Arminfo.info



 Thursday, May 30 2013

EBRD innovation forum skirted Armenia’s innovation ambitions

EBRD innovation forum skirted Armenia’s innovation ambitions

Macedonia, Kazakhstan,
Lithuania, Serbia, Ukraine,
Russia, Turkey and Israel
are the countries the innovation problems of the economic development of which were
in the center of attention of an international business forum within the frames
of a regular annual meeting of EBRD held in Istanbul on 10-11 May of the current year.


 Unfortunately,
the forum did not touch upon Armenia
and its innovation ambitions though our country has always cast itself as a
country which had chosen the innovation way of development. It is no secret, that
unlike the mining industry this sphere is not connected with transport expenses
and does not depend on availability of the semi-blockade communication
conditions of our country’s existence. However, it is very much possible that foreign
innovation community is not yet ready to accept at its face value the pompous
statements that there is no alternative to the innovation way of our country’s
development. But this statement goes on serving a means for the local usage.


  Incidentally,
during the talk about the problems of the innovation development of Eastern Europe
just Israel was serving like
a unique benchmark, though geographically it is located far from Europe. Many participants in the interesting discussion were
referring to Israel’s
experience. And director general of InterIsrael, Maxine Fassberg gave a worthy response
to his counterparts. “We are praying for oil, gas and other mineral deposits be
never found in Israel, as in that case it will be irresistible  not to fall down to the level of the
countries with only a resource-based economy, poor infrastructure  and with many accompanying problems”, - he
said. These words were voiced like the key and important warning to the
partners and governments which  hiding
behind a modern word “innovation”, nevertheless every day keep tab on the quote
of the world prices for hydrocarbons. Unfortunately, Armenia is among them, as it has
got only two key sources for the economic growth – cooper concentrate and
foreign transfers from the Armenian Diaspora.


 Though it
seems strange, but Turkey
itself understands it very well. According to the official data, only for development
of the  high speed Internet the country allocates
up to $1 bln from its budget every year. As the head of  «TurkTelecomGroup» Hakam Kanafani said, development
of this sector depends not  only and not
so much on the number of the people which have the Internet access  as on the country’s investments in the scientific
and technical as well as engineering developments, and on the climate which the
country can create for occupation of a worthy place in the world innovation
chain. It is no secret that just Israel has managed to reach special success,
and unlike many countries of the world, Israel with its IT companies comes
forward not like an outsourcing  country
similar to Armenia, which has been implementing 
small orders of foreign corporations, but like the smart set.  Here we have an effective and right schedule,
according to which just Israeli IT companies supported by the government
establish thousand of branches in many countries of the world, and globalize
its IT sphere in such a way, as they understand very well that the outsourcing
services have no prospect. The whole legislative field and all the regulative
functions of a state should be directed at creation of a maximally favorable
climate for innovations. Here the fragmentary approach is unacceptable and
useless. Only in the countries, which have no system in this sector, we see an
endless brain drain to the West. It is natural that they want to improve their
life quality and to ensure professional growth. For this reason, the countries
which draw special attention to development not only of the innovation but also
venture economy, finally win. Incidentally, in this case they do not rely on
assistance of international donors. Representatives of EBRD, the portfolio of
which has only 3% of bad credits,  said
at the forum  that the bank does not
welcome the financing of the venture, high risk projects by the shareholders of
international financial donors, though everybody understand their significance
for the economic development of the Eastern Europe.     


  But if
the innovation economy in our post-crisis period is the only hope for the stable
economic growth, in that case, how we can combine two factors – the resource expenses
to ensure growth and the regime of economizing financial funds. This problem was also discussed at the forum.
As the English say, “nothing is
impossible”. One should start just from creation of the most favorable work
regime for small companies, not to impose pressure upon them with a help of the
tax and customs administration, to ensure an equal competitive field for all
the economic entities, that is to say, to change the approach in Armenia and
Russia, though the latter manages “to come out” thanks to its big territory and
an endless demand for oil.  Incidentally,
participants in the forum advised Eastern European  countries to revise their foreign political
agenda towards joining the EU as am important component necessary for the
growth of the political stability, as if they do not have an example of Greece, Portugal,
Spain, Cyprus and Iceland. However, there is no doubt
that European standards of business, many all-European  economic directives, anti-corruption and
anti-damping measures and the steps for ensuring competitive field  may serve the best sample for many developing
countries.  A pension reform will not
pave the way to innovative economy for the small and medium-sized enterprises
if there is no competition. This undisputable thesis applies also to Armenia, where
reforms will fail without settlement of basic problems. Even the authoritarian
leaders, inherently dictators, of the countries known as ‘economic tigers’
started with fighting corruption at the grassroots, pressing shadow economy,
creating maximum fair competitive environment, facilitating SME access to bank
financing, creating transparent financial and corporate markets, which boosted
business activity, and only after, launched serious structural reforms. There
are two ways: Chilean and European. The first one was not mentioned at the
forum, indeed, as Pinochet and Lee Kuan Yew remained in the past and the history
cannot be reversed to a great despair of some of our high-ranking compatriots,
especially in conditions of intensive globalization and growing geo-strategic
battles.


 The
European Business Forum in Istanbul, a big city
in the country, to put it mildly, unfriendly for Armenia, that strives for the top
ten of the biggest economies in the world, was a real success. At present, Turkey, and
first of all, Istanbul-Constantinople, is a developed city with 15 million
people, constantly growing population, Europe-oriented economy, and big
innovative potential. Unlike our fading away Armavia airline, Turkish Airlines
are the pride of Turkey’s
authorities. Due to the low tariffs and right positioning, the Turkish
authorities are going to make it a global brand. It is Turkish Airlines that
cherish the Turkish idea to create a regional and not just economic power. This
is another subject, however.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

Nikol Pashinyan is Russia`s principal weapon in Armenia, others are  nothing but playthings - expert Nikol Pashinyan is Russia`s principal weapon in Armenia, others are  nothing but playthings - expert 
Risk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`BrienRisk factors for genocide have been present for many years in  Nagorno-Karabakh - Melanie O`Brien
Azerbaijan: possible amnesty for Karabakh fighters Azerbaijan: possible amnesty for Karabakh fighters 
ECHR obliges Azerbaijan to refrain from any action that could lead to  violation of right to lifeECHR obliges Azerbaijan to refrain from any action that could lead to  violation of right to life
"We are silent witnesses to ethnic cleansing" - Valerie Boyer 
Powerful presence of armed forces to prevent any change in  geopolitics of region and change of borders - Ebrahim RaisiPowerful presence of armed forces to prevent any change in  geopolitics of region and change of borders - Ebrahim Raisi
Armenia`s premier, , EU Special Rep discuss politico-military  situation round Nagorno-KarabakhArmenia`s premier, , EU Special Rep discuss politico-military  situation round Nagorno-Karabakh
Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan negotiating withdrawal of troops,  people`s entry and exit Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan negotiating withdrawal of troops,  people`s entry and exit 
Russian foreign office spokesperson blames France for latest  developments in Artsakh Russian foreign office spokesperson blames France for latest  developments in Artsakh 
It is time for action, rather than being silent and indifferent -  Armenia`s president It is time for action, rather than being silent and indifferent -  Armenia`s president 
No alternative to Nikol Pashinyan`s resignation - Mane TandilyanNo alternative to Nikol Pashinyan`s resignation - Mane Tandilyan
Russia is to blame for Azerbaijan`s blitzkrieg against Armenians -  Luc DevigneRussia is to blame for Azerbaijan`s blitzkrieg against Armenians -  Luc Devigne
Armenia to open humanitarian station in Kornidzor, Syunik province Armenia to open humanitarian station in Kornidzor, Syunik province 
Mirzoyan emphasizeds inadmissibility of Baku`s policy of ethnic  cleansing against people of Nagorno- Karabakh at meeting with Polish  FMMirzoyan emphasizeds inadmissibility of Baku`s policy of ethnic  cleansing against people of Nagorno- Karabakh at meeting with Polish  FM
Armenian Foreign Minister reminds UNSC of its inadequate response to  Azerbaijan`s aggression against ArtsakhArmenian Foreign Minister reminds UNSC of its inadequate response to  Azerbaijan`s aggression against Artsakh
European Commission to provide EUR 500 thousand in humanitarian aid  to conflict-affected peopleEuropean Commission to provide EUR 500 thousand in humanitarian aid  to conflict-affected people
Expert: a- new reality has emerged in Nagorno-Karabakh regionExpert: a- new reality has emerged in Nagorno-Karabakh region
Defender`s Office calls on law enforcement officers to act within law  when detaining participants in civil disobedience Defender`s Office calls on law enforcement officers to act within law  when detaining participants in civil disobedience 
RA Police: At the moment there are no closed roads in YerevanRA Police: At the moment there are no closed roads in Yerevan
Borrell, Hakan discuss situation around ArtsakhBorrell, Hakan discuss situation around Artsakh
Nikol Pashinyan clarified Yerevan`s position regarding possible  displacement of residents of Nagorno- Karabakh to ArmeniaNikol Pashinyan clarified Yerevan`s position regarding possible  displacement of residents of Nagorno- Karabakh to Armenia
There is There is "real chance" for people of Nagorno-Karabakh, Pashinyan  announces
Lawyer: Andranik Tevanyan was brought to Investigative Committee  within administrative proceedingsLawyer: Andranik Tevanyan was brought to Investigative Committee  within administrative proceedings
Bob Menendez introduces bill to support Armenians against AzerbaijanBob Menendez introduces bill to support Armenians against Azerbaijan
FMs of Armenia, Germany emphasize imperative of preventing crimes in  NK after enemy`s latest aggressionFMs of Armenia, Germany emphasize imperative of preventing crimes in  NK after enemy`s latest aggression
Armenia`s Security Council Sec: Yerevan tries to change situation in  NK through UN platformArmenia`s Security Council Sec: Yerevan tries to change situation in  NK through UN platform
Armenia`s Permanent Rep to OSCE: Immediate intervention of int`l  community and introduction of int`l mechanisms to ensure rights of  Artsakh people is imperativeArmenia`s Permanent Rep to OSCE: Immediate intervention of int`l  community and introduction of int`l mechanisms to ensure rights of  Artsakh people is imperative
UNSC permanent members call on Azerbaijan to ensure rights and  security of Armenians of Nagorno- KarabakhUNSC permanent members call on Azerbaijan to ensure rights and  security of Armenians of Nagorno- Karabakh
UN Assistant Sec General voices only sustainable course for future on  Artsakh issueUN Assistant Sec General voices only sustainable course for future on  Artsakh issue
German Foreign Minister: Displacement of ethnic Armenians from  Nagorno-Karabakh is unacceptableGerman Foreign Minister: Displacement of ethnic Armenians from  Nagorno-Karabakh is unacceptable
EU threatens Baku in case of forced displacement of Nagorno-Karabakh  ArmeniansEU threatens Baku in case of forced displacement of Nagorno-Karabakh  Armenians
Pashinyan threatens demonstrators with law and  Pashinyan threatens demonstrators with law and  "steel mandate"
If peacekeepers could agree on ceasefire, why couldn`t they agree  that there would be no attack on Nagorno-Karabakh? - Prime Minister If peacekeepers could agree on ceasefire, why couldn`t they agree  that there would be no attack on Nagorno-Karabakh? - Prime Minister 
Pashinyan chairs extraordinary meeting of Security Council; situation  in Nagorno-Karabakh discussedPashinyan chairs extraordinary meeting of Security Council; situation  in Nagorno-Karabakh discussed
Ahead of UNSC discussions, Pashinyan declares that there is no direct  threat to population of NK and that evacuation should not be `Plan  A`, nor even `Plan B`Ahead of UNSC discussions, Pashinyan declares that there is no direct  threat to population of NK and that evacuation should not be `Plan  A`, nor even `Plan B`
Pashinyan believes that at moment there is no direct threat to NK  civilian population Pashinyan believes that at moment there is no direct threat to NK  civilian population 
Ceasefire in NK does not mean that Baku will no longer try to drag  Armenia into  war - PashinyanCeasefire in NK does not mean that Baku will no longer try to drag  Armenia into  war - Pashinyan
David Babayan: people of Artsakh could not be left to dieDavid Babayan: people of Artsakh could not be left to die
EU states assessing situation in NK, but have not yet made decisions  to impose sanctions against BakuEU states assessing situation in NK, but have not yet made decisions  to impose sanctions against Baku
Gegham Stepanyan: People in Artsakh are desperately looking for each  otherGegham Stepanyan: People in Artsakh are desperately looking for each  other
Kremlin: `main issue to whom belongs Nagorno-Karabakh resolved`Kremlin: `main issue to whom belongs Nagorno-Karabakh resolved`
David Melkumyan: There is no final agreement with BakuDavid Melkumyan: There is no final agreement with Baku
Cooperation instead of sanctions? Azerbaijan, U.S discuss prospects  for development of defense cooperationCooperation instead of sanctions? Azerbaijan, U.S discuss prospects  for development of defense cooperation
Yerevan developed necessary preparations for possible evacuation of  Armenians from NK- Prime Minister`s OfficeYerevan developed necessary preparations for possible evacuation of  Armenians from NK- Prime Minister`s Office
Azerbaijanis found Azerbaijanis found "scapegoats" of murder of Russian peacekeepers in  Artsakh
Reports about entry of Azerbaijani troops into Stepanakert fake,  Permanent Representation of Artsakh in Armenia saysReports about entry of Azerbaijani troops into Stepanakert fake,  Permanent Representation of Artsakh in Armenia says
More than 60 MEPs demand sanctions against AliyevMore than 60 MEPs demand sanctions against Aliyev
Azerbaijanis killed  civilian in  occupied Artsakh village of Haterq  - BeglaryanAzerbaijanis killed  civilian in  occupied Artsakh village of Haterq  - Beglaryan
Aliyev calls Putin and apologizes for killing peacekeepersAliyev calls Putin and apologizes for killing peacekeepers
Armenia`s Foreign Minister: Azerbaijan continues policy of ethnic  cleansing in NKArmenia`s Foreign Minister: Azerbaijan continues policy of ethnic  cleansing in NK
RA MFA: statements alone are not enough; clear actions by int`l  partners are needed to restrain AzerbaijanRA MFA: statements alone are not enough; clear actions by int`l  partners are needed to restrain Azerbaijan
EUMA reinforces patrols at  Armenian-Azerbaijani border areas, also  near SotkEUMA reinforces patrols at  Armenian-Azerbaijani border areas, also  near Sotk
Azerbaijan violates truce agreement with Nagorno-KarabakhAzerbaijan violates truce agreement with Nagorno-Karabakh
Mirzoyan calls for ensuring safety of Armenians of ArtsakhMirzoyan calls for ensuring safety of Armenians of Artsakh
Source: `response options` to inapplicable `means` that Azerbaijan  used against NK discussed in EUSource: `response options` to inapplicable `means` that Azerbaijan  used against NK discussed in EU
Karabakh delegation arrives in Yevlakh  to negotiate with Azerbaijani  delegation Karabakh delegation arrives in Yevlakh  to negotiate with Azerbaijani  delegation 
Handover of Artsakh to Baku regime poses serious risks to Russia`s  domestic stability - expert Handover of Artsakh to Baku regime poses serious risks to Russia`s  domestic stability - expert 
Strength and endurance to the Armenian people - Robert KocharyanStrength and endurance to the Armenian people - Robert Kocharyan
Tension between two Iranian neighbors unacceptable - Ebrahim RaisiTension between two Iranian neighbors unacceptable - Ebrahim Raisi
USA watching very closely worsening humanitarian situation inside  Nagorno-Karabakh - John KirbyUSA watching very closely worsening humanitarian situation inside  Nagorno-Karabakh - John Kirby