Arminfo.info




 Tuesday, October 3 2017 16:15
David Stepanyan

Avigdor Eskin: Due to referendums in Kurdistan and Catalonia, pressure on Armenia in Karabakh issue may weaken

Avigdor Eskin: Due to referendums in Kurdistan and Catalonia, pressure on Armenia in Karabakh issue may weaken

A well-known Israeli publicist, public figure, political scientist Avigdor Eskin in an interview with ArmInfo discusses the latest developments in world politics, analyzes them in the light of global trends. He also comments on the logic and goals of centrifugal processes in Iraq and Spain. 

 

What are the consequences and threats  of Iraq, Turkey, Syria and Iran, as countries with a compact Kurdish residence, implementing plans for gaining independence by the Iraqi Kurdistan? 

If these countries recognize Kurdistan and enter into serious negotiations with Erbil on peaceful coexistence, then this will bring universal benefit. Kurds of Turkey, Iran and Syria will have an opportunity to build their country. This can significantly defuse the situation. However, if these countries behave aggressively, this will lead to a war in which they will inevitably lose. Iraqi Kurdistan is de facto independent. They control their own borders and even carry out oil sales themselves. The independence of Kurdistan in the created conditions is simply inevitable. These people were victims of a brutal attack by the Islamic state, by the Arabs. And here is the picture - twenty-two Arab states in the Middle East, now there will be Kurdistan as well. 

 

Almost  all countries of the world, excluding French neutrality, opposed the recent referendum in Iraqi Kurdistan. All except Israel. What is the interest of independent Kurdistan to Jerusalem? 

 I can say that Russia has also taken a neutral and benevolent position. As for Israel, we have been cooperating with the Kurds since the sixties. These are our allies and friends. And Israel does not betray friends. From the first years of its existence, Israel sought to establish friendly contacts with non-Arab nations  of the Middle East. That is why the Kurds in Iraq and the Persians in Iran have become our natural allies. Israel was the first who came to their aid at a time when Saddam Hussein was poisoning them with chemical weapons. It was the Israeli pressure on the US that led to the help of the Kurds. Israel was also the first to assist them in the fight against the IG. And now our relationship looks natural. While Kurds are Kurds, Israel is Israel. Our way of life, of course, is different.

 

 

A few months ago, you expressed an opinion on Israel's interest in establishing relations with Iran, highlighting the changing geopolitical situation in the Greater Middle East as a justification. Is the situation continuing to develop in this vein, or is it already possible to ascertain the change in the vector of its development and, accordingly, the intentions of Jerusalem regarding Tehran? 

 Iran was our ally until 1979. I think there are no rational reasons for the existing hostility today. However, so far the Iranian side is not interested in detente. We expected that after Iran and the Syrian regime collided with Sunni terrorists, they would review their position.

Iran helped the Hamas movement and the Syrian regime too. However, we should not forget that the terrorists of "Hamas" in the course of the war shot in the back to their Syrian benefactors. They are in fact part of the structure of the Muslim Brotherhood. And how great was our surprise when we discovered that Iran had recently resumed financing these terrorists. In this light, while hatred for Israel for Iran is above its own interests, I have to remain pessimistic. 

 

The arrest and imprisonment of an Israeli citizen in the Baku prison showed the presence of certain underwater reefs in Israel-Azerbaijan relations. Describe the state of these relations for today, in your opinion. 

 Israel helped to liberate its citizen. This was an example of effective and noble behavior on the part of the state. Considering that the aforementioned citizen wrote many bad things about Israel. We do not have full diplomatic relations with Azerbaijan. There is no embassy in Israel. But there is wide cooperation between us: Israel sells weapons to Baku and buys oil. The position of Azerbaijan is unacceptable to me personally. They tell us that they are not ready to open the embassy until we create a Palestinian state. This is an unheard of insult! We do not demand from them urgently to create a state for Kurds, for Talysh or for Armenians ... But I understand the government of Israel. This is business, as with Turkey. Although friendship with them did not work. I think that they lose more from this than we do. 

 

After a recent visit to Transnistria, you proposed your own model of relations between this unrecognized republic and Moldova. Is this model, in your opinion, suitable for the unrecognized Republic of Artsakh? 

No, Transnistria and Karabakh are not alike. Transnistria has a quarter of a century as an independent entity. Karabakh aspires to become a part of Armenia. There is a completely different situation. After the solution of the Karabakh problem is found, part of Karabakh will join Armenia de jure. And Transnistria can in fact exist further as an independent entity. At the same time, I can assume that pressure on Armenia in the Karabakh issue may weaken due to referendums in Kurdistan and Catalonia. The principle of inviolability of borders becomes less significant. But legally and politically for Karabakh, unequivocally, there will be a different solution than for Transnistria.

 

 

Assess the reaction of the Spanish authorities to the Catalan referendum on secession from Spain. Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy has already stated that "there was no referendum on Catalonia's independence." Do not you think that ignoring the opinion of 90% of voted Catalans creates a threat to European liberalism? 

 

I hope  that the authorities in Madrid are doing everything today to make the separatist forces even stronger. We can already say that they lost both on the street and in the media space. And most importantly, while demonstrating unjustified rudeness and cruelty. In other words, they aroused a burning discontent, while not preventing a referendum. At a minimum, this indicates that in many European countries the existing system can withstand serious tests is practically incapable.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Foreign Ministry statement: The war unleashed by Azerbaijan against  Nagorno-Karabakh is a criminal manifestation of Azerbaijan`s state  policy of ethnic cleansing of Armenians of ArtsakhForeign Ministry statement: The war unleashed by Azerbaijan against  Nagorno-Karabakh is a criminal manifestation of Azerbaijan`s state  policy of ethnic cleansing of Armenians of Artsakh
Earthquake in Turkey felt by residents of Shirak region and YerevanEarthquake in Turkey felt by residents of Shirak region and Yerevan
Greece is determined to raise the cooperation with Armenia to a new  level: Nikos DendiasGreece is determined to raise the cooperation with Armenia to a new  level: Nikos Dendias
CSTO explains why Stanislav Zas did not meet with Nikol PashinyanCSTO explains why Stanislav Zas did not meet with Nikol Pashinyan
Armenia highly appreciates official position of French president -  SpeakerArmenia highly appreciates official position of French president -  Speaker
The Guardian: Demand for private jets to fly to Armenia has risen  sharply in RussiaThe Guardian: Demand for private jets to fly to Armenia has risen  sharply in Russia
ICRC representatives visit Armenian POWs held in AzerbaijanICRC representatives visit Armenian POWs held in Azerbaijan
Greek Foreign Minister: Solutions and peace cannot be built in  conditions where there is a threat of the use of forceGreek Foreign Minister: Solutions and peace cannot be built in  conditions where there is a threat of the use of force
Armenian Foreign Minister on Azerbaijani aggression: Inadequate,  equating responses to the aggressor and the target of aggression lead  to new crimesArmenian Foreign Minister on Azerbaijani aggression: Inadequate,  equating responses to the aggressor and the target of aggression lead  to new crimes
U.S. Ambassador: Our primary task is to support the normalization of  relations between Baku and YerevanU.S. Ambassador: Our primary task is to support the normalization of  relations between Baku and Yerevan
CoE to continue its efforts on return of Armenian POWs and civiliansCoE to continue its efforts on return of Armenian POWs and civilians
There are about 80 Armenian prisoners of war, whose presence the  Azerbaijani authorities still do not recognize - human rights  activistThere are about 80 Armenian prisoners of war, whose presence the  Azerbaijani authorities still do not recognize - human rights  activist
The first president of Armenia did not change his approaches -  OppositionistThe first president of Armenia did not change his approaches -  Oppositionist
Former President: This is the time for us to make hard, painful  decisions.Former President: This is the time for us to make hard, painful  decisions.
There is no such political force in the world that could force  Azerbaijan to give up its claims to Nagorno- Karabakh.- AnalystThere is no such political force in the world that could force  Azerbaijan to give up its claims to Nagorno- Karabakh.- Analyst
RA Security Council Secretary: Baku invaded Armenia`s sovereign  territory and threatens its democracyRA Security Council Secretary: Baku invaded Armenia`s sovereign  territory and threatens its democracy
44-day war result of ruling regime`s inability 44-day war result of ruling regime`s inability 
Artsakh issue settled - Levon Ter-PetrosyanArtsakh issue settled - Levon Ter-Petrosyan
U.S. Embassy in Armenia issues statement on 2nd anniversary of the  44-day warU.S. Embassy in Armenia issues statement on 2nd anniversary of the  44-day war
UNODC, Armenia sign New Roadmap of Cooperation to address drug and  crime related challengesUNODC, Armenia sign New Roadmap of Cooperation to address drug and  crime related challenges
Armenia, Nagorno-Karabakh mark 2nd anniversary of Azerbaijan`s  aggression against Nagorno-Karabakh Armenia, Nagorno-Karabakh mark 2nd anniversary of Azerbaijan`s  aggression against Nagorno-Karabakh 
Continued engagement directly between Armenia and Azerbaijan meets  their and regional interests - U.S.  Department of State Continued engagement directly between Armenia and Azerbaijan meets  their and regional interests - U.S.  Department of State 
France demanded Azerbaijani forces` return to their initial positions  - Emmanuel Macron France demanded Azerbaijani forces` return to their initial positions  - Emmanuel Macron 
U.S. considering selling arms to ArmeniaU.S. considering selling arms to Armenia
Speculations on non-existent precise border between Armenia and  Azerbaijan have nothing to do with reality Speculations on non-existent precise border between Armenia and  Azerbaijan have nothing to do with reality 
Armenia does not participate in CSTO exercises launched in KazakhstanArmenia does not participate in CSTO exercises launched in Kazakhstan
Jackie Speier introduces resolution holding Azerbaijan accountable  for war crimesJackie Speier introduces resolution holding Azerbaijan accountable  for war crimes
Team Telecom Armenia awarded Koreez-2022 winners with prizesTeam Telecom Armenia awarded Koreez-2022 winners with prizes
Valerie Boyer launches campaign in support of ArmeniaValerie Boyer launches campaign in support of Armenia
British Embassy on Azerbaijani aggression: Armed Forces should be  withdrawn to the positions they held prior to this outbreak of  hostilitiesBritish Embassy on Azerbaijani aggression: Armed Forces should be  withdrawn to the positions they held prior to this outbreak of  hostilities
 USD 25 million to support the private sector USD 25 million to support the private sector
Belarusian FM`s remarks about Nancy Pelosi`s Armenia visit  inappropriate - Zohrab MnatsakanyanBelarusian FM`s remarks about Nancy Pelosi`s Armenia visit  inappropriate - Zohrab Mnatsakanyan
Parents of missing servicemen protesting in front of Armenia`s  defense office Parents of missing servicemen protesting in front of Armenia`s  defense office 
Armenia, Spain see need for developing relations Armenia, Spain see need for developing relations 
Armenia`s premier arrives in France for working visit Armenia`s premier arrives in France for working visit 
Azerbaijan requests additional time from ECHR to provide information  on Armenian POWsAzerbaijan requests additional time from ECHR to provide information  on Armenian POWs
Artsakh FM meets with U.S. Congressman Adam SchiffArtsakh FM meets with U.S. Congressman Adam Schiff
Azerbaijani servicemen send killed Armenian soldier`s photo to his  wife via WhatsApp - Tatoyan FoundationAzerbaijani servicemen send killed Armenian soldier`s photo to his  wife via WhatsApp - Tatoyan Foundation
Armenian FM holds meetings in New York Armenian FM holds meetings in New York 
Armenian Security Council Sec leaves for U.S. Armenian Security Council Sec leaves for U.S. 
Non-targeted responses provide fertile ground for new Azerbaijani  aggressions - Armenian FMNon-targeted responses provide fertile ground for new Azerbaijani  aggressions - Armenian FM
U.S. Sec of State comments on his meeting with Armenia`s premierU.S. Sec of State comments on his meeting with Armenia`s premier
Armenian, Georgian PMs meet in New York: Georgia`s premier reaffirms  readiness to contribute to regional peaceArmenian, Georgian PMs meet in New York: Georgia`s premier reaffirms  readiness to contribute to regional peace
Armenia`s premier meets with European Council president, stresses  need for addressed assessments over Azerbaijani aggressionArmenia`s premier meets with European Council president, stresses  need for addressed assessments over Azerbaijani aggression
Armenia premier meets with European Council president, stresses  need for addressed assessments over Azerbaijani aggressionU.N. Sec Gen concerned over tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani borderArmenia premier meets with European Council president, stresses  need for addressed assessments over Azerbaijani aggressionU.N. Sec Gen concerned over tension on Armenian-Azerbaijani border
Azerbaijani foreign office accuses U.S. Embassy in Armenia of bias Azerbaijani foreign office accuses U.S. Embassy in Armenia of bias 
Informal meeting of Armenian, Azerbaijani Deputy Premiers was held in  MoscowInformal meeting of Armenian, Azerbaijani Deputy Premiers was held in  Moscow
Azerbaijan handed over six more bodies of Armenian servicemen to  ArmeniaAzerbaijan handed over six more bodies of Armenian servicemen to  Armenia
Mher Grigoryan: Azerbaijan`s aggressive policy is aimed at  frustrating efforts to establish peace in the regionMher Grigoryan: Azerbaijan`s aggressive policy is aimed at  frustrating efforts to establish peace in the region
French Embassy urges its citizens to avoid from trips to  Armenian-Azerbaijani border zonesFrench Embassy urges its citizens to avoid from trips to  Armenian-Azerbaijani border zones
Valerie Pecresse expresses her support for territorial integrity of  ArmeniaValerie Pecresse expresses her support for territorial integrity of  Armenia
First Armenian-Canadian inter-MFA political consultations were held  in OttawaFirst Armenian-Canadian inter-MFA political consultations were held  in Ottawa
U.S. Embassy in Armenia advises its citizens to avoid from traveling  to Gegharkunik, Syunik, Tavush, Ararat and Vayots DzorU.S. Embassy in Armenia advises its citizens to avoid from traveling  to Gegharkunik, Syunik, Tavush, Ararat and Vayots Dzor
Opinion: Nikol Pashinyan ejected from the game everyone who could  independently change something in favor of the Armenians in the  situation with AzerbaijanOpinion: Nikol Pashinyan ejected from the game everyone who could  independently change something in favor of the Armenians in the  situation with Azerbaijan
Tigran Avinyan was elected Deputy Mayor of YerevanTigran Avinyan was elected Deputy Mayor of Yerevan
Powers of judge Alexander Azaryan, who released Robert Kocharyan from  arrest in 2018, were terminatedPowers of judge Alexander Azaryan, who released Robert Kocharyan from  arrest in 2018, were terminated
Senator Bob Menendez calls on Biden administration to cut U.S.  assistance to AzerbaijanSenator Bob Menendez calls on Biden administration to cut U.S.  assistance to Azerbaijan
Experts and politicians comment on Armenian premier`s speech at 77th  session of U.N. General AssemblyExperts and politicians comment on Armenian premier`s speech at 77th  session of U.N. General Assembly
Azerbaijan misleads the international community with lies - Tatoyan  FoundationAzerbaijan misleads the international community with lies - Tatoyan  Foundation
Georgia ready to serve as venue for Armenian-Azerbaijani dialogue to  bring much-needed peace to region - Irakli Garibashvili Georgia ready to serve as venue for Armenian-Azerbaijani dialogue to  bring much-needed peace to region - Irakli Garibashvili 
Read more



Commented