Arminfo.info



 Saturday, June 29 2013

Safaryan Ashot

Maxim Shevchenko: Russia still has no comprehensive policy in the Caucasus

Maxim Shevchenko: Russia still has no comprehensive policy in the Caucasus

Mr. Shevchenko, the weapon deal between Moscow and Baku has had a wide
public response. What made Russia sell weapons to a country – enemy of its
strategic ally Armenia?  


Russia is
connected with Armenia via CSTO, therefore contractual relationships between
the two countries are deeper than the relations of Moscow and Baku. Armenia and
Russia are closely cooperating in many key fields.  However, Azerbaijan is not an enemy for
Russia either. In Russia we are very upset over the Armenian-Azerbaijani
conflict. As regards the sale of weapons to Azerbaijan, I don't know what is
the logic of the Russian government or the president. I think, however, that
balance of forces in the region is the guarantee of peace and stability. If
disarmament is impossible, balance of force is the guarantee against military
actions and use of force. There is nothing anti-Armenian in the sale of the
Russian weapons to Azerbaijan. The contractual relations of Armenia and Russia
make Moscow protect Armenia in case of a threat.


 Supply of Russian weapons to Azerbaijan leads to a new wave of
anti-Russian sentiments in the Armenian public. Isn’t Russia concerned over
that fact?


Public sentiments in Armenia and Russia
have no impact on the decisions of politicians. Russia cannot take either
pro-Armenia or pro-Azerbaijani position in the Karabakh conflict.  Moscow will observe certain balance in
it.  We will not allow military  


Russian politicians say that Russia supplies weapons to Azerbaijan not
to lose its weapons sale market. Otherwise, USA, Turkey or Israel will start
supplying weapons to Azerbaijan. Do you share these views?


Russia does
not want to lose Azerbaijan as a sales market for its military production or
yield it to the USA, for instance. That is not the point, however. If the USA
decides to supply weapons, it will do that irrespective of Russia. We have
already witnessed how the USA 'pushes through' its decisions at any cost. I
think that in the light of rather serious developments in the regions, threats
of war around Iran, unfortunately, the balance of forces is the guarantee
against the use of force by the conflicting parties.


What do you think of further relations of Iran and Azerbaijan under new
President of Iran Hassan Rouhani? Yet during the presidential race, Rouhani
called Baku a threat to the security of Iran…


A
confrontation with Iran would be dangerous for Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan's
decision to let Israel use its territory for anti-Iranian reconnaissance is
dangerous for Iran, but it is no less dangerous for Azerbaijan as it may lead
to an Azeri-Iranian confrontation. One of the scenarios the United States and
NATO are considering for withdrawing their troops from Afghanistan is the use
of Azerbaijan's territory, which will hardly be good for the Azeri people. The
mass arrests of Shias in Nardaran are aimed against Iran. Azerbaijan should not
to conduct such a policy now that Wahhabis are getting increasingly active in
its south.


Over the last 2-3 years, some experts and politicians in Armenia have
revised the Armenian-Russian relations criticizing them for inequality. What do
Russian experts and politicians think of these relations/


I’d not say that the relations have been revised. We can see certain
activation of the interests of the USA and NATO in Armenia. I think Russia
takes little efforts, maybe, because the Armenian-Russian relations are at
rather a high level and do not need any caution. The two leaders have good
personal relations and activity of the western structures will hardly be able
to spoil those relations. However, I think it is necessary to be a little more
cautious.


On the other hand, Russia still has no comprehensive policy in the
Caucasus. Russia does not perceive the Caucasus as a single whole. All the
countries in the Caucasus are inter-related, which must be reflected in the
Kremlin’s policy. Moscow needs an efficient policy meeting the interests of all
the subjects in the region.


There are hot debates in Armenia over deep integration into EU and
integration projects offered by Moscow. Is it a dilemma for Armenia or
complementary foreign policy?


To join the Customs Union, Armenia needs to sign certain documents.
However, Armenia will hardly manage to fulfill the provisions of those
documents unless the Russian-Georgian and Armenian-Azerbaijan relations are
settled and the railway communication via Abkhazia and Georgia is restored. The
idea of the Eurasian Union is worth supporting, of course. I think it is a
historical, strategic project and the relations of Moscow and Tbilisi must be
normalized. As for the relations with the EU, I think Armenia’s joining that
structure is unreal.


European officials speak of ‘deep integration’ and not admission…


If
Armenia continues integrating into the EU, it may be required to stop its
relations with Iran. The pro-European lobby in Armenia consists of politicians
receiving grants from Brussels. But they don't specify what benefits Armenia
may expect from its integration into Europe. 
The EU is not ready to make Armenia its member. On the other hand, it
may set preconditions, like withdrawal from the Collective Security Treaty
Organization, closer cooperation with NATO and no more contacts with Iran. I
don't think that the last precondition will be good for Armenia and its big
community in Iran.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?
Zakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fireZakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fire
Team Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey AcademyTeam Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey Academy
Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted    Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted   
Withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MPWithdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MP
U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  
Initiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  ArmeniaInitiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  Armenia
Armenian-French political consultations were held in YerevanArmenian-French political consultations were held in Yerevan
Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox 
Karasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  AzerbaijanKarasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  Azerbaijan
Zatulin: There is Zatulin: There is "zero" need for Russian peacekeepers in  Nagorno-Karabakh
Nazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to TavushNazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to Tavush
US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024
OSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South CaucasusOSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South Caucasus
Member of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandonedMember of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandoned
Armenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracyArmenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracy
Lawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of ArmeniaLawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of Armenia
Pashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents againPashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents again
Russia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirmsRussia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirms
Ex-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHREx-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHR
Artsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in ArmeniaArtsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in Armenia
Converse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 millionConverse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 million
The President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements ProgramThe President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements Program
Russian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-KarabakhRussian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-Karabakh
Armenia`s former human rights defender demands probe into torture of  citizenArmenia`s former human rights defender demands probe into torture of  citizen
Activist accused of insulting MP transported to Yerevan department of  Investigative CommitteeActivist accused of insulting MP transported to Yerevan department of  Investigative Committee
EPP youth organization adopts resolution on Artsakh EPP youth organization adopts resolution on Artsakh 
Police had no right to abuse civil activist - lawyer Police had no right to abuse civil activist - lawyer 
France recalls its ambassador to Azerbaijan, accuses Baku of  France recalls its ambassador to Azerbaijan, accuses Baku of  "damaging" ties
CSTO Sec Gen does not use term CSTO Sec Gen does not use term "freezing" regarding Armenia`s CSTO  membership 
Opposition calls on CoE to condemn gross violations of human rights  and fundamental freedoms in ArmeniaOpposition calls on CoE to condemn gross violations of human rights  and fundamental freedoms in Armenia
Human rights activist: policemen beat and tortured citizen by order  of Armenia`s ruling political forceHuman rights activist: policemen beat and tortured citizen by order  of Armenia`s ruling political force
Sobhani: Iran`s Sobhani: Iran`s "red lines" regarding inviolability of borders of  countries in region have not changed
Ambassador: Iran cannot be against Armenia`s efforts to strengthen  its own economic sustainability and solve Artsakh refugees` problems Ambassador: Iran cannot be against Armenia`s efforts to strengthen  its own economic sustainability and solve Artsakh refugees` problems 
Iranian ambassador advises collective West to stop trying to involve  Armenia in its geopolitical gamesIranian ambassador advises collective West to stop trying to involve  Armenia in its geopolitical games
Parliamentarian: There is masked gang in Armenia that allows itself  to brutally beat citizen under police protectionParliamentarian: There is masked gang in Armenia that allows itself  to brutally beat citizen under police protection
Armenia, Azerbaijan start debate on Armenia v Azerbaijan case at ICJArmenia, Azerbaijan start debate on Armenia v Azerbaijan case at ICJ
Armenia`s authorities lying - public figure Armenia`s authorities lying - public figure 
Turkiye behind Islamic State - Armenian MP Turkiye behind Islamic State - Armenian MP 
Stop discussing Armenian Genocide - Edmon Marukyan Stop discussing Armenian Genocide - Edmon Marukyan 
Armenia`s former human rights defender draws parallels between  Armenian, Turkish authorities Armenia`s former human rights defender draws parallels between  Armenian, Turkish authorities 
Law-enforcers detain citizen who insulted MP on bus Law-enforcers detain citizen who insulted MP on bus 
Before, After: Reflections on Armenian Genocide Opens at ReflectSpace  GalleryBefore, After: Reflections on Armenian Genocide Opens at ReflectSpace  Gallery
Armenian ambassador to Germany severely critical of Russia, CSTOArmenian ambassador to Germany severely critical of Russia, CSTO
Issues of development of Turkmen-Uzbek relations were discussedIssues of development of Turkmen-Uzbek relations were discussed
Citizen Samvel Vardanyan detained on suspicion of hooliganism after  altercation with MP from  ruling factionCitizen Samvel Vardanyan detained on suspicion of hooliganism after  altercation with MP from  ruling faction
Hranush Kharatyan gives harsh answer to Andranik Kocharyan, who  wanted to compile lists of victims of Armenian GenocideHranush Kharatyan gives harsh answer to Andranik Kocharyan, who  wanted to compile lists of victims of Armenian Genocide
The delegation of Turkmenistan took part in the Second Ministerial Meeting of the “GCC + Central Asia” Strategic DialogueThe delegation of Turkmenistan took part in the Second Ministerial Meeting of the “GCC + Central Asia” Strategic Dialogue
Pro-government MP: Whether Armenia is democratic or not is not  decided by Freedom HousePro-government MP: Whether Armenia is democratic or not is not  decided by Freedom House
President of Kazakhstan was presented with manuscripts kept in  Matenadaran, incl in Ghpchagh ones with Armenian scriptPresident of Kazakhstan was presented with manuscripts kept in  Matenadaran, incl in Ghpchagh ones with Armenian script
Armenia`s Central Election Commission delegation visits KoreaArmenia`s Central Election Commission delegation visits Korea
ICRC staff visits Armenians held hostage in BakuICRC staff visits Armenians held hostage in Baku
Azerbaijan continues its cynical strategy of instrumentalizing  alleged environmental concerns for political reasons - statementAzerbaijan continues its cynical strategy of instrumentalizing  alleged environmental concerns for political reasons - statement
Yerevan, Astana became sister citiesYerevan, Astana became sister cities
Orientalist: Iran responded to Israel asymmetrically, thereby raising  escalation bar in Middle EastOrientalist: Iran responded to Israel asymmetrically, thereby raising  escalation bar in Middle East
Richter Trio to perform in Yerevan Richter Trio to perform in Yerevan 
Police detain Antifake staff members Police detain Antifake staff members 
Day of Remembrance of victims of the Yazidi Genocide in Iraqi Sinjar  to be marked in Armenia Day of Remembrance of victims of the Yazidi Genocide in Iraqi Sinjar  to be marked in Armenia 
Arsonist targeting Armenian cemeteryArsonist targeting Armenian cemetery
London, Yerevan hold talks on sending illegal migrants to Armenia -  The Times London, Yerevan hold talks on sending illegal migrants to Armenia -  The Times