Arminfo.info



 Monday, March 4 2019 13:24
David Stepanyan

Karabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the region

Karabakh negotiation process has entered so-called “Cyprus path” when geopolitical players appeared in the region

ArmInfo.Political scientist Arif Yunusov, Head of Department of Conflict and Migration Studies  in Institute for Peace and Democracy, who received political asylum in Netherlands, comments in an interview to ArmInfo on the recent impulses related to Karabakh settlement. He forecasts the most possible scenarios of the situation development, shares his view of the role and goals of external factors in the Karabakh settlement.

 

Mr. Yunusov, judging from the statements of Yerevan and Baku the approaches of the sides have not changed at the background of certain activation of the process, although the foreign ministers met 5 times in less than a year and the heads of state 3 times. In this light can it be assumed that the Karabakh negotiation process has entered a so-called Cyprus path and now the negotiations towards peace will last for decades?

 

 

For me personally, it became clear after the signing of the so-called «Contract of the Century», when geopolitical players appeared in the region. Prior to that, the West did not pay intensive attention to our region, tacitly considering it as a sphere of influence of Russia. But later, when large investments began to be made in the energy resources of Azerbaijan and the real geopolitical confrontation between the West and Russia in the region began, the Karabakh conflict lost its status of internal Armenian - Azerbaijani conflict.

 

 And since the interests of the geopolitical players differed sharply, it became clear that this would inevitably affect the negotiating process of the conflicting parties. And when the Baku-Ceyhan oil pipeline was launched,  it became finally clear that in the negotiation process there are few chances for serious progress. It also became obvious  that the proposals made by the co-chairs will remain on paper until the geopolitical situation in the region changes. An additional factor was that Armenians and Azerbaijanis are not tired of the conflict.

 

 

Continuing to constantly talk about the desire to resolve the conflict peacefully, each side interprets the phrase “just and peaceful settlement”  in its favor. Armenians and Azerbaijanis have traveled only an insignificant part of the path leading to the real negotiation process. As a result of the above-mentioned the negotiation process is more likely to be an imitation, when the positions of the conflicting parties  sharply contradict to each other, however geopolitical players will not allow a big war between them considering a number of reasons. There may be regular escalations of the situation at the front line for 2-5 days  including military actions, but they will not be allowed to launch a  large-scale war. And such a situation may continue for quite a long time...

 

In order to realize that the April 2016 war has led to a further strengthening of Moscow’s position in both Armenia and Azerbaijan, it is sufficient to estimate the volume of Russian arms supplies to parties to the conflict in the recent two years. In your opinion, are the latest impulses in the negotiation process a consequence of the efforts of the West, primarily the United States, to bring the negotiations back to the OSCE Minsk Group and prevent the possibility of a new escalation of the conflict in the future?

 

It should be admitted that today Russia is the one to be more active in the region. And it is not by chance that Armenia and Azerbaijan listen more to its opinion. And Aliyev’s first meetings with Pashinyan in Dushanbe and St. Petersburg took place largely due to Russia, let's not forget about it. At the same time,  Western countries do not completely lose sight of our region. And this was reflected on the meeting at the beginning of this year of the foreign ministers and the preparations for the meeting between Aliyev and Pashinyan at the official level in the framework of the negotiation process.

 

 On February 1, in Berlin, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan made a political statement during negotiations with the German Chancellor Angela Merkel - any settlement option should be acceptable to the peoples of Armenia, Karabakh and Azerbaijan. It is clear that even “renewed” Ilham Aliyev (not least because of the change of power in Armenia) is unable to make a similar statement. Thus, the inability of Baku to oppose this line, is something new that goes beyond the multi-year theses on territorial integrity, creates a qualitatively new situation advantageous for the Armenian parties to the conflict. Isn't it time for Baku, in your opinion, to change the strategy?

 

Actually, I see nothing new here. All the predecessors of Pashinyan said the same. In turn, the concept of official Azerbaijan in the negotiation process was formed by the father of the current president, Heydar Aliyev. Once, official Baku, including Heydar Aliyev, had contacts with the authorities of Nagorno-Karabakh and the truce of 1994 was concluded exactly this way, with the participation of three parties. But then Heydar Aliyev began to reject the role of Nagorno-Karabakh in the conflict, and today this is  the position of official Baku. At the same time, the Azerbaijani authorities also constantly assure that after Armenia and Azerbaijan solve all the problems between themselves, then, of course, Nagorno-Karabakh will become part of the negotiation process. But not earlier. And for now I do not see any prerequisites that this line will change.

 

 

 Due to a number of factors, the main catalyst for the intensification of negotiations around Karabakh is the growing interest of the US Administration in the South Caucasus. This was reflected, for example, in the Caucasian visit of the adviser to the President of the United States on national security John Bolton. It seems that the United States is seeking to bring the Karabakh process out of the deadlock precisely with the goal of reducing the dependence of Yerevan and Baku on Moscow. There is an opinion that it was precisely due to Moscow that the conflict was driven into the status quo, which corresponds to its interests even more than, perhaps, the interests of Armenia. And for the US, Armenia and Azerbaijan are only interesting as Iran’s neighbors ...

 

Let`s be pragmatic - the president of the United States is Donald Trump, who is clearly not inclined to deepening the conflict with Russia. Quite the contrary. For Trump, the Karabakh conflict is a trifle that he does not intend to think particularly about. Iran is another matter. Everything here is much more serious for him and therefore the current US administration views our countries only as neighbors of Iran and in the context of their future relations with official Tehran.

 

 

The Azerbaijani authorities have repeatedly voiced the desire for a new strategic relationship with the United States, following the example of Kazakhstan, which signed the “Agreement on Enhanced Strategic Partnership” with Washington, which has given the country the status of a strategic partner of the United States. And if this status of Kazakhstan allows the United States to include this country in the global projection to contain China, then in the case of Azerbaijan, the question, first of all, is about deterring Iran. Are such prospects real and do they correspond to the interests of Azerbaijan?

 

The American policy of deterring Iran is not new; in the mid-1990s, the United States tried to use the territory of Azerbaijan in this regard. But this more than once led to the aggravation of Iranian-Azerbaijani relations. Moreover, in 2001, Azerbaijan and Iran were even on the brink of war — Iranian fighters began to regularly violate the airspace of Azerbaijan. And only the harsh statements of the United States, and military aid to Turkey, then stopped the escalation. But Iranian-Azerbaijani relations remained complex, and the Americans even began to supply ships and military equipment to the Caspian Sea and not only. That is, there is no novelty here either, and Azerbaijan stands between the United States and Iran, and this, of course, is not in the interests of Azerbaijan. Therefore, the example of Kazakhstan is not perceived as positive in Azerbaijan. Quite the contrary. The task of official Baku is to manage not to spoil relations with both the United States and Iran.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Tatoyan Foundation: By ceding territories to Azerbaijan, head of government undermines Armenia`s security  and rights of those territories` population Tatoyan Foundation: By ceding territories to Azerbaijan, head of government undermines Armenia`s security  and rights of those territories` population 
Vladimir Kazimirov, famous diplomat and peace advocate, passed awayVladimir Kazimirov, famous diplomat and peace advocate, passed away
Up to 10% cashback from GetTransfer with IDBank cardsUp to 10% cashback from GetTransfer with IDBank cards
"Azerbaijan receives villages, Armenia gets risks` reduction":  Premier`s Office comments on joint statement of RA, AR commissions on  border delimitation 
"We are": Russian policy promotes Aliyev`s permissiveness
Armenian Foreign Ministry: 8th meeting of state commissions on  delimitation of state border between Armenia, Azerbaijan was heldArmenian Foreign Ministry: 8th meeting of state commissions on  delimitation of state border between Armenia, Azerbaijan was held
Embassy: U.S. remains committed to partnering with Armenia to combat  transnational crimeEmbassy: U.S. remains committed to partnering with Armenia to combat  transnational crime
Aliyev to visit BerlinAliyev to visit Berlin
Aliyev leaves for Russia for talks with PutinAliyev leaves for Russia for talks with Putin
G7 countries call on Armenia, Azerbaijan to remain committed to peace  processG7 countries call on Armenia, Azerbaijan to remain committed to peace  process
Stepanyan: About 35% of refugees from Artsakh are thinking about  leaving ArmeniaStepanyan: About 35% of refugees from Artsakh are thinking about  leaving Armenia
Ruben Vardanyan launches hunger strike; he demands immediate,  unconditional release of all Armenian political prisoners illegally  held in BakuRuben Vardanyan launches hunger strike; he demands immediate,  unconditional release of all Armenian political prisoners illegally  held in Baku
Lavrov: Unilateral concessions by Armenian authorities make Armenia`s  borders undefinedLavrov: Unilateral concessions by Armenian authorities make Armenia`s  borders undefined
EU EU "takes note" of withdrawal of Russian troops from Nagorno-Karabakh
House of Representatives of Cyprus observed a minute`s silence for  Armenian genocide victimsHouse of Representatives of Cyprus observed a minute`s silence for  Armenian genocide victims
Russian MP Konstantin Zatulin responds to Armenia`s ex-premier Russian MP Konstantin Zatulin responds to Armenia`s ex-premier 
Anahit prize in Anahit prize in "Best sound design" category awarded to Andranik  Berberyan for Michael Goorjian`s Amerikatsi
Armenia`s former defense minister offers Armenia s premier to inspect  Armenia`s former defense minister offers Armenia s premier to inspect  "unusable missiles"
Crossroads of Peace project should be considered in context of  geopolitical developments - expert Crossroads of Peace project should be considered in context of  geopolitical developments - expert 
Two Arcs Art Space to host exhibition dedicated to Charles AznavourTwo Arcs Art Space to host exhibition dedicated to Charles Aznavour
Azerbaijan continues destroying Armenian churches in Nagorno-Karabakh  - Jean Christophe BuissonAzerbaijan continues destroying Armenian churches in Nagorno-Karabakh  - Jean Christophe Buisson
Azerbaijani media reports on Armenia-EU-USA high-level meeting fake -  MFA  Azerbaijani media reports on Armenia-EU-USA high-level meeting fake -  MFA  
100 pages of atrocities of Baku regime:  report has been submitted to  ICC prosecutor for consideration100 pages of atrocities of Baku regime:  report has been submitted to  ICC prosecutor for consideration
Bipartisan, Bicameral Coalition of U.S. legislators calls for  American leadership to secure justice Justice for Artsakh and  Armenian GenocideBipartisan, Bicameral Coalition of U.S. legislators calls for  American leadership to secure justice Justice for Artsakh and  Armenian Genocide
To return to PACE, Baku must fulfill  number of requirements -  rapporteur on AzerbaijanTo return to PACE, Baku must fulfill  number of requirements -  rapporteur on Azerbaijan
Moscow once again emphasizes `complete ineffectiveness of EU  presence` in Armenia in terms of preventing incidents Moscow once again emphasizes `complete ineffectiveness of EU  presence` in Armenia in terms of preventing incidents "on ground"
Zakharova reminds Azerbaijani journalist about Armenians who left  Azerbaijan in late 1980s Zakharova reminds Azerbaijani journalist about Armenians who left  Azerbaijan in late 1980s 
IC initiates  criminal case regarding report of violence against  Samvel VardanyanIC initiates  criminal case regarding report of violence against  Samvel Vardanyan
Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?Zakharova on expulsion of illegal immigrants from UK to Armenia: If  there were no meaningful negotiations, maybe there were meaningless  ones?
Military correspondent Kotenok: We are leaving Artsakh, which no  longer existsMilitary correspondent Kotenok: We are leaving Artsakh, which no  longer exists
Zakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fireZakharova:  US, EU assign Armenia only the role of an instrument for  igniting a new big fire
Immortal Regiment to march along Yerevan streets Immortal Regiment to march along Yerevan streets 
List of diseases preventing army service to be reviewed in Armenia List of diseases preventing army service to be reviewed in Armenia 
Armenia`s premier meets with residents of Kirants village Armenia`s premier meets with residents of Kirants village 
Team Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey AcademyTeam Telecom Armenia partner of CaseKey Academy
Armenia`s premier meets with residents of BerkaberArmenia`s premier meets with residents of Berkaber
UJA condemns MP`s verbal attack on journalist UJA condemns MP`s verbal attack on journalist 
Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted    Position of Armenia`s military attache in UK instituted   
Withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MPWithdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Nagorno-Karabakh confirms  stronger influence of Turkish factor in region - MP
U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  U.S. Department of State comments on withdrawal of Russian troops  from Nagorno-Karabakh  
Yerevan court makes decision on Samvel Vardanyan case  Yerevan court makes decision on Samvel Vardanyan case  
Initiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  ArmeniaInitiatives aimed at developing French language were discussed in  Armenia
Armenian-French political consultations were held in YerevanArmenian-French political consultations were held in Yerevan
Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox Lilit Shaboyan appointed economy minister spox 
Karasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  AzerbaijanKarasin: withdrawal of RPC from Nagorno-Karabakh is logical  consequence of Pashinyan`s recognition of this territory as part of  Azerbaijan
Zatulin: There is Zatulin: There is "zero" need for Russian peacekeepers in  Nagorno-Karabakh
Nazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to TavushNazeli Baghdasaryan refutes statements attributed to PM during his  visit to Tavush
US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024US State Dept: Armenia does not intend to restart full implementation  of VD11 in 2024
OSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South CaucasusOSCE Chair-in-Office travels to South Caucasus
Member of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandonedMember of Armenian delegation to PACE: historic, cultural and  religious heritage of Armenian people in Nagorno Karabakh cannot be  lost, and this issue shall not be abandoned
Armenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracyArmenian MP: our mission is to develop real mechanisms for early  prevention of backsliding from democracy
Lawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of ArmeniaLawyer:  criminal case against Samvel Varodanyan was initiated on  direct orders of political authorities of Armenia
Pashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents againPashinyan decided to communicate with Voskepar residents again
Russia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirmsRussia has begun withdrawing peacekeepers from Artsakh, Peskov  confirms
Ex-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHREx-minister`s lawyer intends to apply to ECHR
Artsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in ArmeniaArtsakh Ombudsman considers disgusting attempts of ruling force to  blame Artsakh refugees for  problems in Armenia
Converse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 millionConverse Bank starts initial placement of next AMD, USD bonds in  amount of AMD 5 billion, $10 million
The President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements ProgramThe President of Turkmenistan received the Acting Executive Director of the UN Human Settlements Program
With the support of AraratBank, Matenadaran will record a new milestone in the restoration of manuscripts and expand the scope of international cooperation.With the support of AraratBank, Matenadaran will record a new milestone in the restoration of manuscripts and expand the scope of international cooperation.
Russian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-KarabakhRussian peacekeepers leaving Nagorno-Karabakh
Read more



Commented