Arminfo.info



 Tuesday, June 2 2015 11:37

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Sergey Kurginyan: Russia's Responses to Azerbaijani and Armenian Impulses are Conditioned by the Rules of Geopolitical Market

Sergey Kurginyan: Russia

 What minuses and pluses are you tracing in Russia’s current Caucasian policy – particularly towards Armenia? What is your opinion on Moscow’s policy on the post-Soviet territory?  

After the collapse of the USSR we have been facing new rules of the reality. I believe that the new type of the Armenian-Russian relations can be built on the basis of our countries' national development only. Therefore, the optimality of the national development is to be Russia's only interest in the relations with Armenia. If this national development implies that Armenia is to have relations with any other country but not Russia, Moscow will simply have to accept it for it realizes there will be a configuration to meet the national interests. Taking into account the current realias and that sooner or later the society's impulses will decide everything, subduing or transforming someone makes no sense. One can contribute to the faster development of these impulses but never control them - this will result in counterreaction. It is another matter that most not only Caucasian but also European countries resemble pots with specific lids with a completely different content boiling inside. Most often these lids appear to be way more pro- Western than the boiling content they cover. In this case we should clearly differentiate the wakening of national spirit from globalism and the lid from the content.

 

Nevertheless, Armenia is a member of the Eurasian Economic Union. What tendencies are expected from Moscow towards Yerevan in this context? 

As I understand, modern Russia and Russian president's foreign policy is characterized by the attention they pay to the directions of their national interest - Armenia, for example, or any other state. This is the profile of Putin's policy, which is, properly speaking, not imperial. This policy is targeting at guessing tendencies, seeing where this or that nation and elite is intending to turn - this is for delicate consideration. If Armenia ever wishes to develop a good rapport with Turkey, let it be, it's Armenia's problem. As far as I know no one in Moscow will ever counteract this. They will simply deduce relevant conclusions and elaborate a certain line of conduct.  No one in Moscow will ever blame Armenia for treason. In other words, Russia builds one type of relations with countries of national interest and another type of relations with other countries. I believe that such a policy is normal.

 

 

What about Armenia’s national interests?

 

I cannot say for sure. Armenia's national interest is defined by its domestic conflicting groups and the political elite. I do understand the euphoria of the late 80s, the talks that Armenia would be the USA's foothold in Caucasus. British Petroleum and other companies' interest in the adjacent state shows that this never happened. This caused the new formation of the Armenian policy.  The time for hopes and unconditional utopias has passed. I don't blame anyone for Russia also had the same utopias once. I can't say that someone has gone mad and believed the USA. The Russian elite trusted them just the way other post-Soviet countries did.

 

 Many believe that the Karabakh conflict defines Armenia’s national interest. More people believe that Russia holds the key to the solution to this conflict…

I do not agree with people who say that Russia holds the key to the solution to the Karabakh conflict. I do not see that, therefore I do not share that misbelief. I would like to get evidence on Russia manipulating the Karabakh conflict. I wouldn't mind tht but I do not see it. Russia moves on in accordance with its own national interests - that is reciprocating the impulses of the adjacent territory. Therefore, Russia relevantly responds to both Azerbaijani and Armenian impulses. This reaction is a part of a peculiar geopolitical market. Here Russia monitors the development of tendencies by responding to reality and moving the wheel relevantly.  This is Russia's multi-vector nature. Kremlin realizes that neither Russian embassy, not residentura or Russian Armenians control Armenia.  The national elite, the complex alloy of elite and national tendencies control Armenia. I believe, Kremlin simply monitors the track of these tendencies.

 

 You have characterized some countries as pots with specific lids with a completely different content boiling inside. What boils in Armenia and what sort of a lid covers that pot?

 It is rather difficult to estimate this in case of Armenia. I keep an eye on Eastern European countries and I can assure you that this is happening in Bulgaria. I believe that Italy, Greece, Spain and even France will soon witness these processes. I think that in Ukraine everything has been split into several civilization modules each of which having different directions. The Greek “Sirisa” or Italian “5 Star” Movement speak about their nations’ discontent with their lids. Ythis means, there are direct indexes there, which I cannot tell I see in Armenia now. I see no bodies that express the dissent between the people and the elite. 

 

 The Armenian authorities were long aspiring for the European Association; meanwhile ordinary citizens were aspiring to join the Trade Union. Doesn’t this speak for the different content of the pot and lid?

 

 Might be. Then why has there been no relevant referendum held in Armenia?

 

Lausanne agreements on Iran's nuclear program have created new prospects for a new reality. How do you see this?

 I do not share the optimism about it. I do share the opinion of religious leader Khamenei, who said, "If you are so eager to conduct these talks, do that. Let's see what happens next." Naturally, we will be very glad to see progress in this matter.  However, my teammates and I do not believe in such rosy prospects.

 

Based on the existing phobias and the negative experience the Armenian society is rather concerned over the Russian-Turkish economic convergence. Do you share these concerns?

I think the Russian-Turkish relationship is much subtler than it seems to be. Generally speaking, the relationship with Turkey is an incredibly complicated process. That country is still on a crossroad.  It has not yet found its place in the world. The main economic projects with Russia are still being checked and tested. All this is being done very carefullyIf Russia sought to take Turkey's side; Russian President Vladimir Putin would not have attended the Armenian Genocide Centennial events in Yerevan on April 24. I would not say that Armenia's policy with respect to Turkey is not unambiguous either for there are various internal streams in Armenia. The notorious anti-Turkish sentiments in Armenia are not unlimited. We perfectly see pro-Turkish streams in the Armenian elite as well.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
100 pages of atrocities of Baku regime:  report has been submitted to  ICC prosecutor for consideration100 pages of atrocities of Baku regime:  report has been submitted to  ICC prosecutor for consideration
Bipartisan, Bicameral Coalition of U.S. legislators calls for  American leadership to secure justice Justice for Artsakh and  Armenian GenocideBipartisan, Bicameral Coalition of U.S. legislators calls for  American leadership to secure justice Justice for Artsakh and  Armenian Genocide
To return to PACE, Baku must fulfill  number of requirements -  rapporteur on AzerbaijanTo return to PACE, Baku must fulfill  number of requirements -  rapporteur on Azerbaijan
Moscow once again emphasizes `complete ineffectiveness of EU  presence` in Armenia in terms of preventing incidents Moscow once again emphasizes `complete ineffectiveness of EU  presence` in Armenia in terms of preventing incidents "on ground"
Zakharova reminds Azerbaijani journalist about Armenians who left  Azerbaijan in late 1980s Zakharova reminds Azerbaijani journalist about Armenians who left  Azerbaijan in late 1980s 
IC initiates  criminal case regarding report of violence against  Samvel VardanyanIC initiates  criminal case regarding report of violence against  Samvel Vardanyan
Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?
Military correspondent Kotenok: We are leaving Artsakh, which no  longer existsMilitary correspondent Kotenok: We are leaving Artsakh, which no  longer exists
Zakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fireZakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fire
Immortal Regiment to march along Yerevan streets Immortal Regiment to march along Yerevan streets 
List of diseases preventing army service to be reviewed in Armenia List of diseases preventing army service to be reviewed in Armenia 
Armenia`s premier meets with residents of Kirants village Armenia`s premier meets with residents of Kirants village 
Team Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey AcademyTeam Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey Academy
Armenia`s premier meets with residents of BerkaberArmenia`s premier meets with residents of Berkaber
UJA condemns MP`s verbal attack on journalist UJA condemns MP`s verbal attack on journalist 
Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted    Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted   
Withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MPWithdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MP
U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  
Yerevan court makes decision on Samvel Vardanyan case  Yerevan court makes decision on Samvel Vardanyan case  
Initiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  ArmeniaInitiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  Armenia
Armenian-French political consultations were held in YerevanArmenian-French political consultations were held in Yerevan
Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox 
Karasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  AzerbaijanKarasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  Azerbaijan
Zatulin: There is Zatulin: There is "zero" need for Russian peacekeepers in  Nagorno-Karabakh
Nazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to TavushNazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to Tavush
US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024
OSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South CaucasusOSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South Caucasus
Member of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandonedMember of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandoned
Armenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracyArmenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracy
Lawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of ArmeniaLawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of Armenia
Pashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents againPashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents again
Russia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirmsRussia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirms
Ex-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHREx-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHR
Artsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in ArmeniaArtsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in Armenia
Converse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 millionConverse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 million
The President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements ProgramThe President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements Program
Russian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-KarabakhRussian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-Karabakh
Armenia`s former human rights defender demands probe into torture of  citizenArmenia`s former human rights defender demands probe into torture of  citizen
Activist accused of insulting MP transported to Yerevan department of  Investigative CommitteeActivist accused of insulting MP transported to Yerevan department of  Investigative Committee
EPP youth organization adopts resolution on Artsakh EPP youth organization adopts resolution on Artsakh 
Police had no right to abuse civil activist - lawyer Police had no right to abuse civil activist - lawyer 
France recalls its ambassador to Azerbaijan, accuses Baku of  France recalls its ambassador to Azerbaijan, accuses Baku of  "damaging" ties
CSTO Sec Gen does not use term CSTO Sec Gen does not use term "freezing" regarding Armenia`s CSTO  membership 
Opposition calls on CoE to condemn gross violations of human rights  and fundamental freedoms in ArmeniaOpposition calls on CoE to condemn gross violations of human rights  and fundamental freedoms in Armenia
Human rights activist: policemen beat and tortured citizen by order  of Armenia`s ruling political forceHuman rights activist: policemen beat and tortured citizen by order  of Armenia`s ruling political force
Sobhani: Iran`s Sobhani: Iran`s "red lines" regarding inviolability of borders of  countries in region have not changed
Ambassador: Iran cannot be against Armenia`s efforts to strengthen  its own economic sustainability and solve Artsakh refugees` problems Ambassador: Iran cannot be against Armenia`s efforts to strengthen  its own economic sustainability and solve Artsakh refugees` problems 
Iranian ambassador advises collective West to stop trying to involve  Armenia in its geopolitical gamesIranian ambassador advises collective West to stop trying to involve  Armenia in its geopolitical games
Parliamentarian: There is masked gang in Armenia that allows itself  to brutally beat citizen under police protectionParliamentarian: There is masked gang in Armenia that allows itself  to brutally beat citizen under police protection
Armenia, Azerbaijan start debate on Armenia v Azerbaijan case at ICJArmenia, Azerbaijan start debate on Armenia v Azerbaijan case at ICJ
Armenia`s authorities lying - public figure Armenia`s authorities lying - public figure 
Turkiye behind Islamic State - Armenian MP Turkiye behind Islamic State - Armenian MP 
Stop discussing Armenian Genocide - Edmon Marukyan Stop discussing Armenian Genocide - Edmon Marukyan 
Armenia`s former human rights defender draws parallels between  Armenian, Turkish authorities Armenia`s former human rights defender draws parallels between  Armenian, Turkish authorities 
Law-enforcers detain citizen who insulted MP on bus Law-enforcers detain citizen who insulted MP on bus 
Before, After: Reflections on Armenian Genocide Opens at ReflectSpace  GalleryBefore, After: Reflections on Armenian Genocide Opens at ReflectSpace  Gallery
Armenian ambassador to Germany severely critical of Russia, CSTOArmenian ambassador to Germany severely critical of Russia, CSTO
Issues of development of Turkmen-Uzbek relations were discussedIssues of development of Turkmen-Uzbek relations were discussed
Citizen Samvel Vardanyan detained on suspicion of hooliganism after  altercation with MP from  ruling factionCitizen Samvel Vardanyan detained on suspicion of hooliganism after  altercation with MP from  ruling faction
Hranush Kharatyan gives harsh answer to Andranik Kocharyan, who  wanted to compile lists of victims of Armenian GenocideHranush Kharatyan gives harsh answer to Andranik Kocharyan, who  wanted to compile lists of victims of Armenian Genocide
Read more



Commented