Arminfo.info


 Saturday, October 7 2017 10:57
David Stepanyan

Ilgar Velizade: It is no longer possible to ignore the political reality that is being raised  everywhere in the world by the specter of separatism

Ilgar Velizade: It is no longer possible to ignore the political reality that is being raised  everywhere in the world by the specter of separatism

The head  of  "South Caucasus" political scientists club (Baku) Ilgar Velizadeh in his  interview with ArmInfo discusses the latest trends in the Karabakh talks, comments on Baku's position on the centrifugal sentiments in Iraqi Kurdistan and Catalonia. He shares the vision of the Azerbaijani-Israeli relations, justifies the scandal around  the "Azerbaijani laundry." 

 

Not so long ago, Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan stated that during the last stages of the talks on Karabakh, the issues of a final settlement of the conflict are not being discussed. Is the last meeting of the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan a  part of the above-mentioned negotiating logic,  or do you have other considerations? 

I believe that at this stage it would be more expedient to withdraw the final status of Nagorny Karabakh beyond the negotiating process and concentrate on resolving those issues that create conditions for normalizing the situation around the settlement process. Simply put, it is necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the negotiation process in order to minimize the risks of a new war in the region. In this context, the form of substantive negotiations, which involves the discussion of topics in a sequential order and depending on the degree of their importance and mutual consistency, is appropriate. And if we take into account that both the moderators of the negotiation process and its immediate participants are increasingly talking about substantive negotiations, it is not difficult to imagine that the final settlement of the conflict is considered just as one of the subsequent stages of negotiations. 

 

Moscow has repeatedly offered the West, through the American and French co-chairmanship of the OSCE Minsk Group, "to find a common denominator" by permission. Karabakh problem. What, in your opinion, could such a common denominator be based on and what are the prospects for developing a common position of the mediators on Karabakh? 

I think that the "common denominator" in the understanding of Moscow is the so-called "Kazan formula", proposed by the Russian side. We are talking about the return of areas around Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijan, the deployment of peacekeeping forces in the conflict zone. Perhaps, under the condition of parity participation of peacekeepers from Russia and NATO countries, and possibly with the participation of peacekeepers from those countries that have no direct relationship to the negotiation process, this is the subject of subsequent agreements, the deblokade of the conflict region and provision of temporary status to Nagorno-Karabakh. In general, there were no objections from Western mediators to this proposal, but we also did not see any clear agreement. In my opinion, Western countries prefer to adhere to the Madrid principles, which have a common resemblance to the Kazan formula and differ only in details.

 

Comment on Baku's reaction to centrifugal processes in Iraqi Kurdistan and Catalonia. Is Karabakh the only motivation or are there new, more relevant reasons for Azerbaijan? 

Things  happening in Spain and Iraq is attentively monitored in Baku  and  the appropriate conclusions are being drawn. In both cases, we are talking about destructive processes that have the consequence of disintegration inside important political players on the map of Europe and the Middle East, respectively, and the emergence of a new political reality, new hotbeds of open conflicts. Of course, analogies are being made with Karabakh, but there is another motivation in the interest displayed. For example, Iraq, in a sense, is a neighboring state with Azerbaijan. The two countries have close historical and humanitarian ties. Suffice it to say that it is commonly believed that the tomb of one of the well-known Azerbaijani thinkers and poets Fizuli in the East is in Iraq. A lot of Iraqi students were trained in Baku at the time, and now businessmen of the two countries are actively interacting, mutual trade is developing, Azerbaijani pilgrims often make visits to holy places in Najaf and Karbella, all these are connected by our countries. And the disintegration of this state in connection with the referendum in Iraqi Kurdistan, fraught with a serious aggravation of the military and political situation in the region, can lead to negative humanitarian consequences, lead to the growth of refugees from Iraq and this wave threatens to cover the entire region. I am not talking about the prospects of the disintegration of Iraq into several states. Of course, Azerbaijan can not remain indifferent to what is happening, and Turkey, Iran, other regional and extra-regional states support the neighboring countries, after all, the Iraqi government itself in their desire to keep Iraq a single state. The state, viewed not as a hotbed for the subsequent destabilization of the entire region, but as an example of the coexistence of various ethnic and confessional groups within a single country. The further fragmentation of Iraq, and indeed of the entire Middle East, carries risks for all countries, both within this region and the regions bordering on it. The same applies to Spain. Catalans have the right to determine their own destiny - this is fair, but it is also fair that the interests of other nations should not suffer. His happiness at the expense of the misfortune of another cannot be built. The history of the Karabakh conflict,  the history of many other conflicts like ours shows this more than eloquent. 

 

Kurdistan and Catalonia became regular examples of the realization of the international principle - the right of peoples to self-determination. And, given the rapid growth of UN member states during the past and the beginning of the 21st century, it seems very likely that in the future the trend will only gain momentum. In your opinion, does this process have a common ground that fits into global politics, justification, or should we only have in mind the local features of each situation? 

Any referendum on the fate of a self-governing autonomy can only be considered legitimate if it is the result of an encompassing political compromise and is recognized by all parties involved in the agreement. Just like  it took place  in Scotland, for example. That referendum was the result of a large political agreement between the central authorities in London and the regional ones in Edinburgh. At the same time, both of its participants agreed to recognize the results of the vote, whatever it showed. What happened in Catalonia and in the north of Iraq is not any compromise, no consensus, it goes beyond the legal field and, in fact, is illegitimate. However, the main international organizations and states have already expressed their attitude to these plebiscites, calling them inconsistent with the norms of the constitution of Spain and Iraq. At the same time, objectively assessing the situation, we must admit that, figuratively speaking, the specter of separatism has long been moving around the world, creating a new political reality everywhere, which cannot be ignored. This circumstance is already willingly used  for a  pretty long time for realization of the purposes of  various political players that leads to rather pitiable consequences. That is why there is a need to make all these facts, in general, and individually, a coherent political and legal assessment and the definition of more precise instruments on this issue at the supranational level, at the level of the United Nations. Moreover, I'm talking not so much about punitive measures as about preventive measures that would prevent the emergence of new foci of separatism and prevent current people from accepting the form of open conflicts, with all the ensuing consequences. We must try to prevent  the erosion of the current world order by developing clearer and more articulated rules of the game. It is not a secret that the question concerning the fact that the "territorial integrity of states" or "the right of nations to self-determination" has long been the subject of endless disputes not only in the political field, but also in scientific discussions and debates of jurists. Naturally, international law as a whole prioritizes the principle of "territorial integrity" and puts it in the first positions, but how then to interpret the concept of "the right of nations to self-determination", does that mean that the realization of this right implies only and only the creation of their own state? There is no unequivocal attitude to these issues. But in a number of cases there are clear answers. So, according to the EU Global Strategy, sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity of states, inviolability of borders and peaceful settlement of conflicts are key elements of the European concept of security. Does this approach take into account local features, or is it still about generalizations found in the world practice, everyone is free to judge in his own way.

 

The journalistic investigation "Azerbaijan laundry" is just one of numerous Western initiatives to pacify Baku. "Official" reasons - corruption, anti-democratic authorities of the country. Let's talk about the informal and unofficial?

The foreign policy of Azerbaijan is to ensure the greatest possible equidistance from the world's policy centers, which is not always satisfied with influential political circles in these same centers. Various means of direct and indirect pressure are used to integrate Azerbaijan into the orbit of their plans. The example you mentioned is more suitable for indirect pressure methods. Exactly one year later presidential elections will be held in Azerbaijan. It seems that someone decided to prepare in advance for this event. It is something like playing ahead. 

 

 

The arrest and imprisonment of an Israeli citizen in the Baku prison showed the presence of certain underwater reefs in Israel-Azerbaijan relations. Describe the state of these relations, in your opinion, for today? 

In my opinion, there are no significant underwater reefs in the Israeli-Azerbaijani relations. At least, the so-called "Lapshin case" did not affect their condition in any way. Suffice it to recall that the visit of Israeli Prime Minister B. Netanyahu to Azerbaijan in December last year, I must say a successful visit, fell precisely at the time when the flywheel of this case was actively spinning. I believe that if the Lapshin factor played any significant role in the relations between the two countries, this visit might not be at all. Today, it can be said without exaggeration that relations between the two countries are an important factor in regional politics, a unique experience of the productive cooperation of the Muslim country with the Jewish state. Both Israel and Azerbaijan value the long-standing experience of cooperation. A large number of Mountain Jews still live in Azerbaijan, and tens of thousands of immigrants from Azerbaijan live in Israel, it is a resource that serves as a bridge for maintaining humanitarian ties between the two countries. I do not specifically dwell on the known facts of military-technical cooperation to demonstrate a significant part of other factors, often falling out of sight. In addition, Israel is one of the buyers of Azerbaijani oil in significant volumes and an important supplier of new technologies to the Azerbaijani market in a wide variety of areas.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan`s lawyers filed petition with  prosecutor`s office to terminate  criminal prosecutionArchbishop Mikael Ajapahyan`s lawyers filed petition with  prosecutor`s office to terminate  criminal prosecution
Russians in Azerbaijan reported cases of physical violence against  them Russians in Azerbaijan reported cases of physical violence against  them 
Deterioration of relations between Azerbaijan and Russia should be  considered in the format of a geopolitical matryoshka - political  scientistDeterioration of relations between Azerbaijan and Russia should be  considered in the format of a geopolitical matryoshka - political  scientist
Moscow: Russia is sincerely interested in stability in fraternal  Armenia, as it is beneficial to usMoscow: Russia is sincerely interested in stability in fraternal  Armenia, as it is beneficial to us
Civil Contract faction introduces  NA draft statement on  inadmissibility of  seizing  state powerCivil Contract faction introduces  NA draft statement on  inadmissibility of  seizing  state power
Catholicos of All Armenians notes the importance of support from  international structures and organizations toward the Armenian peopleCatholicos of All Armenians notes the importance of support from  international structures and organizations toward the Armenian people
RA Investigative Committee: Searches at Tashir Group Company head  office on the grounds of  money laundering and tax evasionRA Investigative Committee: Searches at Tashir Group Company head  office on the grounds of  money laundering and tax evasion
Armenia`s first president  considers Pashinyan`s attacks on  Church  to be  external orderArmenia`s first president  considers Pashinyan`s attacks on  Church  to be  external order
Ardshinbank at the Forefront of Digital Security: Sponsor and Participant of BugBounty 2025 EventArdshinbank at the Forefront of Digital Security: Sponsor and Participant of BugBounty 2025 Event
Armenian Defense Minister met with Indian AmbassadorArmenian Defense Minister met with Indian Ambassador
Criminal case against third president of Armenia sent to  Anti-Corruption CourtCriminal case against third president of Armenia sent to  Anti-Corruption Court
MP: consolidation of society around David Hambardzumyan`s candidacy  is more than possibleMP: consolidation of society around David Hambardzumyan`s candidacy  is more than possible
Electric Networks nationalization project  is unconstitutional:  LawyerElectric Networks nationalization project  is unconstitutional:  Lawyer
Searches  conducted at the head office of Tashir Group of Companies  in YerevanSearches  conducted at the head office of Tashir Group of Companies  in Yerevan
Businessman Karapetyan`s Defense Council  responds to Pashinyan`s  threats against employees of Electric NetworksBusinessman Karapetyan`s Defense Council  responds to Pashinyan`s  threats against employees of Electric Networks
Mikhail Onufrienko: where there is crime, secret services and illegal  agents  always  workMikhail Onufrienko: where there is crime, secret services and illegal  agents  always  work
IDBank Opens a New Branch at Homplex MallIDBank Opens a New Branch at Homplex Mall
Age qualifications for police service to be abolished in Armenia Age qualifications for police service to be abolished in Armenia 
Consideration of Samvel Karapetyan`s appeal transferred to judge  whose `career growth` depends on ruling parliamentary faction -  lawyer Consideration of Samvel Karapetyan`s appeal transferred to judge  whose `career growth` depends on ruling parliamentary faction -  lawyer 
Armenia, France discuss defense cooperation issues Armenia, France discuss defense cooperation issues 
We express our gratitude for Canada`s principled support for  Armenia`s sovereignty, territorial integrity and democratic  development - NA vice-speaker We express our gratitude for Canada`s principled support for  Armenia`s sovereignty, territorial integrity and democratic  development - NA vice-speaker 
Severer punishment for unlicensed driving to take effect in Armenia Severer punishment for unlicensed driving to take effect in Armenia 
Samvel Karapetyan case `political persecution` Samvel Karapetyan case `political persecution` 
Armenia`s premier threatens ENA staff over political intrigue Armenia`s premier threatens ENA staff over political intrigue 
Armenian NA speaker raises issue of blocking Russian TV channels in  Armenia Armenian NA speaker raises issue of blocking Russian TV channels in  Armenia 
Armenia main goal of Turkiye and Azerbaijan - expert Armenia main goal of Turkiye and Azerbaijan - expert 
Fraudsters using forged banknotes exposed in Armenia Fraudsters using forged banknotes exposed in Armenia 
Armenian, Canadian FMs discuss bilateral cooperation agenda Armenian, Canadian FMs discuss bilateral cooperation agenda 
Eight Russian nationals arrested in Azerbaijan Eight Russian nationals arrested in Azerbaijan 
It is time for us to seriously discuss the matter of stopping the  broadcasting of Russian TV channels in Armenia: Alen SimonyanIt is time for us to seriously discuss the matter of stopping the  broadcasting of Russian TV channels in Armenia: Alen Simonyan
 Labor Ministry  expands access to  state housing program for Artsakh  families Labor Ministry  expands access to  state housing program for Artsakh  families
AraratBank: Special Rate for SWIFT Transfers up to EUR 20,000AraratBank: Special Rate for SWIFT Transfers up to EUR 20,000
A march in support of businessman Samvel Karapetyan to take place in  Yerevan on July 4A march in support of businessman Samvel Karapetyan to take place in  Yerevan on July 4
Serzh Sargsyan didn`t want it either: Alen Simonyan on how the  authorities will achieve removal of Karekin IISerzh Sargsyan didn`t want it either: Alen Simonyan on how the  authorities will achieve removal of Karekin II
Team Telecom Armenia, Team Systems under one roof: new Team Place  smart solutions center  openedTeam Telecom Armenia, Team Systems under one roof: new Team Place  smart solutions center  opened
Armenia`s Deputy PM met with EU Special Representative for the South  Caucasus and the crisis in GeorgiaArmenia`s Deputy PM met with EU Special Representative for the South  Caucasus and the crisis in Georgia
Alen Simonyan believes that Pashinyan`s social media posts on   Ajapahyan case don`t constitute pressure on  courtAlen Simonyan believes that Pashinyan`s social media posts on   Ajapahyan case don`t constitute pressure on  court
There are foreign agents of influence, because Prime Minister talks  about them: NA SpeakerThere are foreign agents of influence, because Prime Minister talks  about them: NA Speaker
Armenia- EU Security and Defense first session of consultations held  in YerevanArmenia- EU Security and Defense first session of consultations held  in Yerevan
Ucom Launches 5G Network in Abovyan and EjmiatsinUcom Launches 5G Network in Abovyan and Ejmiatsin
Armenian defense minister meets with RA military attaches Armenian defense minister meets with RA military attaches 
Professor Armen Charchyan leaves for Spain Professor Armen Charchyan leaves for Spain 
From July 1, 2025, German Embassy in Armenia to offer improved  application service via TLS Contact to all Armenian citizens who need  Schengen visaFrom July 1, 2025, German Embassy in Armenia to offer improved  application service via TLS Contact to all Armenian citizens who need  Schengen visa
Armenia, Iran highlight further efforts to improve transnational  crime control Armenia, Iran highlight further efforts to improve transnational  crime control 
Armenia`s premier sends congratulatory message to Canadian  counterpart Armenia`s premier sends congratulatory message to Canadian  counterpart 
Nonstandard Europe: EU ambassador to Baku enlisted in criminal  circles Nonstandard Europe: EU ambassador to Baku enlisted in criminal  circles 
Azerbaijan cannot do without clashing with Russia in context of  ambitious tasks in Armenian and Iranian theaters - Russian expert Azerbaijan cannot do without clashing with Russia in context of  ambitious tasks in Armenian and Iranian theaters - Russian expert 
Armenia forced to focus its limited resources on servicing its  national debt rather than investing in humanitarian needs - Vahagn  Khachaturyan Armenia forced to focus its limited resources on servicing its  national debt rather than investing in humanitarian needs - Vahagn  Khachaturyan 
Peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan could be success story -  Armenian MPPeace between Armenia and Azerbaijan could be success story -  Armenian MP
Professor Armen Charchyan not allowed to leave Armenia Professor Armen Charchyan not allowed to leave Armenia 
Peace achievable in South Caucasus - Armenian MP at OSCE Peace achievable in South Caucasus - Armenian MP at OSCE 
AGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unityAGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unity
Representatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All ArmeniansRepresentatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All Armenians
Kallas promised Pashinyan EU supportKallas promised Pashinyan EU support
Swiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-KarabakhSwiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-Karabakh
ARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptableARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptable
Azerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFAAzerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFA
MFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against IranMFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against Iran
Samvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorshipSamvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorship
After  After  "velvet revolution" Pashinyan tripled RA National Security  Service`s funding  
Read more



Commented