: a verbal altercation escalated into a fight.A ruling party MP provoked a brawl in the Armenian parliament: a verbal altercation escalated into a fight.
Representatives of the Armenian Ombudsman visited a convict who has been on hunger strike for 44 daysRepresentatives of the Armenian Ombudsman visited a convict who has been on hunger strike for 44 days
Read more



Commented
"Strong Armenia": The brawl in parliament was staged to distract public attention from Pashinyan`s failed foreign policy
Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about Zakharova commented on the scandalous epithets of the governor of Armenia`s Shirak region about "Ivanov"
Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.Nikolai Bordyuzha proposed excluding Armenia from the CSTO.
The participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassiesThe participation of Artsakh ensembles in an international festival in Vienna was cancelled following the intervention of several foreign embassies
Expert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and EastExpert: It`s time for Armenia to move away from uncertainty and choose between West and East
The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.The Armenian Foreign Minister commented on the country`s return to work within the CSTO.
The Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behaviorThe Artsakh Public Council expressed outrage at the UN Secretary-General`s behavior
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place