Arminfo.info


 Friday, December 2 2016 11:25
David Stepanyan

Presence of the joint Armenian-Russian military group will allow Armenia to send more forces for defending Artsakh

Presence of the joint Armenian-Russian military group will allow Armenia to send more forces for defending Artsakh

Former Defense Minister of Armenia, Lt.-Gen Vagharshak Harutyunyan in an interview to ArmInfo comments on the recent trends in Armenian-Russian cooperation in the sector of Military Industrial Juggernaut. He brings reasons for establishing joint Armenian-Russian group, shares his opinion about the current balance of forces of Karabakh conflict sides, as well as comments on the latest changes in security systems of the region’s countries and the European continent.

 

 The process of improving Armenian military industrial juggernaut gradually raises to a new level judging from statements made on quite high level both in Yerevan and Moscow about the idea of Armenia's joining Russian-Belarusian interstate financial-industrial group of “Defense System”. In your opinion, what benefits will Armenia have by making this step?

 

 The cooperation in military sector is very delicate issue demonstrating the real level of relationship between any of countries, and not only between Armenia and Russia. And Armenia's joining tight connections of Russia and Belarus in this aspect gives us opportunities to develop own military industrial juggernaut and to exchange different scientific and technological data. I am confident that Armenia's joining to Russian-Belarusian interstate financial-industrial group of Defense System will lead to the qualitative growth of Armenian MIJ, as well as to the establishment of different joint ventures in this sector. In other words, I see it as a regular step to improve the defense system of Armenia.

  In your opinion, what kind of prospects of developing own defense industry does Armenia have?

Armenia's objectives should be own and joint researches, staff training and preparation of manufacturing capacities to provide volumes as large as possible in respect to production, repair and working out new kinds of armaments and technical means. And it is exactly the effective cooperation and work with Russia and Belarus that makes us hope to reach the results expected in the sphere of military industrial juggernaut. I am sure that such cooperation will essentially decrease our expenditures for army equipment, improving at the same time it's military power.  Of course, we are not able to produce global-range armaments by now, we have no such financial assets, but the process mentioned will promote Armenian industries anyway.

 On November 14, the President of Russia approved creation of the joint Armenian-Russian group, which is the logical completion of military cooperation between Yerevan and Moscow. Despite the fact that this group has existed for quite a long time, this information sparked turmoil in Armenia, particularly opinions are voiced that Armenia’s Armed Forces are passing under Russian command. Would you please comment on the situation?

Turmoil is sparked among the people who do not fully understand the core of the processes and this turmoil is artificial. On the other hand, this is a part of the information war aimed at deteriorating the Armenian- Russian relations. Such a scenario meets the interests of Azerbaijan and Turkey, first of all. In fact, the creation of the joint military group is the logical continuation of the Armenian-Russian military and political cooperation - both bilateral and within the CSTO. But given the threats from Azerbaijan and Turkey, Armenia could not simply do without an ally - Russia in this particular case. The presence of the 102nd Russian military base in Armenia, which is meant to suppress Turkish and other threats, implies creation of such a group.  Joint forces and a single commander are needed to jointly resist the aggression. An Armenian can be such a commander, though in case of Turkish aggression against Russia there can be a Russian commander upon mutual agreement of the parties. The thing is that earlier this cooperation was based on interdepartmental agreements and documents, whereas now it has been raised to an international level.

Do you suppose that the joint Armenian-Russian military group may act against Azerbaijan?

Of course, in case of aggression against Armenia. The agreement does not apply to Artsakh and this lets some people speculate on this topic. However, in case of Azerbaijani aggression against Artsakh, the presence of the joint military group itself will allow Armenia to send more forces for defending Artsakh

So, do you think that the level of confidence between authorities of Armenia and Russia is so high that defense of Armenia’s border can be entrusted to the joint group?

 

 Russia and Armenia have the most trust-based relations in the post-Soviet space today.  Even Belarus - Russia's ally - does not enjoy such confidence, because the level of confidence depends on deeds rather than statements. I think the supply of Iskander strategic systems to Armenia is direct evidence of that confidence. Other countries do not get such systems. They cannot even purchase them. By the way, the Iskander systems were provided to Armenia to prevent Azerbaijani aggression. 

 We already had “Iskander” in April but this fact did not stop Azerbaijan…

  What happened in April was not a large-scale war, but a provocation by Baku to demonstrate to the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs that Baku is able to seize Karabakh in a military way and to make the Co-Chairs resolve the conflict in Azerbaijan's favor. However, Baku failed to achieve that goal. It is only the balance of forces ensured by Armenia - including due to the military and technical cooperation with Russia - that prevents Azerbaijan from unleashing a large-scale war today.  Certainly, Azerbaijan is at advantage in terms of certain types of weapons, however, the Armenian side remains at advantage in strategic and military-political terms. Turkey and Azerbaijan will undertake no aggression against Armenia because the 102nd Russian military base is located in Armenia. The huge gap between the military potentials of Russia and Turkey also contributes to maintenance of the balance of forces between the Karabakh conflict parties.     

 “Iskanders”, “Skads” and “Tochka-U” in our case play a role of nuclear weapon preventing a large-scale war. Are there any mechanisms to prevent local wars like the April one?

 There are both diplomatic and military mechanisms that can prevent April-type local wars. Each provocation should be repelled in a worthy manner - there is no other military mechanism.  However, it is impossible to resolve the problem by means of military mechanisms only. A complex of measures is needed given that military provocations are the only mechanism in Baku's arsenal to influence the settlement, because Azerbaijan is unable to resolve the Karabakh problem by means of negotiations or large-scale war.

  Armenia holds only the third position in the threats list of Azerbaijani unofficial security doctrine, while Russia and Iran hold the first two positions. Why is Azerbaijan so much afraid of Russia and Iran?

  I have mentioned many times that exaggerated military budget of Azerbaijan is aimed not only at Armenia. And beside Russia and Iran Azerbaijan is seriously afraid of Turkmenistan. Acceptance of Iran as a threat to own security is preconditioned first by Turkey factor, which tries to solve own problems in the region through Baku, including the 2016 April events. Tensions between Iran and Azerbaijan are also determined by existence of Southern Azerbaijan as north Iranian provinces. Turkey also affects the relations between Azerbaijan and Russia, second being the ally of Armenia, which, in fact, is an obstacle for Azerbaijan and Turkey to solve common task, to solve the Karabakh problem in their own manner. There are also Lezgians in the Northern part of Azerbaijan, and many other factors. Moscow does not use those yet, but if Baku takes anti Russian path, those will be activated for sure. At that in Karabakh issue, Baku accepts as ally to Armenia not only Russia, but also Iran.

 Erdogan’s intention to topple Asad is just another regular evidence of geopolitical competition between Moscow and Ankara. Considering this fact Russia’s intention to sell S-400 air defense missiles to Turkey seems illogical…

 Turkish air defense systems do not have long-range means. “Patriot” systems, which are of S-400 type were deployed by Turkey’s allies in NATO, particularly the USA on the Turkish-Syrian border after Turkish plane was shot-down only for temporary use, and Americans remained their owners. That is why Turkey is extremely interested in Russian S-400. Turkey today voices intentions to refuse from European vector of development up to quitting NATO membership and to join EEU and CSTO. I am, of course, skeptical about such intentions considering Turkey's addiction to falsifications. I think that Turkey just tries to get from Russia as much as possible, and after to return to NATO.  Within this, Moscow tries hard to isolate Turkey from NATO, and Russia’s intention to sell air defense systems to Turkey is pretty logical in this context. Within this meaning, the military and technical cooperation is the best tool for Russia. Moreover, the S- 400 in not a limit for Russia any more, because the latest armament makes are never being sold. Russia has already developed S-500 and Moscow holds the negotiation on selling S-400 within the consideration of the factor mentioned. But, considering the technical capacities of Russia, this deal will have much more political dividends. To note, Russia has similar military-technical cooperation with another NATO member - Greece.

 Throughout all the recent decades the USA have been ensuring Europe’s security and US forces in Europe are evidence of that. Newly elected US president Donald Tramp’s pre-election call to stop ensuring this security for free raised big concerns in Europe. After this Europe started to make overtures to Russia. Do you think that in this light the EU United Army may be created or the EU may revise its own security strategy?

 

Knowing the European mentality, I could suppose that they will not give up the American security umbrella in the nearest future. That is why we should not expect any essential changes in respect to this issue. After all, that is simply impossible. During all the recent decades European safety was secured by the United States, and the evidence of that is American forces in Europe. And, setting the ultimatum to quit that security, Donald Trump, the President-elect, clearly understands, that 70% of NATO expenditures are on USA, and yet Europe has no option for own security other than US. And the BREXIT is the brightest example that everything in Europe today is not so good, and not only in the aspect of security. The United Army of European Union is an utopia in my opinion. And the implementation of that idea is impossible not only due to economic reasons, because without American forces European army could never stand off Russian Military Forces. United Europe has attacked Russia several times, and every time that ended with Russian army entering Paris and Berlin. Considering also the nuclear potential and Russian military industry, Europe has no chances today. And Trump, who is businessmen, clearly understands that, and that is the reason he requires to be paid.  And Europe will pay, as far as there is no other option. In respect to relations with Russia, taking into consideration the strengthening of China, there could of course be some changes, bonuses like "soft power" cancellation of bans, but the competition between the West and Russia will not expire.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
AGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unityAGBU urges Armenian authorities and  Church to exercise restraint and  unity
Representatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All ArmeniansRepresentatives of  Catholicos of  Great House of Cilicia met with   Catholicos of All Armenians
Kallas promised Pashinyan EU supportKallas promised Pashinyan EU support
Swiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-KarabakhSwiss MP: Pashinyan will hardly work for the return of the displaced  from Nagorno-Karabakh
ARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptableARF  Central Committee in Western Europe calls Macron`s stance on the  situation in Armenia unacceptable
Azerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFAAzerbaijani Ambassador summoned to Russian MFA
MFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against IranMFA: Tehran is closely monitoring Israel`s actions to use the  territory of neighboring countries to renew aggression against Iran
Samvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorshipSamvel Karapetyan`s office: Public support cannot and should not be  subject to censorship
After  After  "velvet revolution" Pashinyan tripled RA National Security  Service`s funding  
NA Member: Processes  in Armenia are its internal affairNA Member: Processes  in Armenia are its internal affair
Lavrov: If Armenia turns away from its allies, it will hardly benefit  the Armenian peopleLavrov: If Armenia turns away from its allies, it will hardly benefit  the Armenian people
Armenian MPs held several meetings in  U.S.Armenian MPs held several meetings in  U.S.
Zakharova: Our diplomats in Baku unable to contact Russian citizensZakharova: Our diplomats in Baku unable to contact Russian citizens
Kremlin: Membership in CSTO guarantees certain benefits, but the  decision is only up to YerevanKremlin: Membership in CSTO guarantees certain benefits, but the  decision is only up to Yerevan
Mirzoyan: Armenia, EU signal  important achievements in bilateral  relationsMirzoyan: Armenia, EU signal  important achievements in bilateral  relations
Mirzoyan, Kallas signed agreement on establishing framework for  Armenia`s participation in  EU crisis management operationsMirzoyan, Kallas signed agreement on establishing framework for  Armenia`s participation in  EU crisis management operations
Kallas: EU excited about peace process between Yerevan and Baku and  hopes for a swift resolutionKallas: EU excited about peace process between Yerevan and Baku and  hopes for a swift resolution
NA Vice Speaker, Iranian Ambassador discuss developments in South  Caucasus and  Middle EastNA Vice Speaker, Iranian Ambassador discuss developments in South  Caucasus and  Middle East
Customer Appreciation Day at IDBankCustomer Appreciation Day at IDBank
Poland met about 85% of Armenia`s requests for legal assistance - RA  Prosecutor GeneralPoland met about 85% of Armenia`s requests for legal assistance - RA  Prosecutor General
Mirzoyan calls on Lavrov not to interfere Mirzoyan calls on Lavrov not to interfere "in  internal affairs" of  Armenia
Samvel Karapetyan`s another message from pre-trial detention centerSamvel Karapetyan`s another message from pre-trial detention center
Two clergymen in one cell to wiretapping - lawyer Two clergymen in one cell to wiretapping - lawyer 
Attacks on Armenian church arouse concern - Russian FMAttacks on Armenian church arouse concern - Russian FM
Clergyman`s lawyers explain his position on nomination for Armenia`s  premiershipClergyman`s lawyers explain his position on nomination for Armenia`s  premiership
AraratBank Joins BAFT AssociationAraratBank Joins BAFT Association
Head of the European office of ARF calls on Kaja Kallas to visit  Mother See of EtchmiadzinHead of the European office of ARF calls on Kaja Kallas to visit  Mother See of Etchmiadzin
Armenian Community of Bulgaria condemns attacks on Armenian church Armenian Community of Bulgaria condemns attacks on Armenian church 
1937 back in Armenia - Bagrat Galstanyan 1937 back in Armenia - Bagrat Galstanyan 
Cathedral of Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin to host prayer service  all week for release of prisoners, consolation of grieving and peace  in homelandCathedral of Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin to host prayer service  all week for release of prisoners, consolation of grieving and peace  in homeland
Armenian FM not to take part in CSTO Council of Foreign Ministers`  meeting in KyrgyzstanArmenian FM not to take part in CSTO Council of Foreign Ministers`  meeting in Kyrgyzstan
EU High Rep holding negotiations in Yerevan EU High Rep holding negotiations in Yerevan 
Azerbaijan has never been Russia`s strategic partner - Konstantin  Zatulin Azerbaijan has never been Russia`s strategic partner - Konstantin  Zatulin 
Watchful eye of Sauron-Erdogan in Baku, cowardly bleating of freaks  in power in Yerevan and Russia`s silence: Armenians expelled from  their places of thousand-year residence in Nagorno-Karabakh - analyst Watchful eye of Sauron-Erdogan in Baku, cowardly bleating of freaks  in power in Yerevan and Russia`s silence: Armenians expelled from  their places of thousand-year residence in Nagorno-Karabakh - analyst 
French president`s statement encourages establishment of dictatorship  in Armenia - ARD rep French president`s statement encourages establishment of dictatorship  in Armenia - ARD rep 
French president voices support for reforms in Armenia French president voices support for reforms in Armenia 
 Patriarch of Moscow and All Rus` congratulates Aram I on 30th  anniversary of his enthronement Patriarch of Moscow and All Rus` congratulates Aram I on 30th  anniversary of his enthronement
Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem condemns incident at the Mother  See of Holy EtchmiadzinArmenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem condemns incident at the Mother  See of Holy Etchmiadzin
IEC supports Samvel Karapetyan, President of Tashir Group of  Companies IEC supports Samvel Karapetyan, President of Tashir Group of  Companies 
Andranik Simonyan appointed head of National Security Service of  ArmeniaAndranik Simonyan appointed head of National Security Service of  Armenia
Armenia Prime Minister  suggests putting an end to the use of vulgar  language in publicArmenia Prime Minister  suggests putting an end to the use of vulgar  language in public
David Ananyan: The ultimate goal of this political play is clear: the  Patriarch and the AACDavid Ananyan: The ultimate goal of this political play is clear: the  Patriarch and the AAC
Mekhitarist Order of Venice supports AAC and  Catholicos of All  ArmeniansMekhitarist Order of Venice supports AAC and  Catholicos of All  Armenians
Minors detained during events at Mother See of Echmiadzin  -  Ombudsman`s OfficeMinors detained during events at Mother See of Echmiadzin  -  Ombudsman`s Office
In U.S., NA MPs presented details of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace processIn U.S., NA MPs presented details of Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process
Swedish Ambassador: Leaving Armenia with good memoriesSwedish Ambassador: Leaving Armenia with good memories
RA Prosecutor`s Office presents evidence of Archbishop Mikael  Ajapahyan`s guiltRA Prosecutor`s Office presents evidence of Archbishop Mikael  Ajapahyan`s guilt
Earthquake  recorded in ArmeniaEarthquake  recorded in Armenia
Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan arrested for two months - lawyerArchbishop Mikael Ajapahyan arrested for two months - lawyer
Armenian security forces continue repressionsArmenian security forces continue repressions
Russia closely following the situation in Armenian EchmiadzinRussia closely following the situation in Armenian Echmiadzin
Armenia`s National Security Service  recalls security considerationsArmenia`s National Security Service  recalls security considerations
Mother See of Holy Echmiadzin: June 27 of this year will be  remembered as a day of national disgraceMother See of Holy Echmiadzin: June 27 of this year will be  remembered as a day of national disgrace
Sati Spivakova: Stop Sati Spivakova: Stop "the witch hunt"! Don`t block the road leading  to the Temple!
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin: The behavior exhibited by the law  enforcement officers at the spiritual center of all  Armenians-particularly the use of force against citizens-is  deplorable and unacceptableMother See of Holy Etchmiadzin: The behavior exhibited by the law  enforcement officers at the spiritual center of all  Armenians-particularly the use of force against citizens-is  deplorable and unacceptable
ANC strongly condemns  security forces` attack on Holy EtchmiadzinANC strongly condemns  security forces` attack on Holy Etchmiadzin
Mikheil Saakashvili states that Armenia has already signed a peace  agreementMikheil Saakashvili states that Armenia has already signed a peace  agreement
Pashinyan s latest accusation against Elseti is another liePashinyan s latest accusation against Elseti is another lie
Diplomats: An open war  declared against our national identityDiplomats: An open war  declared against our national identity
Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan "surrendered" to the Investigative  Committee
Read more



Commented