Wednesday, December 18 2013

Safaryan Ashot

European Court of Human Rights rules that denial of Armenian Genocide falls under freedom of expression

European Court of Human Rights rules that denial of Armenian Genocide falls under freedom of expression

European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) adopted a decision saying that the Swiss authorities had breached Article 10 of the European Convention of Human Rights covering freedom of expression when the Lausanne Police Court found Turkish Workers Party Leader Dogu Perincek guilty of racial discrimination on March 9, 2007, based on the Swiss Criminal Code. 

"The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled Dec. 17 that denial of the 1915 mass killings of Armenians as genocide falls under freedom of expression, following an appeal from a Turkish politician to his conviction in Switzerland," Asbarez reported.


Turkish Workers' Party (IP) Chairman Dogu Perincek, who had described the Armenian genocide as an "international lie," had complained that Swiss courts had breached his freedom of expression, based on Article 10 covering freedom of expression.


The ECHR ruling stated that "the free exercise of the right to openly discuss questions of a sensitive and controversial nature is one of the fundamental aspects of freedom of expression and distinguishes a tolerant and pluralistic democratic society from a totalitarian or dictatorial regime."
"The December 17 decision by the European Court of Human Rights must be condemned because it opens the door to the spread of hatred under the veil of 'freedom of expression,' and can be deemed as a sad example of Armenian Genocide denial," said a statement from the Political Affairs Office of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation.
"The fact that the court's decision was not unanimous, signals that there is legal room to advance and change the decision. We must direct our efforts to that end," added the ARF statement.
Meanwhile the Armenian National Committee offices in Europe, in conjunction with the European Armenian Federation for Justice and Democracy (ANC of Europe) are working with European legal officials on the matter and will issue relevant statements and actions items as they become available. 
The original case emerged from Perincek's participation in a number of conferences in Switzerland in 2005, during which he publicly denied that the Ottoman Empire had perpetrated the crime of genocide against the Armenian people in 1915.
The Lausanne Police Court found Perincek guilty of racial discrimination on March 9, 2007, based on the Swiss Criminal Code. After a complaint filed by the Switzerland-Armenia Association on July 15, 2005, the court found that Perincek's motives were of a "racist tendency" and did not contribute to the historical debate.
"The Court underlined that the free exercise of the right to openly discuss questions of a sensitive and controversial nature was one of the fundamental aspects of freedom of expression and distinguished a tolerant and pluralistic democratic society from a totalitarian or dictatorial regime," said the official ECHR press release.


"The Court also pointed out that it was not called upon to rule on the legal characterization of the Armenian genocide. The existence of a 'genocide,' which was a precisely defined legal concept, was not easy to prove. The Court doubted that there could be a general consensus as to events such as those at issue, given that historical research was by definition open to discussion and a matter of debate, without necessarily giving rise to final conclusions or to the assertion of objective and absolute truths," added the ECHR release.


"Lastly, the Court observed that those States which had officially recognized the Armenian genocide had not found it necessary to enact laws imposing criminal sanctions on individuals questioning the official view, being mindful that one of the main goals of freedom of expression was to protect minority views capable of contributing to a debate on questions of general interest which were not fully settled," explained the ECHR.
Perincek was handed an aggravated life sentence in the Ergenekon coup plot trial, as part of the Ergenekon network, which was ultimately acknowledged by the court as a terrorist organization that had attempted to overthrow the government.
The ECHR judgment is not final, and may be appealed by any party within a period of three months.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

Date of presidential and parliamentary elections in Artsakh decided Date of presidential and parliamentary elections in Artsakh decided 
Residents of the Georgian Gorelovka village blocked the road leading  to ArmeniaResidents of the Georgian Gorelovka village blocked the road leading  to Armenia
Armenian Ministry of Education delegation familiarized itself with  British education systemArmenian Ministry of Education delegation familiarized itself with  British education system
Human rights activist: Kutoyan`s death deprived society of details  about the state capture processHuman rights activist: Kutoyan`s death deprived society of details  about the state capture process
 National Security Service discovered drug smuggling channel from USA  to Armenia National Security Service discovered drug smuggling channel from USA  to Armenia
Gevorg Petrosyan will represent Prosperous Armenia faction in the  specialized committee on constitutional reformsGevorg Petrosyan will represent Prosperous Armenia faction in the  specialized committee on constitutional reforms
Forecast: The resignation of the government will not lead to  significant changes in RussiaForecast: The resignation of the government will not lead to  significant changes in Russia
10 types of national awards to be introduced in Armenia10 types of national awards to be introduced in Armenia
Over 30 SRC employees undergo retraining as part of EU initiativeOver 30 SRC employees undergo retraining as part of EU initiative
American Turks are trying to disrupt the conditional release of  American Turks are trying to disrupt the conditional release of  "ASALA" fighter  Hampig Sassounian
In Armenia an attempt is being made to simplify procedure for holding referendumIn Armenia an attempt is being made to simplify procedure for holding referendum
NSS submitted a motion for extension of Gagik Khachatryan`s nephew  arrestNSS submitted a motion for extension of Gagik Khachatryan`s nephew  arrest
Armenian President holds another meeting with representatives of  Thales Group in ZurichArmenian President holds another meeting with representatives of  Thales Group in Zurich
Kopyrkin sees no prerequisites for changing course of  Armenian-Russian relations in connection with Medvedev`s government  resignation Kopyrkin sees no prerequisites for changing course of  Armenian-Russian relations in connection with Medvedev`s government  resignation 
Imposing severe sanctions against drivers operating one or two  vehicles without state numbers will be cushioned in ArmeniaImposing severe sanctions against drivers operating one or two  vehicles without state numbers will be cushioned in Armenia
Butchers hold another protest in front of Government buildingButchers hold another protest in front of Government building
Lilit Makunts: Nikol Pashinyan expressed his condolences on the death  of Georgy KutoyanLilit Makunts: Nikol Pashinyan expressed his condolences on the death  of Georgy Kutoyan
Criminal case in which Serzh Sargsyan is including, submitted to  prosecutor with a motion to send it to courtCriminal case in which Serzh Sargsyan is including, submitted to  prosecutor with a motion to send it to court
Tourism industry representatives expect increase in tourist flow from  China to ArmeniaTourism industry representatives expect increase in tourist flow from  China to Armenia
PAP head said that there is no cooperation between him and former  head of the National Security Council of Armenia Arthur VanetsyanPAP head said that there is no cooperation between him and former  head of the National Security Council of Armenia Arthur Vanetsyan
Heads of power structures expressed their opinion on the death of  Georgy KutoyanHeads of power structures expressed their opinion on the death of  Georgy Kutoyan
The fourth session of the seventh convocation of the National  Assembly of Armenia starts on January 20The fourth session of the seventh convocation of the National  Assembly of Armenia starts on January 20
Fire in the building of the Print House localized Fire in the building of the Print House localized 
Chief of the General Staff of Armenia responded to the message about  theft of jet fuel in the Ministry of DefenseChief of the General Staff of Armenia responded to the message about  theft of jet fuel in the Ministry of Defense
A special meeting of  Inter-Parliamentary Committee  on Cooperation  between  NA of Armenia and Artsakh, dedicated to  30th anniversary of   pogroms in Baku  held in YerevanA special meeting of  Inter-Parliamentary Committee  on Cooperation  between  NA of Armenia and Artsakh, dedicated to  30th anniversary of   pogroms in Baku  held in Yerevan
NSS of Armenia: Georgy Kutoyan was a highly qualified, well-educated,  conscientious and responsible officerNSS of Armenia: Georgy Kutoyan was a highly qualified, well-educated,  conscientious and responsible officer
Enemy violated ceasefire at  frontline more than 80 times last weekEnemy violated ceasefire at  frontline more than 80 times last week
13 years have passed since assassination of Hrant Dink, but  case is  still not fully resolved13 years have passed since assassination of Hrant Dink, but  case is  still not fully resolved
A fire broke out in the building of  Press HouseA fire broke out in the building of  Press House
SCAT Airline temporarily suspends  Nur-Sultan - Yerevan flight SCAT Airline temporarily suspends  Nur-Sultan - Yerevan flight 
There are still closed and impassable roads in ArmeniaThere are still closed and impassable roads in Armenia
Two earthquakes occurred in Armenia with an interval of three hoursTwo earthquakes occurred in Armenia with an interval of three hours
Current and third Presidents of Armenia, as well as a number of other  statesmen expressed condolences on death of Former NSS Director  Current and third Presidents of Armenia, as well as a number of other  statesmen expressed condolences on death of Former NSS Director  
Dozens of bullets and shells were found in the room where the body of  the former head of the NSS was discoveredDozens of bullets and shells were found in the room where the body of  the former head of the NSS was discovered
Hayk Marutyan and Andrea Victorin discuss the possibility of  expanding cooperationHayk Marutyan and Andrea Victorin discuss the possibility of  expanding cooperation
Criminal proceedings against Judge of the Administrative Court Artur  Avagyan discontinuedCriminal proceedings against Judge of the Administrative Court Artur  Avagyan discontinued
Attempt to transport 5 kg of narcotic substances through Armenia  preventedAttempt to transport 5 kg of narcotic substances through Armenia  prevented
Prime Minister appointed Robert Ghukasyan  member of  Board of  Trustees of  Armenian Territorial Development FoundationPrime Minister appointed Robert Ghukasyan  member of  Board of  Trustees of  Armenian Territorial Development Foundation
Arthur Melikyan: The body of Georgy Kutoyan was discovered by his  wifeArthur Melikyan: The body of Georgy Kutoyan was discovered by his  wife
VTB Bank (Armenia) intends to firmly establish its leading position by total number of opening new ATMs and branches in 2020VTB Bank (Armenia) intends to firmly establish its leading position by total number of opening new ATMs and branches in 2020
Arman Tatoyan: It is very important for us to do everything possible  to prevent torture in places of detention in ArmeniaArman Tatoyan: It is very important for us to do everything possible  to prevent torture in places of detention in Armenia
Vice-Speaker: The news of the death of former NSS Director Gevorg  Kutoyan was shockingVice-Speaker: The news of the death of former NSS Director Gevorg  Kutoyan was shocking
Yerevan ranks 380th in the list of the most expensive cities in the  world Yerevan ranks 380th in the list of the most expensive cities in the  world 
Lena Nazaryan harshly answered those who criticize the Prime  Minister`s familyLena Nazaryan harshly answered those who criticize the Prime  Minister`s family
Armenian Ombudsman: Manvel Grigoryan`s condition worsened on the day  of release from custodyArmenian Ombudsman: Manvel Grigoryan`s condition worsened on the day  of release from custody
Forecast: Iran`s desire to achieve the USA withdrawal from the Middle  East is achievableForecast: Iran`s desire to achieve the USA withdrawal from the Middle  East is achievable
Head of EU Delegation to Armenia: I am impressed by legal reformsHead of EU Delegation to Armenia: I am impressed by legal reforms
MP: To declare war on the media is simply absurdMP: To declare war on the media is simply absurd
At a meeting of Pashinyan with members of the At a meeting of Pashinyan with members of the "My Step" faction,  issues of foreign and domestic policy were discussed
Russian Foreign Ministry: No noticeable changes in Karabakh  settlementRussian Foreign Ministry: No noticeable changes in Karabakh  settlement
Body of Former National Security Service Director of Armenia found in  YerevanBody of Former National Security Service Director of Armenia found in  Yerevan
Forecast: A few more years and rallies in Russia could grow into  something moreForecast: A few more years and rallies in Russia could grow into  something more
Mammadyarov announced visit of co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group to  the regionMammadyarov announced visit of co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group to  the region
Chamber of Architects: Urban Development Committee of Armenia does  not comply with the requirements of the Law on the activities of  architectsChamber of Architects: Urban Development Committee of Armenia does  not comply with the requirements of the Law on the activities of  architects
Nikol Pashinyan meets with members of Nikol Pashinyan meets with members of "My Step" faction in Yerevan
Director of Meghri Regional Medical Center accused of abuseDirector of Meghri Regional Medical Center accused of abuse
House collapsed in Kotayk region of ArmeniaHouse collapsed in Kotayk region of Armenia
 The Vardenenyats pass is difficult to pass for all types of vehicles,  Sotk-Karvachar is closed for heavy trucks The Vardenenyats pass is difficult to pass for all types of vehicles,  Sotk-Karvachar is closed for heavy trucks
Minister: The staff of closing obstetric services will be employedMinister: The staff of closing obstetric services will be employed
Zohrab Mnatsakanyan: Armenia is concerned about the destabilization  of the Middle EastZohrab Mnatsakanyan: Armenia is concerned about the destabilization  of the Middle East



Azerbaijani political scientist: Trump`s decision to neutralize  Suleimani is part of the internal political struggle in the USAAzerbaijani political scientist: Trump`s decision to neutralize  Suleimani is part of the internal political struggle in the USA
Sergey Markedonov: In 2019, Pashinyan demonstrated the ability to  roll with the punchesSergey Markedonov: In 2019, Pashinyan demonstrated the ability to  roll with the punches
Satanovsky: Soleimani became a victim of Trump`s election ambitionsSatanovsky: Soleimani became a victim of Trump`s election ambitions
Lavrov in Baku discussed details of his plan on KarabakhLavrov in Baku discussed details of his plan on Karabakh
Armenian-Indian ties have great potential for development in the pharmaceutical industryArmenian-Indian ties have great potential for development in the pharmaceutical industry
The invasion of Syria is the result of Erdogan`s panic reaction to  problems with the US, EU and NATOThe invasion of Syria is the result of Erdogan`s panic reaction to  problems with the US, EU and NATO
Politician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthroughPolitician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthrough
Fyodor Lukyanov: The fragility of the situation around Karabakh by no  means contain high risks of a warFyodor Lukyanov: The fragility of the situation around Karabakh by no  means contain high risks of a war
By creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South CaucasusBy creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South Caucasus
Rachya Arzumanyan: Former power in Artsakh today solves the problem  of its own reproductionRachya Arzumanyan: Former power in Artsakh today solves the problem  of its own reproduction
Edmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in ArmeniaEdmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in Armenia
View from Baku: Small amounts of US aid to Armenia are conditioned by  the latter`s membership in the CSTOView from Baku: Small amounts of US aid to Armenia are conditioned by  the latter`s membership in the CSTO
Academician: Europe`s soft line towards Turkey is explained by the  problem of refugeesAcademician: Europe`s soft line towards Turkey is explained by the  problem of refugees
Expert: Washington increases military component of its pressure on  IranExpert: Washington increases military component of its pressure on  Iran
NKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weaponsNKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weapons
Artsakh Foreign Minister: There are still no grounds for positive  expectations from the talksArtsakh Foreign Minister: There are still no grounds for positive  expectations from the talks
Alexey Malashenko: Alexey Malashenko: "It doesn`t matter to us who is in power in  Armenia, we will agree, all are our fellows"
Muslim Armenians in terrorist networks is a serious wake-up call for ArmeniaMuslim Armenians in terrorist networks is a serious wake-up call for Armenia
Analyst: Armenia has not realized what happened in St. PetersburgAnalyst: Armenia has not realized what happened in St. Petersburg
 Forecast: Turkey`s classification by US think tanks as a Forecast: Turkey`s classification by US think tanks as a "formal ally" will lead to increase of the importance of the South Caucasus countries
Wojciech Goretski: If Moscow could control April the war to the end, in Karabakh would have stood the Russian peacekeepersWojciech Goretski: If Moscow could control April the war to the end, in Karabakh would have stood the Russian peacekeepers
Forecast: Yerevan`s Forecast: Yerevan`s "flight" from Moscow is unlikely
State Minister: Artsakh`s economy needs investment rather than assistanceState Minister: Artsakh`s economy needs investment rather than assistance
Arayik Harutyunyan: We will in civilized manner put in their place all those who try to destabilize the situation in ArtsakhArayik Harutyunyan: We will in civilized manner put in their place all those who try to destabilize the situation in Artsakh
Hrachya Arzumanyan: There are three scenarios of Artsakh settlement in the 21st centuryHrachya Arzumanyan: There are three scenarios of Artsakh settlement in the 21st century
Armenia conducts equally open policy both in relations with the West  and RussiaArmenia conducts equally open policy both in relations with the West  and Russia
Kiro Manoyan: Armenia-Artsakh military-political agreement will be a  yellow card for AzerbaijanKiro Manoyan: Armenia-Artsakh military-political agreement will be a  yellow card for Azerbaijan
Ukrainian analyst: Zelensky`s victory is another catastrophic defeat  for Putin`s Russia in UkraineUkrainian analyst: Zelensky`s victory is another catastrophic defeat  for Putin`s Russia in Ukraine
Karabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the regionKarabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the region
Andrey Pyatakhin: Operators in Armenia are competing today for Internet rather than for voiceAndrey Pyatakhin: Operators in Armenia are competing today for Internet rather than for voice
MP: In Armenia, the media turn into a weapon of political struggle in  the information warMP: In Armenia, the media turn into a weapon of political struggle in  the information war
ICG representative: In order find a compromise on new settlements,  legalistic approach should be abandoned and the issue should be  considered in political frameworkICG representative: In order find a compromise on new settlements,  legalistic approach should be abandoned and the issue should be  considered in political framework
Robert Kocharyan`s supporter, who suggested that  witness in criminal  case refuses to testify, was detainedRobert Kocharyan`s supporter, who suggested that  witness in criminal  case refuses to testify, was detained
Forecast: The US administration may move towards the recognition of  the Armenian GenocideForecast: The US administration may move towards the recognition of  the Armenian Genocide
 Robert Kocharian: The stage of tactical expectation has passed,  Armenian society is entering a phase of active operations Robert Kocharian: The stage of tactical expectation has passed,  Armenian society is entering a phase of active operations
A look from Jerusalem: Armenia is busy with internal problems and  looks at the rest of the world very littleA look from Jerusalem: Armenia is busy with internal problems and  looks at the rest of the world very little
The desecration of the monument to Griboedov in Yerevan: A worthy  answer for Nzhdeh or the voiced slap in the face of the Armenian  people?The desecration of the monument to Griboedov in Yerevan: A worthy  answer for Nzhdeh or the voiced slap in the face of the Armenian  people?
Lavrov in Baku discussed details of his plan on KarabakhLavrov in Baku discussed details of his plan on Karabakh
Nzhdeh memorial plaque dismantled in ArmavirNzhdeh memorial plaque dismantled in Armavir
Oppositionist: Wishing good luck to the Pashinyan government, we are  not going to give up criticism of his workOppositionist: Wishing good luck to the Pashinyan government, we are  not going to give up criticism of his work
MP: Robert Kocharyan`s lawyers are doing everything possible to avoid  the start of the trial MP: Robert Kocharyan`s lawyers are doing everything possible to avoid  the start of the trial 
Armenian President received head of Georgia`s Partnership FundArmenian President received head of Georgia`s Partnership Fund
Wording on Karabakh is reflected in final declaration of II Baku  Summit of World Religious LeadersWording on Karabakh is reflected in final declaration of II Baku  Summit of World Religious Leaders
US Senator blocked vote on draft Armenian Genocide resolution in  upper house of US CongressUS Senator blocked vote on draft Armenian Genocide resolution in  upper house of US Congress
Official Baku reacted to the words of Sergey Lavrov in YerevanOfficial Baku reacted to the words of Sergey Lavrov in Yerevan
Serzh Sargsyan: Real democracy was a response to populism, which  posed a serious challenge to many countries of the worldSerzh Sargsyan: Real democracy was a response to populism, which  posed a serious challenge to many countries of the world
Pashinyan about the reasons for Hayrapetov`s dismissalPashinyan about the reasons for Hayrapetov`s dismissal
Russian Embassy in Armenia has responded to the report Russian Embassy in Armenia has responded to the report "The presence  of the Russian base in Armenia, and its impact on the human rights  situation in the country"
Nikol Pashinyan: Unfortunately, in our country, a general trend today  leads to the rejection of spiritualityNikol Pashinyan: Unfortunately, in our country, a general trend today  leads to the rejection of spirituality
Cavusoglu and Pompeo discuss resolution on Armenian GenocideCavusoglu and Pompeo discuss resolution on Armenian Genocide
Serzh Sargsyan: if by arresting me our people become happy, let them  arrest meSerzh Sargsyan: if by arresting me our people become happy, let them  arrest me
US adopted resolution recognizing Armenian GenocideUS adopted resolution recognizing Armenian Genocide
Working visit  of Artsakh Foreign Minister to Washington has startedWorking visit  of Artsakh Foreign Minister to Washington has started
Armen Sarkissian expressed condolences to Vladimir Putin over the  tragedy in the Krasnoyarsk TerritoryArmen Sarkissian expressed condolences to Vladimir Putin over the  tragedy in the Krasnoyarsk Territory
Andranik Kocharyan states Armenian Second President`s Defense  deliberately delays lawsuitAndranik Kocharyan states Armenian Second President`s Defense  deliberately delays lawsuit
Yerevan: Azerbaijan wants to get Artsakh without its indigenous  populationYerevan: Azerbaijan wants to get Artsakh without its indigenous  population
Expert: I don`t understand why the second President of Armenia Robert  Kocharian is charged only in the case of March 1, 2008Expert: I don`t understand why the second President of Armenia Robert  Kocharian is charged only in the case of March 1, 2008
Israeli political scientist: Turkey`s obvious aggressiveness gives  Armenia a stabilizing importanceIsraeli political scientist: Turkey`s obvious aggressiveness gives  Armenia a stabilizing importance
Politician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthroughPolitician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthrough
Robert Kocharian: I am ready to continue the fight even from the  prison cellRobert Kocharian: I am ready to continue the fight even from the  prison cell