Arminfo.info



 Friday, March 23 2018 16:23
David Stepanyan

Thomas de Waal : The Karabakh conflict will be solved only by a generation capable of asking about its need to be

Thomas de Waal : The Karabakh conflict will be solved only by a generation capable of asking about its need to be

Senior researcher of the American expert-analytical center "Carnegie Europe Foundation" Thomas de Waal in an interview with ArmInfo comments on the latest impetus around the Karabakh settlement. He shares his vision of the prospects for international recognition of Artsakh, the positions of superpowers in this matter. Forecasts possible further scenarios for the development of the situation around the Karabakh conflict. 

 

The Washington visit of the Artsakh delegation led by President Bako Sahakyan  has already provoked quite a tensive  reaction, not only in Baku, but also in Moscow, not to mention the US itself. Meanwhile, Stepanakert is making efforts towards international recognition of Artsakh bypassing the Minsk process for at least several years. What are the prospects of this process, to your vision? 

Recognition of Artsakh is the  old dream of  Karabakh people, which, however, did not come true neither in 1991 with the declaration  of the independence of the NKR, nor in 2008, when Russia recognized Abkhazia and South Ossetia as independent states. In my opinion, all the big powers have their bets and interests with respect to both the Armenian and Azerbaijani sides of the conflict. In this light, according to my forecasts, these countries will not adhere to the recognition of the independence of Karabakh, as this will create an imbalance that seriously infringes the interests of Azerbaijan, which in turn will lead to the infringement of their own interests in this country. Of course, US congressmen, the legislatures of the US states, territorial units of other countries are and will continue to take similar steps in the future. However, I do not think that this is possible on the scale of governments and legislative bodies at the state level.

 

You have absolutely and  correctly  noted the geopolitical component of the Karabakh conflict, having conditioned it by the interests of the superpowers in our region. And as in such conditions it is possible to implement the Madrid principles, in particular, their first point, which says that it is necessary to surrender five Artsakh regions. After all, such a step will undoubtedly change the existing status quo not only between the parties to the conflict, but also the geopolitical status quo between the co-chairing countries, Turkey and Iran? 

I think that Turkey, Iran and the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairing countries, as a whole, will not be against the settlement of the Karabakh conflict, even taking into account all the nuances. For example, Russia does its utmost to preserve its influence in the region. Accordingly, Moscow, of course, strives for a settlement, however, not in a package, but in a phased manner, since in these conditions, at the first stages of the settlement, its influence will not only persist butwill  also grow. 

 

You mean the point of the Madrid principles, presupposing the introduction of peacekeepers into the conflict zone? 

Yes, but not limited to. Thus, superpowers, in my opinion, do not oppose a settlement, on the contrary they welcome the very prospect of that. It is another matter that there is no local demand for peace and such a settlement in Baku, Yerevan and Stepanakert themselves. Against this background, the superpowers do not want to rock the boat, press and thereby infringe on Baku and Yerevan in the interests of preserving their own bilateral relations with the conflicting countries. In the end, such a line does not come from the interests of the international community as a whole. 

 

Do you think that the trend of refusing pressure on the parties to the conflict will remain actual  in the future as well ? 

The situation in this sense can change only in the case of a new conflict (let the Lord rule it out)  resulting  numerous victims, aggravation of the conflict. In such circumstances, superpowers will simply be forced to deal with the conflict more seriously, including through pressure on its sides. At some point, we saw a manifestation of this trend during the post-April negotiations in Vienna. In my opinion, these attempts were not very strong. The second circumstance, which can cause pressure, can be caused by the emergence of a new strategic calculation, necessarily on both sides of the conflict aimed at comprehending conformity, based on mutual settlement of the settlement, on their own interests. Unfortunately, for the time being, we do not see such awareness in either Yerevan or Baku. 

 

There is no awareness, but there is a muscle play and aggressively militaristic rhetoric. Are you looking at this background in  realisticpremises, a request for a "big war" in the countries participating in the conflict? 

I do not see any such  request. However, I have serious concerns due to the heated situation on the contact line between the opposing sides, and in the societies themselves. In such a situation, the conflict can get out of control and flare up to the scale of the war as a result of another trivial incident at the border. And here the situation will be much worse than in the April days of 2016, as the parties will try to go much further. For me personally, this is the most dangerous scenario. 

With the neutralization of the "Islamic state" in Syria and Iraq, the continuing Middle East instability, it seems, is looking for new areas. Could you estimate from this point of view  the smoldering Karabakh? 

Such a threat and risks exist and will be preserved always. However, at least today I do not see any external player interested in such a provocation of the situation with the aim of further projecting to Karabakh. Most likely, external forces are striving to maintain the existing balance of power and, consequently, the status quo around Karabakh. Of course, it is not very convenient, it does not suit everyone, but it's better than radical changes in the situation. 

Proceedingfrom all of the above, what are the visual  prospects for resolving the conflict? 

Unfortunately, I do not see such prospects at all. In my opinion, the resolution of the conflict can become possible after a change of generations. The appearance of   new generation, which finally asks itself, and why do I need this long-standing conflict that prevents my integration into the big world? However, before changing the way of thinking in the two societies to hope for change, unfortunately, not worth it. The change of the ruling elites in the two countries, of course, can make some corrections to one side or the other, however, it is incapable of resolving the conflict. I think that this is exactly the issue that is decided not only by the leadership, but also by the peoples of the two countries. In this light, it is the radicalism of the two societies that influences the process of peaceful settlement of the Karabakh conflict extremely negatively. For decades, assuring the people of a quick and complete victory over the enemy, the authorities have trapped themselves, as people today demand an unconditional victory precisely as a result of appropriate processing by the authorities. At the same time, the huge influence of the authorities on the media in both countries of the conflict is quite capable of changing the trend over time in the direction of strengthening the radicalism in the opposite direction. Of course, in case of the appearance in Baku and Yerevan of such a desire and a request for peace.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Termination of service of MIR cards. IDBankTermination of service of MIR cards. IDBank
Our policy is that we must not allow war to start - Armenian premier Our policy is that we must not allow war to start - Armenian premier 
If president Putin wins in Ukraine, it is not only a challenge for  Ukrainians, but also for Azerbaijan and NATO allies - NATO Sec Gen If president Putin wins in Ukraine, it is not only a challenge for  Ukrainians, but also for Azerbaijan and NATO allies - NATO Sec Gen 
Artsakh-related issues not only of social nature - initiative Artsakh-related issues not only of social nature - initiative 
Armenian general rules out any provocations on Armenian-Turkish  border as long as Russian flag hoisted there Armenian general rules out any provocations on Armenian-Turkish  border as long as Russian flag hoisted there 
Official voting results of Russian citizens in Armenia have been  announcedOfficial voting results of Russian citizens in Armenia have been  announced
With With "demarcation" going at this rate it will reach Yerevan:  Pashinyan points out to Tavush residents the need to quickly transfer  4 villages to Azerbaijan
Pashinyan meets with Tavush residents as promised earlier: Details of  meeting have not yet been providedPashinyan meets with Tavush residents as promised earlier: Details of  meeting have not yet been provided
Stoltenberg: Azerbaijani-Turkish armed forces close cooperation  strengthens Azerbaijan-NATO relationsStoltenberg: Azerbaijani-Turkish armed forces close cooperation  strengthens Azerbaijan-NATO relations
Armenia and Azerbaijan now have opportunity to achieve enduring peace  after years of conflict - NATO Sec GenArmenia and Azerbaijan now have opportunity to achieve enduring peace  after years of conflict - NATO Sec Gen
Armenian government`s intention to waive the claims filed against  Azerbaijan in international courts to cause irreparable damage to  Armenian people - human rights activists Armenian government`s intention to waive the claims filed against  Azerbaijan in international courts to cause irreparable damage to  Armenian people - human rights activists 
Ardshinbank cardholders can now enjoy a 10% cashback!Ardshinbank cardholders can now enjoy a 10% cashback!
Higher school buildings to be managed by international company -  premierHigher school buildings to be managed by international company -  premier
Armenian CEC rep observe U.S. primaries Armenian CEC rep observe U.S. primaries 
Contemporary Indian writer Arjun Krishna Lal`s book released in  Armenian Contemporary Indian writer Arjun Krishna Lal`s book released in  Armenian 
U.S reaffirms commitment to durable and dignified peace between  Azerbaijan and Armenia - Joe Biden U.S reaffirms commitment to durable and dignified peace between  Azerbaijan and Armenia - Joe Biden 
Deepening Armenian-Indian relations among Armenia`s foreign policy  priorities Deepening Armenian-Indian relations among Armenia`s foreign policy  priorities 
Moscow Moscow "testing" its relations with Yerevan
Armenia`s possible withdrawal from CSTO should take country`s real  needs into account - Russian foreign office rep Armenia`s possible withdrawal from CSTO should take country`s real  needs into account - Russian foreign office rep 
Region closer to peace than ever before - president of Azerbaijan Region closer to peace than ever before - president of Azerbaijan 
Three Sad Stories about FraudstersThree Sad Stories about Fraudsters
Armenia`s Deputy FM admits setback in Armenia-EU visa requirement  simplification Armenia`s Deputy FM admits setback in Armenia-EU visa requirement  simplification 
Opposition is denied access to draft peace treaty with Azerbaijan -  MPOpposition is denied access to draft peace treaty with Azerbaijan -  MP
Stoltenberg: NATO sought to support stronger partnerships with both  Armenia, Azerbaijan in 2023Stoltenberg: NATO sought to support stronger partnerships with both  Armenia, Azerbaijan in 2023
Peter Stano: Armenia may apply to join EUPeter Stano: Armenia may apply to join EU
Azerbaijanis destroy13th-century Armenian khachkar in village of  Tsar, Shaumyan region of occupied ArtsakhAzerbaijanis destroy13th-century Armenian khachkar in village of  Tsar, Shaumyan region of occupied Artsakh
Zatulin: Strengthening Armenian-EU relations to require  revision of  Armenia`s membership in EAEUZatulin: Strengthening Armenian-EU relations to require  revision of  Armenia`s membership in EAEU
Basic principles of settling Armenian-Azerbaijani relations remain  unchanged - MFABasic principles of settling Armenian-Azerbaijani relations remain  unchanged - MFA
Oppositionist: Armenian government has failed its program, including  through CSTOOppositionist: Armenian government has failed its program, including  through CSTO
Foreign Minister: We are not negotiating surrender of villages in  Tavush region to AzerbaijanForeign Minister: We are not negotiating surrender of villages in  Tavush region to Azerbaijan
Foreign office: Today, mutual understanding between Yerevan and Baku  regarding mutual recognition of territorial integrity is higher than  month agoForeign office: Today, mutual understanding between Yerevan and Baku  regarding mutual recognition of territorial integrity is higher than  month ago
Statue honoring Soghomon Tehlirian unveiled in MarseilleStatue honoring Soghomon Tehlirian unveiled in Marseille
Armenian Revolutionary Federation holds protest in front of Armenian  Consulate in Los AngelesArmenian Revolutionary Federation holds protest in front of Armenian  Consulate in Los Angeles
Azerbaijan-Iran conflict predestined - Stepan Danielyan Azerbaijan-Iran conflict predestined - Stepan Danielyan 
Turkmenistan and Austria aim to expand the boundaries of bilateral cooperationTurkmenistan and Austria aim to expand the boundaries of bilateral cooperation
Senior Russian diplomat discusses Ukraine, South Caucasus at talks in  AnkaraSenior Russian diplomat discusses Ukraine, South Caucasus at talks in  Ankara
Armenian, Artsakh political forces issue joint statement  Armenian, Artsakh political forces issue joint statement
Our main goal is to return to Artsakh soil - Andrei SergeenkoOur main goal is to return to Artsakh soil - Andrei Sergeenko
AAA disappointed with financial aid to Armenia next year AAA disappointed with financial aid to Armenia next year 
Armenia committed to work actively on implementation of provisions of  EU resolution - Armenia NA speaker Armenia committed to work actively on implementation of provisions of  EU resolution - Armenia NA speaker 
European Parliament approves resolution on closer ties between the EU and ArmeniaEuropean Parliament approves resolution on closer ties between the EU and Armenia
Armenia intends to bring its domestic legislation to conformity with  ICC requirementsArmenia intends to bring its domestic legislation to conformity with  ICC requirements
Artsakh information Center calls on mass media to refrain from unfounded accusations against Artsakh authoritiesArtsakh information Center calls on mass media to refrain from unfounded accusations against Artsakh authorities
4 villages in Tavush are not included in Armenia`s administrative  borders  - minister4 villages in Tavush are not included in Armenia`s administrative  borders  - minister
Defense Minister: Defense Minister: "Nobody gave the order not to open fire"
Ararat Mirzoyan, Louis Bono discuss current security situation in  South Caucasus Ararat Mirzoyan, Louis Bono discuss current security situation in  South Caucasus 
Kremlin: Moscow to clarify with Armenian side situation around  Yerevan`s withdrawal from CSTO Kremlin: Moscow to clarify with Armenian side situation around  Yerevan`s withdrawal from CSTO 
Armenia hosting Francophonie Days Armenia hosting Francophonie Days 
Armenia`s authorities realizing Aliyev`s agenda by starting border  delimitation from Tavush - Mane Tandilyan Armenia`s authorities realizing Aliyev`s agenda by starting border  delimitation from Tavush - Mane Tandilyan 
South Caucasus stability one of Turkiye`s prioritiesSouth Caucasus stability one of Turkiye`s priorities
Tragic events in Nagorno Karabakh made France develop security  cooperation with Armenia - ambassador Tragic events in Nagorno Karabakh made France develop security  cooperation with Armenia - ambassador 
EU applies anti-Russian EU applies anti-Russian "geopolitical optic" everywhere - Russian  official 
Deployment of the EU Civilian Mission in Armenia aimed at  establishing lasting peace and ensuring stability in region - Paruyr  HovhannisyanDeployment of the EU Civilian Mission in Armenia aimed at  establishing lasting peace and ensuring stability in region - Paruyr  Hovhannisyan
Crossroads of Peace project divorced from reality Crossroads of Peace project divorced from reality 
PM: Armenian border guards wto perform their duties at Zvartnots  airport from August 1PM: Armenian border guards wto perform their duties at Zvartnots  airport from August 1
Pashinyan on Arshak Karapetyan`s dismissal reason and his special  relations with MoscowPashinyan on Arshak Karapetyan`s dismissal reason and his special  relations with Moscow
Premier: Yerevan sees and feels Turkiye`s presence in  Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization process Premier: Yerevan sees and feels Turkiye`s presence in  Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization process 
At meeting with French Ambassador, head of Armenia faction, notes  importance of sanctioning Azerbaijan for atrocities in Artsakh At meeting with French Ambassador, head of Armenia faction, notes  importance of sanctioning Azerbaijan for atrocities in Artsakh 
Pashinyan: External forces also provoked main force organizing ethnic  cleansing in KarabakhPashinyan: External forces also provoked main force organizing ethnic  cleansing in Karabakh
Our political force will follow path of institutional solutions -  ex-mayor of Yerevan Our political force will follow path of institutional solutions -  ex-mayor of Yerevan 
Read more



Commented