Arminfo.info



 Sunday, December 8 2013

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Azerbaijan’s ultimate dependence on Russia is in the best interests of Armenia

Azerbaijan’s ultimate dependence on Russia is in the best interests of Armenia

 


Here is the first and the most
popular question in Armenia today. What is the goal of Russia’s up-to-date
military hardware supplies to Azerbaijan?   


 


Military and technical cooperation
is a part of the foreign political activity of the states and it helps attain
foreign political goals, enhance the defensive ability and security. Military
and technical cooperation makes direct or indirect impact on the state and
development of the military and political situation, as well as on conflicts.
Article 3 of the Law “On Military and Technical Cooperation” says that the key
goal of Russia’s military and technical cooperation with foreign states is to
strengthen the military and political positions of Russia in different regions
of the world.    


 


Why does Moscow seek to make
Azerbaijan dependent on Russia?


 


Azerbaijan
is gaining an important role in the geo-political fight for the South Caucasus.
Turkey needs Azerbaijan as a
conductor of its Neo-Ottomanism ideology and is therefore attempting to bring
NATO to that country.  This is a threat
for Russia.
So, the Russians are trying to curb these attempts.  For Armenia
and Nagorno-Karabakh it would be good if Azerbaijan
depended on Russia rather
than Turkey.
But I don't think that the Turks will let the Azeris join the Customs Union.


 


 Russian President Vladimir
Putin has announced creation of a joint air defense system with participation
of Russia, Armenia, Belarus and Kazakhstan. Russia
has already a joint air defense system with Armenia. What goals will this new
initiative have and what will it be directed against?


 


Putin's
initiative to create a joint air defense system is a response to the Customs
Union's enlargement. This system is just supposed to ensure the security of the
Union. I don't agree with those claiming that
this system will deprive Armenia
of sovereignty.


 


 Russia is strengthening the
102nd military base. It is also going to take Erebouni Airport
on lease. The impression is that our allies are strengthening their presence,
not Armenia.
What
for is it being done? How does it meet Armenia’s interests?
 


 


The
enlargement of the Russian air force in Armenia comes from the treaty on the
Russian military base prolonged in 2010. 
Before 2010 the base was obliged to guard Armenia's
borders with Turkey and Iran. Now it
will have to also guard the border with Azerbaijan.


 


Why does Moscow keep controlling the
balance of forces between Armenia and Azerbaijan?


 


Presence
in the region helps Russia to fight for the region. Russia's military doctrine says
that all conflicts near its borders pose a threat to its security. And
Nagorno-Karabakh is one of such threats. Russia does not want this conflict
to resume as it is the only great power having a common border with this
region. As regards Russia's
supplying arms to Azerbaijan,
unless the Russians do it, the Israelis and the Ukrainians will take their
place and they will lose their control over Azerbaijan. I don't think that this
will be good for Armenia,
will it?


 


What impact does the “reset” of
relations between the United States and Russia make on Armenia’s role given the
deal on Syria between Washington and Moscow and the new role Iran has assumed
following
the Geneva
Agreement
with P5+1?  


 


Armenia's role in the region will certainly
change after the latest developments – the US-Russian deal on Syria and the Geneva
agreement on Iran.
Our control of Nagorno-Karabakh is a strong proof of our big role in the
region. Russia's military
base in Armenia
is not only a guarantee of our security, but also a means for the Russians to
enhance their influence in the region. As regards the Nagorno-Karabakh problem,
Russia has never let Armenia down in this matter, and its further
position here will depend on Armenia's
policy.


 


May there be an agreement where Iran agrees to stop
enriching uranium to 20% in exchange for the mediators' promise to force Israel
to join the Nonproliferation Treaty?


 


Israel
and Iran are the key rivals in the region, and a nuclear weapon would certainly
be helpful in this rivalry. But the key factor that caused P5+1 to sign the
Geneva Agreement was the position of Russia,
China and Iran. It was a
kind of a counterbalance to the policy of Turkey
and the United States to
pressure Iran by changing
the regime in its ally, Syria.
So, Israel's
negative response to the agreement was natural. The agreement has given Iran a respite, and this cannot but worry Israel.


 


 When the “cold war” was over,
Turkey lost its role of the advanced guard in NATO and tried to control the
processes in the Middle East. The impression is that the treaties on Syria and Iran
have crossed out Turkey’s
regional ambitions…     


 


In
the very beginning of Ahmet Davutoglu’s "zero problems with
neighbors" policy directed at strengthening of Turkey through
dissemination of Neo-Ottomanism, it was clear that the task exceeds Ankara's
ability. They did not have enough political, military and economic resources
for that. As a result, today Turkey
has ended up with nothing. Its relations with all the countries of the region -
Israel, Egypt, Armenia
and Syria
- have worsened. And today's jactitation of Turkey
from Europe to the East are evidence of an extremely hard geo-political
situation in the country thanks to the political adventurism of Ankara.


 


Turkey and Azerbaijan have a treaty on mutual military support. Can it
be considered legitimate given that Ankara needs NATO’s consent to provide
military aid to Azerbaijan?


 


Certainly,
Turkey has got an
opportunity to show military aid to Azerbaijan within the frames of the
treaty on mutual military support and despite being a NATO member. No
international treaty, including the CSTO, limits any country to show aid to its
partner. NATO and CSTO were set up to protect from aggression directed only
against their members.  Actually, Turkey cannot but consult in the matter of
showing aid to Azerbaijan,
if this aid threatens NATO member-states. 


 


 In other words, will the developments of 1993, when
Turkish armed forces came closer to the border of Armenia, occur again?


 


Actually, they will. At that time the Turks said about
their intention to enter the Karabakh conflict, if the Armenians did not
abandon the attacking operations in Karabakh. 
Marshal Shaposhnikov declared that Turkey's interference in the
Karabakh conflict would result in the third World War. This statement was
followed by the talk of Russia's
defence minister Pavel Grachev with the Turkish president in Istanbul, and everything ended.  


 


Given
the analysis of the current situation, would you assess the

possibility and prospects of new Azerbaijani aggression against Karabakh?


 


The
possibility of the new war in Karabakh has sharply declined because of the
following factors: rising of Russia's role in the world and in the region,
liquidation of the threat of war against Iran and sale of the Russian armament
to Azerbaijan, that allows Moscow to keep Baku under control. As for Armenia's
joining the Customs Union and later the Eurasian Union, it will reduce the
possibility of the war even more taking into consideration the interest of
Russia in Armenia, and the fact that Azerbaijan is beyond these processes. The
moral and psychological climate in the Azerbaijani army is much lower than that
in the Armenian army. The material acquisition by Azerbaijan
should ensure its security in three directions: Armenia,
Turkmenistan and Iran. This
requires forces and funds. Therefore this material acquisition should be
divided into three parts. Meanwhile, by its doctrine Armenia
is a guarantor of the NKR security, and all the strategic facilities and
targets of Azerbaijan
are within the reach of the Armenian firing means. As for Armenia, it is a protecting zone thanks to the
treaties with CSTO and a direct contract with Russia. Finally, the most important
is that Azerbaijan
is not ready for war. For this reason, today to start a new war is equal to
death for Azerbaijan.
They cannot do that physically even irrespective of the military and political
situation.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

UN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflictsUN Committee against Torture is alarmed by extra-judicial killings,  torture and ill-treatment of Armenians by Azerbaijanis during armed  conflicts
Russian border guards leave Nerkin HandRussian border guards leave Nerkin Hand
Armenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of ArdshinbankArmenia to host 33rd EBRD Business Forum with flagship sponsorship of Ardshinbank
By PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee HeadBy PM`s decision, Sisian Boghossian relieved of her post as Tourism  Committee Head
All detained members of opposition movement have been releasedAll detained members of opposition movement have been released
NDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignityNDP welcomes fact that it is Bagrat Srbazan who leads movement to  restore Armenian people`s dignity
If Pashinyan remains in power, then Armenia will become not Russian  province, but Azerbaijani protectorate, which is even worse - Ara  PapyanIf Pashinyan remains in power, then Armenia will become not Russian  province, but Azerbaijani protectorate, which is even worse - Ara  Papyan
Protests of disobedience in Yerevan are suspended until the eveningProtests of disobedience in Yerevan are suspended until the evening
Political scientist: Azerbaijan takes processes taking place in  Armenia very seriouslyPolitical scientist: Azerbaijan takes processes taking place in  Armenia very seriously
UJA strongly condemns all police brutality against journalists  carrying out their professional activitiesUJA strongly condemns all police brutality against journalists  carrying out their professional activities
Azerbaijan concerned about developments in Armenia - Naira ZohrabyanAzerbaijan concerned about developments in Armenia - Naira Zohrabyan
Alain-Richard Donwahi, UNCCD COP 15 President arrives in ArmeniaAlain-Richard Donwahi, UNCCD COP 15 President arrives in Armenia
Lemkin Institute: By parroting Turkish narrative of 1915-1923events,  Armenian premier risks absolving Turkiye of its responsibility for  the Armenian GenocideLemkin Institute: By parroting Turkish narrative of 1915-1923events,  Armenian premier risks absolving Turkiye of its responsibility for  the Armenian Genocide
Armenian Apostolic Church has historically been cementing material  for ethnos - Metropolitan of Russian Orthodox ChurchArmenian Apostolic Church has historically been cementing material  for ethnos - Metropolitan of Russian Orthodox Church
Diplomacy and dialogue are the only path to stability and peace -  OSCE Chair-in-OfficeDiplomacy and dialogue are the only path to stability and peace -  OSCE Chair-in-Office
Armenian FM evades question about legality of use of Almaty  declaration as basis for border delimitation Armenian FM evades question about legality of use of Almaty  declaration as basis for border delimitation 
OSCE Chair-in-Office evades question about help in Artsakh residents`  return to their homesOSCE Chair-in-Office evades question about help in Artsakh residents`  return to their homes
Yerevan and Baku prefer to resolve issues and disagreements between  them in bilateral format - OSCE Chair-in-OfficeYerevan and Baku prefer to resolve issues and disagreements between  them in bilateral format - OSCE Chair-in-Office
IDBank issues the 2nd tranche of dollar bonds of 2024IDBank issues the 2nd tranche of dollar bonds of 2024
France welcomes talks between Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs held in  AlmatyFrance welcomes talks between Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs held in  Almaty
Azerbaijanis destroy Holy Ascension Church in BerdzorAzerbaijanis destroy Holy Ascension Church in Berdzor
Experts discuss problems of Armenia Experts discuss problems of Armenia 
134 protesters detained - report 134 protesters detained - report 
Order to use brute force by police issued by premier himself -  opposition MPOrder to use brute force by police issued by premier himself -  opposition MP
Opposition MP critical of police over Opposition MP critical of police over "efforts for bonuses"
Tavush for Motherland condemns violence against journalists Tavush for Motherland condemns violence against journalists 
OSCE Chair-in-Office arrives in Yerevan OSCE Chair-in-Office arrives in Yerevan 
Armenia, Azerbaijan agree to continue negotiations over controversial  issues Armenia, Azerbaijan agree to continue negotiations over controversial  issues 
Use of brutal force premier`s personal order - lawyer Use of brutal force premier`s personal order - lawyer 
About 50 protesters detained About 50 protesters detained 
Actions of disobedience in Yerevan Actions of disobedience in Yerevan 
Bagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figureBagrat Galstanyan Armenia public and spiritual figure
Bagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrowBagrat Srpazan calls for protests of disobedience across country  tomorrow
Another nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identityAnother nationwide rally takes place on Republic Square:  speakers  call for fight for national identity
Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility Vassilis Maragos: It`s too early to talk about details of assistance  to Armenia through European Peace Facility 
Europe Day celebrations started in YerevanEurope Day celebrations started in Yerevan
Will Pashinyan be impeached?Will Pashinyan be impeached?
Armenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go furtherArmenian Foreign Minister: We should not limit ourselves to signing  peace treaty; we can go further
IC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knivesIC arrests two protesters in Yerevan who were carrying folding knives
Ruben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lotRuben Vardanyan`s message from Baku prison: And one person can change  a lot
Russian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian peopleRussian expert points out dilemma facing Armenian people
Bagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premierBagrat Srbazan: I have no ambitions to become Armenia`s premier
Police detain activist over violence against policeman Police detain activist over violence against policeman 
Clergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justiceClergyman calls on Armenian young people to be in center of struggle  for justice
Bagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FMBagrat Galstanyan must be nominated to Armenian premier`s post -  ex-FM
Armenia makes it through to European Grand FinalArmenia makes it through to European Grand Final
Russian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic WarRussian embassy in Armenia hosts gala reception on occasion of 79th  anniversary of Victory in Great Patriotic War
Our struggle is for justice - clergyman Our struggle is for justice - clergyman
Parliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premierParliamentary opposition ready to support impeachment procedure of  Armenia`s premier
Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader Tavush for Motherland movement to decide on its next steps soon -  leader 
"Five Human Rights Defenders" Initiative ready to support students
Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s Today`s rally to be more massive than yesterday`s 
Bagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resignBagrat Srbazan gave Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resign
Bagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time  to make decisionBagrat Srbazan to authorities: By time we get to Square you have time to make decision
Armenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian  counterpartArmenian Foreign Minister discuss regional issues with his Canadian counterpart
Refrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police  chief urgesRefrain from actions that would prompt police to use force, police chief urges
After power shift, all people who participated in so-called  delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik ChalabyanAfter power shift, all people who participated in so-called delimitation to be brought to the court: Avetik Chalabyan
Varuzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush,  and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik.  The choice is yoursVaruzhan Geghamyan: Yesterday - Artsakh, today- borders of Tavush, and tomorrow - Ararat and Syunik. The choice is yours
"Five Human Rights Defenders" initiative to provide legal assistance to citizens dismissed for participating in peaceful rally
Armenia remains CSTO member: Source in OrganizationArmenia remains CSTO member: Source in Organization