Monday, April 29 2013

Safaryan Ashot

Mikayel Hayrapetyan: The West cannot change power in Armenia yet

 


Mr. Hayrapetyan, how do you assess
the ongoing processes in Armenia? What domestic political changes do you see
after the presidential election?   


 


All the political processes
developing in Armenia today are like a performance, the stage directors of
which must not be looked for among the Armenian politicians or parties. All of
them without exception are stooges in the hands of Russia, first of all. Of
course, the West also pursues its aims, but the share of its interests in
Armenia is not big. Just Russia easily rules the leadership of Armenia as well
as the opposition. And I see no sign of self-respect in the behavior of our
political forces.


 


But many experts, including Russian
ones, criticize the Kremlin for its wrong foreign policy that resulted in
cession of positions in the post-Soviet area…  
 


 


I partly share this opinion. We
remember that the West gained victory over the USSR in the "cold
war". As a contribution, Moscow gradually "ceded" Western
Europe, then Baltic countries. Then "orange revolutions" happened in
Ukraine and Georgia. Similar departure took place in the South Caucasus as
well. Russian subdivisions were first removed from Azerbaijan, except Gabala
radar station. By the way, for withdrawal of the Russian troops Baku paid by
losing Nagornyy Karabakh and respective territories. Later Russian units were
also removed from Georgia, as a result of which Tbilisi lost Abkhazia and South
Ossetia. The five-day war and occupation of Abkhazia and South Ossetia and
timorous mediation of the West, in fact, meant that the West seems to be
inclined to recognize South Caucasus an area of Moscow's privileged interests.
In its flexibility the West has come to the situation when pro-Russian Bidzina
Ivanishvili was chosen as a political opponent of pro-Western Mikheil
Saakashvili. These and other similar serious developments show that at present
these is no disagreement between the West and Russia in our region.


 


How would you explain the West’s
flexible position with respect to Moscow?
 


 


I think that the developments in the
Middle East and the growth of the ideas of radical Islam are the reason of a
little bit retreat of the West against Moscow's interests. Russia has a mission
of blunting the Islam attack at Christian civilization. Despite being a
"prodigal son" for Europe, nevertheless, Russia is a part of Europe
and Christian civilization. Russia has a mission of a frontier guard of
civilization both in the South Caucasus and the Far East.


 


Let’s return to Armenia…


 


As regards Armenia, it has always
been under the influence of Russia. Therefore, any reform of the political
system of Armenia will be cosmetic. Armenia has no leader with a political
dignity ready to launch a challenge against Moscow's hegemony. Stemming from
the above mentioned, I don't think that the present status quo in the political
system of Armenia will be changed in the near future. Armenia cannot differ
from its "metropole". The whole body running a fever, I mean, the
corrupted Russia, cannot have a separate healthy part. If Armenia is Russia's
outpost, only cosmetic transformations may happen here, at best. It is
impossible to change the situation now. I cannot say how long it will last.
Much depends on the situation in the region, as well as on the forthcoming
presidential election in Georgia. The election will show whether the West’s
retreat is temporary or it has decided to cede the South Caucasus to Russia for
a long period.   


 


What about the Armenia-EU
Association Agreement negotiations? Are they also only an instrument for
cosmetic changes or serious processes aimed at gaining long-tern results? 


 


One should first of all take into
account that those negotiations are being held by the authorities of Armenia,
who are the henchmen of Moscow. Does the European Union realize that? Yes, of
course. The EU cannot deploy the NATO troops in Armenia.  So, the EU has nothing to do but fight
against oligarchy by such measures as, for instance, the entry of the French
Retailer Carrefour in the Armenian market. However, Carrefour's case is so far
shy efforts of the West to change the status-quo and it cannot bring any
significant changes. If Russia forces Armenia to join the Eurasian Union, the
authorities will hardly have the courage to resist and to make the right
geopolitical choice to protect the national interests. Much depends on the
West's flexibility, on whether it will make Armenia set tougher conditions to
Moscow or it will try to limit its demands seeing Armenia's despair.


 


But the West is very closely
cooperating with the “henchmen” of Moscow – the authorities of Armenia.
Moreover, the West hurried to congratulate President Serzh Sargsyan on his
re-election whereas it could support Raffi Hovannisian.


 


The West cannot change power in
Armenia at present. It can just express its attitude towards various processes.
We remember that in 2008 the U.S. President Barack Obama did not congratulate
Serzh Sargsyan and the leaders of European countries congratulated him rather
late and did it through the mid-level diplomats and officials. This time the
situation was different. Unfortunately, Serzh Sargsyan won the election. I do not know where the votes were rigged but
one thing is obvious – this time the authorities were able to persuade the West
that the presidential election was fair and transparent. This was what the West
expected. It did not want to completely cede the region that it is keeping with
the help of Russia.


 


By Ashot Safaryan


29 April 2013. ArmInfo 


 


 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

Elmar Mammadyarov expressed disappointment with the last meeting with  Mnatsakanyan in New YorkElmar Mammadyarov expressed disappointment with the last meeting with  Mnatsakanyan in New York
Emergency in Syunik: Polluted water leaked from the tailing dump into  the waters of the Voghji River Emergency in Syunik: Polluted water leaked from the tailing dump into  the waters of the Voghji River 
Minsk mediators arrived in BakuMinsk mediators arrived in Baku
EU expresses assistance in exclusively peaceful settlement of  Karabakh conflictEU expresses assistance in exclusively peaceful settlement of  Karabakh conflict
Converse Bank launched contact-free Visa Pay Stickers and will offer  Mini FOBs soonConverse Bank launched contact-free Visa Pay Stickers and will offer  Mini FOBs soon
Beeline and Child Development Fund announced the 4th stage of the  joint programBeeline and Child Development Fund announced the 4th stage of the  joint program
Armenian MFA: Distorted views of Azerbaijan and Turkey on regional  security impede peaceful resolution of conflictsArmenian MFA: Distorted views of Azerbaijan and Turkey on regional  security impede peaceful resolution of conflicts
ACBA-Credit Agricole Bank starts servicing UnionPay cardsACBA-Credit Agricole Bank starts servicing UnionPay cards
Ardshinbank launched the second phase of bondsArdshinbank launched the second phase of bonds
Only five of  nine honored artists  of Armenia who received  notifications from SRC declared their incomeOnly five of  nine honored artists  of Armenia who received  notifications from SRC declared their income
Vice-Speaker Lena Nazaryan meets with members of California State  Assembly and Los Angeles City CouncilVice-Speaker Lena Nazaryan meets with members of California State  Assembly and Los Angeles City Council
Armenian Minister of Defense points out the need to expand military  cooperation with GermanyArmenian Minister of Defense points out the need to expand military  cooperation with Germany
Igor Popov talked about where and when the next meeting of  Mnatsakanyan-Mammadyarov may holdIgor Popov talked about where and when the next meeting of  Mnatsakanyan-Mammadyarov may hold
Suspects in murder of a policeman committed a robbery a few minutes  before  attack on law enforcement officersSuspects in murder of a policeman committed a robbery a few minutes  before  attack on law enforcement officers
Erdogan does not calm: Whoever wants to see the massacre, let them  look at Afghanistan, Nagorno- Karabakh, Bosnia and HerzegovinaErdogan does not calm: Whoever wants to see the massacre, let them  look at Afghanistan, Nagorno- Karabakh, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Shirak region`s head of tax administration was dismissed after  celebration of Independence DayShirak region`s head of tax administration was dismissed after  celebration of Independence Day
A policeman injured in a armed attack was diagnosed with a concussionA policeman injured in a armed attack was diagnosed with a concussion
After the mass poisoning of schoolchildren in Artashat, inspections  will be held in all schoolsAfter the mass poisoning of schoolchildren in Artashat, inspections  will be held in all schools
Head of Armenian SRC ready to resign if Prime Minister dissatisfied  with his workHead of Armenian SRC ready to resign if Prime Minister dissatisfied  with his work
The Champs Elysees spoke about the decisions taken at a meeting of  the Security Council of France on Syria convened by MacronThe Champs Elysees spoke about the decisions taken at a meeting of  the Security Council of France on Syria convened by Macron
Hovhannes Igityan: Aliyev has no answer to Pashinyan`s main question  Hovhannes Igityan: Aliyev has no answer to Pashinyan`s main question  
Armenia ranks 30th in the Global Hunger Index ratingArmenia ranks 30th in the Global Hunger Index rating
ANCA calls on US authorities to overcome veto and recognize Armenian  Genocide, thereby stopping atrocities of TurkeyANCA calls on US authorities to overcome veto and recognize Armenian  Genocide, thereby stopping atrocities of Turkey
Bako Sahakyan and Minsk mediators discussed the situation on the  border between Artsakh and AzerbaijanBako Sahakyan and Minsk mediators discussed the situation on the  border between Artsakh and Azerbaijan
Note of the prosthesis of Baku Russia and Zatulin`s reaction to  Azerbaijani hysteriaNote of the prosthesis of Baku Russia and Zatulin`s reaction to  Azerbaijani hysteria
Grigory Hayrapetov relieved of the post of head of the State  Protection Service of Armenia`s NSSGrigory Hayrapetov relieved of the post of head of the State  Protection Service of Armenia`s NSS
Former bodyguard of Armenia`s former president will be interrogated  within investigation of death of Georgian citizenFormer bodyguard of Armenia`s former president will be interrogated  within investigation of death of Georgian citizen
Venice Commission: Armenia`s Judicial Reform Package generally  deserves praise however judges` retirement scheme should be strictly  voluntaryVenice Commission: Armenia`s Judicial Reform Package generally  deserves praise however judges` retirement scheme should be strictly  voluntary
Ameriabank expands its network of regional branchesAmeriabank expands its network of regional branches
Armenian President and Georgian Prime Minister discussed the possibility of implementing joint  programsArmenian President and Georgian Prime Minister discussed the possibility of implementing joint  programs
Vitaliy Balasanyan: Robert Kocharyan was arrested for one single  purpose - to destroy everyone, all valuesVitaliy Balasanyan: Robert Kocharyan was arrested for one single  purpose - to destroy everyone, all values
Vitaly Balasanyan believes that the operational connection between  Yerevan and Baku is anti-Armenian and dangerousVitaly Balasanyan believes that the operational connection between  Yerevan and Baku is anti-Armenian and dangerous
The inter-departmental commission will provide petrol for employees  of operational investigative servicesThe inter-departmental commission will provide petrol for employees  of operational investigative services
Another group of Armenian specialists left for SyriaAnother group of Armenian specialists left for Syria
Armenian and French MPs discussed the situation in SyriaArmenian and French MPs discussed the situation in Syria
Balasanyan: If the people of Artsakh elect me as President,  then my personal relations with Pashinyan will not have any roleBalasanyan: If the people of Artsakh elect me as President,  then my personal relations with Pashinyan will not have any role
Vitaliy Balasanyan: Policy of the Armenian authorities on the  Karabakh issue is a continuation of Levon Ter-Petrosyan`s policyVitaliy Balasanyan: Policy of the Armenian authorities on the  Karabakh issue is a continuation of Levon Ter-Petrosyan`s policy
In cooperation with ACBA-Credit Agricole Bank, Hayastan All-Armenian  Fund launched a website for online donationsIn cooperation with ACBA-Credit Agricole Bank, Hayastan All-Armenian  Fund launched a website for online donations
Meeting between Nikol Pashinyan and Bako Sahakyan was heldMeeting between Nikol Pashinyan and Bako Sahakyan was held
Armenia and Georgia consider developing a strategic vision for  developing bilateral relationsArmenia and Georgia consider developing a strategic vision for  developing bilateral relations
In one of the schools of Artashat, 19 students were hospitalized due  to food poisoningIn one of the schools of Artashat, 19 students were hospitalized due  to food poisoning
A Group of friendship with Artsakh may be formed in IraqA Group of friendship with Artsakh may be formed in Iraq
Mikayel Melkumyan: The Turkish initiative at the session of the World  Inter-Parliamentary Union was rejectedMikayel Melkumyan: The Turkish initiative at the session of the World  Inter-Parliamentary Union was rejected
Prosecutor General: On 27.7% of the messages received through the notification system criminal cases were initiated Prosecutor General: On 27.7% of the messages received through the notification system criminal cases were initiated 
Court session Kocharyan`s and other defendants`March 1 case postponed until November 5Court session Kocharyan`s and other defendants`March 1 case postponed until November 5
Kiro Manoyan: Erdogan`s behavior can inspire Aliyev  to take inadequate stepsKiro Manoyan: Erdogan`s behavior can inspire Aliyev  to take inadequate steps
MP: There are no `unsinkable` judges, officials and institutions in  Armenia and there cannot be anyMP: There are no `unsinkable` judges, officials and institutions in  Armenia and there cannot be any
Analyst: The solution to the problem of the Constitutional Court lies  in appointment of new judges and head Analyst: The solution to the problem of the Constitutional Court lies  in appointment of new judges and head 
Giorgi Gakharia hopes to establish deeper relations between Georgia  and ArmeniaGiorgi Gakharia hopes to establish deeper relations between Georgia  and Armenia
Erdogan once again expressed support for Azerbaijan on Karabakh  conflictErdogan once again expressed support for Azerbaijan on Karabakh  conflict
Kiro Manoyan: Artsakh is not Vitaly BalasanyanKiro Manoyan: Artsakh is not Vitaly Balasanyan
Kurdish community holds protest at the USA embassy in Yerevan in  connection with withdrawal of the USA troops from SyriaKurdish community holds protest at the USA embassy in Yerevan in  connection with withdrawal of the USA troops from Syria
Official meeting of Georgian PM held in YerevanOfficial meeting of Georgian PM held in Yerevan
Gagik Khachatryan transferred to jailGagik Khachatryan transferred to jail
Mnatsakanyan at a meeting with Minsk mediators emphasized the need to  ensure proportionality of obligations in the peace processMnatsakanyan at a meeting with Minsk mediators emphasized the need to  ensure proportionality of obligations in the peace process
Airbus delegation arrives in Armenia at the invitation of Armen  SargsyanAirbus delegation arrives in Armenia at the invitation of Armen  Sargsyan
Illegally acquired property worth more than 50 million drams in  Armenia may be confiscated in favor of the stateIllegally acquired property worth more than 50 million drams in  Armenia may be confiscated in favor of the state
Pashinyan: As a result of the exercises, confidence in the Armenian  Armed Forces increasedPashinyan: As a result of the exercises, confidence in the Armenian  Armed Forces increased
Alan Gogbashyan will not head British diplomatic mission in ArmeniaAlan Gogbashyan will not head British diplomatic mission in Armenia
Four persons charged in an incident at Hayeli Press ClubFour persons charged in an incident at Hayeli Press Club



The invasion of Syria is the result of Erdogan`s panic reaction to  problems with the US, EU and NATOThe invasion of Syria is the result of Erdogan`s panic reaction to  problems with the US, EU and NATO
Politician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthroughPolitician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthrough
Fyodor Lukyanov: The fragility of the situation around Karabakh by no  means contain high risks of a warFyodor Lukyanov: The fragility of the situation around Karabakh by no  means contain high risks of a war
By creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South CaucasusBy creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South Caucasus
Rachya Arzumanyan: Former power in Artsakh today solves the problem  of its own reproductionRachya Arzumanyan: Former power in Artsakh today solves the problem  of its own reproduction
Edmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in ArmeniaEdmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in Armenia
View from Baku: Small amounts of US aid to Armenia are conditioned by  the latter`s membership in the CSTOView from Baku: Small amounts of US aid to Armenia are conditioned by  the latter`s membership in the CSTO
Academician: Europe`s soft line towards Turkey is explained by the  problem of refugeesAcademician: Europe`s soft line towards Turkey is explained by the  problem of refugees
Expert: Washington increases military component of its pressure on  IranExpert: Washington increases military component of its pressure on  Iran
NKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weaponsNKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weapons
Artsakh Foreign Minister: There are still no grounds for positive  expectations from the talksArtsakh Foreign Minister: There are still no grounds for positive  expectations from the talks
Alexey Malashenko: Alexey Malashenko: "It doesn`t matter to us who is in power in  Armenia, we will agree, all are our fellows"
Muslim Armenians in terrorist networks is a serious wake-up call for ArmeniaMuslim Armenians in terrorist networks is a serious wake-up call for Armenia
Analyst: Armenia has not realized what happened in St. PetersburgAnalyst: Armenia has not realized what happened in St. Petersburg
 Forecast: Turkey`s classification by US think tanks as a Forecast: Turkey`s classification by US think tanks as a "formal ally" will lead to increase of the importance of the South Caucasus countries
Wojciech Goretski: If Moscow could control April the war to the end, in Karabakh would have stood the Russian peacekeepersWojciech Goretski: If Moscow could control April the war to the end, in Karabakh would have stood the Russian peacekeepers
Forecast: Yerevan`s Forecast: Yerevan`s "flight" from Moscow is unlikely
State Minister: Artsakh`s economy needs investment rather than assistanceState Minister: Artsakh`s economy needs investment rather than assistance
Arayik Harutyunyan: We will in civilized manner put in their place all those who try to destabilize the situation in ArtsakhArayik Harutyunyan: We will in civilized manner put in their place all those who try to destabilize the situation in Artsakh
Hrachya Arzumanyan: There are three scenarios of Artsakh settlement in the 21st centuryHrachya Arzumanyan: There are three scenarios of Artsakh settlement in the 21st century
Armenia conducts equally open policy both in relations with the West  and RussiaArmenia conducts equally open policy both in relations with the West  and Russia
Kiro Manoyan: Armenia-Artsakh military-political agreement will be a  yellow card for AzerbaijanKiro Manoyan: Armenia-Artsakh military-political agreement will be a  yellow card for Azerbaijan
Ukrainian analyst: Zelensky`s victory is another catastrophic defeat  for Putin`s Russia in UkraineUkrainian analyst: Zelensky`s victory is another catastrophic defeat  for Putin`s Russia in Ukraine
Karabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the regionKarabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the region
Andrey Pyatakhin: Operators in Armenia are competing today for Internet rather than for voiceAndrey Pyatakhin: Operators in Armenia are competing today for Internet rather than for voice
France: Fake news and laws, searches and gilets jaunesFrance: Fake news and laws, searches and gilets jaunes
The elimination of Karabakh conflict and of Russian impact as well  is a direct way for US investments in Armenia and AzerbaijanThe elimination of Karabakh conflict and of Russian impact as well  is a direct way for US investments in Armenia and Azerbaijan
Manvel Sargsyan: Oligarchic order was broken in Armenia, but the  threat of a return to authoritarianism remains.(video)Manvel Sargsyan: Oligarchic order was broken in Armenia, but the  threat of a return to authoritarianism remains.(video)
Expert: Only four political forces have chances to be elected to the Armenian parliamentExpert: Only four political forces have chances to be elected to the Armenian parliament
Victor Nadein-Raevsky: The people of Azerbaijan are not ready to  realize the mistakes of the past (video)Victor Nadein-Raevsky: The people of Azerbaijan are not ready to  realize the mistakes of the past (video)
Yerevan: Azerbaijan wants to get Artsakh without its indigenous  populationYerevan: Azerbaijan wants to get Artsakh without its indigenous  population
Expert: I don`t understand why the second President of Armenia Robert  Kocharian is charged only in the case of March 1, 2008Expert: I don`t understand why the second President of Armenia Robert  Kocharian is charged only in the case of March 1, 2008
Israeli political scientist: Turkey`s obvious aggressiveness gives  Armenia a stabilizing importanceIsraeli political scientist: Turkey`s obvious aggressiveness gives  Armenia a stabilizing importance
Politician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthroughPolitician and statesman Masis Mayilyan’s election as Artsakh president is required for Armenia`s breakthrough
Robert Kocharian: I am ready to continue the fight even from the  prison cellRobert Kocharian: I am ready to continue the fight even from the  prison cell
Masis Mayilyan praised the efforts of members of the Committee on  Armenian Issues of the US Congress in support of a peaceful  settlement of the Karabakh conflictMasis Mayilyan praised the efforts of members of the Committee on  Armenian Issues of the US Congress in support of a peaceful  settlement of the Karabakh conflict
Analyst: In the pursuit of sensationalism, national security must be  kept in mindAnalyst: In the pursuit of sensationalism, national security must be  kept in mind
Pashinyan invited all Armenians of the world to celebrate New Year  and Christmas in ArmeniaPashinyan invited all Armenians of the world to celebrate New Year  and Christmas in Armenia
Chinese Embassy in Armenia launches Chinese Embassy in Armenia launches "Discover China" contest - winner  will have the opportunity to see China 
George Tsereteli called on the parties to the Karabakh conflict to  resolve disagreements and find a common languageGeorge Tsereteli called on the parties to the Karabakh conflict to  resolve disagreements and find a common language
Stepanakert called the statement of Georgian Foreign Ministry on the  local elections in Artsakh stereotyped Stepanakert called the statement of Georgian Foreign Ministry on the  local elections in Artsakh stereotyped 
YPC President: Decision of the Constitutional Court on the YPC President: Decision of the Constitutional Court on the "Kocharian  case" may be followed by agreements with external forces.
Russian President congratulates jailed second Armenian president on  jubileeRussian President congratulates jailed second Armenian president on  jubilee
Armenian public is concerned about uranium reserves in Amulsar fieldArmenian public is concerned about uranium reserves in Amulsar field
Over 10 years, 495 children were adopted by foreign citizens from 6  orphanages in Armenia, and only 116 by local citizensOver 10 years, 495 children were adopted by foreign citizens from 6  orphanages in Armenia, and only 116 by local citizens
By creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South CaucasusBy creating a counterbalance to the 102nd base, Turkey will claim for ousting Russia from the South Caucasus
First skyscraper to be built in Yerevan
Supporters of the second president of Armenia demand from the  Ombudsman to declare Kocharyan a political prisoner and protect his  rightsSupporters of the second president of Armenia demand from the  Ombudsman to declare Kocharyan a political prisoner and protect his  rights
View from Baku: Pashinyan actually invited Azerbaijan to recognize  the accession of Karabakh with a View from Baku: Pashinyan actually invited Azerbaijan to recognize  the accession of Karabakh with a "corridor" to Armenia in exchange  for other territories
Yerevan responds to Baku`s statementYerevan responds to Baku`s statement
Official Baku categorically rejects Pashinyan`s statement that  Karabakh is part of ArmeniaOfficial Baku categorically rejects Pashinyan`s statement that  Karabakh is part of Armenia
Hovhannes Igityan: Robert Kocharyan has never been a political  leader. Even being the president of Artsakh and ArmeniaHovhannes Igityan: Robert Kocharyan has never been a political  leader. Even being the president of Artsakh and Armenia
French Embassy provides support in 3D modeling of Armenia`s  historical and religious sites French Embassy provides support in 3D modeling of Armenia`s  historical and religious sites 
Edmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in ArmeniaEdmon Marukyan: We are doing everything to ensure that there is more  America in Armenia
Nikol Pashinyan told why there is no progress in the Karabakh  settlementNikol Pashinyan told why there is no progress in the Karabakh  settlement
NKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weaponsNKR Foreign Minister: Future President of Artsakh should not be  associated with money and weapons
Ardshinbank Increases the Number of Branches Operating on SaturdaysArdshinbank Increases the Number of Branches Operating on Saturdays
29 PACE MPs appealed to RA authorities to ensure rights and freedoms  of LGBT community29 PACE MPs appealed to RA authorities to ensure rights and freedoms  of LGBT community
Head of Migration Service of Armenia: One of the main tasks of our   service is the integration of refugees into the life of the countryHead of Migration Service of Armenia: One of the main tasks of our service is the integration of refugees into the life of the country
Hayastan All-Armenian Fund for 27 years invested $ 370 million in the   development of ArmeniaHayastan All-Armenian Fund for 27 years invested $ 370 million in the development of Armenia