Arminfo.info




 Monday, October 19 2015 13:20

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Alexander Tsinker: None of OSCE MG countries can settle the Karabakh conflict alone

Alexander Tsinker:  None of OSCE MG countries can settle the Karabakh conflict alone

It has become a kind of tradition in Armenia to blame the authorities for their unwillingness to appeal to the CSTO for support despite Azerbaijan’s provocations that claimed the lives of civilians in Tavush region, Armenia.  Don’t you think that Yerevan does not appeal to the CSTO intentionally? Otherwise, Russian “peacekeepers” will inevitably occur on the border and in Karabakh, won’t they? 

The CSTO charter says it is an international regional organization and its goal is to protect the territorial and economic space of the member-states by combined efforts of their armies and other forces against any external military and political aggressors, international terrorists, and large-scale natural calamities. However, since the very establishment of the CSTO, I have got an impression that it will not launch any specific actions in any specific region like NATO does now.  If the CSTO ever takes any specific actions, it is possible only at the request of a member-state and only against a country that has not been part of the former-Soviet Union. Therefore, in case the armed conflict with Azerbaijan resumes, the CSTO will not take Armenia’s side i.e. it seems unreal to me that the CSTO mechanisms can be used in Azerbaijan’s confrontation with Armenia and Nagorny Karabakh. This is what holds Armenia’s leadership from appealing to the CSTO for support, I think, irrespective of the new doctrine, which you have mentioned above and which might have well emerged in Armenia. On the other hand, countries strive for integration and Armenia’s CSTO membership looks quite normal in this light, especially that it helps Armenia get arms and increase its military potential.

Traditionally, Iran has played an essential role in the regional security system, though this is rarely mentioned. Can Iran claim the role of a serious actor in the Karabakh peace process after the sanctions are rescinded, considering its extensive border with the liberated territories?

As sanctions against Iran have been rescinded partially, that country has become a relevant topic. This country has always strived for regional leadership, though the last year’s sanctions created obstacles to it. The latest changes in Syria and Iraq, where Russia and the international coalition have launched air strikes and do not seek to start also land operation, make me think that Iran will undertake a land-based operation.  Actually, Iran’s first units have already been deployed in the territory of Syria. I think Tehran will cooperate with Russia rather than with the U.S.-led coalition in Syria. In this light, Iran’s regional role will increase. It is very interesting how the relations of Iran and Azerbaijan will be developing. I think, Tehran will continue offering its services in the Karabakh peace process, but it’s role will not be crucial in it. Even Russia cannot have a crucial role in the peace process, as the conflicting parties try to win it around and press each another. The 25-year-old conflict is deeply rooted in the conscience of both the peoples and any efforts to settle it from outside without reckoning with the conflicting parties will be rejected by the leaderships and peoples of Azerbaijan, Armenia and NKR.  It is evident that none of the OSCE Minsk Group co-chair states will be allowed to settle the conflict alone. Their immediate partners at the mediation mission will not let them do it. In addition, it appears to me that recently the OSCE Minsk Group has been meeting just to meet. Therefore, when the situation on the border grows tense, the Minsk Group just calls on the parties to observe the ceasefire and does nothing to expose either the reasons of the tension or who is behind it. Consequently, I think Iran can influence certain processes around Nagorny Karabakh, but not settle the conflict.

As a citizen of Israel do you believe that Iran’s nuclear program has become peaceful after the P5+1 deal?

No. I think the program has not changed. Simply, Iranians have become wiser, especially after their president was replaced. In other words, Iran has changed its mask or mouthpiece, but never its intentions, as ayatollahs are who govern the country. We think it was bad agreement, as it gives Iran an opportunity to continue its nuclear program. Yet, I don’t think that the third world war may be nuclear.

In other words, nuclear weapons are just deterrent weapons?

Sure, Iran strives for the family of the countries having nuclear weapons. And I do not think that even after becoming part of that family Iran will be able to attack Israel, though many do not share my views. Nevertheless, If Israel gets any reliable information and proofs that Iran continues its nuclear program for military purposes and the world community does not respond to it adequately, it will have to take relevant measures, as it had signed no agreements.

There is an impression that after Iran’s “return” to the global policy, Turkey that was gradually losing its positions in the foreign policy is now losing them even more rapidly. What do think about it?

Turkey has problems perhaps with all its neighbors now, despite Ahmet Davutoglu’s policy of “zero problems with neighbors.” As the Kurdish problem has grown tense along with the situation in neighboring Syria and Iraq, Turkey has even more stuck in all these problems. The past elections for Erdogan were not successful, as his party failed to gain majority in the parliament even when the situation in the country was not tense. Now, to achieve success at the upcoming elections, he needs to suppress the pro-Kurdish Party. Actually, this is what he is doing now. Turkey’s seeming economic and political success ended yet long before this. The uncertainly of the Syrian scenario makes Turkey’s influence shrink like “The Magic Skin.”  Turkey needs to decide finally whether it is with Russia or U.S. It is very difficult for Ankara to do it, as there is no common stand on it in Turkey. Actually, Turkey is not and will hardly become as strong politically and economy as it was five years ago. This seems impossible also as Iran flexing muscles.

The goals of the United States and its coalition are generally clear. What is Russia seeking in Syria? 

Unlike U.S., Moscow is acting crudely, but efficiently in Syria. I think Russia’s actions in Syria are the right step by Putin. First, he needed to distract the attention from Ukraine. Second, he needed to bring Russia back to the group of the countries that decide something in the world. Third, he needed to return to the Middle East.  Moscow has good relations with Egypt, Iran, and not bad relations with Israel whose relations with U.S. have been spoiled certainly. All this does mean that Russia is back to the club of super powers. After all, it would be silly to lose a base in the Mediterranean. In addition, Russia did not forget about how they had bailed on it in Libya, and will not let it to repeat in Syria. Therefore, the Alawite state with Russian bases in Syria will remain, irrespective of whether Assad will remain in power or not. I think that Russia and U.S. will finally achieve an agreement over Syria, and Assad, particularly.  A new leader will come to power in Syria through elections that will be recognized by all, whether it is good or not.

What about the “Islamic State”?

I think it will disappear at a certain stage. I am more concerned about Europe, where most of the ISIL militants are migrating to, rather than the “Islamic State.” Recently I was in the center of Europe: Vienna, Budapest, and I saw not so pleasant scenes there. Refugees have flooded the biggest cities in Europe. By the way, it is very strange refugees. It seems to me that these are not refugees, but a kind of mass exodus, resettlement, which might be organized by someone. Such resettled people will number about one million in Europe by the end of the year. This will affect mostly the developed countries of Europe: Germany, France, and England…  

Who and why has organized that resettlement? 

 

It is a not an easy question. I am not sure that U.S. is behind this. I can just say that much has changed in Europe and in the world, generally, after the idea of Greater Europe from Lisbon to Vladivostok emerged. It was exactly after Putin, Merkel and Sarkozy caught up the idea of the tri-polar world – U.S., China and Greater Europe – that discrepancies started inside Europe. It is quite probable that U.S. is the main opponent of that project, as it strives for the world domination. As to the problem of re-settlement, the aging Europe needs migrants, labor force, at least to ensure Europeans with pensions. This is another reason why Europe receives migrants.

As far as I understand, the latest wave of migrants leaves for Europe to live of doles, not to work?

That is why refugees strive for Germany. Doles and social housing programs in Germany enable migrants to live and do nothing, and to keep their families. This is what prompted a dramatic decline of the integration of Turkish migrants in Germany. The first wave of migrants – I am speaking about to end of the last century – tried to learn language, get job and integrate into the German society. Their next generation realized that it is quite possible to live on dolls and “retired into shell.” Mosques in Germany have become a place for actively communication and formation of a new world outlook of Muslims in the heart of Europe.   

Angela Merkel has acknowledged that fact recently…

Unfortunately. It means that our concerns are grounded. I hail Slovenia’s response to the situation. That country said it is ready to receive only Christian refugees, as it has no mosques. Australia did almost the same. What I feel when looking at the processes in Europe is concern and pain. The Old Word is turning Muslim and less and less attractive for life and tourism. Therefore, if Europe takes no measures to change the system and the terms of receiving and integrating migrants,  “The Mosque of Notre Dame de Paris” anti-utopia novel of Russian writer Yelena Chudinova will turn into real description of Paris.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Azerbaijan`s actions on Stepanakert-Goris highway another provocation  - Artak BeglaryanAzerbaijan`s actions on Stepanakert-Goris highway another provocation  - Artak Beglaryan
Azerbaijan`s actions aimed at intimidating Artsakh population - Arman  Tatoyan Azerbaijan`s actions aimed at intimidating Artsakh population - Arman  Tatoyan 
120,000 residents of Artsakh under complete blockade - Gegham  Stepanyan120,000 residents of Artsakh under complete blockade - Gegham  Stepanyan
Spanish MP visits Armenia`s Jermuk Spanish MP visits Armenia`s Jermuk 
Artsakh will not be a part of Azerbaijan - Nagorno-Karabakh foreign  office Artsakh will not be a part of Azerbaijan - Nagorno-Karabakh foreign  office 
U.S. committed to ensuring peaceful future in South Caucasus region -  Philip ReekerU.S. committed to ensuring peaceful future in South Caucasus region -  Philip Reeker
Russian Ambassador: There can be no sustainable peace without just  settlement of conflictRussian Ambassador: There can be no sustainable peace without just  settlement of conflict
Russian Ambassador: CSTO does not seek expansion by putting pressure  on its membersRussian Ambassador: CSTO does not seek expansion by putting pressure  on its members
Armenian FM holds separate meetings with his counterparts from  Slovakia, SloveniaArmenian FM holds separate meetings with his counterparts from  Slovakia, Slovenia
FMs of Armenia, Portugal are considering possibilities of establishing business relations between  two countries FMs of Armenia, Portugal are considering possibilities of establishing business relations between  two countries 
Oppositionist: Parliaments of France and Artsakh make statements,  while National Assembly of Armenia refuses to discuss a similar  documentOppositionist: Parliaments of France and Artsakh make statements,  while National Assembly of Armenia refuses to discuss a similar  document
Pashinyan, Reeker discuss formation of international mechanism for  negotiations between Stepanakert and BakuPashinyan, Reeker discuss formation of international mechanism for  negotiations between Stepanakert and Baku
Suren Papikyan refuses to comment on possible purchase of weapons  from IndiaSuren Papikyan refuses to comment on possible purchase of weapons  from India
Armenian FM briefs OSCE Secretary General on fragile security  situation in regionArmenian FM briefs OSCE Secretary General on fragile security  situation in region
Armenia`s National Assembly  discusses draft statement in response  to Azerbaijani parliament`s statementArmenia`s National Assembly  discusses draft statement in response  to Azerbaijani parliament`s statement
Armenian FM: Targeted and principled assessments of intl. community  can contribute to establishment of stability in South CaucasusArmenian FM: Targeted and principled assessments of intl. community  can contribute to establishment of stability in South Caucasus
In the current conditions, international presence on the ground and a  clear attitude towards aggression and the aggressor state are as  important as never before - MirzoyanIn the current conditions, international presence on the ground and a  clear attitude towards aggression and the aggressor state are as  important as never before - Mirzoyan
AMD 4․653․223 to AMD 4․653․223 to "Aren Mehrabyan" foundation: beneficiary of "The Power of One Dram" for December is the Health Fund for Children of Armenia
Borrell, Mirzoyan discuss ways to advance on regional peace building Borrell, Mirzoyan discuss ways to advance on regional peace building 
The President of Turkmenistan received the minister of energy of the Islamic Republic of IranThe President of Turkmenistan received the minister of energy of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Armenian FM presents situation in South Caucasus to his counterparts  from Estonia, Lithuania, Switzerland and Greece Armenian FM presents situation in South Caucasus to his counterparts  from Estonia, Lithuania, Switzerland and Greece 
Foreign Ministry provides details of meeting of representatives of  Armenia, Turkey on borderForeign Ministry provides details of meeting of representatives of  Armenia, Turkey on border
U.S. Embassy in Armenia welcomes Ambassador Philip Reeker to YerevanU.S. Embassy in Armenia welcomes Ambassador Philip Reeker to Yerevan
Lavrov: Alma-Ata Declaration envisages Nagorno-Karabakh as part of  AzerbaijanLavrov: Alma-Ata Declaration envisages Nagorno-Karabakh as part of  Azerbaijan
BeechCraft 95 private plane that crashed in Armenia was on  Yerevan-Astrakhan routeBeechCraft 95 private plane that crashed in Armenia was on  Yerevan-Astrakhan route
Paris: Resolution on assistance to Armenia does not reflect the  official position of FranceParis: Resolution on assistance to Armenia does not reflect the  official position of France
Armenian, Czech FMs discuss South CaucasusArmenian, Czech FMs discuss South Caucasus
Ardshinbank holds a campaign 10000 AMD for every 300th client making a money transferArdshinbank holds a campaign 10000 AMD for every 300th client making a money transfer
Director of Law and Justice Center briefs Australian officials on  Azerbaijani aggressionDirector of Law and Justice Center briefs Australian officials on  Azerbaijani aggression
Armenian NA speaker welcomes French Senate`s resolution in support of  ArmeniaArmenian NA speaker welcomes French Senate`s resolution in support of  Armenia
"Without accountability, there isn`t justice"  - Bob Menendez
Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations 
French National Assembly unanimously adopts resolution calling for  sanctions against AzerbaijanFrench National Assembly unanimously adopts resolution calling for  sanctions against Azerbaijan
Ambassador: Chile unequivocally stands for the principle of conflict  resolution without the use of forceAmbassador: Chile unequivocally stands for the principle of conflict  resolution without the use of force
NA MP presents to French Ambassador situation resulted from  Azerbaijani aggression NA MP presents to French Ambassador situation resulted from  Azerbaijani aggression 
MP: MP: "Civil Contract" to take part in extraordinary meeting of NA,  initiated by opposition
Parliamentary form of government in Armenia to be retainedParliamentary form of government in Armenia to be retained
Actual directions for the development of Turkmen-Korean cooperation determinedActual directions for the development of Turkmen-Korean cooperation determined
Ameria PhonePOS.  New application for receiving non-cash payments with a smartphoneAmeria PhonePOS.  New application for receiving non-cash payments with a smartphone
Artsakh Defense Army refutes another misinformation of Azerbaijani  sideArtsakh Defense Army refutes another misinformation of Azerbaijani  side
Armenia and Artsakh attacked five times since end of 44-day war - MPArmenia and Artsakh attacked five times since end of 44-day war - MP
Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations 
Centrist Democrat International issues statement on situation in  Armenia Centrist Democrat International issues statement on situation in  Armenia 
Armenia, Germany agree to more intensively develop high-level  political dialogueArmenia, Germany agree to more intensively develop high-level  political dialogue
Russian peacekeepers record violation of ceasefire by Azerbaijani  armed forces in Shushi regionRussian peacekeepers record violation of ceasefire by Azerbaijani  armed forces in Shushi region
MoD: Armenian serviceman was injured by enemy gun fireMoD: Armenian serviceman was injured by enemy gun fire
There are media reports saying that Brussels has not given up on idea  of organizing meeting between leaders of Armenia, AzerbaijanThere are media reports saying that Brussels has not given up on idea  of organizing meeting between leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan
Poll: To counter Azerbaijani aggression, it is necessary to arm and  fight backPoll: To counter Azerbaijani aggression, it is necessary to arm and  fight back
Poll: Armenia is against granting the population of Artsakh the  status of an ethnic minority within AzerbaijanPoll: Armenia is against granting the population of Artsakh the  status of an ethnic minority within Azerbaijan
Poll: About half of the country`s respondents do not support any  political force in ArmeniaPoll: About half of the country`s respondents do not support any  political force in Armenia
Poll: Armenian citizens still rely on Russia, but are disappointed in  CSTOPoll: Armenian citizens still rely on Russia, but are disappointed in  CSTO
Reborn Armenia party ceases its activity in ParliamentReborn Armenia party ceases its activity in Parliament
Armenia needs to Armenia needs to "distance itself from dependence" on Russia without  seceding from CSTO
Valerie Boyer once again warns international community against  turning blind eye to Azerbaijan`s aggression against ArmeniaValerie Boyer once again warns international community against  turning blind eye to Azerbaijan`s aggression against Armenia
Armenian Security Council Secretary holds meetings in Paris Armenian Security Council Secretary holds meetings in Paris 
ANCA calls for close Senate scrutiny of next U.S. ambassador to  ArmeniaANCA calls for close Senate scrutiny of next U.S. ambassador to  Armenia
Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations 
 Ardshinbank is the exclusive sponsor of Vladimir Spivakov`s charity concert Ardshinbank is the exclusive sponsor of Vladimir Spivakov`s charity concert
Artsakh President convenes working consultation Artsakh President convenes working consultation 
Mirzoyan: Azerbaijan responded to Armenia`s proposals on a peace  treaty only yesterdayMirzoyan: Azerbaijan responded to Armenia`s proposals on a peace  treaty only yesterday
Read more



Commented