Arminfo.info



 Thursday, January 19 2023 15:01
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Tragic loss of Armenian soldiers; Unanswered questions

Tragic loss of Armenian soldiers; Unanswered questions

ArmInfo.In this story, it is unclear why and under what circumstances 15 soldiers stayed in the burning shelter and turned into ashes. Taguhi Tovmasyan, tanding  Committee on Protection of Human Rights and Public Affairs , wrote.

"And why is the hypothesis of a drone attack on Azat border excluded?  There are a lot of question marks ...  sorry for our soldiers ...  On  January 19, at about 01:30, a fire broke out in the shelter of the  engineer-sapper company of the Nth military unit of the RA Ministry  of Defense, located in the territory of the village of Azat,  Gegharkunik region, under circumstances that have not yet been  established. According to preliminary data, 15 servicemen died as a  result of the fire, the condition of 3 servicemen is serious ,"  Tovmasyan recalled.

In turn, human rights activist Avetik Ishkhanyan, commenting on this  egregious tragic incident that claimed the lives of 18-year-old boys,  noted that treacherous high-ranking officials of Armenia enjoy their  life, with luxurious official cars, state-owned mansions, millions in  bonuses, even business trips abroad.

"The same so-called Minister of Defense, who, after the attack of the  enemy in September with hundreds of victims, continued his wild life.  And the soldier guarding the border in the cold winter, heats the  shelter with an old stove and uses gasoline as fuel. The first person  responsible for 15 victims - this is you, the prime minister, the  second responsible is you, miserable, dishonorable defense minister.  This is not a state, but a mess in the truest sense of the word, "he  summed up.

In turn, blogger Alexander Lapshin, referring to the tragedy with  Armenian soldiers in the military unit in the village of Azat in  Gegharkunik, on the border with Azerbaijan, noted that he had two  questions in this regard.

"I looked at the Google map and found the village of Azat. The  village is clearly abandoned, judging by the picture (I've never been  there myself), and on the right are only residential buildings with  fresh roofs and buildings resembling garages for equipment. This is  probably the same military unit where the soldiers died. If I'm wrong  and this is about another military unit, then correct me. So, the  question arises, how is it possible that just 3 (three) kilometers  from the Azerbaijani positions, the military unit is ordinary  unprotected building.  A hundred times everyone wrote and talked  (including me) about the importance of building protected bunkers and  defense lines - it's useless. The place is shot through not only by  ordinary mortars (not to mention artillery), but even by snipers from  the commanding heights captured by the Azerbaijanis in September  2022. In the event of new clashes on the border, all these soldiers  would die in a few minutes, the Azerbaijanis would cover this  barracks with artillery,"  the blogger noted.

Secondly, according to him, in this case, the soldiers died even  without the participation of the enemy, they simply burned alive in  the barracks. "How is it even possible that 17 young and full of  strength guys could not get out of a small 2-3-story building? Even  if they jumped out of the windows, the jump from the second floor  would not be fatal. It turns out that the windows and doors of the  barracks were blocked? Do I understand correctly that the windows of  the Armenian barracks are closed with bars, and the iron doors are  closed at night so that the soldiers cannot go out? If so, then this  is a gross violation of fire safety rules, not to mention that in the  event of a sudden shelling, soldiers should be able to run out of the  building," he added.

According to Lapshin, if the commanders responsible for this tragedy  do not find themselves in a "closed room with bars on the windows"  for ten years (I can recommend the Nubarashen prison), then it would  be more logical to close the Republic of Armenia project.

"Degenerates have already made comments on Facebook (sorry for being  blunt) that the Russians, the French, some mythical provocateurs and  saboteurs are to blame. " Everyone around is to blame, except for  themselves. "It turns out that foreigners are building Armenian  barracks without any protection from the enemy, it was foreigners who  put bars on the windows so that your soldiers could not escape. No,  it's not your own generals who plunder the budget for the  construction of defensive fortifications, but the French, Russians  and Jews are to blame. Well, as usual. It is very easy to become a  friend for this sofa cavalry that does not tolerate criticism, just  praise the pits on the roads and water, "the second in the world" is  all, you are their friend and brother, "summed up the blogger.,

It is noteworthy that the footage from the scene of the tragedy calls  into question the version that was literally immediately put forward  by the authorities. According to which, they say that the servicemen  used gasoline to kindle a potbelly stove and, due to a violation of  safety rules, burned down. We add that the photo from the place  raises many questions, including about the part of the building in  which the soldiers were stationed. Rhetorical questions arise where  all the money allocated for the army goes, and where are the  notorious ambitious reforms in the Armed Forces of the Republic of  Armenia, about which the current authorities sing so beautifully at  any opportunity 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
UN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflictsUN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflicts
Russian border guards leave Nerkin HandRussian border guards leave Nerkin Hand
Armenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of ArdshinbankArmenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of Ardshinbank
By PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee HeadBy PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee Head
All detained members of opposition movement have been releasedAll detained members of opposition movement have been released
NDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignityNDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignity
If Pashinyan remains in power, then Armenia will become not Russian  province, but Azerbaijani protectorate, which is even worse - Ara  PapyanIf Pashinyan remains in power, then Armenia will become not Russian  province, but Azerbaijani protectorate, which is even worse - Ara  Papyan
Protests of disobedience in Yerevan are suspended until the eveningProtests of disobedience in Yerevan are suspended until the evening
Political scientist: Azerbaijan takes processes taking place in  Armenia very seriouslyPolitical scientist: Azerbaijan takes processes taking place in  Armenia very seriously
UJA strongly condemns all police brutality against journalists  carrying out their professional activitiesUJA strongly condemns all police brutality against journalists  carrying out their professional activities
Azerbaijan concerned about developments in Armenia - Naira ZohrabyanAzerbaijan concerned about developments in Armenia - Naira Zohrabyan
Alain-Richard Donwahi, UNCCD COP 15 President arrives in ArmeniaAlain-Richard Donwahi, UNCCD COP 15 President arrives in Armenia
Lemkin Institute: By parroting Turkish narrative of 1915-1923events,  Armenian premier risks absolving Turkiye of its responsibility for  the Armenian GenocideLemkin Institute: By parroting Turkish narrative of 1915-1923events,  Armenian premier risks absolving Turkiye of its responsibility for  the Armenian Genocide
Armenian Apostolic Church has historically been cementing material  for ethnos - Metropolitan of Russian Orthodox ChurchArmenian Apostolic Church has historically been cementing material  for ethnos - Metropolitan of Russian Orthodox Church
Diplomacy and dialogue are the only path to stability and peace -  OSCE Chair-in-OfficeDiplomacy and dialogue are the only path to stability and peace -  OSCE Chair-in-Office
Armenian FM evades question about legality of use of Almaty  declaration as basis for border delimitation Armenian FM evades question about legality of use of Almaty  declaration as basis for border delimitation 
OSCE Chair-in-Office evades question about help in Artsakh residents`  return to their homesOSCE Chair-in-Office evades question about help in Artsakh residents`  return to their homes
Yerevan and Baku prefer to resolve issues and disagreements between  them in bilateral format - OSCE Chair-in-OfficeYerevan and Baku prefer to resolve issues and disagreements between  them in bilateral format - OSCE Chair-in-Office
IDBank issues the 2nd tranche of dollar bonds of 2024IDBank issues the 2nd tranche of dollar bonds of 2024
France welcomes talks between Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs held in  AlmatyFrance welcomes talks between Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs held in  Almaty
Azerbaijanis destroy Holy Ascension Church in BerdzorAzerbaijanis destroy Holy Ascension Church in Berdzor
Experts discuss problems of Armenia Experts discuss problems of Armenia 
134 protesters detained - report 134 protesters detained - report 
Order to use brute force by police issued by premier himself -  opposition MPOrder to use brute force by police issued by premier himself -  opposition MP
Opposition MP critical of police over Opposition MP critical of police over "efforts for bonuses"
Tavush for Motherland condemns violence against journalists Tavush for Motherland condemns violence against journalists 
OSCE Chair-in-Office arrives in Yerevan OSCE Chair-in-Office arrives in Yerevan 
Armenia, Azerbaijan agree to continue negotiations over controversial  issues Armenia, Azerbaijan agree to continue negotiations over controversial  issues 
Use of brutal force premier`s personal order - lawyer Use of brutal force premier`s personal order - lawyer 
About 50 protesters detained About 50 protesters detained 
Actions of disobedience in Yerevan Actions of disobedience in Yerevan 
Bagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figureBagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figure
Bagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrowBagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrow
Another nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identityAnother nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identity
Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility 
Europe Day celebrations started in YerevanEurope Day celebrations started in Yerevan
Will Pashinyan be impeached?Will Pashinyan be impeached?
Armenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go furtherArmenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go further
IC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knivesIC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knives
Ruben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lotRuben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lot
Russian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian peopleRussian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian people
Bagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premierBagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premier
Police detain activist over violence against policeman Police detain activist over violence against policeman 
Clergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justiceClergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justice
Bagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FMBagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FM
Armenia makes it through to European Grand FinalArmenia makes it through to European Grand Final
Russian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic WarRussian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic War
Our struggle is for justice - clergyman Our struggle is for justice - clergyman
Parliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premierParliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premier
Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader 
"Five Human Rights Defenders" Initiative ready to support students
Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s 
Bagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resignBagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resign
Bagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time  to make decisionBagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time to make decision
Armenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian  counterpartArmenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian counterpart
Refrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police  chief urgesRefrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police chief urges
After power shift, all people who participated in so-called  delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik ChalabyanAfter power shift, all people who participated in so-called delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik Chalabyan
Varuzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush,  and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik.  The choice is yoursVaruzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush, and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik. The choice is yours
"Five Human Rights Defenders" initiative to provide legal assistance to citizens dismissed for participating in peaceful rally
Armenia remains CSTO member: Source in OrganizationArmenia remains CSTO member: Source in Organization
Read more



Commented