Monday, September 28 2026 13:22
Aline Grigoryan

International Law Specialist: Azerbaijan intends to initiate legal proceedings against Armenia by sentencing Armenian prisoners

International Law Specialist: Azerbaijan intends to initiate legal proceedings against Armenia by sentencing Armenian prisoners

ArmInfo. Azerbaijan intends to use the sentences against Armenian prisoners of war to initiate legal proceedings against Armenia. This was stated on September 28 at a press conference in Yerevan entitled "Three Years in Prison: Peace and Armenian Prisoners," by Taron Simonyan, an international law specialist and founding partner of the law firm ELL PARTNERSHIP.

According to him, all these trials against Armenian prisoners of war pursued a much broader goal from the very beginning. "In particular, they were intended to serve as the basis for subsequent legal proceedings against Armenia." "It's no coincidence that in this context, the indictment is based on the assertion that the Republic of Artsakh is a terrorist organization financed by Armenia," the expert noted.

According to him, if we examine the case of philanthropist and former Artsakh State Minister Ruben Vardanyan separately, we can see that approximately 100 pages of the verdict are devoted to events that took place from 1988 to the late 1990s. All of them, as Simonyan noted, are presented as actions committed by a single "organization" (Azerbaijan calls Artsakh a terrorist organization - ed.). According to him, such an interpretation can essentially be applied to any official in the Artsakh government and even to ordinary citizens.

"Thus, everyone who participated in the governance of the Republic to one degree or another, including participating in elections, according to the Azerbaijani interpretation, is effectively implicated in the activities of a terrorist organization and, therefore, becomes subject to criminal prosecution. Even without a thorough analysis, it is obvious that all of this is being done with one goal in mind: to accuse Armenia of inciting crimes and portray it as the organizer of the events, and Artsakh as a tool used against Azerbaijan," the international law specialist explained.

He also noted that the sentences handed down have not only numerous legal problems but also technical flaws. "Representatives of the Azerbaijani judicial system even committed technical errors, which could have serious consequences for our compatriots," Simonyan emphasized.

In turn, international expert and specialist in peacebuilding and conflict resolution Hrayr Palean noted that sentencing prisoners is also an act of revenge. According to him, Azerbaijan is avenging the defeat it suffered in the 1990s. Thus, as Palean noted, attempts are being made to humiliate Armenians and deprive them of their dignity.

Speaking about the peace process, he noted that in his 30 years of professional practice, he has never encountered a situation where two countries continued to hold prisoners as part of a peace process, especially given the declarations of peace and the signing of the Washington Declaration of Peace. In this regard, Palean noted that, if events unfold in this way, the country will ultimately receive only a "cold peace."

"Cold peace" in the context of conflict resolution is a concept that describes a situation in which a peace treaty is formally concluded between countries and peace is established, but in reality, this peace remains fragile and temporary," the expert explained.

It should be noted that the exact number of Armenian prisoners of war and hostages held in Azerbaijani prisons is still unknown. Experts estimate the number to be several hundred. Today, Azerbaijani authorities confirm the presence of 19 Armenians in their custody. Among those held in Azerbaijani captivity are eight former and current members of the military-political leadership of Artsakh. These include former Artsakh presidents Arkady Ghukasyan, Bako Sahakyan, and Arayik Harutyunyan; former Foreign Minister Davit Babayan; as well as Parliament Speaker Davit Ishkhanyan; former Commander of the Artsakh Defense Army General Levon Mnatsakanyan; General David Manukyan; and former State Minister Ruben Vardanyan.

In February, a Baku puppet court sentenced Arayik Harutyunyan, Davit Babayan, Davit Ishkhanyan, Davit Manukyan, and Levon Mnatsakanyan to life imprisonment on trumped-up charges, and Bako Sahakyan, Arkady Ghukasyan, and Ruben Vardanyan to 20 years in prison. The so-called court sentenced the remaining Artsakh residents to up to 15 years in prison.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
The Country for Life party will participate in the local government elections in the Noyemberyan community on November 29.The Country for Life party will participate in the local government elections in the Noyemberyan community on November 29.
The Armenian parliamentary delegation will participate in the international conference The Armenian parliamentary delegation will participate in the international conference "Foundations of European Civilization - 1700 Years of Christianity in Georgia"
The Chairman of the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia will participate in the European Conference of Speakers of Parliaments, which will be held in Rome.The Chairman of the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia will participate in the European Conference of Speakers of Parliaments, which will be held in Rome.
A criminal investigation has been opened into the fire at the Tsitsernakaberd substation – the Investigative CommitteeA criminal investigation has been opened into the fire at the Tsitsernakaberd substation – the Investigative Committee
International Law Specialist: Azerbaijan intends to initiate legal proceedings against Armenia by sentencing Armenian prisonersInternational Law Specialist: Azerbaijan intends to initiate legal proceedings against Armenia by sentencing Armenian prisoners
Three plots of land with a total area of 5.9 hectares have been returned to the Berd community of the Tavush region - Prosecutor General`s OfficeThree plots of land with a total area of 5.9 hectares have been returned to the Berd community of the Tavush region - Prosecutor General`s Office
Back to the USSR: An opposition deputy on the elections in the Tumanyan community of Armenia`s Lori regionBack to the USSR: An opposition deputy on the elections in the Tumanyan community of Armenia`s Lori region
Public Television (PTA) apologized for broadcasting Tata Simonyan`s concert on the anniversary of the 44-day Artsakh WarPublic Television (PTA) apologized for broadcasting Tata Simonyan`s concert on the anniversary of the 44-day Artsakh War
An Armenian Turkologist spoke out against attempts to deny the value of Artsakh and the liberation of Armenia.An Armenian Turkologist spoke out against attempts to deny the value of Artsakh and the liberation of Armenia.
The structure of the investigation into the March 1 case has changed and is now divided into five areas.The structure of the investigation into the March 1 case has changed and is now divided into five areas.
Dalma Garden Mall will be closed on September 28Dalma Garden Mall will be closed on September 28
From September 28 to 30, the air temperature in Armenia will drop by 3–6 degrees.From September 28 to 30, the air temperature in Armenia will drop by 3–6 degrees.
The Armenian Foreign Minister took part in discussions on AI at the UN headquartersThe Armenian Foreign Minister took part in discussions on AI at the UN headquarters
Srbuhi Galyan was elected Vice-President of the 15th United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal JusticeSrbuhi Galyan was elected Vice-President of the 15th United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice
Armenia is the initiator of the adoption of a political declaration on pandemicsArmenia is the initiator of the adoption of a political declaration on pandemics
Armenia and Nepal intend to intensify business ties in a number of areasArmenia and Nepal intend to intensify business ties in a number of areas
The Central Election Commission has determined the numbers of parties and blocs for the local government elections on October 25The Central Election Commission has determined the numbers of parties and blocs for the local government elections on October 25
De facto peace has been reached between Azerbaijan and Armenia, according to BayramovDe facto peace has been reached between Azerbaijan and Armenia, according to Bayramov
Armenia signed agreements with Angola and Rwanda on visa exemption for persons with official, special, and diplomatic passportsArmenia signed agreements with Angola and Rwanda on visa exemption for persons with official, special, and diplomatic passports
Armenia and Hungary expressed their readiness to develop a promising partnershipArmenia and Hungary expressed their readiness to develop a promising partnership
A meeting with the Russian Ambassador was held at the Ministry of Technology and IndustryA meeting with the Russian Ambassador was held at the Ministry of Technology and Industry
Even in its statement to the Georgian Patriarchate, the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry did not avoid mentioning the Armenian Church.Even in its statement to the Georgian Patriarchate, the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry did not avoid mentioning the Armenian Church.
Samvel Karapetyan: Armenia`s European integration agenda is aimed against RussiaSamvel Karapetyan: Armenia`s European integration agenda is aimed against Russia
Samvel Karapetyan: Following external dictates, talking about Armenia`s sovereignty is pointless.Samvel Karapetyan: Following external dictates, talking about Armenia`s sovereignty is pointless.
PAP Press Secretary: Trucks carrying Tsarukyan`s PAP Press Secretary: Trucks carrying Tsarukyan`s "Noah" cognac have been unable to enter Russia for almost 20 days.
Rate.Trading: Currency Exchange on a New Digital PlatformRate.Trading: Currency Exchange on a New Digital Platform
A Career Start with Idram and IDBankA Career Start with Idram and IDBank
Poll: About 65% of respondents believe the presence of a Russian base   in Armenia is necessary Poll: About 65% of respondents believe the presence of a Russian base   in Armenia is necessary 
Suren Surenyants: Suren Surenyants: "Pashinyan has begun a process of total redistribution of property in the country."
Marta Koss called on European consumers to include Armenian products in their shopping baskets.Marta Koss called on European consumers to include Armenian products in their shopping baskets.
A meeting with the Iranian ambassador took place at the Security CouncilA meeting with the Iranian ambassador took place at the Security Council
The third president of the Republic of Armenia must attend the next court hearings.The third president of the Republic of Armenia must attend the next court hearings.
Armenia and Morocco expressed political readiness to establish closer tiesArmenia and Morocco expressed political readiness to establish closer ties
Terminator and Titanic director James Cameron will visit Armenia.Terminator and Titanic director James Cameron will visit Armenia.
The Speaker of the National Assembly and the Ambassador discussed issues related to the development and deepening of bilateral relations between Armenia and the NetherlandsThe Speaker of the National Assembly and the Ambassador discussed issues related to the development and deepening of bilateral relations between Armenia and the Netherlands
Poll: 59% of respondents believe that the Armenian authorities have no right to transfer Tigranashen to AzerbaijanPoll: 59% of respondents believe that the Armenian authorities have no right to transfer Tigranashen to Azerbaijan
The Secretary of the Armenian Security Council received the Czech AmbassadorThe Secretary of the Armenian Security Council received the Czech Ambassador
From September 25, tropical warm air masses will leave ArmeniaFrom September 25, tropical warm air masses will leave Armenia
Poll: About 60% of Armenian citizens surveyed believe it is necessary to hold a referendum to choose between the EAEU and the EUPoll: About 60% of Armenian citizens surveyed believe it is necessary to hold a referendum to choose between the EAEU and the EU
Poll: 54% of respondents believe there are political prisoners in ArmeniaPoll: 54% of respondents believe there are political prisoners in Armenia
Poll: 31% of Armenian residents approve of the work of the Prime Minister, while 29.3% disapprove of it at allPoll: 31% of Armenian residents approve of the work of the Prime Minister, while 29.3% disapprove of it at all
ARF: The Armenian people are facing a fateful turning pointARF: The Armenian people are facing a fateful turning point
Russia`s Security Council: The refusal of Russian gas will be far more painful for Armenia than for European countriesRussia`s Security Council: The refusal of Russian gas will be far more painful for Armenia than for European countries
The German Foundation for International Legal Cooperation will assist specialists of the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia in developing their professional competencies.The German Foundation for International Legal Cooperation will assist specialists of the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Republic of Armenia in developing their professional competencies.
Armenia and France emphasize the importance of cooperation in the economic, infrastructure, educational, and cultural spheresArmenia and France emphasize the importance of cooperation in the economic, infrastructure, educational, and cultural spheres
Robert Abisoghomonyan: Developing human capital and protecting vulnerable groups are a development priority for ArmeniaRobert Abisoghomonyan: Developing human capital and protecting vulnerable groups are a development priority for Armenia
Russian political scientist: Moscow`s reaction to the TRIPP project will largely depend on the trend in Russian-American relationsRussian political scientist: Moscow`s reaction to the TRIPP project will largely depend on the trend in Russian-American relations
The Speaker of the National Assembly of Armenia and the Lithuanian Ambassador discussed bilateral cooperation between Yerevan and Vilnius.The Speaker of the National Assembly of Armenia and the Lithuanian Ambassador discussed bilateral cooperation between Yerevan and Vilnius.
An Armenian court has refused to dismiss a criminal case against former officialsAn Armenian court has refused to dismiss a criminal case against former officials
Three years have passed since the explosion at a fuel depot near StepanakertThree years have passed since the explosion at a fuel depot near Stepanakert
Ahead of COP-17, the European Parliament will host a special preparatory eventAhead of COP-17, the European Parliament will host a special preparatory event
Mirzoyan and Bayramov discussed unblocking economic and transport communications between Armenia and AzerbaijanMirzoyan and Bayramov discussed unblocking economic and transport communications between Armenia and Azerbaijan
The Russian Security Council: Yerevan faces potential disappointment if it chooses American rather than Russian security guaranteesThe Russian Security Council: Yerevan faces potential disappointment if it chooses American rather than Russian security guarantees
The Russian Foreign Ministry: The EU`s internal market is competitive, and there will be no favorable conditions for Armenian products thereThe Russian Foreign Ministry: The EU`s internal market is competitive, and there will be no favorable conditions for Armenian products there
Media: The United States has allocated approximately $7.5 million to finance Armenian media outlets.Media: The United States has allocated approximately $7.5 million to finance Armenian media outlets.
Deputy Prime Minister: Yerevan highly values the development of political dialogue with China, the expansion of economic ties, and Beijing`s support for Armenia`s Deputy Prime Minister: Yerevan highly values the development of political dialogue with China, the expansion of economic ties, and Beijing`s support for Armenia`s "Crossroads of the World" project
Pashinyan from the UN podium: Peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan has opened up new opportunities for the South Caucasus regionPashinyan from the UN podium: Peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan has opened up new opportunities for the South Caucasus region
Nikol Pashinyan held a series of new meetings with his colleagues and partners in New YorkNikol Pashinyan held a series of new meetings with his colleagues and partners in New York
A meeting between the Prime Ministers of Armenia and Slovenia took place at the UN headquartersA meeting between the Prime Ministers of Armenia and Slovenia took place at the UN headquarters
The first meeting of the special commission of the National Assembly of Armenia on parliamentary ethics was heldThe first meeting of the special commission of the National Assembly of Armenia on parliamentary ethics was held
Read more



Commented
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place
Political scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and strugglePolitical scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and struggle
Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.
Zakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itselfZakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itself
Putin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent characterPutin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent character
Putin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic UnionPutin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic Union
Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.
Aram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  ParliamentAram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  Parliament
Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs Arrested Armenian oligarch on economy and new jobs 
 "In Baku, we gave a worthy rebuff to the false claims regarding the  past and present of our people" – Former Artsakh Parliament Speaker  from Baku captivity