Arminfo.info



 Thursday, August 20 2015 08:42

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Yana Amelina: viting U.S. to Nagorno Karabakh will Trigger the Beginning of the End of the NKR and Armenia

Yana Amelina: viting U.S. to Nagorno Karabakh will Trigger the Beginning of the End of the NKR and Armenia

 

Could you please share your impressions from the meetings with out analysts, experts and ordinary citizens? Have they proved the viewpoints popular among some of our Russian colleagues and experts concerning the anti-Russian sentiments in Armenia?

I can say this for sure as I was in Armenia when people were protesting in Baghramyan Avenue. The level of discussions around the problems we voiced at a roundtable in Yerevan showed that the level of the Armenian expert society is much higher than the 'average Russian' one. I am afraid there are no such highly-qualified and impartial experts in Russia to discuss the entire spectrum of the Russian-Armenian relations or hold a detailed discussion on the development trends of the so-called 'Islamic State' at least publicly. Real attitude of Armenians to the Russians and Russia has nothing to do with the stories of the Russian television that whip up tension. My Armenian colleagues brought a big number of facts speaking of the real - though not insurmountable - differences between Russia and Armenia and predicted even deterioration of the situation, if Russia's 'let it all hang out' policy continues. Sure, Armenia's leadership is not insane. They should also be blamed for the given situation. Yet, Russia is also responsible for no positive shifts in the social and economic, public and political fields in Armenia after its Eurasian integration. Hopefully, the situation will change to better. Although there are many West-funded Mass Media and NGOs in Armenia, the anti-Russian sentiments are observed only among part of their members and readers that have little clout in public. However, such sentiments do not concern the Russian people. Nevertheless, to some part, they come from the passivity of Russia that reduces its presence in the Armenian public and information field instead of increasing it

Russia’s policy in the post-Soviet space, particularly toward Armenia, is still based on the security factors. Meantime, joint economic projects and successful economic expansion is what strengthens the influence now, at least look at Germany. The situation with the Electric Networks of Armenia showed how vulnerable are Russia’s positions in the field. What do you think of the prospects of such policy?

The talks that economy decides everything in the present-day world is an attempt to muddy waters just like to make a human being with his great plans to limit itself my eating and sleeping.  Eventually, we will have a 'talking pig' or flat nonsense, in case economy is given an absolute priority.  After all, if economic needs are prioritized, most of the people become simply unnecessary. For instance, look at the situation with the Electric Networks of Armenia that was a result of 'mismanagement' and improper understanding of the political and geopolitical realities, not economy. If dollar costs 30 rubles today and 60 rubles in a week, it bears no relations with economy.  There is just "economy" that does not worth discussion like any other game where the rules are changed by the strongest player. In this light, it is clear that everything is based on the religion and geopolitical interests.  Moscow should stem from these very factors in its actions. As to the 'economic' interests, it is obvious that Russia must stake on Turkey.  It is not within the interests of Armenia to make a point of economic issues, though, the Russian-Armenian relations must be economically attractive too.

At the last joint summit of BRICS, EEU and SCO in Ufa, Russia, President of Armenia Serzh Sargsan has actually invited these organizations in involve in the construction of Armenia-Iran railway that will ensure for the EEU countries an access to the Indian Ocean via the Persian Gulf. What do you think about the project?

This project is quite long-term and technically complicate and quite expensive. So far, the situation in the region is not stable. After all, it is not good time for launching such large-scale projects.

On August 3, Iran and Armenia signed a new contract for the construction of the third power transmission line that will enable the two countries to exchange more electricity. Is it a result of the UN Security Council’s resolution curbing Iran's most sensitive nuclear activities for at least 10 years in exchange for a gradual end to all sanctions on the Islamic Republic? Will this cooperation of Iran and Armenia anyhow affect the Armenian-Russian relations? 

 

I suppose such large-scale agreements as the one made on August 3 on the construction of the third power transmission line Iran-Armenia and the other that looks to boost the bilateral cooperation between the two countries, especially by Iran, have been discussed for much longer time than it has passed since the Security Council's resolution. Nevertheless, the developing cooperation of Iran and Armenia will create no obstacles to the Russian-Armenian relations, the more so as Russia also weights various options to expand its trade and economic relations with Iran. The attempts of Iran's religious expansion are another matter. However, it does not concern Armenia, while Russia successfully copes with it and will be doing it in future too.

 

Some Russian media have interpreted the statement by David Tonoyan, the deputy minister of defence of Armenia, on USA’s role in settling the NKR conflict as an "invitation for Washington to Nagorno Karabakh".  Do you share these views?

 

‘Inviting Washington to Nagorno Karabakh’ - meaning the physical presence of American troops in the conflict zone - will trigger the beginning of the end of the NKR sovereignty, which in turn means the end of Armenia.

 

It is quite obvious that the U.S. has a pro-Azeri stance in the NKR issue, which is not going to be changed, for the control over a region of the Greater Caucasus is at stake. The Americans are not interested in the NKR or Armenian sovereignty.  It is to be encouraged if enhancing the U.S. presence in the NKR means putting Baku under pressure to compel it to recognize the Nagorno Karabakh independence. However, I think such changes are rather unbelievable and impossible. It is clear that the NKR conflict situation will hardly undergo any changes in the nearest future. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Armenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest actionArmenians of Berlin met Aliyev with protest action
Aliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, ArmeniaAliyev: We highly appreciate peace negotiations ongoing between  Azerbaijan, Armenia
Armenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperationArmenian, Greek academic circles to strengthen cooperation
Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official Less hate speech, disinformation on Armenian TV channels - official 
Closing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  AghdamClosing ceremony of Russian-Turkish monitoring center takes place in  Aghdam
Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  Date of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs` meeting in Kazakhstan not yet  specified  
India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism India responds to Azerbaijan`s criticism 
Armenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in TavushArmenia`s former human rights defender presents of demarcation of  Armenian-Azerbaijani border in Tavush
May One procession to take place in Yerevan May One procession to take place in Yerevan 
Armenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s bordersArmenian MP, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia discuss situation on  Armenia`s borders
Contract serviceman injured in demining operations in TavushContract serviceman injured in demining operations in Tavush
Armenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc MelenchonArmenia today is in a particularly difficult situation and deserves  attention more than ever before - Jean-Luc Melenchon
Driver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roadsDriver blocks one of Yerevan`s tangled roads
France is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  DevinazFrance is ready to expand framework of interaction with Armenia -  Devinaz
Ruben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strikeRuben Vardanyan`s family persuaded him to stop his hunger strike
20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 20 border pillars have already been installed on Armenia-Azerbaijan  border 
Freedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  TsitsernakaberdFreedom of speech is not highly valued in `bastion` of democracy: 7  people detained due to incident involving Premier`s wife in  Tsitsernakaberd
Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners Armenia`s Parliament Speaker has not yet received letters from his  Federation Council partners 
Current situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - SpeakerCurrent situation in region brings new challenges for both Armenia  and Syria - Speaker
European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29European Parliament: human rights violations in Azerbaijan are  incompatible with country`s preparations to host COP29
"We are waiting!", Russian side expects Pashinyan`s participation in  EAEU summit
Protests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizensProtests in Armenia: roads, streets are closed; police use  disproportionate force to detain citizens
Legitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA SpeakerLegitimate borders are very the guarantee of security that is talked  about a lot - RA NA Speaker
Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?Zakharova: How should CSTO actually act when Armenian leadership  itself decided to transfer several settlements to Azerbaijan?
Vladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levelsVladimir Vardanyan: it is important to develop Armenian-French  cooperation at regional and local levels
Yeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupierYeghishe Kirakosyan: European Court,UN Security Council have never  considered Armenia aggressor or occupier
Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`Zakharova considers reports about recognition of Artsakh as part of  Azerbaijan back in 2020 by Russian President `shameless lie` and  `falsehoods`
Political analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary electionsPolitical analyst:  only way to change situation in Armenia is  extraordinary parliamentary elections
U.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-AzerbaijanU.S. welcomes border delimitation process between Armenia-Azerbaijan
If left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. KennedyIf left without international support, the Armenian Genocide of 1915  will be finalized in the coming weeks and months - Robert F. Kennedy
Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan Those consigning Armenian Genocide to oblivion will not digest it -  Robert Kocharyan 
Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan Russian pianist Ilya Ramlav to perform in Yerevan 
Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge Armenia`s authorities plan demining of section near Kirants bridge 
Situation in Tavush remains tenseSituation in Tavush remains tense
Armenia plans to open consulate general in TabrizArmenia plans to open consulate general in Tabriz
Summer conscription starts in Armenia Summer conscription starts in Armenia 
Armenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schoolsArmenia`s government proposes reviewing procedure for admission to  higher schools
Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert Children in Tavush have been forced to fight for their safety -  expert 
French PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian GenocideFrench PM makes speech on 109th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide
Six Combat Brotherhood members released Six Combat Brotherhood members released 
Actions of disobedience start in Armenia Actions of disobedience start in Armenia 
Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square Protest rally calling for unity against Nikol Pashinyan taking place on Yerevan Republic Square 
On April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of UruguayOn April 23, commemoration ceremony to 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide held at  House of Representatives of Uruguay
British MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian QuarterBritish MP calls on Israeli officials to respond to attacks on Christians in Jerusalem`s Armenian Quarter
President of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgottenPresident of Greece: Victims of Armenian Genocide must never be forgotten
Nikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanityNikos Dendias: Recognition of historical truth is necessary to avoid repeating crimes against humanity
Turkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman EmpireTurkish Foreign Ministry continues its policy of denying  Armenian Genocide in Ottoman Empire
Russian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian peopleRussian Embassy: We mourn together with Armenian people
Abkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian peopleAbkhazia`s Leader: Today we mourn together with  Armenian people
Support for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to TsitsernakaberdSupport for Armenian prisoners held illegally in Baku prison: March to Tsitsernakaberd
`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire`We renew our pledge to never forget` -Joe Biden on Armenian Genocide in  Ottoman Empire
Turkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideTurkish Peoples` Equality and Democracy Party issues statement on  109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
Ruben Vardanyan: Ruben Vardanyan: "Now I understand that principles and values are  much more important than life"
Syrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian GenocideSyrian Parliament delegation came to support Armenia on day of  remembrance of holy martyrs of Armenian Genocide
Jonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian GenocideJonathan Lacote calls for being on side of memory, truth and justice  regarding Armenian Genocide
Pan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram IPan-Turan movement forming aimed to strangle Armenia - Aram I
Armenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian GenocideArmenia`s foreign office issues statement on 109th anniversary of Armenian Genocide
French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide French president calls for remembering Armenian Genocide
In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on  western democracies to recognize it In 2000, 126 scholars confirmed Armenian Genocide and called on western democracies to recognize it
Armenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in VarnaArmenian-Bulgarian Cultural and Information Center opens in Varna
Read more



Commented